Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not have a birthday party for my 4 year old?

36 replies

PartyPoopertime · 05/10/2021 15:36

DS is turning 4 soon. He's my first so not sure what the done thing is. He has started being invited to nursery friends birthday parties.
I just don't know how much he'd enjoy/appreciate a party at his age!? I feel like he'd just get overwhelmed!
PIL and SIL basically insinuated that it's cruel not to?
AIBU to not do a party?

We'd have presents and cake/balloons on the day (just parents him and little brother)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
APurpleSquirrel · 05/10/2021 23:53

We've done parties of a sort for all of DDs birthdays - her 4th was at a local miniature railway centre were they got to ride trains & play. She & her friends (mostly from nursery, some family friends & family) loved it.
We've done small parties at home; a joint village hall party with bouncy castle; a trampoline party; a forest school party & last month a whole class party at a soft play for her 7th.
DS had a small home party for his 1st, but his subsequent birthday's have been in lockdown. His 4th next year will definitely be a proper party.
Parties can be very stressful if you're doing everything yourself; but if you go for somewhere that supplies the food & entertainment, it's a lot easier.

Xmasbaby11 · 05/10/2021 23:42

We did parties from age 3. My dds both enjoyed them and love looking back on birthday memories. My 7yo can remember everyone at her 3rd birthday! But I had friends with 3 year olds as well as nursery friends, so it wasn't a load of strangers, and I'm quite extrovert so it wouldn't stress me out. We don't have a big family and it's mostly older generation so no fun big family get togethers- I suppose we've tried to develop friendships.

By 4 mine were very aware and wanted a party - probably 8-10 kids. If your ds isn't bothered there's no need. Mine are still into parties but not all kids are.

Bellyups · 05/10/2021 23:34

I didn’t until they were older

Littlecaf · 05/10/2021 23:31

We’ve just done one for DS at 4. 8 of his preschool friends. Party games, birthday tea, party bags. Cost about £50 in all. They loved it.

ShinyGreenElephant · 05/10/2021 23:26

Weve just had a party for dd2s 3rd birthday and she absolutely loved it- church hall with soft play, a bouncy castle and an entertainer then party food and a character visit. There was 10 kids plus 4 baby siblings which was a good amount and she absolutely loved it and hasnt stopped talking about it since. My eldest started having parties from 3 as well and she always had a ball. I do think it depends on personality though and what they're used to - my dd is very sociable and goes to lots of playgroups and toddler classes so it wasn't overwhelming for her at all just very exciting. We did have tears at the end but not from her, that was my 6 year old stepson who didn't want the bouncy castle to leave!

Mermaidpool · 05/10/2021 23:17

We did one at home with 4 friends at age 4. They played in the garden, ate some food and went home after 2 hours it was lovely. I knew the parents from preschool so no adults stayed which I preferred

Sinthie · 05/10/2021 23:12

I took my 4 year old trampolining with her 3 cousins and brother. Pizza after. She loved it. She couldn’t really decide who she wanted to invite to a party from nursery and didn’t seem bothered about a big party at all.

PartyPoopertime · 05/10/2021 18:16

Thanks for all the replies!

Ah I still feel conflicted now reading the comments! It seems like lots of peoples little ones enjoyed it.
I don't necessarily think he'd be bothered with a party but as mentioned by a PP, I actually think just the four of us at home isn't very special now I think about it.

Family aren't really an option as they all live quite far away/abroad.
I did have cousins/family for his first birthday.

OP posts:
Suddenlyfamily5 · 05/10/2021 17:27

Not cruel not to have a party obviously.

But my now 8 year old still remembers and talks about his 4th birthday. It was a busy stressful day for me, but he loved it and I am glad he had one.

Beseen22 · 05/10/2021 17:27

Mine is 5 in Jan and having first party then. Remember we had one at pizza express when he was 2 but it was a our friends..really just an excuse for a meal out. He loved that but he was a quirky kid

jezzyj · 05/10/2021 17:21

Mine is turning 4 in a about 5 months. We've also had the nursery invites and I'm worrying about having to do a party

I feel like it's just awkward. It's not like primary school where the necessarily have proper friends.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 05/10/2021 17:16

When mine were 4 we took a couple of their friends to McDonald's.

MajorCarolDanvers · 05/10/2021 17:15

I didn't do parties till 5th birthdays when they had started primary school.

cleckheatonwanderer · 05/10/2021 17:14

plenty of time for parties I mean

cleckheatonwanderer · 05/10/2021 17:14

We didn't for DS at that age as he's not the most confident of children; at parties he would seek out 1 or 2 friends and hover around the edge of the action.

Don't feel like you should do a party just because others are, there's plenty of time for that!

mswales · 05/10/2021 16:56

We've done parties for each birthday but just family and my son's actual friends gathering in the park, so not an entire nursery class or anything, that sounds awful. I always say thanks but please don't bring presents, I don't do party bags, ask people to bring your own drink though always provide some - so the only expense and logistics on our side has been getting some nibbles and drinks and thinking of a couple of fun simple games. This year we did musical statues and a pinata, and had a lucky dip box filled with second hand little toys off ebay (cost about £7 for 30 toys!).
If you do something lowkey with max 10-15 kids who all know each other it can be really fun. However it is definitely not cruel to do a small celebration at home, it could easily be preferable for many children!

Flowerpower23 · 05/10/2021 16:54

I’ve just booked my daughters fifth bday party, 180 for the community centre 🤯 66 for a bouncy castle and 50 for a princess visit plus food and party bags etc!! Honestly just leave it 🤦🏼‍♀️

Orangedaisy · 05/10/2021 16:52

Mine love their parties and have done since aged 3. But you know your child. Local leisure centre soft play/bouncy castle parties have worked very well for us at that age.

saoirse31 · 05/10/2021 16:51

Did a party from 4, not whole class, Ds loved them

Twizbe · 05/10/2021 16:51

I've not done parties for my two. Tbf their last birthdays were in lockdown so couldn't have one.

My son has asked for a party for his next (5th birthday) but until he'd asked, we weren't going to do one for him.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 05/10/2021 16:50

My DS was clear that he wanted birthday parties from when he was 3, and he loved them and remembers where they were held and who was there. At 4 he definitely would have wanted his friends there, but would have been happy to just have it at home.

Beyondword · 05/10/2021 16:49

Yanbu.
Possibly invite one friend but a big party isn't necessary. Even the less likely to be overwhelmed children often get overwhelmed at Birthday parties and it's just so stressful and full-on for them.
You know what's best for your child.

adoreyou · 05/10/2021 16:47

DD had her first proper party at 4 and she loved it. Everyone did. Was such a memorable day.... especially as her next birthday was in lockdown so we couldn't go or do anything or see anyone!

But you know your child best. But if they are ok attending parties how will having one be any different?

Ledition · 05/10/2021 16:46

My DDs have loved parties from the get go it seemed. I'd never get away with not having one at 4 - they count down the days! I only invite family though. So my parents, siblings and their DC and the same on DHs side. With a couple of great aunts thrown into the mix. They have cousins their age on both sides though so it seems like a proper party to them. Could you invite family? I do think it's a bit rubbish not to have some sort of celebration besides just the four of you at home like normal but with cake.

5yo just started school this year so I imagine I'll have to have her classmates for the 6th bday - dreading that to be honest Grin

Zezet · 05/10/2021 16:45

I would do a party! My kids loved them from age 3.
But:

  • at home
  • no more than 1,5 hour for 3yo, maybe 2h for 5yo
  • age = amount of friends invited (4 years=4 classmates max). Maybe a parent for little kids but otherwise no extra adults.
  • keep it small. Paper crown, 1 dish, 2 drinks to chose from (1 is water), maybe some dancing in the room. Nothing that is so cool it will overwhelm them.
  • talk them through the plan

Won't cost much either that way, and they'll be able to handle it.