Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To know anyone irl with munchausens?

506 replies

Lw87 · 05/10/2021 22:21

Watching the gypsy rose doc, I'd never heard of munchausens disease before and can't even think I'd know anyone with it in real life

Has anyone actually had an RL encounter with someone with this?

OP posts:
me4real · 06/10/2021 03:25

@BlackeyedSusan I thiink maybe the people are being told they have hypermobility and then pronouncing themselves to have EDS. Or maybe they've just read stuff online.

Sunshinebuttercups · 06/10/2021 02:50

@Tuesdayschildisfairofface I would say EDS is being far less diagnosed. In my area the lead paediatric rheumatologist is very anti EDS/hypermobility. @Becca19962014 it’s interesting you mention Professor Potson because the same doctor wrote an article for the BMJ criticising him. I have 2 friends who asked for second opinions from GOSH and both children got diagnosed with hyper mobility syndrome.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 06/10/2021 02:49

Not Munchausens, no - but I have known several hypochondriacs.

And then there's the people like my mum, who always had a cold worse than anyone else (Flu), or pretty much anything worse than anyone else EVAH. (Until she was actually seriously ill, then she'd downplay it).

BlackeyedSusan · 06/10/2021 02:17

hEDS is the commonest, "mildest" EDS on average but still has strict criteria some of which can not be faked. (The bendiness, those little bumps on the side of your feet, the stretchy skin as opposed to reported pain)

It is very sensitive to progesterone... DD got a lot worse before puberty. I got worse during menopause but have improved a bit again.

Becca19962014 · 06/10/2021 02:08

@Lw87 sorry I've derailed your thread with my experiences. It wasn't my intention.

@me4real I'm off to try rest soon too. My PMs are open. I'll try and remember to reply! I'd I don't, I may have forgotten or my device has gone south (it's very old!)

@Tuesdayschildisfairofface I wonder if it's down to it being in more journals etc but it's often written up WRONGLY and then assumptions are made. I had both knees subluxed despite telling the clinician I had the condition, he just said "yeh yeh" and then grabbed my ankles to move my hips causing a huge amount of pain (I've no cartridge left in my knees and they need replacing) he didn't believe he hurt me until I showed him knees gradually going purple and swelling.

I don't know what the new criteria is I must admit, I was diagnosed by Prof Grahame before he retired. I know my "score" was almost double the maximum and he was "impressed"!

Tuesdayschildisfairofface · 06/10/2021 02:02

Becca. I’m so sorry you experienced all that.

I’m wondering if EDS is going from being underdiagnosed to over diagnosed. I was misdiagnosed for years as no one put all the weird and wonderful things I had going on together. I was diagnosed just after the criteria changed in 2017 and it was an all day job at The hospital.

me4real · 06/10/2021 02:01

@Becca19962014 Am going to bed sooon buut sending you a PM x

me4real · 06/10/2021 02:00

Plus, I know the HCPs would be professional and civil with you, but they'd hardly be effusively friendly or sympathetic when they see that it's you yet again, wasting their time once more, would they?

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll No but then that becomes part of the soap opera. Medical Staff did X, Y, Z to me proclaimed all over FB etc.

I know of a notorious person online (won't name names in case I get post removed) apparently combines calling the fire brigade with flashing or something.

Becca19962014 · 06/10/2021 01:58

@me4real I've none at all now. Not even GP in 18 months. My conditions are so much worse now. It's a mess as they keep referring back to how things were then forgetting the illness deteriorates !!

It's very frightening doing it alone i admit. Even more so as I know my benefits are due to be renewed and won't be without any support at all.

me4real · 06/10/2021 01:56

@Becca19962014 I hope you come across some doctors/consultants who treat you well. Finding a (comparatively) good'un can make all the difference.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 06/10/2021 01:54

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll To some extent they enjoy it, I mean they're constantly getting that 'hit' of attenton and drama. I suppose it might be a bit like an addiction and in the rare event any of them wanted to stop, they'd have to break the habit.

People can maybe snap out of it a bit if they have something else happening in their life to keep their interest- work or something.

May well be, but it still can't be any kind of life wanting to spend all your days doing that. I could maybe understand somebody who 'loves the drama' doing it even once a week or so, but 5 or 6 times every single day?! You wouldn't get a single other thing done - ever - whether necessary or pleasurable, because your schedule was already jam-packed with spurious hospital visits.

Plus, I know the HCPs would be professional and civil with you, but they'd hardly be effusively friendly or sympathetic when they see that it's you yet again, wasting their time once more, would they?

me4real · 06/10/2021 01:53

Sorry to hear that @Becca19962014 , I hope it doesn't turn out that way. Flowers

There are many different clinical types of EDS so I imagine the fakers/exaggerators have a very mild type that doesn't effect any significant bodily structures.

Becca19962014 · 06/10/2021 01:53

@me4real I've tried, believe me but they won't budge. I don't even believe mental health diangoses actually help in my experience they just fuel prejudice.

No one cares what's actually happening.

If they did then they'd be forced to do something to help me...

Much easier to slap the borderline label on, and then manipulate everything to "prove it". Like the therapist I mentioned, despite being proven right that complaint against him is still used to prove I refuse to engage and stalk staff (hardly stalking is it to check someones qualifications! Or lack thereof in his case).

NeedTesla · 06/10/2021 01:51

@me4real

As some other posters have mentioned, unfortunately accusations of FII are genuinely levelled at the Mother and often on baseless grounds.

@Sunshinebuttercups A friend of mine was hinted at by doctors that she might get labelled as having Munchausen's by Proxy (she was a new mum and also a nurse, and I think nurses can develop some anxieties around illness etc.)

So when her son was next off colour, she didn't go to the hospital immediately as she had been told she was on the verge of being labelled as Munchausen's.

Her son had a fractured leg and she's had her child taken off her and been accused of neglect because she didn't immediately take him to the hosp. Angry

That’s so sad. I do agree that some health professionals have health anxiety. I think I do following a mistake I witnessed that had serious consequences for the child. So I do worry excessively about things being missed.
Becca19962014 · 06/10/2021 01:48

@Tuesdayschildisfairofface I think it depends on your doctors as well. I know being put on a saline drip is like the best thing ever for me. Really seriously perks me up and that's recognised in literature for autonomic issues BUT it's also recognised that there's a rebound effect so it's not used as treatment in the U.K. whereas in the U.S. it is for autonomic issues.

EDS criteria was tightened, but many Drs don't actually know the criteria in the uk. It's usually just down to "being a bit bendy" when it's much much more than that.

Mine is severely effecting my neck, I was given two years before it collapsed and I died. It hasn't yet but I've been told it will and nothing can be done. It's a very rare thing to have happen but it does to some people and I was told my mental health has a role in that - I suffer with night terrors and PTSD which means my neck muscles are used a lot. My knees have already collapsed due to it, my one hip is totally wrecked.

me4real · 06/10/2021 01:48

@Becca19962014 So sorry you had those experiences. Sad I hope you can get that taken off your notes somehow. xx I was misdiagnosed with Alcohol Dependency Disorder a couple of weeks before I was admitted to hospital wiith bipolar, and that's at the top of my notes. Shock I hope to try and get it taken off soon.

You can imagine/will know from your own experience how it means doctors act towards me.

I was accused of having Borderline but got diagnosed with some ADHD in the end. If you can get them to consider what was actually happening, or to see new consultants, you might be able to get it taken off. My current consultant says 'everyone has traiits of something but if you really had Borderline, your life would be far more chaotic.'

NotMyCat · 06/10/2021 01:45

There's a lot on Instagram, and also illness fakers on Reddit
MCAS seems to be the one at the minute (I have chronic urticaria and it comes up in the tags on insta sometimes)

But then I get the frustration at something not being right. I spent years in and out the doctors with infections and just not being well. Eight years it took for someone to look at every blood test and chart them and realise I had virtually no white blood cells which funnily = constant infections. I was diagnosed after that very quickly and on medication and now rarely need to see the GP!

Tuesdayschildisfairofface · 06/10/2021 01:42

me4real. When I was diagnosed it was a whole process with very strict criteria. I have it mild to moderately and I am lucky not to have too many gastric problems. I have family members with it worse than I do but literally no one I have come across in RL with EDS come close to the women with it on YouTube. Oh actually there’s one woman who does seem very similar and in her 30s is in some sort of care home. She clearly has serious MH issues that I think are driving a lot of her eds problems. She is constantly posting on Facebook everything that’s going on with her and videos of her walking with her legs wobbling a lot while using crutches. She then reports that she fainted after she stopped filming due to POTS/dysautonomia or FND ( functional neurological disorder)I really feel for her.

purplejungle · 06/10/2021 01:39

Have come across FII twice in 8 years of SW practice.

Becca19962014 · 06/10/2021 01:38

My underlying condition that's considered to be the root cause of all my physical needs is Ehlers Danlos Syndrome.

Becca19962014 · 06/10/2021 01:37

I was diagnosed as borderline because I was fostered too.

To quote the "expert therapist" I saw at cmht "my parents didn't want me so what would anyone else want with me except abuse" when I got angry, given he told me my parents were lovely and I'd rejected them at birth and they DID abuse me, and my foster family didn't (and are long time dead) I was rightly annoyed, he took it as proof. This was decades ago. I still remember them and their kindness, yep like all kids there was telling off but that was all it was. My parents idea of telling me off was to bounce my head off a brick wall (I'm not kidding).

Turned out this "expert therapist" was nothing of the sort. He got fired for lying about his qualifications, as in he was doing a night course in counselling that was it. His professional qualifications didn't exist at all and when I reported him (over a decade before he was caught) I was then put in a room with him whilst he had a go at me for being extremely passive aggressive and unfair and a bully trying to get him fired when he just cared and wanted to help.

Now he's banned for life from ever registering as a therapist, or nurse (he also pretended to be a nurse) or working with any vulnerable people.

Yet the diagnosis of "borderline" is still on the front of my notes.

SophieKaczynsky · 06/10/2021 01:34

I keep thinking of more people I've known in the past that I suspect have at the very least exaggerated their medical history.

When my youngest child was at primary school there was a mum who often walked with a stick but was always very cagey about why she needed said stick. She also, as has been mentioned upthread, only seemed to have her disability and her stick when it suited her. I saw her running on the treadmill at the gym for example, and then an hour later hobbling in the school gates with her stick where people would be holding the gate open for her and moving out of her way to let her through. She had two kids that also had apparent disabilities but again she was very vague about what they were

A big group of us went on a day trip to London and she took her stick and genuinely seemed to love the attention and the fact that everyone was fussing over her and giving her the best seat at the show we went to see, and carrying her bag for her.

me4real · 06/10/2021 01:34

As some other posters have mentioned, unfortunately accusations of FII are genuinely levelled at the Mother and often on baseless grounds.

@Sunshinebuttercups A friend of mine was hinted at by doctors that she might get labelled as having Munchausen's by Proxy (she was a new mum and also a nurse, and I think nurses can develop some anxieties around illness etc.)

So when her son was next off colour, she didn't go to the hospital immediately as she had been told she was on the verge of being labelled as Munchausen's.

Her son had a fractured leg and she's had her child taken off her and been accused of neglect because she didn't immediately take him to the hosp. Angry

teenmumandsowhat · 06/10/2021 01:33

As someone who has genuine chonic conditions this is something that really annoys me.
I have (and have been properly diagnosed with etc) Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension, Nerve damage- now being simply referred to as fibromyalgia by the doctors! Hmm and a Not fully diagnosed, but obvious according to My neuros case of Functional Neurological syndrome disorder (FND)

Unfortunately all of these have been used by “fakers” as a result, everytime I’m genuinely ill it is so much more difficult to get taken seriously until I deteriorate considerably because of the stereotypes that have developed.

BlackeyedSusan · 06/10/2021 01:30

Lots of people with hypermobility disorders (including hEDS) get accused of this (fii) it is specifically mentioned in the RCGP Ehlers-Danlos toolkit with the tag line, "if you can't connect the issues, think connective tissues." Quite frankly connective tissues hold everything together so it is hardly surprising that lots of body systems are going to be a bit fucked.

According to academic research, those with HSDs have a higher incidence of other conditions such as autism, asthma, allergies, arthritis, gut issues, POTS, bladder issues, mast cell disorders....

Plus hypermobility is genetic passed on 50% of the time so it is likely that parents and child are going to be always having medical issues.

Try Marco Castori for academic papers or prof Graham though he is retired now. Many are linked to by the HSD society/charity in the UK. ( From where I got most of my info on DD and my HSD)

Swipe left for the next trending thread