Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have no idea what I'm looking out for in a primary school?

64 replies

giraffes2021 · 05/10/2021 16:44

HELP
Looking at primary schools for DD

What should I be looking out for ? Anything specific?

OP posts:
Vickim03 · 05/10/2021 19:15

Go with your gut and look for what’s on the walls. Ofstead means nothings, my children’s school is rated outstanding but that was assessed years and years ago, there’s been no inspection since we’ve attended and my son is now y5.

anxiouscrazymum · 05/10/2021 19:03

I disagree with walkable, I went with gut feel and after visiting several schools I walked out of my daughters now school and felt very emotional! It's a 15min drive away and I wound travel double to get to it if required as it's amazing wind better than my local walkable school. X

HarryBoa · 05/10/2021 19:01

@MyDcAreMarvel

Good not outstanding, you want a child centred school not an Ofsted centred one.
I completely agree with this. Have had DC at both a good and and outstanding one. The main difference that I could see between the two was the latter's preponderance with forms and data, with the former quite clearly putting children first, often to the detriment of paperwork (as opposed to producing reams and reams of marketing material to tell parents that they were putting children first).
MintyGreenDream · 05/10/2021 18:58

I'm not on benefits but wtf has that got to do with anything?

MintyGreenDream · 05/10/2021 18:56

Good ofsted.
As close to home as possible.

GreyTriangleCatEars · 05/10/2021 18:54

@CatNamedEaster

I asked what sort of art, PE, music etc lessons they had, to see how non-academic lessons are provided. I asked whether they use attendance awards (discounted a school on the basis that they DID); how they ensure that kids who are average (not needing attention because they disruptive; not needing extra help or extra challenges due to struggling/being gifted) aren't just ignored but also nurtured. I asked how food allergies are accommodated (one school discounted as the head said those kids would just not be in Food Tech classes). I asked how they deal with bullying.
This was a question for me to, and I discounted a school where the headteacher said "Bullying never happens in this school". I don't want a school that looks passed it's problems, I want a school that says "These things happen and this is how we deal with it"
FourLaneEnds · 05/10/2021 18:52

A school within your own community.
This is the first opportunity for your child to be independent, make their own friends and be part of their own local community.

CatNamedEaster · 05/10/2021 18:50

I asked what sort of art, PE, music etc lessons they had, to see how non-academic lessons are provided.
I asked whether they use attendance awards (discounted a school on the basis that they DID); how they ensure that kids who are average (not needing attention because they disruptive; not needing extra help or extra challenges due to struggling/being gifted) aren't just ignored but also nurtured.
I asked how food allergies are accommodated (one school discounted as the head said those kids would just not be in Food Tech classes).
I asked how they deal with bullying.

HungryHippo11 · 05/10/2021 18:48

@MyDcAreMarvel

Good not outstanding, you want a child centred school not an Ofsted centred one.
I agree with this. Too much pressure in an outstanding school.
2tired2bewitty · 05/10/2021 18:46

Meh, my kids have managed four different primary schools in different parts of the country (eldest now in Y7, youngest in Y1) and due to work based house moves we’ve never had any choice and on two occasions hadn’t set foot through the door before they started, and they’ve all been fine 🤷‍♀️

HumunaHey · 05/10/2021 18:46

@NumberNineTwo

Number of kids being dropped off by car = parents who can afford a car and are probably going to work.

Number of kids receiving pupil premium also gives you an idea about whether the families are mostly middle class or on benefits.

Breakfast club and after school clubs.
Destinations for leavers.
Class sizes (I prefer smaller).
Good playground areas and outdoor facilities.
Staff turnover (low turnover indicates a good school).
Decent buildings, new extensions.
Start and end times.

Avoid any not rated Good by Ofsted! And check why they weren’t rated Outstanding - hopefully it’s nothing serious. Also check past Ofsted ratings - choose a school that has been reliably Good for some time, not one that was previously poorer.

Lots of Ofsted reports mention the standard of the average intake - avoid ones where they say the new starters are below average in ability, because this will hold your child back.

Hmm
andyindurham · 05/10/2021 18:42

For a lot of schools at the moment, the pandemic is affecting their ability to offer open days etc. I felt we learned quite a bit from the different responses our local schools had to that last year - the one that went ahead with open days (small, distanced groups), the one that set up an online one-to-one with the head, the one that just put a video on the website. Depending on where you are, you may have similar questions.

One question we discussed after each school was 'if this was the only school available to us, would we be happy to send DD there?'. Thinking about it that way took some of the comparison pressure out of the equation and we quickly felt that basically all our local schools were good enough and the details were relatively minor.

In the end, we went for the school closest to us - mostly because it's a three-minute walk, door-to-door. So, of course, we'd seen a lot of the children coming and going past our house every day and there are lots of familiar faces around the school. The other genuine contender would be a 30-minute walk with DD, or a drive. Neither of those appealed.

During the application process, I was offered a job in another town (completely unfamiliar to me previously). In the end, I didn't take the offer, partly because I felt I was making an almost 'blind' choice between schools and there wasn't much time to speak with anyone before we had to make a decision. If the job offer came a few weeks earlier, we might have been better placed to move.

RobinPenguins · 05/10/2021 18:42

In my area the primary and first schools are all good or outstanding. There’s a lot more variation between the secondary and high schools so I’ve got half an eye on leaver destinations (although also bearing in mind that a lot can change in 7 years).

Headteacher412 · 05/10/2021 18:42

As a headteacher, I'd suggest the only things that matter ...

Will my child be happy here? (you'll just know when you look round)

Is there a lot going on (clubs, trips, PTA - a strong indicator of whether the school is going the extra mile?)

How are all abilities catered for - you don't know whether your child is the next Einstein or will need additional support? (if all in class are doing exactly the same thing, that is not realistic and someone somewhere is missing out!).

Look at progress, not attainment scores in the league tables. They show what the school adds compared to others. Read the Ofsted report, but see it as a snapshot in time - things change quickly for better or worse.

Ultimately, and sadly in the sense of today's society, you also need to look through the eyes of "Will my child make close, secure friendships here" which makes schools where the intake is radically different from your background more of a challenge for your child to fit in.

The rest is just window dressing. Forest school or dance clubs? You're overthinking it. If the outcome is happy, successful children, it won't matter in 10 years time which route they took to get them there.

RobinPenguins · 05/10/2021 18:40

Number of kids being dropped off by car = parents who can afford a car and are probably going to work.

I would look for the opposite - too many kids being dropped off in the car is not a positive. I’d much rather a school with a good mix of children arriving on foot, cycling, off the bus and a small proportion in the car.

ToastieSnowy · 05/10/2021 18:39

If you work then times and cost of breakfast & afterschool clubs. Some schools done have wraparound care and it’s much more expensive using private childcare.

Whether the teachers seem relaxed & happy (as well as the kids).

Ask about trips. I moved my DS from a junior school that didn’t do much extra curricular to one that had loads and loads each year. The head believed in pastoral care and the values of those enrichment activities. It made a huge difference to my DCs development.

yellowgingham · 05/10/2021 18:39

Sounds bizarre but when we were deciding between two schools, a significant factor for us was the Christmas fair. It gave a really good insight into the feel and culture of the schools and whether they had a supportive parent community.

I do think results are important to a point. I'd probably want performance to be average or above.

Everyone talks about outdoor space but I think this depends on your child. It might be a consideration for DD2 but I think DD1 could take it or leave it, she's more of an indoor girl (takes after me!)

Overall convenience of location, start/finish times, breakfast and after school club if needed etc.

LizzieBet14 · 05/10/2021 18:37

We went on gut feeling, outdoor space, staff turnover, the 'life of the school' e.g what events/traditions do they have? They are what make the happy memories that the kids look back on.
My kids have left now but loved the after school clubs, end of year picnics with other families, residentials, links with the local community, Christmas events.

MyDcAreMarvel · 05/10/2021 18:34

avoid ones where they say the new starters are below average in ability, because this will hold your child back.
That’s a horrible comment.

Kettletoaster · 05/10/2021 18:29

An an Ofsted Outstanding score and a great reputation does not always translate to your child having a good experience. Have recently had to move DD from a school of this criteria because the makeup of the kids in her class was awful. Rest of the school was great. Her class was not.

GreyTriangleCatEars · 05/10/2021 18:18

For me I wasn't bothered about academics, I wanted a nurturing school. When I looked round DDs primary school I looked at how the children engaged with each other and the staff, I wanted somewhere staff where respected but not shouty. I wanted a school where the headteacher was involved day to day either teaching or covering staff who're absent or just walking round the school and chatting to the children not one that comes out of the office once a week for assembly and on special occasions, I wanted somewhere with plenty of space to run around in as I don't have a garden, I wanted somewhere where outside was celebrated as much as inside.

I am very happy with my choice, and the only compromise was it's religion as neither me or ExH are religious but it was an acceptable compromise for me ExH was less happy

NumberNineTwo · 05/10/2021 17:56

Number of kids being dropped off by car = parents who can afford a car and are probably going to work.

Number of kids receiving pupil premium also gives you an idea about whether the families are mostly middle class or on benefits.

Breakfast club and after school clubs.
Destinations for leavers.
Class sizes (I prefer smaller).
Good playground areas and outdoor facilities.
Staff turnover (low turnover indicates a good school).
Decent buildings, new extensions.
Start and end times.

Avoid any not rated Good by Ofsted! And check why they weren’t rated Outstanding - hopefully it’s nothing serious. Also check past Ofsted ratings - choose a school that has been reliably Good for some time, not one that was previously poorer.

Lots of Ofsted reports mention the standard of the average intake - avoid ones where they say the new starters are below average in ability, because this will hold your child back.

AnUnlikelyCombination · 05/10/2021 17:37

I like to see the YR children happily chatting to the Head, and the Y6 children looking as though they’re on their best behaviour when the Head appears. That signals to me that they have a good balance of nurturing and discipline.

clary · 05/10/2021 17:24

Agree with what others have said, but @fourminutestosavetheworld there is no such thing as a satisfactory Ofsted - it's now requires improvement, which the OP may want to avoid (tho I would always look at what is RI - if it is pastoral care and how bullying is dealt with, then I would swerve).

MargosKaftan · 05/10/2021 17:23

You've had some great advice! I'd add, where do most children leaving at year 6 go to?

If you can speak to some current students (they often get year 6s to talk to you), ask them what the food is like. They'll have opinions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread