Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Big row about expensive belt

456 replies

PegorySpeck · 05/10/2021 20:31

DS 17 loves expensive clothes and designer labels. He currently wants a Louis Vuitton belt which costs £400. His Dad and I think it’s ridiculous to spend this amount of money on a belt. He asked us if he could have it for Christmas we said no. He knows our budget for him and his brother is £500 each so he has asked why as it’s within budget. We have responded because it’s a ridiculous waste of money.

He has a part time job and earns about £150 per week. He has just taken on an extra shift because he wants extra money for the belt. His Dad is going mad at him saying how stupid it is, but I guess it’s his money and therefore his choice.

He has now said we are completely unreasonable and have no right to tell him what he can do with his money. It’s all blown up into a massive argument and no-one is talking. He is now saying we are favouring his brother as we have already got his Christmas present which cost £500 which he saw arrive in the post a few days ago.

I don’t know how I can fix this? What should I do?

OP posts:
sjxoxo · 05/10/2021 22:17

I agree you aren’t obliged to buy it for him if you think it’s a daft gift… however.. he should be able to buy it for himself if he has earnt that money. I think there are two sides to this:

  1. you are reasonable in that he needs to understand the value of money- if he has rent/food etc to pay for as an adult for example obviously he needs to carefully consider his purchases! I understand this as a worry for the future.
  2. a controversial one here- yes it’s expensive. But- it’s a high quality purchase that will hold its value. If you spent £400 on adidas/ASOS/jd sports or another cheap/high street brand; it might last a few years, and also ethically perhaps not as solid.. This is the sort of item that is designed last a lifetime, and will hold value very well. Some might see designer purchases as shallow; but there is also a ‘longevity’ element which I increasingly think is not silly- items to last, in a world of fast cheap fashion & labour; pieces from brands like LV are often handmade and keep skill sets alive in acceptable conditions rather than in sweatshops. I think that’s worth considering! As long as he is not forcing you to buy him a new school bag every month out of vanity Xo
Bounce55 · 05/10/2021 22:17

If you can't physically bring yourself to buy it then give him the money so that he can buy it.
It's what he wants, his brother has got what he asked for so why can't he have what he's asked for?
I'm sure you and your H wouldn't take too kindly to someone asking you what you would like and then retracting it because they don't agree with the cost.
Either compromise and give him half toward it or just buy it for him
He's 17, if he's that much into his designer stuff he's going to take pride in wearing it and will look after it
And his wages are his to spend how he wishesnot for you to dictate on what he buys__

RussianSpy101 · 05/10/2021 22:16

YABU. He has asked for a particular gift within the budget you have set. Why buy him cheaper things to make up the budget when you already know what he wants? Just because he has different taste to you, doesn’t mean you can disregard them.

godmum56 · 05/10/2021 22:16

If that's what he REALLY wants, then why would you spend the money you would spend on him on something he doesn't really want because you think its better value? I could get it if it was more than you would spend but honestly it seems to me to be getting a bit overblown....
When I was 11, the only thing I wanted for christmas was a bureau type desk...the kind with a drop leaf front. My parents thought I was crazy but I convinced them I was serious so they said that I could have it but it would be the ONLY christmas present I had from them because it was such an expensive thing. Anyway I went window shopping with Mum and we found the one I wanted...tat's more or less 55 years ago and I have still got the bureau and I still use it. Its not some great antique, its basically stained plywood with some veneer but i love it....so maybe I am biased.

MyDogLovesBiscuits · 05/10/2021 22:15

If he grows out of it or his tastes change he can sell it on in future, his brother wouldn't make nearly as much selling a used PS5 in as many years Wink

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 05/10/2021 22:14

A PS 5 is more of a waste in a way. Obsolete in a couple of years time while your son might be wearing the belt in 10 years.

Though if it is the one a PP posted earlier on, he may grow out of it. I think most of us realised at a fairly young age that designer items with logos splashed all over them don't look expensive, but quite the opposite.

BrainPotter · 05/10/2021 22:12

Ridiculous waste of money - yes.
Within budget for Xmas present - yes.

Buy him the belt! It would be more wasteful to buy him something for £500 that he doesn’t want.

cakecakecheese · 05/10/2021 22:12

Buy him a PS5 and give him the receipt Wink

But yeah it does seem a bit unfair that a belt is deemed a waste of money over anything else that could also be considered frivolous.

MrsRobbieHart · 05/10/2021 22:12

I would explain to him the true cost of the belt. Break down the cost in terms of marketing, experience shop rents and fittings, staff wages etc and production costs. Also how he is being manipulated into advertising another companies goods for free. And then harp on about being a sheep and not defining himself by labels.

😂😂😂

What a joyless life you must lead.

OnTheBoardwalk · 05/10/2021 22:12

Eh so he knows the Christmas budget for him is £500 and that’s what you’ve spent on his brother. He asks fir something within budget and you say no

In my family we’ve agreed to stop buying loads of cheap stuff fir Christmas and just buy one gift someone really wants. This fits in this category

So after you buy him something fir Christmas he really doesn’t want you then complain he’s working extra shifts to buy himself what he really wants?

Makes no sense

In4mation · 05/10/2021 22:11

Charge him rent and save it up for him.

Maybe tell him that whatever amount he manages to save for the car, you’ll match from the rent money.

Let him use/waste his own earning on what he wants. It’s his money, but give him the incentive above.

QuestionEverythingBaby · 05/10/2021 22:10

[quote TatianaBis]@QuestionEverythingBaby

So you dictate what gift you would buy someone, it's not their choice? Wow Hmm

Damn right I do.[/quote]

So little children shouldn't write a list for Father Christmas of things they would like? They should just get what they're given?
Or a wish list for a wedding you ignore and get the married couple what you deem they should have?
OP's DS would get what YOU want not what he wants? Okaaaaay.

How miserable.

PigletJohn · 05/10/2021 22:06

@Flavabobble

Whilst I think spending £400 on a belt is overkill - what are you buying his brother, and is he likely to still have it in 10 years? 'Cos I bet he'd still have the belt.
but he'll probably be too fat to buckle it.
HelloDulling · 05/10/2021 22:06

I can't imagine how anyone could be happy or grateful to open a present that you knew your parents didn't want to buy.

I can’t imagine watching my child opening a £500 present that I had bought, knowing that it was not what they had wanted. That is truly a waste of money.

WhatAShilohPitt · 05/10/2021 22:03

@HappyDays101010

Are you scared he’s gay. Is that why your DH has over reacted to this?
What on earth are you on about?
Terminallysleepdeprived · 05/10/2021 22:03

I don't think this is a hill to die on especially when you have wasted a small fortune on a computer game console for his brother. That will be outdated long before the belt will.

I agree that you either need to compromise or you need to swallow it and buy the belt.

Sorry

TatianaBis · 05/10/2021 22:02

@QuestionEverythingBaby

So you dictate what gift you would buy someone, it's not their choice? Wow Hmm

Damn right I do.

MyDogLovesBiscuits · 05/10/2021 22:01

Do you have a DH problem OP?

PS5 is equally frivolous to the designer belt - they'll probably get similar use out of them though at least and will probably hold similar value for at least a few years, then the belt will hold better value than the console after that. So belt is a better investment overall than a PS5.

So yes I can see your DS's point about you seeming to favour the other DC in relation to the presents this year.

As PP say if you are still subsidising his lifestyle by taxiing him around while he is supposed to be saving to drive and is spending his money then you have a slight point, but these issues with his priorities should have been addressed already.

If you haven't talked to him about it why not? If you are his taxi service, stop ferrying him around until he starts paying for lessons, he can walk/cycle/bus till then. I'm not sure the way you spend so much at Christmas doesn't play a part in an attitude like that though, sorry.

He won't see the budgeting and other financial considerations you do internally, he'll just see you dropping a tonne of cash on the holidays (birthdays too?), and just see frivolous spending I think. 17YO's are not the most financially responsible or observant and sometimes they have to just live in the real world and fall flat on their faces before it sinks in.

TatianaBis · 05/10/2021 22:00

I easily spend that on each of my children! If we can afford it then why not?

That is so not the point. We could easily afford it, but my kids have 3 houses, holidays, independent school fees, music lessons + instruments, there is no way on earth they are getting presents of £500. If they want that kind of money they have to earn it.

flippertyop · 05/10/2021 21:58

@FatBettyintheCoop I would be delighted if my kids invested in some lovely designer gear and aspires to buy more for themselves in the future. Different strokes eh?

Sommernacht89 · 05/10/2021 21:57

Goodness, rich people and their money problems.....it always feels a bit sickly....

BurntO · 05/10/2021 21:57

I wouldn’t get it. YABU for getting angry over what he spends his own money on though

maz82 · 05/10/2021 21:56

I has exactly the same with my dd. She wanted a gucci belt for Christmas and I refused. I did in the end give her a contribution to it. She bought it and has worn it so many times. She loves it! If uts what he has asked for then I would say get it for him or contribute. It's his Christmas present at the end of the day.

ViceLikeBlip · 05/10/2021 21:56

@QuestionEverythingBaby

Of course it matters what it's on: laptop for school, accessories for a productive hobby like sport/art/culture etc - fine.

Tacky belt - hell no.

So you dictate what gift you would buy someone, it's not their choice? Wow Hmm

I absolutely 100% dictate the presents I buy people with my own money!! A gift is offered, not demanded.

I can't imagine how anyone could be happy or grateful to open a present that you knew your parents didn't want to buy.

LadyMuckington · 05/10/2021 21:54

YABU, it’s within budget so why not? My Mum bought me my first designer bag for my 21st birthday and I love it and still cherish it, more than anything else she has ever bought me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread