Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To know anyone irl with munchausens?

506 replies

Lw87 · 05/10/2021 22:21

Watching the gypsy rose doc, I'd never heard of munchausens disease before and can't even think I'd know anyone with it in real life

Has anyone actually had an RL encounter with someone with this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
damageReputation · 11/03/2023 11:21

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 11:08

Exactly, I’m seeing it in real life. You’re not. So I’m certain I know this person more than you do. & just because I didn’t mention how it could be from a different perspective doesn’t mean I’m not aware of it.

The OP wasn’t about FII from a different perspective. It was did anyone know anyone with it IRL. Hence why the majority of people on here have shared their experiences they’ve had or witnessed with people who have or potentially have FII.

Now if this post was about people falsely accused of having FII I wouldn’t have commented because I don’t know anyone accused of having FII. But the post wasn’t about that was it. So on that note have a great day 👌

Hopefully I’ve opened your mind to the possibility of an alternative explanation for this person’s presentation

CuriousMama · 11/03/2023 11:10

SophieKaczynsky · 05/10/2021 22:29

I know someone whom I suspect has munchausens and also munchausens by proxy. Of course, I can never prove it so I keep my mouth shut, but I do feel for her three children, who all seem to have medical issue after medical issue.

I'd be reporting that to SS. You can do it anonymously.

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 11:08

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 10:57

I don’t claim to be an expert I just can see things from both sides. Obviously you are seeing this is real life and I’m not so your judgement is based on that . I’m just offering an alternative perspective because if someone gets this wrong it could devastate a family and destroy a child’s life who needs their parents.

As you say, professionals have this on their radar and they will be best placed to assess the parents and their intentions. I just want people to be aware how rare FII is and how it’s more likely a false accusation will destroy a family than for it to be a genuine case of child abuse.

FII/munchausens can’t be discussed without mentioning the high percentage of those falsely accused because it’s an absolute scandal. Nearly always parents of children with a genuine diagnosed illness, often mothers with ASD and as they don’t act how society thinks they should act under the pressure of having an unwell child immediately that is a red flag.

Exactly, I’m seeing it in real life. You’re not. So I’m certain I know this person more than you do. & just because I didn’t mention how it could be from a different perspective doesn’t mean I’m not aware of it.

The OP wasn’t about FII from a different perspective. It was did anyone know anyone with it IRL. Hence why the majority of people on here have shared their experiences they’ve had or witnessed with people who have or potentially have FII.

Now if this post was about people falsely accused of having FII I wouldn’t have commented because I don’t know anyone accused of having FII. But the post wasn’t about that was it. So on that note have a great day 👌

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 10:57

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 10:49

I’m no expert in FII but I’m pretty sure I can tell the difference between a parent who puts on a brave face or just deals with their child’s illness differently compared to a parent who takes enjoyment of the attention they get when their child is poorly. But since you seem to be the expert here so I’m sure you know. There’s no accusation, everyone who knows this person has said the same. But like I said, you seem to know more 😂So crack on with your educated self & as for the parents who have been accused of having FII I feel sorry for them. As for the parents who do have FII I don’t feel sorry for them. But this OP wasn’t about parents who have been falsely accused is it. This was about people who DO have it.

I don’t claim to be an expert I just can see things from both sides. Obviously you are seeing this is real life and I’m not so your judgement is based on that . I’m just offering an alternative perspective because if someone gets this wrong it could devastate a family and destroy a child’s life who needs their parents.

As you say, professionals have this on their radar and they will be best placed to assess the parents and their intentions. I just want people to be aware how rare FII is and how it’s more likely a false accusation will destroy a family than for it to be a genuine case of child abuse.

FII/munchausens can’t be discussed without mentioning the high percentage of those falsely accused because it’s an absolute scandal. Nearly always parents of children with a genuine diagnosed illness, often mothers with ASD and as they don’t act how society thinks they should act under the pressure of having an unwell child immediately that is a red flag.

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 10:49

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 10:36

I’m not looking for an argument I’m just trying to point out that under stress people cope in very different ways. What you perceive as ‘revelling in it’ or being happy to be in hospital or attending a and e for no reason there could be behind closed doors a parent in pieces , over anxious so going to a and e for that reason not for attention, seeming happy but actually desperately trying to put on a brave face for her child and for herself.

I might be right and you might be wrong or vice versa. Can you imagine the devastation though if an accusation of this caused removal of a terminally ill child ? Just because a parent doesn’t present in a way everyone expects them to when under stress

I’m no expert in FII but I’m pretty sure I can tell the difference between a parent who puts on a brave face or just deals with their child’s illness differently compared to a parent who takes enjoyment of the attention they get when their child is poorly. But since you seem to be the expert here so I’m sure you know. There’s no accusation, everyone who knows this person has said the same. But like I said, you seem to know more 😂So crack on with your educated self & as for the parents who have been accused of having FII I feel sorry for them. As for the parents who do have FII I don’t feel sorry for them. But this OP wasn’t about parents who have been falsely accused is it. This was about people who DO have it.

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 10:36

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 10:16

I’m a mother of a child with a terminal
disease. I don’t revel in it, I certainly don’t make his life harder to garner sympathy, I don’t purposely take him to A&E & lie to get him on to the wards. So maybe stop twisting my words. Everyone else has voiced their opinion but funnily enough it’s just mine you’ve picked up on. When have I said that all parents have FII? I haven’t have I. You’re just implying I have. Im
speaking on someone I know personally enough to know when it’s genuine & when it’s fake, just like everyone else on this thread. So stop looking for arguments. Just plain odd.

I’m not looking for an argument I’m just trying to point out that under stress people cope in very different ways. What you perceive as ‘revelling in it’ or being happy to be in hospital or attending a and e for no reason there could be behind closed doors a parent in pieces , over anxious so going to a and e for that reason not for attention, seeming happy but actually desperately trying to put on a brave face for her child and for herself.

I might be right and you might be wrong or vice versa. Can you imagine the devastation though if an accusation of this caused removal of a terminally ill child ? Just because a parent doesn’t present in a way everyone expects them to when under stress

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 10:16

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 10:09

But by posting what you did you’ve dived into her life on mumsnet ..

Being a parent of a genuinely ill child and being accused of FII/ munchausens is horrendous. It’s such a rare type of abuse that the odds of being wrongly accused are so much higher than the chance of someone actually having munchausens. It can rip families apart.

I’m a mother of a child with a terminal
disease. I don’t revel in it, I certainly don’t make his life harder to garner sympathy, I don’t purposely take him to A&E & lie to get him on to the wards. So maybe stop twisting my words. Everyone else has voiced their opinion but funnily enough it’s just mine you’ve picked up on. When have I said that all parents have FII? I haven’t have I. You’re just implying I have. Im
speaking on someone I know personally enough to know when it’s genuine & when it’s fake, just like everyone else on this thread. So stop looking for arguments. Just plain odd.

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 10:09

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 10:03

I’m not about to dive into her life on Mumsnet. I’m aware the team Know as the mum herself has told me. Any attention is good attention to her unfortunately. I simply replied to OPs post. I’m not here to get into some Piers Morgan Debate about it 🙃

But by posting what you did you’ve dived into her life on mumsnet ..

Being a parent of a genuinely ill child and being accused of FII/ munchausens is horrendous. It’s such a rare type of abuse that the odds of being wrongly accused are so much higher than the chance of someone actually having munchausens. It can rip families apart.

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 10:03

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 09:59

Would A+E not assess/test and only admit if there was a clinical need ?

Are you saying she is inducing symptoms or withholding medication to worsen a genuine condition? How are you aware that they team know anything as they shouldn’t be discussing this where anyone else could hear ?

I’m not about to dive into her life on Mumsnet. I’m aware the team Know as the mum herself has told me. Any attention is good attention to her unfortunately. I simply replied to OPs post. I’m not here to get into some Piers Morgan Debate about it 🙃

BlackeyedSusan · 11/03/2023 10:00

damageReputation · 07/10/2021 19:34

FII is incredibly rare this thread is just bitchy and gossipy. Unless you’re with someone 24/7 you have no idea.

Lots of parents with children with hidden disabilities get accused of this or if the children have ASD and mask at school. It is an incredibly damaging accusation and not something that shown be thrown around so carelessly as there are far more cases of harm done by wrongful accusations than there are of real FII cases.

Given academic peer reviewed research (Castori et al) has found that hypermobility syndrome disorder in associated with an increased risk of asthma, allergies, autism, gut issues, bladder issues and a whole host of other things... which are the list of things ffi training articles say to look for.... I imagine there are several.people who have been accused of this and it's not. Met two of them on a course and I've not met that many parents of autistic children who have shared enough to know.

And given that autism often has a genetic link, autistic parents of autistic children are often accused as the way their autism presents is similar to how people are told ffi parents present, quite a few accused cases are going to be bog standard autism and hypermobility.

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 09:59

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 09:42

Maybe I haven’t explained it properly. She basically revels in her daughter being sick. She purposely takes her to A&E so they will take her in to the ward. She has told me this herself & she’s not ashamed to admit it either. If someone else’s child is sick, her child is sicker. A bit like if I’ve been to Tenerife she’s been to elevenrife. The child was made to sit in a pram constantly because her mum made out she couldn’t walk, the doctors went as far as doing a muscle biopsy thinking she genuinely couldn’t walk, turns out she could walk but her mum wanted a mobility car & wanted people’s sympathy. Everyone who knows her knows she latches on to parents of really poorly children & then she will text & say “So and so died, I was so close to that child” so casually & it’s funny you say her daughter probably does play with them. She doesn’t as the genetic disease her daughter has, like my sons means they have to have their own isolation room & cannot leave it. Her child is 100% more poorly because she is keeping her poorly on purpose & the team are aware of this.

Would A+E not assess/test and only admit if there was a clinical need ?

Are you saying she is inducing symptoms or withholding medication to worsen a genuine condition? How are you aware that they team know anything as they shouldn’t be discussing this where anyone else could hear ?

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 09:42

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 09:15

That’s not munchausens/FII

Her child has a genuine condition. Not caused by her or faked or exaggerated.

The way a parent copes with genuine illness in a child isn’t an indication of FII. She may be trying to make the best of a bad situation and be positive or she may be putting on a mask and trying to smile through it. Plus if she’s on a ward with terminally ill children the probability is high that she will play with those child who have a high chance of passing away. It’s not like she’s getting access to a ward she shouldn’t be on ?

Maybe I haven’t explained it properly. She basically revels in her daughter being sick. She purposely takes her to A&E so they will take her in to the ward. She has told me this herself & she’s not ashamed to admit it either. If someone else’s child is sick, her child is sicker. A bit like if I’ve been to Tenerife she’s been to elevenrife. The child was made to sit in a pram constantly because her mum made out she couldn’t walk, the doctors went as far as doing a muscle biopsy thinking she genuinely couldn’t walk, turns out she could walk but her mum wanted a mobility car & wanted people’s sympathy. Everyone who knows her knows she latches on to parents of really poorly children & then she will text & say “So and so died, I was so close to that child” so casually & it’s funny you say her daughter probably does play with them. She doesn’t as the genetic disease her daughter has, like my sons means they have to have their own isolation room & cannot leave it. Her child is 100% more poorly because she is keeping her poorly on purpose & the team are aware of this.

damageReputation · 11/03/2023 09:15

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 09:01

Yes I do. I know a woman whose daughter has the same genetic disease as mine. Both our children spend a lot of time in hospital for IVs & she thrives when her daughter is sick in hospital. She latches on to parents in the hospital whose children are on end of life care, then she brags about how she knew that child & how her daughter would play with them before they died. This has happened well over 5 times with terminally sick children so it’s a pattern. Honestly it’s hard to explain. I get so down & stressed when my son has to go in to hospital, whereas she loves it. Loves that her daughter is the more poorly child out of the two. It sounds weird writing it down like I’m making it up but I’m not. Very sad for the child, she doesn’t deserve her.

That’s not munchausens/FII

Her child has a genuine condition. Not caused by her or faked or exaggerated.

The way a parent copes with genuine illness in a child isn’t an indication of FII. She may be trying to make the best of a bad situation and be positive or she may be putting on a mask and trying to smile through it. Plus if she’s on a ward with terminally ill children the probability is high that she will play with those child who have a high chance of passing away. It’s not like she’s getting access to a ward she shouldn’t be on ?

CouldItBeImFallingInLove · 11/03/2023 09:01

Yes I do. I know a woman whose daughter has the same genetic disease as mine. Both our children spend a lot of time in hospital for IVs & she thrives when her daughter is sick in hospital. She latches on to parents in the hospital whose children are on end of life care, then she brags about how she knew that child & how her daughter would play with them before they died. This has happened well over 5 times with terminally sick children so it’s a pattern. Honestly it’s hard to explain. I get so down & stressed when my son has to go in to hospital, whereas she loves it. Loves that her daughter is the more poorly child out of the two. It sounds weird writing it down like I’m making it up but I’m not. Very sad for the child, she doesn’t deserve her.

FancyLampshade · 11/03/2023 08:54

Atmywitsend29 · 05/10/2021 22:48

I knew someone with munchausens. At least, I suspect she had it, she was diagnosed as having a personality disorder. But the things she would do and say.
Sudden onset of random chest pains and dizziness, collapsing to the floor, begging me to ring an ambulance. They'd come out and wire her up, normal results, but they'd always end up taking her in to hospital because of one thing or another.
Every week a stream of pictures of her in a hospital bed, pictures of cannulas. Always a serious illness. The list of conditions she has or has had is long, meningitis, heart attacks, fibromyalgia, temporary blindness, severe breathlessness, etc.
Last I spoke to her, she had some paralysis condition and was wheelchair bound, in one of those chairs with a joystick control? She fell out of it apparently and broke her wrist in such a horrific way that she can't use that hand anymore.
While it's quite fascinating, I think it must be awful to be so unwell in your mental health to be like that.

The chest pains and dizziness sounds like a panic attack

MyMumSaysALot · 11/03/2023 01:37

Lw87 · 05/10/2021 23:12

@StoneofDestiny it just came up on my suggested on YouTube! It's called Gypsys revenge.

I'd never ever heard of it before just watching this and it's heartbreaking. It must be so scary for medical pros as well

@Lw87

I’m in California & familiar with Gypsy Rose. Her mother took advantage of free trips to Disney, etc., free homes, food, the finest medical care - and fooled everyone.
She even convinced her daughter Gypsy for years that she was very ill.
But I believe at some point, Gypsy figured out that she wasn’t ill and the mom started chaining (tying?) her to her bed and locking her in her room. It was bad.
And then somehow, Gypsy got access to the internet and dating sites - and that’s how she met her accomplice.
I haven’t thought about this case for a long time, but I’m happy to read here that Munchausen By Proxy is now classified as child abuse - because that’s exactly what Gypsy Rose suffered. And no, I don’t think her mother deserved to die for it.
Gypsy doesn’t look anything now like she did when she was that ill little child in the wheelchair.

LunaTheCat · 11/03/2023 00:48

WindyRose · 06/10/2021 00:18

My adoptive parents were typical Munchausen's (a/mother) and Munchausen's by proxy (a/father) and during my childhood I was a victim as well. Looking back it was a horrible life for a child but at the time it was my 'normal' and my earliest memory is emergency dashes to hospital in the middle of the night, mostly following the ambulance which was under lights and sirens, hoping she would pull through. But after numerous tests etc, the hospital would send her home with yet another mystery illness and the cycle started again.

Of course, each new illness brought new medications and it was my 'special job' to dispense these as required and I can remember this from around 4-5 yrs old. When I turned 7 I was 'big enough' to give injections and remember the GP teaching me to inject into an orange with water in the syringe.

Scarily I was injecting Morphine and similar, which sends shivers down my spine when I think about it now, because A/M would request another injection maybe an hour or two after the previous one...yes, it seems she was a drug addict and me (7 yrs old) the unwitting perpetrator. I often ask myself how I would feel right now if she had died from one of those overdoses, even though I was too young to know what was happening and being told I was 'special' because I was helping. It's a scary thought...

Although it's some years since they both died, A/M lived to 85 yrs old. Further 'proof' those serious and fatal illnesses weren't real at all.

Oh my goodness.. that is utterly awful.… Hope that you are OK now.

User678945 · 11/03/2023 00:08

As someone with a diagnosis of HEDs (diagnosed by a rheumatologist) I wish I hadn't read through this thread.

cacolac · 10/03/2023 20:29

Hiw donyou know they don't. Family members have similar genes and environmental exposures. It's not uncommon for several family members to be impacted by eds, me cfs, pans pandas, ehlers danlos etc. These Conditions have lots of symptoms.

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 23/12/2021 18:34

I know someone who I strongly suspect has traits of Munchasusens. Her children are adults now, but she was often taking them to hospital etc. With the children, I have no idea if she was fabricating anything, but with herself, her stories never quite added up.

ZaraBananaAnd · 23/12/2021 18:22

I got falsely accused of it and nearly lost my children. It was harrowing how things were twisted to fit an agenda I had to fight to clear my name

Newmumlake · 23/12/2021 18:20

I’ve previously worked in a childcare setting were we had to make numerous child protection referrals against a parent claiming the child was seriously ill however the school nurse told us there was absolutely no record of any illness of any kind

DroopyClematis · 23/12/2021 18:17

The trouble with Munchausens is that it is difficult to diagnose as most Health Professionals are loathe to diagnose until the behaviour is well embedded.

I really think that this needs looking into.
But there are so many cases , and I remember from childhood, of certain children that seemed to always be off sick ( gluten, allergies, IBS etc.. maybe) similarly, there were all the usual suspects that would come into school with fractures etc...

I know someone who appears to have both Munchausens and Proxy.
It's really scary and current safeguarding guidelines seem to not be able to trigger intervention until it's almost /usually too late.

Beggars belief , in fact.

ldontWanna · 22/12/2021 11:09

I'm on the other side of this. The kid that was actually ill with weird or unrelated symptoms that seemed fine so no one really believed me including my parents. Or if they did they didn't think it was serious.

It started with side/lower back sharp pains that were intermittent and eventually went away. That was put down to attention seeking, hurting myself and not remembering etc.

Then I was complaining of being breathless, feeling faint, having to sit down just when going for a walk. This was put down to me being overweight /unfit and since I still wanted to go out and play must be fine.

Then I started looking kinda unwell so I saw a couple of paediatricians. They listened to my chest, claimed it was viral and it'll go away. I didn't have any cold symptoms besides still breathing kinda funny.

Then the high fevers started 40/41 and it was finally agreed that I should have a chest xray after much uhmmming and ahhhing whether it's really necessary and the risks of an unnecessary xray.

Once the xray came back it showed my left lung was 75% filled with fluid (pleurisy I think it's called?) and I was admitted right then and there. By then I was lethargic,stopped eating, refused to leave the bed except going to the toilet. I was on antibiotics, meds (with the next step being the tube draining thingy if no improvement) and a shit load of other meds. I was in hospital for a month, had to had physio to recover lung function, on meds for a very long time after and excused from PE for a whole year(that was a bonus tbh).

All because I was 13 and behaved like it (wanting to go out and be with friends and play)and looked well and was a bit chubby.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 22/12/2021 07:57

My mother was accused of having it when I was little; I was extremely sick with a very hard to recognise and diagnose condition, and she was a nurse so every time I collapsed at home, by the time the ambulance arrived she had always brought me round/cooled me down etc. They thought she was mental and neurotic. Obviously in the end she was proven correct.

My son had the same and because of my history I was taken more seriously but initially my paedatrician was definitely sceptical and it wasn’t a very nice feeling.

This thread is fascinating. The article about Belle Gibson is 😱

Swipe left for the next trending thread