Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To know anyone irl with munchausens?

506 replies

Lw87 · 05/10/2021 22:21

Watching the gypsy rose doc, I'd never heard of munchausens disease before and can't even think I'd know anyone with it in real life

Has anyone actually had an RL encounter with someone with this?

OP posts:
BiLuminous · 06/10/2021 01:30

@SophieKaczynsky

Weirdly all the people that I know that always claim to be ill or have ill children all claim to her Erlers Danlos and/or Fibromyalgia. I know that both are both extremely real and debilitating health conditions, but I find it hard to believe that they all have these conditions, plus children with every condition under the sun, too.
The thing is these conditions can have co-morbidities, so it can be hard to tell. For example, my son has epilepsy. There are quite a lot of co-morbidities associated with it. So far, it doesn't look like he has any of them but for example- lots of people who have epilepsy are also autistic. EDS is also associated with epilepsy. You could in theory have all 3. EDS is also largely inherited so it figures that other family members might also have it...
Becca19962014 · 06/10/2021 01:28

I was accused of it for over three decades. The Drs insisted it was due to being fostered Confused I actually have a severe medical phobia due to how I was treated, by everyone. Incidentally it was my (abusive) parents who gave them the idea I was making it up.

Even when diagnosed with my illnesses (all caused by an underlying genetic condition) I still got accused of it. In the end at my last hospital appointment having waited over twelve hours, no food or drink and had a hypo (which I was blamed for causing because I supposedly wanted to be admitted and couldn't "really" have diabetes) I lost my temper (dodgy blood sugars do nothing for my mental control) and demanded they rang my specialist in front of me after telling me they'd rang and he confirmed I was making everything up and was "fine and had tricked him into a diagnosis". They rang. It didn't end well for them. First, they never rang in the first place so lied to me, second they told him they could tell I was lying. The man was a specialist, one of the best in the world, they didn't stand a chance of convincing him with all his knowledge and test results and evidence that I'd faked it!

To be fair the specialist did warn me even with his details on my notes any diagnosis wouldn't be accepted.

The point is this is a highly damaging diagnosis to make. I've an aunt (now deceased) who had the same condition as me, and was diagnosed with it. Her cancer was missed.

I'm not denying it happens. It obviously does. But when you're admitted to a specialist hospital and every person you speak to had the same diagnosis which was wrong that's worrying.

me4real · 06/10/2021 01:28

It's a monumental abuse of resources and phenomenal waste of money, but I simply cannot imagine how terrifying it must be to be that person and to be trapped inside their mind 24/7. I'm astonished they were able (left) to live independently, really.

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll To some extent they enjoy it, I mean they're constantly getting that 'hit' of attenton and drama. I suppose it might be a bit like an addiction and in the rare event any of them wanted to stop, they'd have to break the habit.

People can maybe snap out of it a bit if they have something else happening in their life to keep their interest- work or something.

I think maybe it can be linked to Borderline traits or other personaliity disorders.

Sunshinebuttercups · 06/10/2021 01:25

I don’t know anyone in real life with the condition or by proxy. By proxy is actually very rare and is now known as Fabricated or Induced Illness now. I think the current thinking is more that health anxiety (often driven by the internet) is more the issue, rather then people tampering with results. So people genuinely believe their child has problems and then their actions worsen problems. So for example there child has a sore foot, they worry it’s broken, X-ray is fine, but child still in pain. They become convinced something is missed, don’t make child walk on foot etc.

As some other posters have mentioned, unfortunately accusations of FII are genuinely levelled at the Mother and often on baseless grounds. I also know a lot of women though who have been disbelieved by medical professionals. Told that they are just suffering “stress”, including a friend who had bowel cancer (and sadly died) and another friend who actually had MS.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 06/10/2021 01:21

I don't know if it's exactly the same, but I always remember reading a news article from years and years ago about a specialist facility (in Falkirk, IIRC) where they treated two patients by amputating a leg from each of them. The legs (and the rest of the patients) were perfectly (physically) healthy, but they were so utterly convinced that their healthy legs were diseased/going to kill them/hated them that they were borderline suicidal.

Then again, I suppose it's not necessarily uncommon for people to be obsessively upset by the presence of perfectly normal, healthy body parts in other circumstances.

I also remember them talking on Jeremy Vine's radio show a couple of years ago about 'frequent flyers' who called 999 a lot. I calculated that the person who held the 'record' must have literally called 999 for an ambulance once every three hours of their waking life.

They were legally required to send one each time, so each of those 3-hour periods presumably included the dispatch, trip to hospital, examination and trip back home. Their life must have basically consisted of getting back home from hospital without needing any treatment and then immediately reaching for the phone to start the whole process off again - five or six times every single day.

It's a monumental abuse of resources and phenomenal waste of money, but I simply cannot imagine how terrifying it must be to be that person and to be trapped inside their mind 24/7. I'm astonished they were able (left) to live independently, really.

BiLuminous · 06/10/2021 01:20

@DisasterPasta

I don’t think muchausen by proxy is classed as a psychological disorder any more, it’s just a form of child abuse.

Classing it as a disorder the abuser has diminishes their responsibility and deflects from the real victim.

AFAIK, it's a disorder in the DSM5.
me4real · 06/10/2021 01:20

I know 2 people supposedly with it who are like that, and another who is oh-so-disabled by it she couldn't lift a hairbrush or something.

One of the things with fakers/exaggerators is their illness rarely stops them doing things they don't want to do. They can even miraculously stop needing the wheelchair they're supposedly confined to if they're meeting someone for a date, while ditching arrangements with friends.

Don't get me wrong, I have a severe disability myself so I understand about spoons and stuff.

me4real · 06/10/2021 01:15

@Tuesdayschildisfairofface Ehlers Danlos syndrome is a favorite of such types as while some people have it genuinely and severely, some people are being diagnosed with it nowadays when they just have joint pain with no apparent cause.

simitra · 06/10/2021 01:09

Looking back I suspect that my mother had a form of this. For as long as I can remember she had what we in the family called her "wobblers" but were actually panic attacks. She used to scream and cry and lose coherence of her speech.

As time went on we learned to dread any family get together, occasion or day out because it was sure to provoke one of my mothers meld downs. She revelled in the attention of docters, nurses and so on. She did have some physical illnesses which made various hospital visits and stays necessary. When these wre coming up she would sit down by the phone and ring EVERY member of the family to tell them about having to go into hospital. Then when she came out it was the same again in reverse - a blow by blow account of every moment of her stay there or visit, what the surgeon had said, and so on.

I was heartily glad when I went to live in another city as there were no mobiles, internet or social media then. My mother would have been posting on Farcebook every day about her health. When you live a distance away and work in a job which takes you abroad then its so much easier to "miss" all these calls. I know she drove my sister crazy.

SophieKaczynsky · 06/10/2021 00:58

Weirdly all the people that I know that always claim to be ill or have ill children all claim to her Erlers Danlos and/or Fibromyalgia. I know that both are both extremely real and debilitating health conditions, but I find it hard to believe that they all have these conditions, plus children with every condition under the sun, too.

monarchoftheglen · 06/10/2021 00:55

[quote SudokuWillNotSaveYou]Unfortunately, there’s an absolutely huge rabbit hole if you’re interested in this now, due to Munchausens by Internet. It’s the truly active frontier now for factitious disorders. There are people on things like Instagram and YouTube who run accounts about living with legitimate illnesses and use it as a way to connect with others facing the same symptoms or illnesses, but some have VERY popular accounts about illnesses and are believed to be faking, and then there are thousands of others who use sickness-based “sickstagram” accounts to figure out how to fake symptoms or follow what the “hip” new bandwagon illness is. Five year ago, very few people knew what Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome is, though it is a very real illness and there are people who have it; but now thousands upon thousands of girls and women on Instagram say they have it, many of them undiagnosed by a medical professional. Some who have eating disorders, specifically anorexia nervosa, have latched onto the illness gastroparesis and are all over Instagram tags for tube feeding. This is particularly dangerous, as people can die from complications with feeding tubes, associated surgeries, etc. Some have claimed autism (always high functioning and never medically diagnosed) and go so far as to post videos with fake stimming that have REALLY angered those with true, uncontrollable autism symptoms, not stimming that looks like dancing to music. It’s seriously like the Wild West out there, and they’ve just barely started research (it’s being called Munchausens by Internet as you can see in the research article, no terminology with factitious disorders yet). There are boards dedicated to being sick, and entire boards dedicated to tracking those who they deem to “fake” it, on opposite sides. Funnily enough, this article even features a quote from MN Towers:
www.theguardian.com/society/2015/apr/29/jules-gibson-munchausen-by-internet-sickness-bloggers-fake-it-whole-pantry

Source on the research:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3510683/[/quote]
There's a documentary somewhere about Belle Gibson and The Whole Pantry - I think it's on the BBC iPlayer

Ffs2020 · 06/10/2021 00:51

We suspect someone we know has something similar. Her dd does have autism and some other mild childhood type illnesses and conditions, but her mother tells everybody that she's going to need a wheelchair in the next year because she can't walk properly. She can. The child's dad spoke to the doctors who all told him that she'll outgrow most of her conditions, and that she's a perfectly healthy 8 year old otherwise. Mum's main motivations seem to be Facebook sympathy, and preventing contact with the dad.

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 06/10/2021 00:51

Not officially but a mum from a sn group im on has been investigated multiple times.

She had bath hoists, wheelchairs and mobility aids. All bought second hand. He didnt need any of it. But at home he was forced to use them.

She would overdose him on movicol so he had to wear nappies.

His only real diagnosis was ' failure to thrive' he was very small for his age. Any normal parent would offer food regularly at least, he wouldn't refuse food. He'd eat if offered, it just wouldnt occur to him to ask for it. If food was put down in front of him...... A friend of ours who'd started to get suspicious once went camping with them. She'd noticed the food thing too..... The boy ended up going from 10am until 11pm when my friend finally said something without eating. Who the hell doesn't feed their already tiny six year old?

She was extremely manipulative and would befriend professionals and in some cases school staff...... Yes, schools did get onto her and each time she'd move him. He attended every primary school in my town, and at least 3 secondary schools.

Tuesdayschildisfairofface · 06/10/2021 00:46

SudokuWillNotSaveYou. I totally agree with what you say about Munchausens By Internet. I have Ehlers Danlos Syndrome and after I was diagnosed looked online for info. I came across so many channels by young women (mainly in the US) who had just about every possible effect of EDS that it’s possible to have. They had braces on every limb and digit, huge neck braces, nasogastric tubes, catheters, rounds of surgeries and often had loads of piercings, tattoos and blue/green/pink hair. It was just so weird. I’ve been in so many outpatient clinics over the years and have rarely seen anyone in RL with Ehlers Danlos Syndrome in this state. Yes some are in wheelchairs and have a brace or too, but I’ve only seen a handful of people who have feeding tubes over the years. I know there’s different severities of the condition but they all seem to have the worst form of the type that can’t be tested for and a lot don’t even appear to have a proper diagnosis. It looks very performative and attention seeking. Most have gastroparisis, POTS. I think a lot of them have MH issues rather than EDS.

SophieKaczynsky · 06/10/2021 00:42

@Thewiseoneincognito oh god yes, the FB checking in at A&E does my head in. Usually this woman will check in at A&E and then go AWOL for hours so that all her fellow munchausens by proxy FB friends will be asking where she is and hopes she's ok. She will then update and say something like one of her kids had a splinter or a sore throat.

Oh and they also seem to have the world record in their house for the amount of times they've all apparently had covid, despite all getting their jabs very quickly as apparently all vulnerable

Thewiseoneincognito · 06/10/2021 00:37

@SophieKaczynsky very bizarre, it must be a thing because you described exactly what they do. Always moaning about the NHS services too.

Her posts tend to be ‘X and I in A&E for four hours again last night, Y still isn’t feeling up to school so is having a day in her pjs and Z fell out of her high chair again this morning so I’m on FB in A&E again, signal isn’t great’. Literally every other week.

julieca · 06/10/2021 00:36

Alos knew a woman who claimed to be in constant pain and the Drs would not help her. Her partner used to advocate for her and take her to A and E for emergency pain relief, until she realised her partner was a drug addict and seeking strong painkillers.

me4real · 06/10/2021 00:32

One would pretend to have a fall, lie on the floor and call the ambulance. Dd stuff like that repeatedly, always posting about iit on FB. Even took a fake potentially lethal overdose. It is hard not to be annoyed.

SophieKaczynsky · 06/10/2021 00:31

@Thewiseoneincognito the daily FB health updates are just so bizarre aren't they! Every single day at least one of this woman's kids has some issue or another, whether it's a cold, anxiety, allergy, an injury. She also decided a couple of years back that all 5 kids were far too anxious for school so she home schools them. Poor kids

me4real · 06/10/2021 00:30

I've known a couple of medical malingerers, fakers and attention seekers who annoyed nurses etc.

NoLeafClover · 06/10/2021 00:30

@owlbethere

I think the thing to remember about people with factitious disorder is they ARE unwell, just not with the things they fake, it’s a psychological problem. As a child I used to fake illnesses or pretend illnesses were worse than they were because it was the only time I got my mothers attention. I stopped when I was in my teens because it wasnt really working anymore and took up ED and self harm instead. I was a very lonely sad neglected child and only years of therapy have helped.
Absolutely, it's an illness in itself. One that unfortunately generates less sympathy than physical illnesses or even other MH illnesses, but it's definitely an illness. Nobody chooses to live like that. I can however understand why it angers people, as it can do so much harm. The person I mentioned did so much harm to their child, and to the rest of their family.

And I'm very sorry for what you went through. I've battled an ED, I've self-harmed, so I have some understanding of your pain. It's so difficult.

Thewiseoneincognito · 06/10/2021 00:29

@SophieKaczynsky there’s a few on my FB who are they same. A constant stream of daily updates on their sickly children. Surely their GP should be alerting social services if kids keep having accidents or being ill constantly is it not a sign of poor nutrition or abuse?

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 06/10/2021 00:27

Unfortunately, there’s an absolutely huge rabbit hole if you’re interested in this now, due to Munchausens by Internet. It’s the truly active frontier now for factitious disorders. There are people on things like Instagram and YouTube who run accounts about living with legitimate illnesses and use it as a way to connect with others facing the same symptoms or illnesses, but some have VERY popular accounts about illnesses and are believed to be faking, and then there are thousands of others who use sickness-based “sickstagram” accounts to figure out how to fake symptoms or follow what the “hip” new bandwagon illness is. Five year ago, very few people knew what Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome is, though it is a very real illness and there are people who have it; but now thousands upon thousands of girls and women on Instagram say they have it, many of them undiagnosed by a medical professional. Some who have eating disorders, specifically anorexia nervosa, have latched onto the illness gastroparesis and are all over Instagram tags for tube feeding. This is particularly dangerous, as people can die from complications with feeding tubes, associated surgeries, etc. Some have claimed autism (always high functioning and never medically diagnosed) and go so far as to post videos with fake stimming that have REALLY angered those with true, uncontrollable autism symptoms, not stimming that looks like dancing to music. It’s seriously like the Wild West out there, and they’ve just barely started research (it’s being called Munchausens by Internet as you can see in the research article, no terminology with factitious disorders yet). There are boards dedicated to being sick, and entire boards dedicated to tracking those who they deem to “fake” it, on opposite sides. Funnily enough, this article even features a quote from MN Towers:
www.theguardian.com/society/2015/apr/29/jules-gibson-munchausen-by-internet-sickness-bloggers-fake-it-whole-pantry

Source on the research:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3510683/

Thewiseoneincognito · 06/10/2021 00:26

I believe I know someone with it -but how on Earth can it be proven?

SophieKaczynsky · 06/10/2021 00:25

I have noticed too that FB seems to be a platform for people to go on about their/their children's ailments and to get attention, which I think encourages them to make up even more issues.

Someone on my FB has five kids and literally every day she does a FB status asking for advice about one of them about some illness or condition she thinks they might have. If anyone else mentions their kids have X, Y or Z condition then sure enough soon she can will suspect that one of her kids has it, too.

She loves attention and approval from others so this is clearly why she does it. She even tries to start 'Go Fund Me' pages for her kids to see private doctors and other health professionals as NHS always say the kids don't have the conditions she claims they do.