Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think what Boris Johnson has said today is unacceptable?

211 replies

NoviceNewMN · 05/10/2021 14:00

first he has said (I'm guessing as a sop to commercial landlords complaining about properties being abandoned by businesses) that everyone needs to go back to work because they will be gossiped about:

"You have got to be able to come in, you have got to know what everyone else is talking about – otherwise you are going to be gossiped about and you are going to lose out"

Really? Firstly so what? and secondly, it's basically condoning bullying as a reason to get back to work.

Then he has said

'It's not the job of government to come in and try and fix every problem in business and industry."

Boris says it is 'not my job to fix all of the UK's problems': PM’s astonishing claim as he denies nation is in 'crisis' and DISMISSES inflation spike fears, fuel shortages and empty supermarket shelves as 'just part of his new approach'

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10060043/Boris-denies-claims-supply-chain-chaos-just-ending-UKs-low-wage-economy.html

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 05/10/2021 16:14

A lot of time is wasted during in person meetings. Sometimes that is necessary, but a lot of the time it is just people avoiding actual work.

I find myself actually scheduling my formal meetings, boards etc for the days I'm WFH. I really like hybrid but there's no way I'm wasting office time on sitting in meetings - I get the most out of my office days working alongside people, getting on with collaborative task work, having more junior staff members shadow me - the things that are less easy to do (though still possible) from home.

I don't buy, though, that you can't train people remotely. We've had new interns, new apprentices and people early in their careers join in the last eighteen months. Was it as satisfying an experience than being in the office fulltime? Almost certainly not. But we were still able to train and induct and integrate them into the team and work on their skills and capabilities remotely. They're all doing really well, meeting and exceeding targets. It helps that we've hired good people, but it's also helped that we've been responsive to them and willing to tweak and adjust where things aren't working. It's surprised me that it's actually as much some of the junior people who don't want to be back in the office 5 days a week as the seniors.

It's certainly not been perfect - we've definitely screwed some things up, and some things are definitely easier in person. But let's not pretend that under hybrid or majority WFH models, people just won't (or can't) get trained. I'm sure there are some places where it will happen like that. I wouldn't stay at one of those places for long, though, and TBH they don't deserve to do well.
And yes, a lot of the City workers I know - investment banks, Big 4, etc - have been doing a hybrid model for years, especially if they are working across time zones.

JinglingHellsBells · 05/10/2021 16:13

@EarlGreywithLemon what does that person do for a job?

If you are a chief exec (ceo, cfo, cmo) of a major company or on the board of directors, say Tesco, or Waitrose, or J Lewis, you can't work from home for all of your time. Or if you are work at the Stock Exchange etc.

If the person you know is self employed ( sole trader or small business owner) that's different.

HouseworkDodger · 05/10/2021 16:11

Can’t abide Boris or the Tory ethos but I agree with what he said about business and industry. They have benefitted from low pay, unsociable hours and poor working conditions for too long so they could pour money into their shareholders pockets.

Look at how many billions the supermarkets make but now can’t get drivers to deliver their stock. They should have been investing in that a long time ago, that’s not the government’s fault.

My DH is a HGV driver for a supermarket and they were relying heavily on agency drivers which of which a large proportion were Eastern European because they didn’t want to give out proper contracts. Now they can’t get them and they’re desperate, they’ve doubled the hourly pay for agency drivers but kept the contract workers on the same amount. At one depot all the drivers walked out as they could walk straight into new jobs. It was no surprise we’d be in this situation now.

julieca · 05/10/2021 16:07

@Badbadbunny you make arrangements. Our new apprentice is in the office with a few other staff. But he has met far more of us in online meetings in his first week of work than he would have in a busy office.
No one is saying that we should have no one in offices, but employers and staff can sort out for themselves what works best. They don't need government micro managing.
What next? Are they going to start telling us that buying a takeaway coffee makes us more productive and makes our colleagues like us more?
I mean it is just so transparent.

NumberNineTwo · 05/10/2021 16:06

Trouble is that companies will also lose talent with the inevitable eventual shortfall in younger workers coming through the ranks
On the contrary - younger workers are refusing jobs that don’t offer at least partial WFH. They value work-life balance and see no need to get on the treadmill of commuting every day. DH has been having huge trouble employing a graduate trainee because they all decline when they find out the job doesn’t offer any WFH.

Weirdwonders · 05/10/2021 16:06

If it’s not his job to try and fix every problem in business and industry he can refrain from commenting on aspects of it that are working then, like home working, can’t he.

EarlGreywithLemon · 05/10/2021 16:06

*Many not manny.

EarlGreywithLemon · 05/10/2021 16:04

@JinglingHellsBells

Leaders in industry have been saying for months that successful careers and businesses are best achieved when people work face to face.

If you read the business pages of the broadsheets, many respected CEOs are saying that the way to get on in a company is to be there, physically, and also that interaction between colleagues in informal settings ( lunches, over the coffee machine etc) are vital to good working practices.

You can't build a career working from home for the rest of your life.

I think you’ll find you can. I know people who have done just that. One of my most competent and highly regarded colleagues has been working from home for manny years now, long before the pandemic.
julieca · 05/10/2021 16:04

@JinglingHellsBells

But I can see if you work in a relaxed office without much work, then being in the office and chatting a lot will make you more likely to be promoted.

Oh no, quite the opposite.

The people I know who are IN offices are snr management, who need to talk to each other face to face. They don't have time to chat or slack if that's what you mean!

I guess it depends where you work. When I was in management a lot of people were out of the office on visits and meetings during the day anyway, so all conversation between managers except for scheduled meetings in advance, was always virtually anyway. In my current workplace, I find it much easier to get hold of people for a quick meeting online, than I did when I was trying to talk to people in the office. Even our CEO is fairly easy now to get hold of for a quick chat about a project. A lot of time is wasted during in person meetings. Sometimes that is necessary, but a lot of the time it is just people avoiding actual work.
EarlGreywithLemon · 05/10/2021 16:01

@Dreamstate

As a previous poster said the Tory politi s aren't to micromanage peoples lives for them. That's socialism and they are not socialists. You want thr state to basically do everything for you go vote Labour in and see how you like being molly coddled.

Some of you would probably like it if the government paid for everything, dealt with everything and gave you xx amount to spend on whatever you like without having to worry about paying bills etc.

So why are they presumptions enough to tell us where we should be doing our work from?
Badbadbunny · 05/10/2021 16:01

@catgirl1976

Why on earth should people "get back to work"? Those working from home are already "at work". Work is a verb - a thing you do, not a place.

And companies that cannot move with the times will lose talent.

Trouble is that companies will also lose talent with the inevitable eventual shortfall in younger workers coming through the ranks. The school/Uni leavers either won't be taken on at all, or will take longer to be trained if there are few people actually in the workplace to train them. The next thing, in a few years, will be business & industry bleating that they can't get experienced/qualified staff - the workers who'd usually have been taken on to train last year, this year and next year!
SusieBob · 05/10/2021 15:59

@JinglingHellsBells

Leaders in industry have been saying for months that successful careers and businesses are best achieved when people work face to face.

If you read the business pages of the broadsheets, many respected CEOs are saying that the way to get on in a company is to be there, physically, and also that interaction between colleagues in informal settings ( lunches, over the coffee machine etc) are vital to good working practices.

You can't build a career working from home for the rest of your life.

Of course you can, and the best businesses have fully embraced this.

Companies that don't are bleeding staff.

Ozanj · 05/10/2021 15:59

I should point out that most London / Canary Wharf jobs have always been hybrid working & even analysts who are at the bottom of the pole would be able to wfh on Fridays.

JinglingHellsBells · 05/10/2021 15:58

But I can see if you work in a relaxed office without much work, then being in the office and chatting a lot will make you more likely to be promoted.

Oh no, quite the opposite.

The people I know who are IN offices are snr management, who need to talk to each other face to face. They don't have time to chat or slack if that's what you mean!

julieca · 05/10/2021 15:58

Also we have stuff like a watercooler virtual chat online once a week.
But being honest, i do not want to build a career and a lot of people don't. They just want to do their job and get paid. What works for high fliers is different to what works for everyone else.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/10/2021 15:57

It is just realistic to say people will miss out if they don’t come in to the office. I’m no Boris fan either!

I thought this was going to be able his views on misogyny as a hate crime.

JinglingHellsBells · 05/10/2021 15:56

Most businesses are now being flexible.
Most people are combining WFH and 2 or 3 days in the office.

It's not all one or the other.

People often need to be face to face to pick up on body language, especially during hard negotiating in business.

It's behavioural psychology and it makes a lot of sense.

Badbadbunny · 05/10/2021 15:56

It's a bit much him saying it's not governments job to fix every industry when it's government foul ups that have caused most of the problems.

julieca · 05/10/2021 15:56

@JinglingHellsBells which is why hybrid working is becoming popular. I spend time on spreadsheets during the week. I do not need anyone's input and tbh doing it in a busy office is difficult. Doing it from home is ideal.
But I can see if you work in a relaxed office without much work, then being in the office and chatting a lot will make you more likely to be promoted.

Ozanj · 05/10/2021 15:56

@JinglingHellsBells

Leaders in industry have been saying for months that successful careers and businesses are best achieved when people work face to face.

If you read the business pages of the broadsheets, many respected CEOs are saying that the way to get on in a company is to be there, physically, and also that interaction between colleagues in informal settings ( lunches, over the coffee machine etc) are vital to good working practices.

You can't build a career working from home for the rest of your life.

This only applies to young people at the start of their careers & Sunak and others have been clear about that because Wfh actually is better for people of colour, older workers & women as it destroys discrimimation in the workplace.
NumberNineTwo · 05/10/2021 15:56

You can't build a career working from home for the rest of your life
Agreed. But people want hybrid as a minimum. And some people don’t care about building a career, they just want to pay the bills and be around to look after their kids.

JassyRadlett · 05/10/2021 15:54

[quote julieca]@JassyRadlett agreed. My employer invested in home working. I have been shocked at how some people are expected to work without access to info. My friend works for Experian and before the first lockdown they tested out home working so they could adapt systems for the inevitable lockdown. They deal with very confidential info, but planned and invested. Now a lot of staff are hybrid.[/quote]
Totally! Organisations that expected home working to happen just as in person working did, without any changes to systems, processes or support. And then moaned about the results.

Ozanj · 05/10/2021 15:54

* Working from home can lead to lower productivity in some businesses, got nothing to do with management. Not all businesses are exactly the same.*

It doesn’t have to. Case in point, in Asia, most GPs wfh for at least part of their day. But technology is so advanced that they can diagnose virtually. In the UK most NHS GPs have to work from the office even to make telephone / virtual appointments because the tech is so shit you need to physically see someone if you’re not sure.

Similarly DH works in engineering. They are permanently wfh and have been for 30 years. They have an output based management style. So as long as they produce x output each month they can work however they like. Number of hours spent online means nothing if you miss your targets.

JinglingHellsBells · 05/10/2021 15:53

Leaders in industry have been saying for months that successful careers and businesses are best achieved when people work face to face.

If you read the business pages of the broadsheets, many respected CEOs are saying that the way to get on in a company is to be there, physically, and also that interaction between colleagues in informal settings ( lunches, over the coffee machine etc) are vital to good working practices.

You can't build a career working from home for the rest of your life.

JassyRadlett · 05/10/2021 15:53

@NumberNineTwo

Is there really any reason why people shouldn't be back in the office now? Because they don’t want to. It’s inconvenient and unnecessary. The world has moved on and technology has freed us from having to commute. I see no good reason to go back.
For me, my work life balance is immeasurably better with DH and I both working from home 2-3 days a week. The kids never need to go to breakfast club. They are home an hour earlier than they were before the pandemic. I no longer have any stress related to making sure my commute works perfectly, that I leave the office right on time, that I'm not stressing and calling round to see if friends can get my kids if there's a delay with trains.

I get to spend more of my discretionary time with my kids rather than on a train.

I get to save a bit on breakfast club and our mornings are less rushed and stressful.

It's a real benefit, and I would now automatically discount any employer that required more than 2-3 days a week in the office. I'm fortunate in that my skills are in demand so I'm able to be choosy. But in a talent-constrained marketplace (as we currently have) the 'won't someone think of the property developer donors!' argument may not cut much ice with either employers or employees.