Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To know anyone irl with munchausens?

506 replies

Lw87 · 05/10/2021 22:21

Watching the gypsy rose doc, I'd never heard of munchausens disease before and can't even think I'd know anyone with it in real life

Has anyone actually had an RL encounter with someone with this?

OP posts:
QuarantineQueen · 06/10/2021 09:08

I think we need to remember that Munchausens (or FII as it is now called) is extremely rare.
Women with chronic conditions causing all sorts of symptoms dismissed and left untreated by doctors? Extremely common.
Don't armchair diagnose. It is far more likely that people you know who seem to have endless symptoms are just being dismissed by their doctors and their chronic illnesses are going untreated than the very rare chance that they have Munchausens.

Sunshinebuttercups · 06/10/2021 09:07

@TheDaydreamBelievers MUS, physically unexplained symptoms, non-epileptic seizures do not always have a psychological cause. One of the reasons behind the change from conversion disorder to functional neurological disorder was because there were patients where no underlying psychological problems could be found. These patients would get batted from neurology and psychiatry (and still often do) being told “not our discipline”.

There definitely is still a massive problem in medicine with the mind and body being seen as 2 separate entities when of course it is not as simple as that. Most illness have a bio-psych-social-elements.

NotPersephone · 06/10/2021 09:05

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Tuesdayschildisfairofface · 06/10/2021 08:56

Iloveeverytypeofcat. I read about the woman who died after complications from surgeries for EDS. So so tragic. There seems to be a very different attitude in the US to treating people with it, with surgeries seeming to be not at all unusual. Here surgery is the last resort after everything else has been tried. I need my sacro-iliac joint pinning but they are still dickering because of the iffy outcome of surgery in people with EDS.

sunshinebuttercups. It definitely seems harder to get a diagnosis for EDS after the criteria changed but I wonder if people self-diagnose more as awareness of the condition has grown. It’s good there is awareness though because it took till I was in my 50s to get diagnosed after a lifetime of dislocations, tendonitis, wounds that take forever to heal, skin that tears. I didn’t walk till I was nearly 3 and used to ask my Mum to go to bed after dinner at 6pm because I was so tired and she would try to persuade me to stay up longer. I was in searing pain after eating at times. Things were clearly not right from early childhood but no one thought anything of it other than I was a sickly child and everything was dealt with separately but more often just or ignored. As an adult the GP was often very dismissive but if a man had turned up with similar problems they’d have probably been sent for a whole load of tests. Chronic conditions in women are rarely taken at all seriously . It’s awful.

TheDaydreamBelievers · 06/10/2021 08:55

There's a few different mental health conditions (with decent overlaps) that are being discussed here.

Fictitious disorder - in self or imposed on another. In this condition, the person knows they/the other person is not truly unwell. However they still seek medical input, for reasons that can be unclear. Its very rare. More common in women as described above or in unmarried men 30-50. There seems to be something in it about seeking caring. If 'by proxy', this is almost always someone they are in a caring role for.

The phrase "malingering" isn't a diagnosis, but refers to the above where there is an obvious benefit for doing so. For example someone suing another person after a car crash pretends to have worse injuries than they do to increase compensation.

Persistent physical symptoms/medically unexplained symptoms/somatic symptoms disorder/non epileptic seizures - all of these refer to physical symptoms which have a psychological cause. The separation from factitious disorders is that these individuals do not create or lie about symptoms consciously. They do have these symptoms, but do not realise they are originating from a psychological place. Often people with PPS have an existing physical health condition and the psychosomatic symptoms are additional to it, related to stress and distress.

Health anxiety - about yourself or someone else. Someone affected may notice physical symptoms more than others because they are so focused on worries about being unwell. They may mistake anxiety symptoms for being unwell. They feel momentarily better once checked out by a medic but then typically build anxiety about it again.

I really want to stress that 1) all the above conditions are a source or expression of great distress and 2) the other possibility is that the person has a physical health condition that is not diagnosed. Medics are not perfect and do miss things. People are thought to be anxious/somatic/fabricating who later turn out to have a physical condition that had not been identified.

EllaPaella · 06/10/2021 08:55

There is a difference between fabricated illness and illness anxiety disorder though. Some people truly believe there is something wrong with them when there isn't- that isn't the same as Munchausen's. Munchausens is when you fabricate symptoms and at times actually harm yourself to deceive medical professionals and even interfere with tests.
Believing you are ill when you aren't is a different disorder.

TaRaLa · 06/10/2021 08:53

@Tuesdayschildisfairofface I’ve not checked but you remind me of another poster who had mild EDS who always goes on about the fact that she has it mildly means no one else could be severe. Mum friends daughter has it severely, she has all the things you listed as making people fake.
Do you really think in the U.K. she would have a feeding tube surgically made for shits and giggles? The doctors have to be sure they are doing the right thing.

You always seem to come on here and spout that you haven’t seen people in U.K. or clinics. We’ll if you’re mild you won’t be in hospital and someone with e PEG you won’t see and the sickest are at home or in other clinics for their specialty for that surgery they’ve had.
It’s great you are mildly affected but you spouting things like this is the reason my lovely friend god considered for FII, but her daughter is genuinely ill and has the surgeries you state weren’t needed. Perhaps you can write to her NHS consultants and ask why they did surgery with no medical evidence on this child?

Yes some people have a social media presence, I guess if you are disabled and dependent on family then having no career and life and having a following makes you feel like you have a purpose in life?

But please look outside your own box. Just because you haven’t seen in doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen.

rainbowdashsneeze · 06/10/2021 08:45

Yes my mother has it and it has impacted all of our lives for many many years.

5zeds · 06/10/2021 08:43

Yes I know someone I think struggles with this. We have several (obvious) disabilities and illnesses and it took me a LONG time to realise her interest was in symptoms mirroring rather than support. It was a very confusing and painful experience as I thought it was friendship and some of it was.

Chickychickydodah · 06/10/2021 08:42

Yes I do. I know someone who has both and loves her and her dh to be ill all the time. I think it also has to do with the fact they are claiming disability money so they “have “ to be ill .

justanoldhack · 06/10/2021 08:41

Some really sad stories here. Noticed also that pretty much all (bar a couple) cases are about women who are afflicted with this. I wonder whether it affects women more than men, and if so, why?

SedentaryCat · 06/10/2021 08:37

Yes, someone at the DCs primary school. Lost touch now, but still hear things through mutual friends. They were mainly focussed on their child's mental health. They went through a messy divorce and really needed professional support which they were unable to access. Issues were projected onto the child.

Child ended up with several diagnoses that are inaccurate and which have now limited their life choices.

QOD · 06/10/2021 08:35

🤷🏻‍♀️ it was in her medical records
I think it was in the early 90’s she got that label and turned to homeopathic remedies and attention
She had a lot of unnecessary surgery and medication from the late 60’s on

ShaneTheThird · 06/10/2021 08:27

I watched a documentary on it ages ago on Amazon prime, can't remember the name but it was so shocking. It told both sides of the story, from one family falsely accused of M by proxy when their baby actually had a serious genetic illness that eventually killed him, the drs blamed the mother and said she was causing his illness. The saddest part was visually you could tell this baby had Genetic illness so it was appalling she was accused. Then it told real cases including hard to watch footage a Dr secretly filmed in hospital one night. The baby in questions heart rate kept going erratic and dropping but they couldn't physically tell why on tests except a CCG. So the Dr noticed it always happened when the mother was alone with him so he set up a camera and filmed the mother smothering the baby until his heart rate shot up and then she stopped and comforted the crying baby. Was hard to watch.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 06/10/2021 08:27

I do believe that women are often under-diagnosed though, especially for chronic illness. I have a friend who felt very ill, and exhausted and just not 'there' somehow, and her doctor convinced her, as did others around her, that it was just her depression returning coupled with low iron. I remember saying to her 'but you aren't depressed'! She said 'I know'. She eventually had a very dramatic episode, got taken to hospital, diagnosed with a brain tumour and has since died. She was lovely, I miss that friend. I don't think it would have changed anything as it was such an aggressive tumour but I just remember her distress at being told it was just her depression coming back when she and I knew she wasn't depressed.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 06/10/2021 08:24

I have a male family member who has continuous 'illnesses' and presents at A and E and Minor Injuries pretty frequently, although not all the time. Never anything really wrong, had 100's of scans, seen so many consultants, definitely doesn't feel great a lot but also has MH issues which have gone largely untreated.

This is not Munchausens though, they aren't faking their illness, they feel very ill and then seek help, it's just that their illnesses are linked to their MH conditions, so dizziness, breathlessness, weakness, balance and so forth. These conditions also fluctuate so if they want to do something fun, they often find a way, or travel, or holiday, but the rest of the time are 'disabled' by them.

It is very tiring to be around this for a lifetime and I find myself losing attention when they yet again tell me about their life-threatening trip to hospital (which leaves them absolutely fine!)

Covidworries · 06/10/2021 08:22

Yes it awful mental illness. On the other end of the scale is parents fighting for help a not not being taken seriously. I sure the doctors suspected I was making stuff up with my eldest. Kept getting fobbed off until one doctor diagnosed a serious defect . On the same day that doctor found it a different doctor told us nothing was wrong with child. Life saving surgery was needed for this condition. I spent yrs believing i didnt have any mothers instinct because every dr appt i was told child had no problem.

crochetmonkey74 · 06/10/2021 08:21

Teacher here and one family I know of where the children were always ill, or broken bones but every illness or injury took ages to heal and the suspicion was they were tampering with the recovery. Children removed several times and then returned- when removed , they were healthy and recovered quickly from everything. Eventually they were fully removed for other reasons so it was never really addressed

thepastisanothercountry · 06/10/2021 08:18

@olympicsrock

I have seen patients who have done this. One patient went round A abs E departments pretending to have been raped. That was pretty distressing as a health care professional .
A major problem with these ones is when they follow it up with the police and ruin the lives of those they accuse and sadly this happens too particularly if a third party reports concerns then they feel they have to follow it through. It can get very very nasty. I know someone who was on the receiving end of this and ended up in a police cell then waiting for 2 years until the CPS decided on no further action.
frumpety · 06/10/2021 08:18

I had another parent at school practically accuse me of Munchausens by proxy over a diagnosis my child had, she asked me how I had managed to 'convince' the Doctors to believe 'my' diagnosis, I said it was really simple , I took the child to the Doctors where the symptoms were obvious and we were sent to the nearest large teaching hospital for specific tests which confirmed what the Doctor saw.
She was very friendly with a TA at the school and I think she had managed to convince them and some of the other staff, that I was making it all up, given some of the looks I got for a while. DC's symptoms worsened before they got better, so all the staff witnessed them and the funny looks stopped.

LindaEllen · 06/10/2021 08:14

I know a girl who displays symptoms of munchausens by proxy. She is constantly posting things online about the health of her child, taking him to A&E, giving him gluten even though he shouldn't be eating it - so he has symptoms worthy of taking him in.

She's clearly very unwell and her parents have written several times on their own social medias explaining the situation - so we don't worry about the little boy.

CallMeNutribullet · 06/10/2021 08:13

Gypsy manipulated a damaged young man into murdering her mother then they posted on Facebook that they'd killed the bitch or something similar.

She's been abused her entire life but this wasn't self defense. She's a victim but her abuse has made her extremely manipulative herself. She won't serve the full 10 years and she's getting extremely specialised help in prison- I think she's where she needs to be right now.

kinzarose · 06/10/2021 08:13

There was a school mum who supposedly had every single disability under the sun, but was the martyr about it. "oh you know me, I just get on with it". Despite walking completely normally and walking 20 minutes to school, her mobility was very limited apparently. The last I saw of her she was telling me that she was moving soon as she needed a fully adaptable bungalow as her mobility was so poor. Apparently all the specialists in the world in the hospital couldn't believe how well she battled on. It was all because of her positive mindset you see, disability wasn't a label to her Hmm

userxx · 06/10/2021 08:11

Where are you watching the documentary?

ShaneTheThird · 06/10/2021 08:07

Yes my neighbour had it by proxy. Made her kid have a feeding tube and everything. I lived in a small community then and one day she took her kid to the Dr and the Dr took out the feeding tube saying she absolutely did not need it and my neighbour screamed the place down that the Dr was murdering her child. We all witnessed that kid eating normal food on multiple occasions. Anytime anyone in our community was diagnosed with something she said her kid had it too. Including when my friends child was diagnosed with autism, selective mutism, OCD and ADHD she claimed her kid had the exact same diagnosis. The weird bit was she actually had 2 kids and completely ignored one of them.