Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BIL getting MIL to buy DD's birthday presents

34 replies

anotherbloodycold · 05/10/2021 17:25

Ever since BIL and SIL split up he's been half arsed with everything and he is the biggest earner out of all of us. For Christmas he decided we only buy the kids presents and not bother with adults. (Whatever fair enough I think it's more he can't be bothered though)

DD birthday he gets MIL to buy all her presents he couldn't even be arsed to buy her a card MIL picked one up and then he wrote his name in it.

He skipped OH birthday and his other brother not even a happy birthday.

He's now only invited DS to his cousins birthday as they was only 10 spaces and DD isn't old enough. He even spelt her name wrong when he messaged to say she couldn't come. She is gutted as she is super close with her cousin.

AIBU to be annoyed? DD is upset and keeps saying it's not fair. I'm just fed up of his half effort with everything.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PikachuAndMe · 06/10/2021 10:48

YABU

Bigeggsinapackoften · 06/10/2021 07:36

If your mil is happy to do it for him, what odds. Why do you care?

Re the party - that’s what happens. Cousins of a different age do drop off parties because they are too old or not old enough or the birthday child wants their friends.

You’re looking for something to be offended about. Why is that?

Brefugee · 06/10/2021 07:35

As long as other women (MIL and SIL In this case) let men* get away with this, it will happen.

But if it were me and my DD I'd recognise that it is entirely up to BIL and MIL how they handle this. And maybe the cousin has asked only for your DS? it's his party, and your DD needs to learn to handle disappointment so it's a good lesson.

*where are the NAMALTers when we're talking about this btw?

MichelleScarn · 06/10/2021 07:34

@RobertaFirmino

he is the biggest earner out of all of us Completely irrelevant DD birthday he gets MIL to buy all her presents he couldn't even be arsed to buy her a card MIL picked one up and then he wrote his name in it That's just what lots of men are like. Does it really matter that he did not physically enter the shop himself? He's now only invited DS to his cousins birthday as they was only 10 spaces and DD isn't old enough It's the cousin's day, not your DD's. Maybe she needs to be reminded of this?
Lots about dd and her presents and not being happy about invites etc, what about your ds?

Agree its the cousins day, not hers, do you quiz every other gift giver as to who choose it?

Naunet · 06/10/2021 07:29

God, he does sound rather pathetic, a grown man expecting mummy to buy cards for him (more fool her), and not spelling your daughters name right. I doubt a woman behaving that way would get quite so defended on here, but ultimately this is what you’re dealing with now. Just don’t bother for his birthday/Christmas, and let it go - it’s not worth falling out over.

Goldbar · 06/10/2021 06:49

Wifework. It’s shite, and until women earn equally as men, it’ll always exist.

This. You're right, it's a bit shit. It's true that a lot of men are like this. They just don't put the effort into friendships and family relationships in the same way that women do.

You'll get people telling you that you're lucky he even remembers your DD and DS exist, let alone buys them a present, since exSIL is no longer around to do it for him. And there's some truth in that - not that it's ok but that a lot of men do think 'life shit' (which I'm afraid encompasses buying children's birthday gifts) is beneath them and not their problem.

YANBU to hope for better, but honestly YABU to expect anything else. Assuming SIL was mostly responsible for the kids' stuff pre-split, he's already having to adapt to doing a bigger share of that. So your DC and their feelings aren't going to be a high priority for him.

If you're still in touch with ex-SIL, why not get in touch directly and suggest taking all the kids out together to do something so DD can celebrate her cousin's birthday with them?

Nightbringer · 06/10/2021 06:40

I think yabu.

Not sure what you want to happen about the party? Change it so it includes dd? Not invite your ds? Is your ds not allowed to do anything that can't also include your younger child?

You need to explain to dd that it feels unfair, but she is simply not old enough and do something else with her that day.

And so what if mil gets the present? If she is happy to do it, not sure why you are so bothered.

I assume both you and dh always get your own gifts and cards for every person for every event. You don't give gifts that just one of you has bought?

Also, I think its fine to not do adult presents.

Is there something else bothering you, because this comes across as you are annoyed that bil isn't catering himself around your family.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 06/10/2021 06:33

I don’t see an issue, you clearly dislike you’re. BIL

The party has limited numbers, so you’re Dd isn’t invited this time, such is life.

londonrach · 06/10/2021 06:24

Yabu. He making the effect. Your dd gets a present. It's vvvv common in families for family members to ask others if they no idea what to get. My mum always like probably 90÷ of my patients who do the same for their family gives the mum money to buy something their grandchildren would like.

ShipOfTheseus · 06/10/2021 03:27

YABU.

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 06/10/2021 03:11

Oh, so you never buy a present “from the family” and then just have your husband sign the card?

I mean, I know I do, so I’m not really in a position to complain when what you’re saying is: “BIL and SIL did the same thing DH and I do. They split and now MIL is doing it for him.” And?

Your DD is too young to be invited to the party; you said so yourself. End of.

I’m at a loss to understand any part of this OP. Tell me, in your house, does DH arrange the childrens’ birthday parties? Buy presents for other children in the family? Or even for your own DC? I doubt you ever questioned that your BIL never did any of these things before and now that he’s split from SIL, he’s not just going to magically start. She’s going to keep taking care of all things regarding their DC, and he’ll outsource to some other woman (MIL now, eventually new partner or girlfriend) things like present-buying.

Wifework. It’s shite, and until women earn equally as men, it’ll always exist.

BustedCanOfBiscuits · 06/10/2021 03:05

Move on, he's not that person. At least he gives enough of a shit to make sure she doesn't miss out

JustLyra · 05/10/2021 23:59

You can’t expect your nephew to invite two cousins out of ten spaces. Especially if your daughter is a good bit younger.

That’s a total non issue

ittakes2 · 05/10/2021 23:58

Your b'n'law pay for presents for his nephew and niece? Many wouldn't bother.
Its funny how people are different - I actually think its thoughtful he has attempted to continue with present buying and has chosen someone who probably would choose better presents for your kids than he would.

Kite22 · 05/10/2021 23:53

YABU, for all the reasons people have said above.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/10/2021 23:52

I think you're being unreasonable on the party front. I had friends of different ages as a child but parties were always friends with similar ages. It changes the dynamic too much if younger kids are there. My daughter adores her cousin, who is 3 years older than her. They love spending time together. But she hasnt been invited to her parties since the cousin was 5, because a load of 10 year olds dont want a 7 year old hanging out with them, and the party girl doesnt want to have to explain references and things that the young one doesnt get instead of enjoying her friends. It's normal

BurntO · 05/10/2021 23:48

Sounds like he’s going through a hard time.

Thesearmsofmine · 05/10/2021 23:23

Does it really matter about the presents? Maybe your mil enjoys doing it?

As for the birthday day out, presumably the cousin has chosen something he wants to do on his birthday. You just need to remind your dd that it his birthday not hers.

neededafart · 05/10/2021 23:15

I think you are being a bit dramatic.

Some people don't do birthdays.

My brother for example has never bought my kids a card. He does however see them every week and takes them on a day out once a month. Birthday cards/gifts don't equate to how much a person cares.

ANameChangeAgain · 05/10/2021 23:08

I would have been upset on dd being missed out because she's a girl, but not because of age. Everything else isn't the end of the world.
My dh's sil arranged a boys' day for his nephew's bday doing my dd's hobby (which is traditionally seen as a "male" hobby), just inviting my dh and ds. My dh refused to go as he wouldn't leave my dd out, which was sweet.

junebirthdaygirl · 05/10/2021 23:01

My dh often gets me to get stuff for his nieces/ nephews. He hates shopping and has no imagination. I quite like it so win win. He is still being generous as he pays. I wouldn't give it another thought.

KellyJonesLeatherTrousers · 05/10/2021 22:48

YABU. Not sure why you’re so bothered if he asks MIL to help out buying presents, she’ll know what’s appropriate more than him - I get the feeling you’d complain if he bought something himself that you considered inappropriate, can he win?
We have cousins around the same age and not everyone can go to every birthday party, completely normal just to have the closest age one/ones.
Do you just not like him?

RobertaFirmino · 05/10/2021 19:04

he is the biggest earner out of all of us
Completely irrelevant
DD birthday he gets MIL to buy all her presents he couldn't even be arsed to buy her a card MIL picked one up and then he wrote his name in it
That's just what lots of men are like. Does it really matter that he did not physically enter the shop himself?
He's now only invited DS to his cousins birthday as they was only 10 spaces and DD isn't old enough
It's the cousin's day, not your DD's. Maybe she needs to be reminded of this?

Zwellers · 05/10/2021 17:55

Why do you care. Your daughters still getting a present and it's not his fault she is too young for the activity.

namechange30455 · 05/10/2021 17:52

How do you even know MIL is so involved in buying presents and cards for him? Who is telling you this?