Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end at Charles?

184 replies

freudien · 06/10/2021 00:26

I've just noticed a lot of republican talk recently (prompted by the other thread on the earth shot prize, also generally twitter and recent republican stuff happening in Wales) and I wonder whether it's because I'm in an echo chamber? Or is MN also an echo chamber? Either way. Are you a royalist or a republican?

Personally I feel the royal family is worth the money spent but should be kept out of politics. Kind of like other european monarchies.

But then on the other hand by dissolving the aristocracy wouldn't we be solving the problems of inequity in society?

OP posts:
MynameisWa · 06/10/2021 22:30

Very confused as to why you think electing a good president is a straightforward thing. No one ever likes anyone with power in Britain. Why would it be any different when it came to the president of Britain?

The thing about elected heads of state is that they are free to operate in the short term and can push through agendas. Obama is a good example. He was a great statesman and spoke up for the vulnerable. Now he’s not in power he’s swapped over to celebrity dynasty world, milking it in lala land. He’s become what he stood against when he was elected.

Presidents end up using the platform to fulfil their own ambitions. The royals have to see it through to the bitter end and this makes it a different relationship with the people they serve. They stay accountable.

Point taken about Andrew. However, the fact that a royal cannot run away from scandal probably means in the end there is less. For a big family with huge amounts of power who have been at the top and within the scrutiny of the media for so long, there has been a surprisingly small amount of scandal associated with the current royal family.

The ‘little picture’ came straight from the BBC.

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2021 21:24

Crikey, if the birth order had been different we'd be having Andrew!

With no means of getting rid of him

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2021 21:23

What replaces it if it’s gone? Boris as the head of state like Biden and Macron? Oh yes that’s preferable

Honestly, this is the laziest argument in the book. Just look at the type of people Ireland elect as their president. Respected people who have achieved things in their own right.

Also, it’s a myth the royal family cost tonnes of money because The Crown Estate makes more than enough money to pay for the sovereign. Because of that the royals are a self funding entity as can be sen in the attachment.

Your attachment is disingenuous. That little Crown icon doesn't indicate that the crown estates belong to the Windsor family. They are state assets.

StoneofDestiny · 06/10/2021 21:21

Ireland has a good system to consider - and anyway, who’s to say countries can’t come up wither their own unique, fit-for-purpose forms of government?

Exactly.
Throwing up the ''but we'd get Boris' argument is ridiculous. Crikey, if the birth order had been different we'd be having Andrew!

We need something we get to choose, one person, if we need a Head of State. Not a whole extended family of spouses, uncles, aunts, nephews, nieces, cousins from every generation with security for all and Royal apartments, Palaces and other grace and favour rewards.

Comedycook · 06/10/2021 21:20

There is still a lot if support for the monarchy. If you don’t think there is then you are in a left wing bubble

It's like the last general election and brexit. The loudest voices would have had you believe we'd still be in the EU with Jeremy Corbyn as prime minister right now.

Very few irl admit to voting Tory yet they're in power.

Royals are still popular with vast majority of the UK.

TheWashingMachine · 06/10/2021 21:17

I'm centre right wing and I think it's time they went, the young ones think they celebs. Nobody has a jot of respect for them, FFS leaving aside Andrew and Harry, look at Charles he is always mouthing off and is quite dim. William looks like an estate agent and I gather he is heavy going Kate is fine, nice hair but dull.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 06/10/2021 21:09

What replaces it if it’s gone? Boris as the head of state like Biden and Macron? Oh yes that’s preferable. Can’t wait for that. Yes I get it that they are democratically elected, but that still doesn’t mean we end up with states people we are proud of.

I am absolutely convinced they’re not going anywhere (and know I’m right Wink), but this thread has been quite clear, if you’ve read it, that there are other options than the US or French models.

Ireland has a good system to consider - and anyway, who’s to say countries can’t come up wither their own unique, fit-for-purpose forms of government?

CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 21:09

Batshit explosion incoming.

Grin

Can't be arsed even to start...

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 06/10/2021 20:57

Batshit explosion incoming.

MynameisWa · 06/10/2021 20:51

Twitter = left wing bias. Guardian = left wing bias. Mumsnet = liberal left wing bias. Republicans = left wing bias.

There is still a lot if support for the monarchy. If you don’t think there is then you are in a left wing bubble.

People love them because they are ingrained in British culture. What replaces it if it’s gone? Boris as the head of state like Biden and Macron? Oh yes that’s preferable. Can’t wait for that. Yes I get it that they are democratically elected, but that still doesn’t mean we end up with states people we are proud of.

Also, it’s a myth the royal family cost tonnes of money because The Crown Estate makes more than enough money to pay for the sovereign. Because of that the royals are a self funding entity as can be sen in the attachment.

Sometimes reigning generations are good. Sometimes they are bad. The point is the royal family is permanent and a constant in an ever changing world. This gives comfort and stability to many who need it.

I hope they are here to stay. William and Kate will be brilliant for the country. Stoic, elegant, selfless Kate. Our Queen!

Long live the Queen!

To think the monarchy will end at Charles?
CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 20:50

If the whole world stopped " believing " in them, what would happen ?

Fairies would die Wink

UsedUpUsername · 06/10/2021 20:50

@mustlovegin

I just don’t think it has a place in the modern world

What do you understand by 'the modern world'?

You are deluded if you believe monarchies have not been replaced by even more influential and autocratic (global) structures. Think of Twitter, Facebook, Amazon and the like. Think about how much power those who control these platforms actually have, and it will only get worse.

The Royal Family, their pomp and their modest expenditure should be the least of our worries really.

Isn’t she one of the world’s largest landowners? If not the largest?
CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 20:48

The Royal Family, their pomp and their modest expenditure should be the least of our worries really

Should we worry about cash for access, gongs for sale, multiple tax dodges, endemic successful lobbying in their own interests and princes playing hide and seek with the law instead?

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 06/10/2021 20:28

"The Royal Family, their pomp and their modest expenditure should be the least of our worries really"

Yes I agree, their fascism, racism, landgrabbing and intimate knowledge of global paedophile rings and arms trafficking should probably be top of the list.

StripeyBadger · 06/10/2021 20:28

It’s not a quick process to get rid of the royal family and so it would be very tricky to time it for when Charles’ dies. I think the reality is that it will carry on for some time yet.

Dontforgetyourbrolly · 06/10/2021 20:25

I love the royal family, but in the way that they are characters in a reality TV show !
When I think about their position, it seems ridiculous, who decided they were better than everyone else ? It's quite bizarre really , they are just people , human beings , but almost universally worshipped .
If the whole world stopped " believing " in them, what would happen ?

mustlovegin · 06/10/2021 20:24

I just don’t think it has a place in the modern world

What do you understand by 'the modern world'?

You are deluded if you believe monarchies have not been replaced by even more influential and autocratic (global) structures. Think of Twitter, Facebook, Amazon and the like. Think about how much power those who control these platforms actually have, and it will only get worse.

The Royal Family, their pomp and their modest expenditure should be the least of our worries really.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 06/10/2021 20:15

Waffle, drivel, garbage, batshit, horseshit, cowpat...

Just one tiny little link, book or article to justify all the monarchist rage and delusion? Pretty please nicely.

mustlovegin · 06/10/2021 20:14

are you passionate about maintaining traditional values in general

No, but it's frustrating when people are gullible and parrot inanities. There's a lot of that at the moment IMO

Soozikinzi · 06/10/2021 20:13

Yes definitely really I think the Queen should be the last . The Queen is brilliant but there are too many hangers on how can anyone be a lord or lady or whatever in 2021 ? It's ridiculous.

mustlovegin · 06/10/2021 20:13

I don't get my news from twitter. I see it as a way of gauging general sentiment of people and how they think. Hence wondering about the echo chamber. The guardian is a reputable source of information

OP, I hope you find your answers.

But...YABU for saying The Guardian is a reputable source of information. It's biased, distorting and hyperbolic.

Also you should consider reading a bit of history and learn about statistics and sampling. Even professionals in this area get it wrong most of the time, but you definitely cannot use Twitter to gauge sentiment

CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 20:10

You may not like the truth or you may not understand what I wrote. But it's certainly not waffle

Of course I understood what you wrote Hmm but vague, unevidenced claims that they make the country far more than we spend on them (it doesn't stop at the Sovereign Grant) don't make for a convincing argument let alone the truth.

mustlovegin · 06/10/2021 20:04

I'm more interested in why you appear to be so angry in all your replies

I'm not angry but I tend to be rather spirited

You, on the contrary give the impression of having been drinking valerian tea all day Smile

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 06/10/2021 19:04

@Comedycook

William and Kate will be hugely popular. They seem to be doing an excellent job raising their kids, so I predict they will all be popular too.
Comedycook Seriously, how many 5 year olds do you know who get indoctrinated into grouse shooting?

19th century values that belong in the 19th century.

TertiusLydgate · 06/10/2021 18:55

I’m 100% republican and would love to see them abolished. I’d hope to it see it end when the queen dies.

The ridiculous forelock tugging when Phillip died made me nauseous. And as for those who bob and curtsy to them…? Ludicrous.