Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resist using the word "queer"

160 replies

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 15:51

I am old enough to remember (not even that long ago) when calling someone queer was a massive insult. So I'm really uncomfortable using the word now even though some sections of LGBT+ seem to have reclaimed it. I would feel the same using the "n" word that some sections of black communities (especially in the US) have reclaimed.

I mentioned this to a friend the other day and she seems to think I was being really unreasonable in not accepting it as a perfectly valid word to describe someone's sexuality/sexual preferences (actually not sure what it even is referring to) and that I was somehow bigoted for not feeling comfortable using it.

AIBU?

OP posts:
GrolliffetheDragon · 05/10/2021 23:09

I'm in my 40's, bi and don't like it. Makes me cringe tbh.

I know people who identify as queer and conform to the stereotypes - blue hair etc. Which is fine, until they start patronisingly explaining it to me.

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 23:03

It's interesting to think about what the difference is though. Some black people would never use the n word because its so offensive. Whereas some black people have reclaimed it. But still white people cannot use the term, only black people can, otherwise its offensive (because white people were the original oppressors).

For queer, some people, as shown on this thread, including the LGBT community, would never use the word due to its offensive connotations. Some people in the LGBT community have reclaimed it. Why should non-LGBT people be able to use it if white people can't use the n word, as it is straight people who have oppressed the LGBT community? What is the difference between the two?

If its all about affirming identities, then why should anyone be pressurised to affirm people as queer even if they find the word offensive, but not be allowed to affirm someone's chosen identity of the n word if they feel comfortable to do so? Is it because the n word is just SO offensive?

Just some ponderings before I go to sleep!

OP posts:
katemuff · 05/10/2021 22:54

@Cabinfever10

I am sick and tired of mainly straight people saying that they are queer. It is and always has been a derogatory slur! I don't know any LGB people who actually want it used especially when it's not them who have "reclaimed " it but stonewall (which is now a very homophobic group) that calls them genital fetishism for being same sex attracted instead of same gender attraction
I couldn't agree more
Ionlydomassiveones · 05/10/2021 22:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Kanaloa · 05/10/2021 22:50

Also in the same vein, ‘gay’ was an insult when I was growing up. If someone did something annoying/embarrassing, people would laugh or sneer and say ‘that’s so gay’ or ‘you’re so gay.’ It was just something nasty that people said.

Kanaloa · 05/10/2021 22:48

Words can evolve though. That’s why using the n word is unacceptable, it’s only ever been used in that one way so could not possibly be used by a white person in any other but a racist way.

Queer used to mean something a bit odd or different, then it was a slur, now it’s no longer a slur. There isn’t really a time when you’ll be forced into using it though so if you don’t want to then just avoid it.

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 22:43

It's not defining someone else's identity to avoid using a word that is sometimes used as an insult or a slur.

OP posts:
Bobsyer · 05/10/2021 22:30

I honestly can't see any time where I'd be comfortable using it. I'm a straight woman, and I won't use the word 'bitch' for broadly the same reason - I don't think it has been 'reclaimed' by the actual people it refers to.

WhatAShilohPitt · 05/10/2021 22:20

YANBU. It’s a horrible word and it has connotations of weird / odd which just don’t seem appropriate any more. No wonder if used to be an insult. I first came across it in the 1990s in a literary theory class at uni that was about ‘queer theory.’ I’m LGBTQ and I think if people want to call themselves queer then let them but don’t expect me to use it too when I dislike it.

Siepie · 05/10/2021 22:17

We’re not talking about school insults though, re “queer”. This was a long-standing historical term of abuse for gay men, and, as a pp said, often accompanied by violence.

I understand that. I'm in my early 30s but grew up in a very homophobic religious environment where 'queer bashing' was seen as acceptable or even to be celebrated.

I still don't think that means that straight people should prioritise their own comfort when talking about another person's sexuality. It comes across as thinking they know better than the LGBT/queer person about that person's own identity.

Would you be happy to call someone an "n" word if that's how they like to refer to themselves?

That's difficult to imagine as there isn't a group of black people asking white people to refer to them by the "n" word.

But I do have a coloured South African colleague and despite my feelings about that word, I do refer to her as coloured, because it's not up to me to define somebody else's identity.

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 21:28

Would you be happy to call someone an "n" word if that's how they like to refer to themselves?

OP posts:
foxgoosefinch · 05/10/2021 21:13

I know straight women who got called lesbians as an insult at school (because they had short hair etc), but I wouldn't be happy if someone refused to call me a lesbian for that reason.

We’re not talking about school insults though, re “queer”. This was a long-standing historical term of abuse for gay men, and, as a pp said, often accompanied by violence.

I’m in my early forties and vividly remember often hearing it said - eg. in my twenties walking through Soho with male friends and hearing aggressive men shouting “queers” at us. I know a fair number of gay men of my age who got “queer-bashed” - as the charming term used to be for beating up gender non-confirming men (once, aged about 22, a gay male friend was beaten up outside the local police station by “queer-bashers” in broad daylight, and no-one came to his aid.)

That must have been around 2002. Not so long ago that gay people my age don’t immediately associate the term with genuine violence - not just playground insults.

Fine for young people without that experience to believe they are reclaiming a positive self-identity by using it; that’s their prerogative - but no, it isn’t disrespectful to avoid it as a term either. It is not a term that’s largely welcomed by anyone over 35 and for very good reasons.

Siepie · 05/10/2021 21:01

@Piapiano

I don't feel comfortable using the word queer as to me it still feels like an insult. In the same as someone asked me to call them the "n" word I wouldn't feel comfortable doing so.

I don't use the phrase when talking about people. I don't use it at all.

I think this could come across as insulting to some people who do describe themselves as queer. I don't know what kind of publishing you work in, but if you e.g. refused to describe someone as 'queer' in an article (when it was relevant) or to write about an academic who works on 'queer theory', I expect they'd be quite put out.

I know straight women who got called lesbians as an insult at school (because they had short hair etc), but I wouldn't be happy if someone refused to call me a lesbian for that reason.

whatswithtodaytoday · 05/10/2021 20:44

*know gay people my age who don't like it

whatswithtodaytoday · 05/10/2021 20:44

I'm 40 and don't feel comfortable using it either. I also know that people my age who don't like it.

However, younger people do use it to describe themselves (including ones who appear to be straight?!) and if they want to use it that's fine. Language evolves. I would feel very odd saying it though.

Biancadelrioisback · 05/10/2021 20:41

Many bi/pan women who have ended up with a male partner or vice versa also use queer because of the connotations associated with saying they're bi/pan.

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 20:32

So can queer sometimes mean heterosexual but not conforming to gender stereotypes then? Eg wearing alternative clothes and hairstyles?

OP posts:
Piapiano · 05/10/2021 20:30

So he is saying that queer is another word for LGBTQ+ and he personally likes the word but acknowledges that other don't like the word queer because of its history.

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 05/10/2021 20:26

My understanding is that gay and queer are not exactly the same thing. I don’t want to label anyone anything at all. I just want to see fellow humans.

Gay is homosexual. Queer is basically straight with a stupid hairdo.

Bagelsandbrie · 05/10/2021 20:22

This is quite a powerful link-

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 20:22

I don't feel comfortable using the word queer as to me it still feels like an insult. In the same as someone asked me to call them the "n" word I wouldn't feel comfortable doing so.

I don't use the phrase when talking about people. I don't use it at all.

OP posts:
Piapiano · 05/10/2021 20:20

I'm finding these responses really interesting, thank you to those who have explained your thoughts. I'm glad I'm not the only one to have reservations about the term and haven't turned into too much of a dinosaur 🦖

I wonder if it is adopted in the mainstream of the younger generation it will eventually lose its negative connotations. Or if, conversely, there will be a backlash against what could be seen as a heterosexual appropriation of the word.

OP posts:
carebearbaby · 05/10/2021 20:15

I'm mid 30s and although not gay myself, I have lots of gay and lesbian friends and I am very much involved in the lgbtq+ community as an ally.

Queer has been a way they have described themselves since early teens and still do. We had queer as folk on repeat, used to go to a club night called queer. It's been a reclaimed word locally (manchester) for 20+ year.

If people want to refer to themselves as queer, why would you not support it? And like others have said, how often would you use the phrase when talking about people, if they haven't confirmed it as a comfortable umbrella term previously?

Bagelsandbrie · 05/10/2021 20:12

Interesting thread.

There’s a scene in Sex Education on Netflix when the non binary character and the “straight” sportsman boy type are kissing and they turn to him and say “You do realise if we continue with this you’d be in a queer relationship?” And Dh and I both looked at each other a bit Confused because for us oldies it was always a gay insult. But young people don’t use it like that anymore at all. It seems to be a way of describing anyone who isn’t heterosexual (as far as I understand it)!

VicSynix · 05/10/2021 20:08

I'm mid 50s, and it just makes me think of 'queer-bashing,' thugs shouting 'Oi, poofter', and horrible 70s sitcoms where being gay was mocked and derided.

Swipe left for the next trending thread