Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to buy DS's maths workbook and let him go through it with a calculator?

108 replies

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 11:03

DS is 11 and struggles in maths. I suspect dyscalculia but the school say not and it's because he has ASD. They will not let him use a calculator until he is at secondary school, whereas I remember having one when I was 9!
He can't hold numbers in his head and mixes up place value.
After another batch of count the petals (one petal; 10 petals to a flower; ten flowers to a bunch) which he keeps getting wrong and has resulted into two days of tantrums and screen time bans, I think he is also bored with it and hates that he can't do it. We've tried writing it down, but he has difficulty with getting everything into he right columns.

I also think he's been very limited in his exposure to maths because the TA won't move on to the next topic until he has learnt the one he has done. then spends so long on the next topic he's forgotten the one he did before and they have to start from the beginning again

Would it be totally crazy to buy the school books, and let him go through them at home with a calculator so he can see that a) being able to count in your head is not the be all and end all and b) there is more interesting stuff out there than petal counting?

YANBU buy the damned book
YABU the TA knows what's she's doing

OP posts:
itsraininghere · 05/10/2021 15:11

He needs specialist help, not just the TA following the same old routine until he 'gets it'. Because quite possibly he will never get it.

And it is best to get in place before he gets to secondary school, so I would do whatever you can to get him the support he really needs, following pp advice.
I think the school are letting him down allowing him to be so far behind but it's time to change that now, good luck.

Ellie56 · 05/10/2021 14:50

So the support for maths is not working at the expense of other support he needs. And how can an unqualified TA even begin to know how to prepare "a separate maths syllabus for him? Hmm

Apply for an EHCNA yourself, using the model letter on the link I posted above.

Sounds like your child needs specialist teaching, not an unqualified TA.

This will only get worse at secondary school.

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 14:34

Or is the TA supposed to be the intervention?
Yes. And she's so busy preparing a separate maths syllabus for him that she doesn't have time to prepare support for this other lessons Hmm

If your child is 5 years behind the rest of his class the EP's advice should have been sought long ago.
It has been, he has had several assessments. They won't test for dyscalculia until they're three years behind and now no one will test because of ASD. The TA has been there for 5.5 years.

Has he ever had an assessment by an EP?
Many.

do you have the same problems with other homework?
Mildly, but nowhere on the same level of the maths.

OP posts:
Ellie56 · 05/10/2021 13:48

This poor poor child. How has he got to age 11 without any significant intervention in maths? Or is the TA supposed to be the intervention? Hmm

Whatever, this clearly isn't working and is not likely to work if your child has problems with working memory (and possibly other undiagnosed difficulties).

@TamponSupport

I wouldn't be buying the maths book, I wouldn't be spending any more time on maths homework (do you have the same problems with other homework?) and I would back off entirely as this kind of pressure resulting in meltdowns like this will be having a serious detrimental impact on his mental health and self esteem.

Has he ever had an assessment by an EP? If not I would make an appointment to see the SENCO and ask for one, with a view to seeking an EHC Needs Assessment. If your child is 5 years behind the rest of his class the EP's advice should have been sought long ago.

If school refuses and is generally unhelpful, you can apply for an EHC Needs Assessment yourself. Information here:

www.ipsea.org.uk/ehc-needs-assessments

LittleOwl153 · 05/10/2021 12:52

But yes definitely seek out the SENCO at school and get either some proper intervention OR the TA to back off a bit. Poor lad.

Personally I'd forget pushing maths at home. Concentrate on building his confidence and getting him into the right secondary.

LittleOwl153 · 05/10/2021 12:50

So from a mum of a now yr8 who had the same issues. Take a step back- take the pressure off. Sometimes maths is a matter of maturity and forcing at whatever point will not improve the issue and just destroys confidence.

My dd was in the "stupid maths group" right the way from year 1 to year 6. (Her words not mine). Expected to get less than 90 in maths SATS (which she never took). She started secondary and was put in the mid stream for maths, where she has remained and is on track for a "C" grade at GCSE.

The difference- approach and confidence and that added maturity. She did have a tutor from yr4 through to half way in year 6. But this was a friend who just helped her through stuff rather than anything formal.

Tomnooktoldmeto · 05/10/2021 12:38

I think in your position I would want the input of an Ed psych

There’s certainly a reason he finds this difficult, understanding this will enable reasonable adjustments to be put in place. It could be dyscalculia or poor working memory or something else entirely

Work books can be helpful but if it’s causing anxiety and some level of demand avoidance and thereafter meltdown then perhaps he should be exempted from homework that is counterproductive

I say this as a mum and wife of people with ASD, DD in particular would become very anxious and demand avoidant over some approaches to learning

I do wonder if the TA needs to think more outside the box on her approach with this topic perhaps get some input from the senco on it

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 12:32

Yes, he has very poor working memory. No, he can't recite the tables, he has to count them out.
We've tried linking it to his obsession, all it has done is make him upset because he won't ever be able to work with his obsession. So we stopped doing this.
We've used sweets, sultanas, biscuits etc ad nauseam.

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 05/10/2021 12:29

Has he got a working memory issue?

Can he recite or rote learn the tables at all or no? He clearly has an issue if he can't remember 2 x 6 at age 11.

Can you try approaching the concepts differently - link it to his interests? Eg if he liked cars, how many wheels on a red car, yellow car, and blue car (4 x3). Thing of a practical thing he likes that involves ten of something, might that help him grasp it?

Practise with sweets at home. Chocolate buttons etc, put 20 in front of him and help him split into two

whosaidtha · 05/10/2021 12:28

If you do this he isn't learning what he's supposed to be learning. You may as well just tell him the answer. It will cause problems as he moves through the school and on to secondary. He won't get through his maths exam if he hasn't mastered the basics. Even the calculator paper. I'm afraid there's no shortcuts. Try a different book but not the one he's doing in school.

woodhill · 05/10/2021 12:27

@TamponSupport

Is this mental maths? Even if it is, encourage him to write down the numbers instead of holding them in his head. I do this at home, but he's not allowed paper for his working at school. So e.g. in a times table test he can't write out the times table somewhere, he has to count every single one out for each question.
That's ridiculous. Writing in rough will embed it

We encourage students to write out tables on scrap paper to work things out

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 12:22

Carrying a calculator around isn't going to be practical.
Our teachers said that to us and now we pretty much all carry calculators wherever we go Grin

With the use of a calculator, he would be able to move on to learning to processes of other maths topics and use the calculator to just get the answers. It isnt cheating or anything because he still need to learn the process and know which numbers to put in etc.
This is the direction in which I'm thinking. I have tried everything, but he still can't tell you what 2x6 is without counting. We practice several times a week, I do extra maths with him, he has iPad games and computer games and a homeschool maths program. We've got angry with him, we've been understanding, we've tried to back off and leave him with a book, we've made him write them out countless times, we've tried all the objects etc, even smarties and if he gets it right, he can eat them. We've tried bribery. He's still pretty much at the stage the rest of the class were 5 years ago...

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 05/10/2021 12:20

After another batch of count the petals (one petal; 10 petals to a flower; ten flowers to a bunch) which he keeps getting wrong

Do I understand correctly - your 11 year old son can't count in 10s?

That would indicate a significant problem with maths, and require significant input from teaching staff.

PeonyTime · 05/10/2021 12:18

Do it, but not the school workbooks. Use a different brand.
Personally, we like CPG but have a look around and see what might work.

From,

A dyslexic who still uses her fingers to add and do times tables, but has a job in a numerate discipline.

Tal45 · 05/10/2021 12:18

The school are in no way qualified to say he doesn't have dyscalculia unless they have had an ed psych in to assess him and they couldn't do that without speaking to you. It really pisses me off that they think they are entitled to make these judgements especially as asd is linked to dyspraxia/dyslexia/dyscalculia etc - mine has asd and dyspraxia.

I think it would be more beneficial for you to get him a diagnosis if you can, you'd have to pay privately so I don't know if that's a possibility. I would give him a calculator but I'd get a different book. I'd also read up a lot on it if you haven't already and find out if there is anything recommended to help. If doing this work at home is leading to melt downs then I would leave that even if it is homework and do your own thing. Tell the school he is not coping with the work if it is homework and he is supposed to do it.

TheWoleb · 05/10/2021 12:14

Well, they arent allowed to write down the times tables. Those are started right at the beginning of school and they need to learn them by heart.
If they dont learn the times tables then all their other work takes twice as long because instead of just knowing the multiplication stage of the whole calculation, they have to stop and do it first. That's why they want the class to just know the times tables answers.

If he genuinely cannot do it, rather than just isnt bothering to learn, then the school are failing him by refusing to help or assess for what could be causing it. He should be allowed a different approach, extra equipment like a calculator etc if he cannot do it the way neuro typical kids can.

With the use of a calculator, he would be able to move on to learning to processes of other maths topics and use the calculator to just get the answers. It isnt cheating or anything because he still need to learn the process and know which numbers to put in etc.

You need to have a meeting with the school and get them to take this seriously. If he has an additional need around maths then they must adjust for that.

WhiskyXray · 05/10/2021 12:12

The thing is, your kid needs to keep doing the addition and subtraction till they get it, or they risk being shortchanged every time they buy a bottle of milk or buy a bus ticket. Carrying a calculator around isn't going to be practical.

Sorry my "look through at bedtime" comment upset you. My child, who does have SEN, is more receptive at that time for whatever reason, and she does better on her spelling tests in particular if we go over them really quickly after her story. I suspect it's because she is delaying lights out.

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 12:04

Is this mental maths? Even if it is, encourage him to write down the numbers instead of holding them in his head.
I do this at home, but he's not allowed paper for his working at school. So e.g. in a times table test he can't write out the times table somewhere, he has to count every single one out for each question.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 05/10/2021 12:03

From the sounds of the current measures, i d ask if nothing ventured nothing gained so to speak ?

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 11:58

Don't take any advice I'm not sure that I would be doing wrong to not try to make an already tired child really upset and ashamed of himself at bedtime like I would if I were to follow this advice:
Sometimes just a casual look through at bedtime goes down well.

Will have a look at that placement test. Thanks.

OP posts:
Testingprof · 05/10/2021 11:57

Don’t do it. Is this mental maths? Even if it is, encourage him to write down the numbers instead of holding them in his head. Work on mechanisms that help him, even in senior school he won’t be able to use a calculator for basic maths.

RantyAunty · 05/10/2021 11:57

Use coins for counting and grouping.

Looking at pictures in a book isn't the same as having real objects to work with.

user1469544430 · 05/10/2021 11:50

Fine. Don't take any advice and just wait until one person agrees with you. Then do what you wanted anyway.

PiglingBland1 · 05/10/2021 11:48

Is a tutor an option for him?
Do a placement test for the good and the beautiful math. It's American and Christian (the math is very easy to skip over Christianstuff), the reason I suggest it is because it's games based and PDF is free for grade 1-5.
Just don't print money pages or cross out dollar sign and put £.
It's a homeschool curriculum but I'd say better alternative to a workbook and a calculator, more fun too

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 11:45

The TA knows what she is doing.
I could write n essay on this TA unfortunately and I'm not sure that would be the conclusion.

🤣🤣🤣 Your son might be assisted by using cuisinere rods as they are quite visual and fun?
Or they might be absolutely no use whatsoever!

Always end on something easy that the child can do so they feel good about themselves, and more confident.
3+5 is not always 8.....

reward charts really help- a page of exercises meaning a tick on her chart, 100 ticks means a present from Amazon. She will work through stuff without tears if she knows her effort /time will be recognised with an eventual reward.
Reward charts don't work. They're too stressful, upsetting and make him feel ashamed every time he looks at one. He also has no concept of doing something now to get a reward in a few weeks time.

Would he do well with one of the sites that has more game-style ways of learning? Screen time whilst learning, make it more fun for him.
Yes, but it's very hit and miss. We do this too.

If you buy the book he will be more bored and misbehave in class.
The TA bally well should be staying on topic until he’s learnt it.

He has been doing tables, addition and subtraction for 5.5 years now. I don't think he could get more bored with it. Is there not a point where you say "we have the technology to help you with this, so have a go"?

OP posts: