Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to let my DD eat cereal?

472 replies

Peridotty · 05/10/2021 19:44

My 16 month old goes to nursery 5 days a week. We pay for her breakfast, lunch and snack (included in the fee). However, I don’t like the thought of her eating cereal so we provide the breakfast and the snack. I don’t think it’s very healthy, even though it’s a wholewheat type cereal. I give her porridge made of steel cut oats instead with some applesauce. Would you be ok with feeding your kids cereal?

OP posts:
HyacynthBucket · 05/10/2021 21:14

Someone said cornflakes are healthy - No! They are extracted refined white cereal, with virtually no nutritional content but likely to push up glycaemic index - ie. bad for blood sugar control. I would not let a child eat them. Better to give them oats, porridge or some other form of whole grain cereal or whole grain bread.

Jamdown123 · 05/10/2021 21:14

I thought children needed carbohydrates for brain development?

Notcontent · 05/10/2021 21:12

@Embroidery

Muffins are definitely just pudding for breakfast. They are literally cakes. Cereal is fine. Cereal, (oats, wheat, rice) should be a bigger part of our diet. Applesauce has far more sugar than cereal.
I agree about most muffins.

But most cereal is also really like eating sugary cardboard - no nutritional value except the vitamins they sometimes add to make it seem healthy. Obviously things like oats, brown rice, etc are really healthy - but cereals in a box??? No.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 05/10/2021 21:12

Steel cut oats 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Jamdown123 · 05/10/2021 21:11

@MintyGreenDream

1st child.Steel cut oats. 2nd child.Rice krispies. 3rd child.Coco pops. 4th child.Biffa Bin surprise.
Haaaaaaaaa!
Twizbe · 05/10/2021 21:10

@Draggondragon

I don't get the nursery angst. Surely it's just guilt about not being there for a small child who should be at home. Of people feel this strongly about parenting why don't they parent instead of outsourcing?
That's rude. The OP is in the states - do you know how much federally mandates paid maternity leave women get? No - it's none! Some states do have paid leave, but most women will be looking at a few weeks off at most.

I know one woman who was back full time at 2 weeks post partum because she had to be.

Don't forget that there if you don't work, you don't have health insurance either which means potentially being hit with crippling medical bills.

So yeah - let's shame women for working ...

shouldistop · 05/10/2021 21:10

There's nothing wrong with 100% whole wheat toast

Newmumatlast · 05/10/2021 21:08

to be honest I read cereals aren't appropriate but then also read toast is not either and cereal better (if malted wheat, bran etc). My daughter won't eat egg. She won't eat homemade breakfast muffins. She won't eat porridge. So do I starve her? I just stick to no added sugar healthy as possible cereal and be done with it.

Temple29 · 05/10/2021 21:07

I see where you’re coming from OP. I’m like this a bit with my first born (now 2.5) but relaxed a little once he was over the age of 2 (and I had another baby). Now offer treats in moderation but mostly a healthy diet. Do what makes you comfortable, it’s your child. I did offer weetabix etc for breakfast though.

Also baked porridge is easy to make and would be handy for nursery.

PearandHoney · 05/10/2021 21:07

@toocold54

I think it’s great you want to teach your child healthy eating but honestly I wouldn’t worry about it. The nursery staff are a lot more qualified on what is and isn’t a healthy breakfast and all the other children eat it too so it must be ok.

If you’re really concerned you could phone around some local nurseries and see if they provide healthier options but honestly if your LO is happy then I would stay there.

Why would the nursery staff be a lot more qualified on what is a healthy breakfast? Confused
shouldistop · 05/10/2021 21:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Graphista · 05/10/2021 21:06

@babybythesea totally agree a balanced approach is far healthier.

I do think some Uk schools/nurseries have gone WAY too far on the "healthy eating" faddiness!

When we have schools telling especially young and impressionable children things like fruit, eggs and cheese are "bad" foods we've seriously lost our way!

@canyoutoleratethis I only have one! I wasn't being snobby at all! I was recognising this stage of parenting- which if you'd read my post PROPERLY you'd see I said we all go through it

I certainly did! Compounded by my having ocd which I had a bad flare up of just after having dd. I gradually learned to relax and pick my battles! ESP as dd was the absolute opposite of me! Dirt magnet who'll eat anything and everything! The afternoon when she was 18 months and I caught her eating a spider I basically gave up! Grin

She is now 20, slim, relatively healthy (barring her genetic disability) and with a healthy approach to food and nutrition.

I am very interested and fairly knowledgeable on healthy eating myself (even if I don't practise it! I'm currently losing weight myself - but the gain is at least partly due to disability and the meds I'm on which affect metabolism and water retention etc) so I'm not being dismissive just offering a bit of a reality check!

I had gd while pregnant even though I'm not a sweet toothed person and was a size 8 prior to pregnancy, but then all the women in my family have had gd with every pregnancy regardless of prior health. I was told that this COULD increase dds risk of developing diabetes herself and so it was best to "limit" processed sugar in the first year. As a result she had absolutely no processed sugar in that first year - that was my pfb moment diet wise.

Of course it didn't last and by 2 she was as much a fan of chocolate, cake and ice cream as any toddler though she still wasn't given such things very often.

As parents become more experienced and more confident as parents they move past the pfb stage (usually not all) and learn to have a more balanced approach to parenting and the decisions one makes as a parent.

I didn't deserve being torn into like that!

KingsleyShacklebolt · 05/10/2021 21:04

[quote brittleheadgirl]@SuperCaliFragalistic
You're totally right. My friends who were total pains about food when our dc were small, now have teenagers who are walking to secondary school drinking red bull and eating haribos. I did warn them!!!!

Didn't 'Dr' Gillian McKeith describe cereal as 'shit in a box'?
Not exactly someone who I'd hold in high regard when it comes to nutrition![/quote]
Sounds like the teenager I was behind in the queue in Lidl at lunchtime.

His lunch consisted of 2 pretzels, 2 white chocolate cookies and a jam doughnut.

Draggondragon · 05/10/2021 21:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

80sMum · 05/10/2021 21:03

I used to be given Frosties, with a couple of spoonfuls of sugar on top! I certainly wouldn't recommend that! But shredded wheat, muesli or porridge is fine, I think.

stormyweather274 · 05/10/2021 21:02

Omg
You're in America - be suspicious as they add sugar to everything!!!

remodelideas · 05/10/2021 21:01

My kid will only eat weetabix or Shreddies for breakfast. Every day. Stopping that is not a hill I'm willing to die on tbh

Frogsandsheep · 05/10/2021 20:58

1st child.Steel cut oats.
2nd child.Rice krispies.
3rd child.Coco pops.
4th child.Biffa Bin surprise.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

My teenagers eat SO much cereal. I often find them eating it at 10pm! They have good teeth, are slim built and 6 foot tall so I’m not too concerned.

They’ve always had cereal but it used to be much healthier. Now if I buy healthy stuff, they just pop to the local shop and spend their own money on sugary cereal 🤦🏼‍♀️

Pixxie7 · 05/10/2021 20:57

It makes me wonder how the older generation ever got old given the amount of rubbish they have consumed in their lives. Asking the nursery to do different meals is in my opinion unfair.

brittleheadgirl · 05/10/2021 20:57

@SuperCaliFragalistic
You're totally right. My friends who were total pains about food when our dc were small, now have teenagers who are walking to secondary school drinking red bull and eating haribos. I did warn them!!!!

Didn't 'Dr' Gillian McKeith describe cereal as 'shit in a box'?
Not exactly someone who I'd hold in high regard when it comes to nutrition!

Embroidery · 05/10/2021 20:57

Muffins are definitely just pudding for breakfast. They are literally cakes.
Cereal is fine. Cereal, (oats, wheat, rice) should be a bigger part of our diet. Applesauce has far more sugar than cereal.

Notdoingthis · 05/10/2021 20:56

When my ds was little my friend said 'OMG do you actually let him eat readybrek? It is so full of rubbish!'
I got down the box for her and read the ingredients. Oats, fortified with iron.

RaoulDufysCat · 05/10/2021 20:55

@Peridotty

Yes I’m British but living in the US. I’m very suspicious of the foods here especially processed foods including cereal. I was brought up on U.K. cereal which is fine. I don’t want to touch US cereals though.
Now that I know you are in the US this all makes sense! I initially voted YABU but actually I would not feed US cereal to a toddler either. Food standards are much lower in the US.
canyoutoleratethis · 05/10/2021 20:54

@Graphista

Definitely an acute case of pfb syndrome!

We all had our moments op.

But yea you kinda need to get over yourself and be more realistic.

The point re the porridge is it IS also processed you're not feeding her raw oats straight off the ears of the grass it grows on!

Almost all food is processed to some degree with the exception of fresh meat, fish, fruit and veg.

Bread, milk, applesauce... Wink

Blueberry muffins are huge cakes for crying out loud! Far more sugary and fatty and processed than a healthy wholegrain cereal with milk!

My understanding (never having been there but have family there) is that both food and childcare standards and regulation in USA is far more lax than here.

My aunt and uncle often despair at what my cousins and now my cousins dc consider "healthy" foods based on USA standards as they're not healthy by Uk standards and the portion sizes when eating out/takeaways are apparently insane!

So maybe this translates to the way the nursery op uses operates?

Certainly no nursery or even childminder or nanny I've ever known (I've worked in childcare) would consider muffins healthy or appropriate as a regular breakfast for little ones, it would also go against the nutrition guidelines here for childcare professionals.

Why is mumsnet always so snobby about PFB’s? Is it just a way for women who have had more than one child to feel smug and sanctimonious for no other reason than the fact they’ve birthed one more child? Or just a rude way to dismiss anyone else’s point of view on the sole basis they’ve only had one child so can’t possibly be as smart or knowledgeable or perfect as you? It’s a strange high horse that only serves to belittle and dismiss people and I wish it would stop. By all means engage in the actual point of the post, but your language and tone is patronising.

I do not eat highly-processed food and therefore have no intention of feeding it to my (shock horror…) only daughter!! It’s got fuck all to do with the fact I have one child. It’s about the food that I myself eat and therefore the food that I will let my child eat. I see no reason why the OP or me need to ‘get over ourselves’, nor that I need to be more ‘realistic’, considering it’s how I’ve eaten for years, as it’s how I will always eat.

Ironi · 05/10/2021 20:54

A while back I read something which was basically along the line of your adult body grows/develops according to the nutrition you were fed as a child. So I try very hard to limit processed foods to my kids. I bake a loaf usually and make eggs bread for them. They don’t eat cereals.