Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resist using the word "queer"

160 replies

Piapiano · 05/10/2021 15:51

I am old enough to remember (not even that long ago) when calling someone queer was a massive insult. So I'm really uncomfortable using the word now even though some sections of LGBT+ seem to have reclaimed it. I would feel the same using the "n" word that some sections of black communities (especially in the US) have reclaimed.

I mentioned this to a friend the other day and she seems to think I was being really unreasonable in not accepting it as a perfectly valid word to describe someone's sexuality/sexual preferences (actually not sure what it even is referring to) and that I was somehow bigoted for not feeling comfortable using it.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Stitchybitch79 · 07/10/2021 23:46

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

I'm gay and use it. To me it just means gay, which I am and it also means a bit odd, and people have always described me as such. It fits. And I don't find it insulting. It does not belong to straight people however.

But that’s the issue. In current day parlance, it’s seemingly straight people appropriating it, because they don’t want to identify as boring old, vanilla ‘straight’.

Yes, I understand that.
Hattie765 · 07/10/2021 22:58

It's all gone over your head a bit hasn't it. It's always been a word used by straight people you idiot! Never a word used by any LGB person. The fact you have made up a new definition of the word in your own minds makes not a bit of difference. It is a word that belongs to straight people.

HermioneAndRoger · 07/10/2021 06:36

@Alekto

MN has automatic filtering of some offensive words

Does it? I know some words which will trigger a deletion if not used carefully, but that is reliant on readers reporting. Do you mean there's an automated system to remove certain words or does the post get the pending message or something else?

I don’t know what all the words are but certainly when I once tried to use the adjective for the noun ‘spasm’ in a discussion of words which are taboo in BrE but common in AmE it was deleted automatically at the point of posting.
Simonjt · 07/10/2021 05:58

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

I'm gay and use it. To me it just means gay, which I am and it also means a bit odd, and people have always described me as such. It fits. And I don't find it insulting. It does not belong to straight people however.

But that’s the issue. In current day parlance, it’s seemingly straight people appropriating it, because they don’t want to identify as boring old, vanilla ‘straight’.

People (mainly straight people) seem to be claiming this, yet I’m set to see a single person who isn’t LGBTQ+ calling themselves queer.
Gwrach · 07/10/2021 00:00

I can't use it. I'm 31 and it was a "playground insult"

I can remember (enter boys name) shouting it across the yard age 13 "YOU FUCKING Q, ILL KNOCK YOU OUT NOW" toward one of the other boys.

Then there was "what's your problem, you a q?!"

So it's a no from me. I just use gay/lesbian but to be honest I don't even have to refer to anyone's sexuality generally. I don't care 🤷🏻‍♀️

KittenKong · 06/10/2021 23:52

Didn’t Lily Cole and that one from The Good Place announce that they were Q? Both either married or in long term straight relationships and not known to have had same sex partners? Hmm

TheCloudBotherer · 06/10/2021 23:04

I'm happy to be described as a lesbian, as gay or as same sex-attracted. I don't want to be described as 'queer' as I associate it with the erosion of my homosexuality.

Basically this. I'm in my late 20s and, by the time I was in 6th Form, "queer" was being used over gay and lesbian. There was an LGBT society in 6th form which I didn't elect to join but there was a massive overlap in members with another club I was part of so I got to know the people in it fairly well. They largely referred to themselves as queer, "gay" was generally used in a jokey context and "lesbian" was pretty much not mentioned at all. They exemplified the "blue haired heterosexuals wanting to be quirky" which other posters have mentioned. I had no qualms about telling family and friends about being a lesbian, or introducing them to a girlfriend if I ever got one, but I realised then that I was very much out of step with the people who I was supposed to be part of a "community" with. I'm still loosely in touch with most of them as friends of friends and, to my knowledge, only two out of 16 have ever been in a same sex relationship. There's a variety of non-binary, genderqueer, pansexual (but only ever dating the opposite sex), demi-girl, and trans but homosexuality seems to have largely fallen out of fashion. Lesbian groups or dating sites which don't refer to themselves as being for "queer women" or fall over themselves to say that they include trans and non binary lesbians within their bracket are increasingly few and far between. (I thought that "non binary lesbians" would be female but, as it turns out, nope.)

I don't call myself queer partly due to the historical association with it as a slur but mostly because I've found I've nothing in common with people my age who use the term. (I'm aware that, in other age brackets, queer seems to be used more to actually mean gay or lesbian rather than someone who fancies themselves as "a bit different".)

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 06/10/2021 23:03

I'm gay and use it. To me it just means gay, which I am and it also means a bit odd, and people have always described me as such. It fits. And I don't find it insulting.
It does not belong to straight people however.

But that’s the issue. In current day parlance, it’s seemingly straight people appropriating it, because they don’t want to identify as boring old, vanilla ‘straight’.

SoupDragon · 06/10/2021 22:25

@Alekto

MN has automatic filtering of some offensive words

Does it? I know some words which will trigger a deletion if not used carefully, but that is reliant on readers reporting. Do you mean there's an automated system to remove certain words or does the post get the pending message or something else?

Posts containing the words are hidden automatically until a member of MNHQ checks them. When it was first introduced you couldn't use the word "snigger" which they fixed! It's used to filter some spam too I think.
Alekto · 06/10/2021 22:16

MN has automatic filtering of some offensive words

Does it? I know some words which will trigger a deletion if not used carefully, but that is reliant on readers reporting. Do you mean there's an automated system to remove certain words or does the post get the pending message or something else?

ComtesseDeSpair · 06/10/2021 22:00

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

Anyone who identifies as ‘queer’ feel like providing us with their understanding of what it means? A definition?

If you use it to label yourself, then surely you’d be happy to do that.

One of my previous partners from years ago was a transman - female born, had altered their appearance with surgery and hormones (though didn’t believe TWAW or TMAM.) And for me, describing myself as a lesbian, when my partner had facial hair and had had their breasts surgically removed, and begun the bottom surgery process, and passed in any public circumstance as a man, didn’t seem quite the right descriptive word for my sexuality, even though my partner’s biology was female. But nor had I become straight, simply because my partner had chosen to change the way they looked and the pronouns they used and pass as a man: my sexuality is ultimately my own and isn’t dependent on the actions of my partner. So I called myself queer. It fitted, at the time.
Stitchybitch79 · 06/10/2021 21:56

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

Anyone who identifies as ‘queer’ feel like providing us with their understanding of what it means? A definition?

If you use it to label yourself, then surely you’d be happy to do that.

I'm gay and use it. To me it just means gay, which I am and it also means a bit odd, and people have always described me as such. It fits. And I don't find it insulting. It does not belong to straight people however.
HermioneAndRoger · 06/10/2021 20:37

It’s genuinely interesting to me that many of the people who are uncomfortable with the word have been happy to type it in full, unlike many of the other taboo words mentioned here. MN has automatic filtering of some offensive words but ‘queer’ is obviously not one of them.

Cabinfever10 · 06/10/2021 18:32

@blameitonthecaffeine
Yes most of the people who call themselves queer (normally straight) have blue hair and the head tilt, go on twitter or her (the supposedly lesbian dating app) and you'll see hundreds of them (mostly biologically males).
I'll let you look for yourself and when you do you'll understand what I mean by the head tilt

ShirleyNotAgain · 06/10/2021 18:23

Im a lesbian, been out over 30 years.

When I was young in the 1980s 'queer' was residually used as a term of offence, but growing up in Yorkshire I heard "there's nowt as queer as folk" - used far more.

In the nineties & beyond when I was a student & then an academic it was used liberally in postmodern discourse - everything was being queered & deconstructed. Some good work went on but much of it was performative & has got us to the place we are today where we face a dangerous & disingenuous gender ideology that, in my view, does harm to women & LGB people especially.

In recent years the only people I find using the term to describe themselves are under 30 & generally heterosexual but 'identify' as anything from non-binary to pan to demisexual & beyond. They're trading on something that they perceive makes them interesting I've had a couple tell me I'm queer because I'm a feminine lesbian. They have no idea of LGB history or culture & for all their talk of self-determination in terms of identity they seem very keen to label me against my wishes 🤔

I'm happy to be described as a lesbian, as gay or as same sex-attracted. I don't want to be described as 'queer' as I associate it with the erosion of my homosexuality. Just the same as I wouldn't have accepted being called a pregnant person when I was en route to becoming a mother.

itssarcasmjoan · 06/10/2021 18:18

I will ever use the word queer. It's vile.
Gay is also still used as a slur as well

KittenKong · 06/10/2021 18:14

I was bullied as a teen because of my gay sister, and yes, that was one of the words in the repertoire of bullies and arseholes (yes I can type that word).

Hattie765 · 06/10/2021 18:13

I think it's mainly used by people who don't remember when it was used as a slur, and a very nasty one at that. I could never use it, my gay brother was beaten up a number of times in the 80s and that was a word he was often targeted with, I find it incredibly difficult to hear and would never use it.

Kanaloa · 06/10/2021 18:12

@blameitonthecaffeine

There’s a joke John Mulaney tells about that, saying basically if you’re comparing the badness of two words and you won’t even say one of them, that’s the worse word.

Comparing queer to the n word is just silly though. We all know the huge difference is that some people identify themselves as queer and want to be called that. No black person I’ve ever met wants to be called the n word by white people as that’s how they identify. It’s just pointless to say but, but why can’t we call people the n word? It’s not relevant.

KittenKong · 06/10/2021 18:11

In what other context is there?

blameitonthecaffeine · 06/10/2021 18:10

But could you bring yourself to type the n word in any context?

KittenKong · 06/10/2021 18:07

I have typed the word once in the context of the well known expression to mean ‘odd’ or ‘weird’.

blameitonthecaffeine · 06/10/2021 18:01

I had no idea that the word queer was linked to having blue hair?! (is that for real of a joke - it's been mentioned multiple times on the thread?)

I can understand the arguments on both sides. I don't think I've ever really thought about it before. My mum still uses queer as a synonym for strange and it annoys me because she claims not to know it as a word in any other context and doesn't link it to homosexuality - even though I've told her about the link many, many times.

I think this thread is a clear example of why the word queer can't be compared to the n word though. Everybody has been happy to type queer and nobody has written 'the q word'. Nobody has been happy to type n*** and everybody has written 'the n word'.

sqirrelfriends · 06/10/2021 16:40

I think it's generally covers more people and preferences. I have a bisexual friend who I wrongly assumed was a lesbian because she's in a long term relationship with a woman. She's had a bit of a bad time in the past for her sexuality, and has generally made to feel like an outsider for not being "properly gay".

I still don't like the word though, it feels almost like a slur.

KittenKong · 06/10/2021 16:30

Soon can demand that people call me c*, your majesty or Eeeeekaaahraaaahhhrahhhhrrrk (flying money sound)?