Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have no idea what I'm looking out for in a primary school?

64 replies

giraffes2021 · 05/10/2021 16:44

HELP
Looking at primary schools for DD

What should I be looking out for ? Anything specific?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
eeek88 · 07/10/2021 22:55

(Primary teacher here)
Don’t be seduced by outstanding ofsted reports. It can indicate that the school is more interested in pleasing inspectors than responding to the needs of the pupils and teachers. ‘Good’ is good enough.

Definitely check staff turnover. Low is good. Find out how many part-timers there are - too many can create lack of continuity for kids. You don’t want too many nqts but nor do you want too many old hacks who have been there for 25 years and should have left a decade ago. A combination of the two is great.

Watch how teachers react when senior management appear at the classroom door. If they seem frightened or defensive, beware.

Then there are the things that may or may not matter to you and your child: outdoor space, clubs, sports, out of hours provision, ict resources, dinners etc.

Above all trust your gut. If you feel comfortable there and leave feeling positive, it’s likely your child will too.

notsureconfused · 07/10/2021 22:42

My advice is be realistic about where you'll get offers - where I live all the schools are so oversubscribed you will only be offered the closest one to you so there is no choice at all!

maddening · 07/10/2021 22:37

Close so friends are local, more important as they get older. Then also a feeder for your catchment secondary so they go up to high school with friends from primary. There is less choice in secondary ime.

Lightswitch123 · 07/10/2021 22:36

We went to a few Christmas/ summer fairs of schools to get a feel for the other families . Was quite surprising. Walkable also fab esp if small catchment as makes friends all super local.

Rosemaryandlemon · 07/10/2021 22:34

I echo those saying gut feeling. I was sure I would send my child to a particular school (private). Went for a visit and I hated it. Although I wanted an academic school this felt pushy and uncaring.

Went round the caring/holistic school which I thought I would find a bit wishy washy. Loved it. Son has gone there and thrived. Is doing brilliant academically but also happy and well rounded.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/10/2021 22:33

I agree - walkable, outdoor space with plants etc as well as equipment etc, nice homely displays of children’s art work inside

I went for a sense of peace in the school during lessons times - some other schools had absolute riots of children roaming around all the time. I didn’t think it would suit Dd to be in a chaotic atmosphere. The school I chose had a lovely peaceful atmosphere - not horribly strict but just calm.

DeepaBeesKit · 07/10/2021 22:31

Think about what your child needs.

  • do they need great SEN support?
  • if they are academically inclined, really consider what the intake and overall achievement is like. If it's an area where the intake is not high attaining, it is difficult for a teacher to challenge a more able child if most of the class are a long way behind.
  • consider their educational "vibe". I have realised I hate the more extreme end of "progressive" style education which can be pervasive in schools and essentially believes teachers provide opportunity and kids will take it up - some kids simply need more direction. I wish I had opted for the more "traditional" school nearby.

Read the Ofsted report. Ignore the rating and read the whole report. You will see red flags as to why they didnt get outstanding - it might be they don't do enough to close the gap for pupil premium, it might be that behaviour isnt as good as it could be, it might be they don't stretch able pupils enough. Think about what actually matters to you.

lazylinguist · 07/10/2021 22:21

Yy to good Ofsted, not outstanding. You want a school that cares more about the children than jumping through Ofsted hoops.

FourLaneEnds · 07/10/2021 20:31

I will also add academy or maintained. I wanted a maintained school supported, funded and held to account by democratic control through a local authority.

I didn't want my local academy, where the school budget contributes to the CEO's £130,000 salary, whilst at the same time the school were sending 'begging letters' to parents to donate new reading books.

thing47 · 06/10/2021 12:56

Parents tend to place undue importance on class size, studies show it's not as important a factor as we think it is. Children are better off in a large class with a good teacher than than they are in a small class with a poor one.

rrhuth · 06/10/2021 11:25

Number of kids being dropped off by car = parents who can afford a car and are probably going to work Well this is really old-fashioned nonsense, many people are in hideous debt paying for cars for starters.

I think this is a view that belongs in the 60s/70s, when the plebs got the bus whilst managers drove. Now it is the elite who can afford not to drive. Many of the higher earners/professionals in my area wouldn't be seen dead doing the school run in a car, they cycle.

MrsAvocet · 06/10/2021 01:51

I went on gut feeling as much as anything.
DS more or less made the decision for us though. He was very shy, and at every school we visited he would cling to my leg and refuse to interact with anyone. Except at one school, where within minutes he took the proffered hand of the TA in Reception and skipped off and sat on the carpet and joined in with the class. When we went to get him at the end our our tour/chat with the headteacher he didn't want to come home. That's where we picked. All 3 of our children went there and we never regretted it for a second even though it was not the best equipped, highest attaining or most sought after school in our area. It oozed happiness and warmth though, from the staff, the pupils and the parents and I am a strong believer in happiness being crucial for a good education.

MistyFrequencies · 05/10/2021 23:51

@donkey86 my daughter goes to a school like you describe, call all teachers by first name, no uniform etc. She absolutely loves it and so do I. They're so in tune with the kids, they really know her and work to her strengths, there's a real sense of team.

Redwinestillfine · 05/10/2021 23:38

Try and speak to parents already there about what the communication is like.

EatYourVegetables · 05/10/2021 23:35

Number of kids being dropped off by car = parents who can afford a car and are probably going to work.

What a pile of nonsense.

Schools in urban areas have tiny catchments - ours is 500m. The promote walking, cycling, and scooting to school as a way of promoting health, reducing air pollution, and making it safer to walk around schools.

People living and working in urban areas may well be able to afford a car or own one but still use public transport to commute.

I would be put off by a school where most people dropped off by car, sounds awful.

What an old fashioned brand of snobbery Hmm

VestaTilley · 05/10/2021 20:35

Good or Outstanding Ofsted reports,
Positive word of mouth recommendations from friends and neighbours,
What do they do for very bright children, those with SEN and children in the middle?
Are you religious? Do you want a CofE, Catholic, Jewish or Muslim school - or none of the above? If you like things like Nativity plays you may want CofE or Catholic.
How far is it from your house?
Are you in catchment?
Do you like the feel of the place, facilities and teachers when you visit?
What do they do re enrichment? Trips, instruments, extra curricular?

MissChanandlerBong81 · 05/10/2021 20:17

I would look for the opposite - too many kids being dropped off in the car is not a positive. I’d much rather a school with a good mix of children arriving on foot, cycling, off the bus and a small proportion in the car.

Yes me too. For one thing it’s awful when you walk past schools where every child is being dropped off by car and you get a face full of exhaust - can’t be good for children.

MargosKaftan · 05/10/2021 20:13

@NumberNineTwo - that doesn't work in many areas as people like us with 2 cars still collect from school on foot because its close and parking is a nightmare.

Id add that kids who and dropped in cars are less likely to be walking home together in year 6 without parents, so going from being driven everywhere to getting buses /trains for secondary is a big step.

Also primaries where everyone walks to school are primaries where classmates all live in walking distance from your house. This is great for weekend /after school / holiday playdates and meet ups. Its easier if you are stuck somewhere and not sure if you'll make it in time for pick up to ask another parent to walk your child home and you'll meet them on the way, than expect someone to have a spare car seat in their car to take your child with them.

giraffes2021 · 05/10/2021 20:10

Thanks for all your replies will add them to my notepad hahaha
I was looking in terms of class size but the school I looked at this week had 3 classes and they said that they split the classes up in terms of ability which I guess is probably a good thing so the kids that need the extra support will get that and the kids that are excelling won't get held back which I guess you won't always get in a one class school!
I think it's got to be gut feeling isn't it x

OP posts:
clary · 05/10/2021 19:39

Wow @NumberNineTwo what an unpleasant post.

So people should avoid schools where people walk to school, as they clearly can't afford a car and don't work?

And even if people don't work, wtf has that got to do with anything?

Starters below average ability "will hold your child back"? Nice

Unavailableusername · 05/10/2021 19:35

Visit in person:

  • Behaviour / atmosphere is key
  • Displays - does the work look interesting / nicely presented?
  • How local is it? You'll get tired of dropping off / arranging social dates
  • Any community events you can go to before your child joins? Christmas fayre etc

Website:
Look at the curriculum topics, texts and visits
What's the parent info / newsletter suggest?
Look at any policies that might be of concern to you
Any extra curricular events / clubs

Read the OFSTED but bear in mind they have unrealistic expectations, constantly change the goalposts and may be well overdue so you can't really compare an outstanding school from 10 years ago with a recent 'good' rating. Some schools play the OFSTED game more than others.

If you go to an open day and see kids doing something lovely, ask how often they use that equipment in lessons. I remember being asked to play with some fancy equipment at one but had never seen it before!

twilightcafe · 05/10/2021 19:29

Gut feeling - do you trust the staff with your child's wellbeing and education?
You can pore over data as much as you like - but it will never give you an accurate picture of a school.

Pazuzu · 05/10/2021 19:25

Happy kids.

Check out the local Facebook groups including the PTA. If they're behind the school it's a damned good sign.

Is it close by? The wonderfully rated primary three changes of bus away may seem a great idea on paper but in the bleak midwinter, having a school that you can get to and from in 20 minutes flat will suddenly become far more appealing.

Go to the open days. Are the staff approachable? What's the staff turnover like? (bear in mind that a change of head especially a long term incumbent can mean a huge turnover really quickly)

Obviously OFSTED ratings. (same caveat for changes of head)

Happy kids. I know I've said it previously but if you can get your kids waiting for you at the door to go to school it's half the battle.

We're lucky as our walking distance primary is pretty damned good with a head who the kids, staff and parents rate.

Bananasareyellow · 05/10/2021 19:18

My son is currently in Y5. When I was looking when he was 4 I focused mainly on his immediate needs, I didnt really know what to look for for when he got older, but I can tell you what I'd look for now. He has got a great teacher this year but had an awful one last year. The great one has a good connection with the kids, knows them all well, gets them doing a variety of different things. The terrible one would have a laugh with the class but didn't know them as well. And lessons were mainly cut and paste or a worksheet printed out. I imagine you'll be taken round to see the best teachers but if you get to look in books or talk to the kids, I'd try and look to see if the teacher has a relationship with them and that the work they do is creative and engaging.

donkey86 · 05/10/2021 19:17

If I can jump on the thread… would you look oddly at a school where the children call all the staff, even the head, by their first names? My nearest school does this and it seems very odd to me. They also have no uniform and a policy of neither rewarding nor punishing behaviour. It’s ofsted outstanding and other mums seem to think I’m crazy, but I think I’d rather send DD to the more normal, but less well rated, school slightly further away.