Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To know anyone irl with munchausens?

506 replies

Lw87 · 05/10/2021 22:21

Watching the gypsy rose doc, I'd never heard of munchausens disease before and can't even think I'd know anyone with it in real life

Has anyone actually had an RL encounter with someone with this?

OP posts:
owlbethere · 06/10/2021 00:18

@DisasterPasta

I don’t think muchausen by proxy is classed as a psychological disorder any more, it’s just a form of child abuse.

Classing it as a disorder the abuser has diminishes their responsibility and deflects from the real victim.

It’s called FDIA and very much a psychological problem. Lots of psychological illnesses lead to child abuse or neglect, doesn’t mean they aren’t illnesses.
NoLeafClover · 06/10/2021 00:18

Yes, I firmly believe that someone I know has FDIA (factitious disorder imposed on another). It's extremely horrible and I'm absolutely not going to go into detail. Suffice to say, she has absolutely destroyed her (now adult) child. Her bright, caring, kind, funny child is now a shadow of their former self. Hospitalised for mental health issues very regularly. Unable to live independently, unable to work, barely able to care for themselves. The Mum has been telling anyone who will listen that their child is weeks from death for over a decade now. I think in a very sad, sick way, she'd actually love if her child died. I know that sounds hideous, but it's true. It's awful.

WindyRose · 06/10/2021 00:18

My adoptive parents were typical Munchausen's (a/mother) and Munchausen's by proxy (a/father) and during my childhood I was a victim as well. Looking back it was a horrible life for a child but at the time it was my 'normal' and my earliest memory is emergency dashes to hospital in the middle of the night, mostly following the ambulance which was under lights and sirens, hoping she would pull through. But after numerous tests etc, the hospital would send her home with yet another mystery illness and the cycle started again.

Of course, each new illness brought new medications and it was my 'special job' to dispense these as required and I can remember this from around 4-5 yrs old. When I turned 7 I was 'big enough' to give injections and remember the GP teaching me to inject into an orange with water in the syringe.

Scarily I was injecting Morphine and similar, which sends shivers down my spine when I think about it now, because A/M would request another injection maybe an hour or two after the previous one...yes, it seems she was a drug addict and me (7 yrs old) the unwitting perpetrator. I often ask myself how I would feel right now if she had died from one of those overdoses, even though I was too young to know what was happening and being told I was 'special' because I was helping. It's a scary thought...

Although it's some years since they both died, A/M lived to 85 yrs old. Further 'proof' those serious and fatal illnesses weren't real at all.

WoodchipNightmares · 06/10/2021 00:16

@coachmylife

When DD had a weird set of symptoms it was entirely clear that this was suspected by our GOSH team. I remain utterly horrified that they focused on me (as imagined perpetrator) and didn’t really investigate what was causing DD’s (admittedly bizarre) symptoms. Her condition is one that has been associated w FII, but that FII was the conclusion they leapt to (not a genuine medical condition) appals me. They had absolutely not one shred of evidence to do this - just the association.
Likewise, it's very common for parents of children born with osteogenesis imperfecta - aka brittle bone disease - to be investigated for child abuse. Far too many have permanently lost their children to adoption, only for them to be later diagnosed.

It's one of those conditions where the (milder, more common) form has the child looking normal but having a remarkable number of soft tissue injuries and broken bones, none of which the parent has an adequate explanation for, because they really did just trip over and break their femur.

Now, there's more child abuse victims out there than children with brittle bone disease, but even the visible hallmark signs are often missed by doctors who should know better.

DemocracyofHypocrisy · 06/10/2021 00:15

There was a widely reported case a few years ago of a mum who did it with 2 of her kids, to the extent that one child (it could have been both, I can’t remember) had gone through surgery to have feeding tubes fitted even though the children didn’t have any issues with being able to eat. The official story was that she was committing benefit fraud, I don’t think MBP was mentioned but you would assume there was more to it than that.

There were various illnesses mentioned in the case, asthma, autism etc and one of the children was forced to be in nappies until they were older.

She was jailed for nearly 10 years I think. I just don’t understand how she managed to manipulate HCPs into agreeing to perform invasive surgery, when there were no actual physical problems with the children.

owlbethere · 06/10/2021 00:14

I think the thing to remember about people with factitious disorder is they ARE unwell, just not with the things they fake, it’s a psychological problem.
As a child I used to fake illnesses or pretend illnesses were worse than they were because it was the only time I got my mothers attention. I stopped when I was in my teens because it wasnt really working anymore and took up ED and self harm instead. I was a very lonely sad neglected child and only years of therapy have helped.

julieca · 06/10/2021 00:13

Yes two people. A teenage friend used to fake fits. I half suspected it but they confirmed to me they had faked it when they got older. Understandable I guess as their home life was not good.

Also a relative who died. She told Drs she could not walk and refused to try. Multiple tests could find nothing and she refused to do any activity that would keep her muscles okay. Eventually, her muscles wore away and she did end up in a wheelchair and finally in a home. Tragic that she made herself disabled. No idea what the motivation was.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 06/10/2021 00:08

I did suspect another parent of this. She would tell anyone who'd listen that her children had a terrible disease caused by parasites. She fed them around 15 pills a day that she bought online.
Her children actually appeared to be in perfect health, bright skin, very fit and bright, but one was hugely anxious.

I would sometimes bump into the mother at a local cafe and she'd have a huge stack of the children's medical notes and would invariably be crying.

It was very strange. My view is that she genuinely believed in what she was doing, that there was no malicious intent but that the only illness the children knew was their mother's instability.

choosername1234 · 06/10/2021 00:05

I on ce treated a man in A&E (I'm a nurse) who fabricated a whole story about having terminal cancer and said he was experiencing nasty side effects of treatment but was visiting our city to see friends before he died.
It all came out as lies when we contacted his "home" hospital, they knew him & his stories well. Apparently he travelled through the country doing the same thing. He left the dept quite quietly after we challenged him.
He then returned the next week with the same story, unfortunately for him, I was on triage the night he returned. He totally denied everything, denied he had ever attended this dept (had changed his details when booking in). So very sad & strange

Flossie44 · 05/10/2021 23:52

@coachmylife

When DD had a weird set of symptoms it was entirely clear that this was suspected by our GOSH team. I remain utterly horrified that they focused on me (as imagined perpetrator) and didn’t really investigate what was causing DD’s (admittedly bizarre) symptoms. Her condition is one that has been associated w FII, but that FII was the conclusion they leapt to (not a genuine medical condition) appals me. They had absolutely not one shred of evidence to do this - just the association.
I had similar I think at GOSH. Or at least firm disbelief of there being issues. I’ve since had an apology from the consultant and a firm diagnosis for my child.
NeedTesla · 05/10/2021 23:47

@coachmylife

When DD had a weird set of symptoms it was entirely clear that this was suspected by our GOSH team. I remain utterly horrified that they focused on me (as imagined perpetrator) and didn’t really investigate what was causing DD’s (admittedly bizarre) symptoms. Her condition is one that has been associated w FII, but that FII was the conclusion they leapt to (not a genuine medical condition) appals me. They had absolutely not one shred of evidence to do this - just the association.
I have seen a pt suspected of this too with absolutely no evidence just because it initially was not a condition that could be diagnosed easily. It horrified me that it was so casually bandied around. When I wrote in the medical records that this was recorded without evidence or proper assessment I got in trouble and the consultant was furious.
Garriet · 05/10/2021 23:42

[quote Lw87]@DontBiteTheBoobThatFeedsYou oh really? What is the new name for it?[/quote]
Fabricated or induced illness.

www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/fabricated-or-induced-illness/overview/

Twofurrycats · 05/10/2021 23:35

Yes. Fortunately not as in doing things to make a child ill.
One claimed her child had all sorts of physical aliments. Usually relating to walking or teeth. Nothing could be found wrong with the child. When the DC got old enough to object that there was nothing wrong with their legs and they could play games the mother started with a shopping list of conditions for herself. Including claiming to have caught a condition that you're born with.
The other went more down the line of speech problems/SEN. Until the child reached 16, passed exams and promptly moved abroad to work. Again the mother then developed vague conditions of her own needed to see lots of specialists and probably buggered up a medical study they got involved in.

llwynogbach · 05/10/2021 23:35

Yes my birth mother has it- horrific for anyone involved, very hard to prove, proved deadly for one of my younger sisters and the impact of it still effects both my youngest sister and I.

TankFlyBoss · 05/10/2021 23:32

In the course of work yes, but it is incredibly difficult to work with and engage with the families let alone prove

StoneofDestiny · 05/10/2021 23:29

@Lw87 Thank you

Justilou1 · 05/10/2021 23:26

My mum had MH problems (undoubtedly some form of personality disorder), but was also a product of her own upbringing with a lot of emotional abuse and neglect, especially as a girl in a family of eight kids with a fire and brimstone Catholic mother. I was her first born child and born early due to a car accident that was her fault: (she always drove like a bat out of hell) Nobody expected me to survive back then, and I attracted a lot of media attention. I had a badly broken leg from being pulled out, and everyone assumed I had some form of brain damage as a result of oxygen deprivation as I needed resuscitation at birth. I didn’t walk until I was nearly three, because everyone assumed I wouldn’t be able to. I was pulling myself up on the dog when the visiting health nurse noticed my hips were badly dislocated from the traction in the humidicrib, and that the dogs guarded me from my mother. I had already had several gynaecological surgeries by this time looking for sources of mystery vaginal infections reported by my mum but never verified medically. This continued until I was eight and I explained to a doctor when I was having my arm reconstructed for the second time that she was responsible for breaking it, and I had never had any problems urinating or itchy bits. SS were never called (mum was a nurse) but my godmother had a long conversation with the hospital and my parents about how they had all been taking notes and one more problem and they would take custody of me. Fuck I wish they had.

coachmylife · 05/10/2021 23:25

When DD had a weird set of symptoms it was entirely clear that this was suspected by our GOSH team. I remain utterly horrified that they focused on me (as imagined perpetrator) and didn’t really investigate what was causing DD’s (admittedly bizarre) symptoms. Her condition is one that has been associated w FII, but that FII was the conclusion they leapt to (not a genuine medical condition) appals me. They had absolutely not one shred of evidence to do this - just the association.

Lw87 · 05/10/2021 23:25

It must be terrifying. It's thrown me off tbh because I'd never heard of it, now I'm on Google looking at what causes it

OP posts:
AugustRose · 05/10/2021 23:24

I know someone who enabled their daughter in a similar way. It wasn't extreme and it wasn't self (or parent inflicted) injury but it was a constant flow of the child 'feeling ill' whenever something happened they didn't like.

For example, if the mum (who is a TA) gave too much attention to other kids the child would suddenly start feeling nauseous, or complain of stomach pains, anything to distract the mum's attention from other kids. Another time the child slightly knocked her foot at school but had been at my house later running up and down the stairs with my kids. As soon as her mum arrived she complained of a pain in her leg and that weekend the mum took her to A&E to have it x-rayed - it was fine!

The worst was that the child (aged around 11) did have a small foot injury that needed a plaster for 6 weeks. Apparently this also required a wheelchair! After the plaster came off, she kept on a brace for months, along with the wheelchair and then sticks.

What made it ridiculous was that everyone saw the child running and swirling around whenever the mum turned her back and sometimes when she was looking. But she would not believe it even when she saw it. 6 months later, by which time she'd moved to secondary school, the wheelchair was back with no explanation.

There were many small episodes like this over the years.

TableFlowerss · 05/10/2021 23:20

@DisasterPasta

I don’t think muchausen by proxy is classed as a psychological disorder any more, it’s just a form of child abuse.

Classing it as a disorder the abuser has diminishes their responsibility and deflects from the real victim.

I agree with you.

It makes you wonder what kind of mental state someone must be in to do that to their kids though.

You’d think they’d need to be mentally unwell to do such a thing

MyCatDribbles · 05/10/2021 23:18

I know someone who made their child ill on multiple occasions, ED visits etc. They ended up in court over it and proved guilty and sent to jail.

Orangejuicemarathoner · 05/10/2021 23:17

@DisasterPasta

I don’t think muchausen by proxy is classed as a psychological disorder any more, it’s just a form of child abuse.

Classing it as a disorder the abuser has diminishes their responsibility and deflects from the real victim.

exactly, both are types of behaviour, not a condition
DisasterPasta · 05/10/2021 23:14

I don’t think muchausen by proxy is classed as a psychological disorder any more, it’s just a form of child abuse.

Classing it as a disorder the abuser has diminishes their responsibility and deflects from the real victim.

Clymene · 05/10/2021 23:12

I think it's quite common on MN