Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resist using the word "queer"

160 replies

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 15:51

I am old enough to remember (not even that long ago) when calling someone queer was a massive insult. So I'm really uncomfortable using the word now even though some sections of LGBT+ seem to have reclaimed it. I would feel the same using the "n" word that some sections of black communities (especially in the US) have reclaimed.

I mentioned this to a friend the other day and she seems to think I was being really unreasonable in not accepting it as a perfectly valid word to describe someone's sexuality/sexual preferences (actually not sure what it even is referring to) and that I was somehow bigoted for not feeling comfortable using it.

AIBU?

OP posts:
GrettaGreen · 05/10/2021 19:52

As a lesbian I hate it. I'll probably get flamed for this but to me it's generally used by people who do belong/want to belong to the LGBT community for anything/everything except being a bog standard gay man or lesbian.

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 05/10/2021 19:33

I'm a lesbian in my mid thirties. It's not my chosen way of describing myself, and I'm cautious in using it for two reasons -

  1. Lots of (LGBT) people still find it offensive, with good reason
  2. It has IMO a shifting meaning so often doesn't aid clarity.

I recognise what people are saying here about it seeming to be a handy identity for people who appear to be straight and not trans but who want the cool points. Having run the gamut of homophobia and lesbophobia for many years now, the idea that there are cool points makes me roll my eyes hard. I also suspect that for many/most teenage girls, lesbian is still a difficult label to assume and present with.

A bit earlier than this, I experienced it as a reclaimed word which strongly connoted a certain set of gay politics - queer theory stuff, before queer theory became so widely discussed in the mainstream, and also lots of gay liberation type stuff which emphasised the shared struggle and overlaps of L/G/B/T people.

I know people who have lived for decades on the boundaries of lesbian/gay/bi/trans, for whom I think it can be a helpful way to capture that. I do think this is different from the wistful straight people who want to perform their queerness whilst also benefiting from societal approval bestowed on their observably-straight relationships. Eg people who are female-bodied, sometimes passing as male but not strongly or consistently identifying as trans men, who have relationships predominantly with other women - it's not on me to tell them they need to call themselves a lesbian, although obviously they qualify for this label (maybe this is where I'm differentiating them from the 'cool points' people).

Finally, it's helpfully more amenable to verbing than lesbian is (or even bi, gay, homosexual etc). So it's easy to talk about queering an aesthetic or a dynamic or whatever, and I'd theoretically use it in that context. I could rework the whole sentence to use some version of the word 'lesbian' instead, but queering is a very usable and well recognised term which works for me.

I think it's a fraught term, and would not recommend straight people adopt it as an inclusive term when they (occasionally) need to discuss LGBT people as a group. But I also know from experience it's very avoidable.

scarpa · 05/10/2021 19:31

I have a fair few gay and lesbian friends who refer to themselves as queer, so I would have no issue using it around them. As a bi woman I wouldn't necessarily use it myself, mostly because I am now married to an (also bi) man - I would have been less bothered/felt more 'deserving' when I was in relationships with women (which is some internalised biphobia probably! But I don't want to be seen as co-opting something when to the casual observer I am in a hetero relationship).

I'd be VERY wary of using it to refer to anyone who hadn't explicitly defined themselves that way to me.

Bombaloorina · 05/10/2021 19:30

@foxgoosefinch

I’m L/B and wouldn’t use it - I come into contact with a fair number of older very posh people through work, and you still hear it used as a slur in casual conversation in those social circles. My students however all love it and it’s widespread in youth social media.

I don’t like the “reclaiming” thing because gay people have spent decades getting to the point where their sexuality is not seen as abnormal, strange, out of the ordinary or odd. Young people using it often want to signal how they are out of the norm and “queer” sexuality is seen as anything non-normative (including kink and so on). Well, that has always undoubtedly been present in some gay communities (largely gay male communities), but at the same time lots of gay people just wanted equal pension and employment rights and to be left alone to book hotel rooms and get mortgages and have kids without it being assumed they were “kinky” or “bent” just because they had fallen in love with someone of the same sex. The right to be considered normal and boring, in fact!

Queer for me is a backward step precisely because of that - but lots of young people see it as precisely their way of asserting their difference from the boring old normies. I presume it will become a lot less attractive as a term when that generation get to the point when they want all the boring stuff too.

Insightful post - thanks, and I agree re your last point.
5zeds · 05/10/2021 19:26

I don’t use it at all. Certainly I would never call someone “queer”.

Bramblecrumble21 · 05/10/2021 19:22

I thought it meant weird and nothing else when I was a kid. Blush

Coogee · 05/10/2021 19:20

My Nan used the word queer all the time purely to describe something odd.

My husband occasionally uses it in that way too.

As in “I feel a bit queer.”

Jennifer11 · 05/10/2021 19:12

I wouldn't use it - still sounds insulting to me and seems to have been adopted by a fair number of straight people who want to make themselves sound edgyConfused

foxgoosefinch · 05/10/2021 19:06

I’m L/B and wouldn’t use it - I come into contact with a fair number of older very posh people through work, and you still hear it used as a slur in casual conversation in those social circles. My students however all love it and it’s widespread in youth social media.

I don’t like the “reclaiming” thing because gay people have spent decades getting to the point where their sexuality is not seen as abnormal, strange, out of the ordinary or odd. Young people using it often want to signal how they are out of the norm and “queer” sexuality is seen as anything non-normative (including kink and so on). Well, that has always undoubtedly been present in some gay communities (largely gay male communities), but at the same time lots of gay people just wanted equal pension and employment rights and to be left alone to book hotel rooms and get mortgages and have kids without it being assumed they were “kinky” or “bent” just because they had fallen in love with someone of the same sex. The right to be considered normal and boring, in fact!

Queer for me is a backward step precisely because of that - but lots of young people see it as precisely their way of asserting their difference from the boring old normies. I presume it will become a lot less attractive as a term when that generation get to the point when they want all the boring stuff too.

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 17:31

I don't understand your first paragraph?

OP posts:
MildCreamyCheddar · 05/10/2021 17:21

I'm queer. Unless you want me to describe what does and doesn't make my vagina moist, whilst explaining how I do or don't feel about my gender, and so on.

Gay was always used more than queer as an insult where I grew up, but once gay people reclaimed the word and lesbians started using the term gay for themselves too, it became quite powerless.

That's all that's happening to the word queer. Those of us who use it and are happy or proud or in circumstances where it's safe to say so, are reclaiming it and making it powerless as an insult.

Nobody has to use it if they don't want to. And if it doesn't apply to you or you don't feel it does, then great. Cool.

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 17:05

No one is "making" me use the word, it just came up in conversation about style and language as my friend and I do similar jobs in publishing. It was the fact that she kind of recoiled from me when I said I felt uncomfortable using it and seemed to suggest I was somehow narrow minded or bigoted for not feeling comfortable using the term.

I'm not going to tell anyone else not to use it, I just don't like hearing it or using it as it sounds like an insult to me. As I said, same as using the "n" word would.

My friend is straight, married, not alternative in any way but also very woke. I was just wondering if I am way behind the times or if other people feel the same as me.

OP posts:
3scape · 05/10/2021 16:54

I was born in the 70s it has moved through use in my life from my grandparents meaning something or someone was odd or unusual to my parents using it as a snide awful insult to my daughter's seeing it as a way to shorthand describe either non heteronormative nor gender normative.

I avoid using the word. My sister in law calls herself queer we are similar ages and both bisexual, see ourselves as women but don't perhaps 'adhere' to some feminine gender norms.

To be frank though, noone has ever challenged my non use of the word as I tend to be quite factual. Sister in law is more expressive and enjoys change to language.

Passmeamenuatthetottenham · 05/10/2021 16:52

It's definitely been appropriated by people that it was definitely not directed at in the past and for that reason I cringe a bit when I hear it now. I agree it is largely becoming meaningless now and is just a way for certain people to identify into a certain group, in the way that young people tend to do.

riotlady · 05/10/2021 16:51

It’s totally fine for you not to use it, so long as you don’t bother those of us that do.

MakkaPakkas · 05/10/2021 16:47

I don't like it either. Fwiw, I'm technically 'queer' as people use it these days and I don't mind when people use it with good intentions but it is jarring when I remember it as quite a vicious homophobic insult.

Shamoo · 05/10/2021 16:46

My wife (in a same sex marriage) describes herself as queer, I describe myself as gay - both of these are fine, as it’s up to us what we describe ourselves as. I have only ever identified as gay since I understood myself, she is not gay as she can be attracted to men (and has been in relationships with men).

Agree that in the last 15 years I have heard gay used as an insult far far more than queer.

Words change. Describing an effeminate man as a queer in a derogatory way (or gay, or see also f-word) = not ok. Describing somebody in the right context as queer or gay because that’s how they identify = ok. It’s not really very difficult.

shouldistop · 05/10/2021 16:44

It's an insult IMO, it means strange.

I can't imagine ever having to refer to someone else's sexuality anyway. It doesn't come up in conversation.

VickyEadieofThigh · 05/10/2021 16:43

@Whatsnewpussyhat

Now used by straight males to appropriate gay oppression so no one questions them when they call lesbians bigots and phobes for not being sexually attracted to their penis.

Also heard it used by priviliged straight students who think they are special and have no clue what used to happen to gay men when it was actually illegal to be gay.

ABSOLUTELY THIS.
Whatsnewpussyhat · 05/10/2021 16:42

Now used by straight males to appropriate gay oppression so no one questions them when they call lesbians bigots and phobes for not being sexually attracted to their penis.

Also heard it used by priviliged straight students who think they are special and have no clue what used to happen to gay men when it was actually illegal to be gay.

ThanksItHasPockets · 05/10/2021 16:26

Like a pp I wonder how often you would ever need to use it?

I encounter the word relatively frequently but only ever used by people who use it to identify themselves. Very occasionally the academic term 'queer theory' comes up in my work and I would use the phrase then. I'd also use it if someone had explicitly asked me to but how often do you find yourself needing to describe someone else's sexuality to a third party?

pinkstripeycat · 05/10/2021 16:26

My Nan used the word queer all the time purely to describe something odd. She’d be vilified for using it now as people no doubt would misunderstand her.
The same as her friend called Gay. Don’t suppose that would be allowed either.
They are words and people get so hung up on them

Tal45 · 05/10/2021 16:25

There's no requirement to refer to anyone as queer so I wouldn't worry about it. I really dislike the word myself but I understand that some people find it useful.

VickyEadieofThigh · 05/10/2021 16:24

@DisappearingGirl

I'm more irritated that some people seem to be identifying as queer when they are not actually gay (or bi, or trans). Looking at you, cool young celebrities!

As far as I can tell they are simply identifying as "a bit alternative" or even as "wanting to be a bit special but not sure how".

But maybe I am just old and grumpy!!

THIS.

I'm in my early 60s, a lesbian and old enough to remember very well that "queer" was usually accompanied - for men at least - with assault.

MOST of the people "reclaiming" this word are just heterosexuals with blue hair and sometimes kinks or fetishes.

ShrikeAttack · 05/10/2021 16:24

Gay and lesbian friends of mine absolutely hate it as it was used as a slur against them when they were younger.

The only friend or acquaintance of mine who uses it as a self-descriptor a bisexual gender-studies lecturer in her 50s who is very TWAW.

I certainly wouldn't use it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread