Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to buy DS's maths workbook and let him go through it with a calculator?

108 replies

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 11:03

DS is 11 and struggles in maths. I suspect dyscalculia but the school say not and it's because he has ASD. They will not let him use a calculator until he is at secondary school, whereas I remember having one when I was 9!
He can't hold numbers in his head and mixes up place value.
After another batch of count the petals (one petal; 10 petals to a flower; ten flowers to a bunch) which he keeps getting wrong and has resulted into two days of tantrums and screen time bans, I think he is also bored with it and hates that he can't do it. We've tried writing it down, but he has difficulty with getting everything into he right columns.

I also think he's been very limited in his exposure to maths because the TA won't move on to the next topic until he has learnt the one he has done. then spends so long on the next topic he's forgotten the one he did before and they have to start from the beginning again

Would it be totally crazy to buy the school books, and let him go through them at home with a calculator so he can see that a) being able to count in your head is not the be all and end all and b) there is more interesting stuff out there than petal counting?

YANBU buy the damned book
YABU the TA knows what's she's doing

OP posts:
drspouse · 06/10/2021 08:11

I vote Doodle Maths, again.

patienceandprudence · 06/10/2021 08:10

It’s all well and good giving him the calculator now, but why about later on? When he’s in secondary school half of his maths exams will be non-calculator— no exceptions.

TamponSupport · 06/10/2021 08:10

learning them by heart might be best
If he could learn them by heart, he would know them by now!

OP posts:
SofiaAmes · 06/10/2021 08:10

Your poor ds. My dd was the same and I fought and paid privately for testing and eventually sent her to a progressive private school when she was 10 and they let her use a calculator and GUESS WHAT she turned out to be really good at math. Especially if you put $$$ in front of all the numbers (we're in the USA). DD is now in her second year of University and got an A in advanced logic and statistics. Not bad for the kid who failed her 1 x tables.

And by the way, I went to MIT and got an A in advanced calculus and never learned my multiplication tables and can't add 5 + 7 in my head and at 58 I still count on my fingers. It makes me so mad to see a child tortured by poor understanding of and teaching to individual learning styles and needs.

Can you take him out of school and home school him until he gets properly assessed.

Barring that, DD worked much better when she had as much time as she needed, wasn't humiliated for counting on her fingers and/or writing numbers down AND did much better if concrete things were attached to the numbers. If you said to DD, what is 5x5 she couldn't tell you, but if you said to her, I have five 5 dollar bills, how much money do I have...she could answer it quickly.

Inim · 06/10/2021 07:58

Not being able to hold it in his head sound like working memory issue? They should let him have paper for working out that’s a pretty minor accommodation.
For times tables etc, learning them by heart might be best? So he’s not having to hold it in his head to work things out? Times table songs on YouTube are good because they’re catchy!

TamponSupport · 06/10/2021 07:52

How much of his maths teaching is coming from this TA?
I would be concerned about that. Is he also taught maths by his teacher?
All of it. His teacher has 23 other pupils in the class and is a primary school teacher, not a special school teacher.
I have been concerned with his TA for a long time (I was allowed to sit in on a lesson so I could see how he behaves in school and had to correct her a couple of times) which is why I have tried everything I can think of over the past few years.

I was also thinking along the lines of: if he has to work the sum out by himself, he manages say 4 sums in half an hour. If he has a calculator, he could cover many, many more. The repetitive input, having to copy the number onto the keypad, think about what he's putting into the calculator and seeing the correct answer over and over again might help him remember e.g. what 4x3 is.

OP posts:
WhoWearsShortShorts · 06/10/2021 07:48

To the people saying "just persevere" and that he mustn't have a calculator to aid him because he needs to know it and implying he's just not trying hard enough - you wouldn't say the same if it was suspected dyslexia.

I have a calculator with me wherever I go on my phone and I also have dyscalculia. I get by.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 06/10/2021 07:36

I'd do some of the book with him with positive reinforcements (bribes), I went to a ridiculous progressive school in the 60's where it was thought we'd teach ourselves maths if given different coloured blocks to play with.
Surprise, surprise I learnt nothing.
I was caught in the post office without a calculator recently trying to work out multiples of stamp books while everyone stared at me and I got gradually more sweaty and flustered. We all need maths basics and to know our times tables.

PurpleDaisies · 06/10/2021 07:34

How much of his maths teaching is coming from this TA?
I would be concerned about that. Is he also taught maths by his teacher?

TamponSupport · 06/10/2021 07:28

titbumwillypoo
DD has something similar from school, which I've tried to use with him but it requires some cooperation on his part! I can't force him to speak, he'd rather sit in silence for ten minutes...

One was pre-teaching - the teacher would take her out of assembly and say 'DD2, we're going to be learning something in maths today that might blow your mind, so we're just going to have a little look at it first.'

  1. that would never happen in our school Shock
  2. DS is so far behind, he doesn't take part in the class lessons, he has separate worksheets to do when his TA isn't there. We have used similar to that Montessori Stamp Game for the past 3 years.

Honestly we are almost in a cashless society as it is, who knows when he grows up if he will even need to check his change etc.
This is something to keep in mind!

OP posts:
Lougle · 05/10/2021 17:49

DD2 used to really struggle with maths, to the point that she literally couldn't learn in a maths lesson because she was so panicked about it. There were lots of things that helped.

One was pre-teaching - the teacher would take her out of assembly and say 'DD2, we're going to be learning something in maths today that might blow your mind, so we're just going to have a little look at it first.' Or, 'DD2, a while ago we did x, and we're going to do it again today, so I just want to remind you of it before we do maths today.'

For place value, the is really helpful. I've linked the least annoying (but still a bit annoying!) video I could find. It really helped DD2 to understand the whole concept of place value and what is happening when you do a sum.

The only trouble with a calculator, I think, is that at secondary school they will still expect him to do stuff without a calculator, and method gets most of the marks in an exam.

3luckystars · 05/10/2021 17:35

Forget the book.
I’d be more concerned that you are saying something to the school and they are ignoring you and fobbing you off.
If you think he has another issue, then insist that this is investigated or pay privately if you can to find out what is going on.

Good luck.

Toomanyradishes · 05/10/2021 17:31

Also my dad is shit at basic maths, cant measure for diy, but can do really complex maths. It may turn out your son is good at some meths he is just being held back by not being allowed to use the tools that might help him. Give him the chance, it may turn out that without the fundamentals he cant progress even with a calculator but at least this gives him the chance to find out.

LeaveYourHatOn · 05/10/2021 17:16

Do it, OP.

As adults, we find ways of helping ourselves with things we find difficult all the sodding time. Maths happens to be one of those things that people process differently. I am absolutely shite at mental arithmetic, I use my fingers to work things out, but written down I can work out complex algebraic equations etc.
If he was just starting to learn and was finding it hard, then no of course you don't reach for the calculator straight away - but after 5 years of maths? Fuck me, yes.

Toomanyradishes · 05/10/2021 17:07

I would just get the lad a calculator and go for it. I cant do maths (or spelling) in my head, I have to see it written down. I also have a very poor 'minds eye' as in I think in words not pictures, so I cant see the spelling of a word I have to physically see it to get it. The only reason I can do my times tables is because I am good at repetition but I used to get into trouble with verbal spelling tests at school because they didnt understand how I could do written spelling tests well and verbal ones badly.

I now work in a heavily maths based profession (data and analytics) and have a science degree and I am part way through a masters. I have to count on my fingers, recite the times table to get the right value, and I have no idea if I have the right change or not. It literally makes no difference to my job as I use coding and spreadsheets and calculators to do maths.

If he can do things written down but not in his head then the teaching approach is crap and needs to allow for that. And if he needs a calculator let him have one, if he builds his confidence and self belief that he can do maths he may improve a little anyway.

Honestly we are almost in a cashless society as it is, who knows when he grows up if he will even need to check his change etc.

QuestionableMouse · 05/10/2021 16:49

Can you get some counting blocks or whatever they're called now and use those so he has something physical to manipulate?

Maybe a maths tutor? I can remember really struggling with something at school then we had a sub teacher who taught it in a different way and it finally clicked for me. Sometimes a different approach can really help!

Iheartbaby · 05/10/2021 16:45

From someone who struggles with maths and still does I think your idea is really good. I ended up hating maths and I still didn’t understand it no matter how many times I was shown, It just never clicked.

drspouse · 05/10/2021 16:21

My DD is in Y3 and is in a slightly better place but has been through this struggle and isn't even really beginning to grasp times tables. She's also got a v poor working memory (possible ADD; DS has ADHD but she doesn't have the hyperactivity).

I agree he HAS to understand place value. Rods/piles of blocks of 10 are the way to go.

I'm not convinced that a label of "dyscalculia" will help because you already know he finds maths hard and that it's related to poor working memory. Are you hoping he will somehow be let off maths? As in he will have help to do it as part of exams (like a child who gets a scribe)? Because that seems unlikely for e.g. science exams. Children who already have a diagnosis/EHCP/extra help should get extra time in relevant exams anyway. Life won't let him off working out how much money he has in his bank account, he will just either need to get there in the end or get help.

We use Doodle Maths for DD which she still needs a little bit of help with but which completely tailors to your child (she's just finished Y1 curriculum). But it means I have a much better idea of what she can do and whether what she's doing at school is appropriate. I feed back what we are working on to school, they can use it or not as they wish. Also it's on an app so appealing to children who like screen time... I have a code at home I think.

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 16:14

For times tables there's a wonderful book called Harry's Magic Tables,
Oh that might appeal to him, thanks! I did get a story one that was recommended on here a few years ago but it didn't really help.

OP posts:
TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 16:09

All birds have two legs and two wings. Farm animals all have four legs
Again, he is 11 and has difficulty with maths. He is not an idiot.

Four people need four plates and four cups.
Obviously. And he knows that, he's not stupid. But he wouldn't be able to tell you how many items e.g. four plates, four cups, four knives and four forks are in total without counting.

OP posts:
ElvenDreamer · 05/10/2021 16:05

For times tables there's a wonderful book called Harry's Magic Tables, it's very cleverly done. All 3 of my kids learned their tables from that rather than the various school methods, my youngest in particular is really responding to it now, and frankly it's helping me nail what I never nailed as a child!

2bazookas · 05/10/2021 16:01

Yes, he has very poor working memory.

Play card games like Happy Families, where he learns to recognise a set. Or matching pairs.

Show him the many ways nature uses pairs and number sets and patterns All birds have two legs and two wings. Farm animals all have four legs . Numbers have patterns that make things work right.
In our house, numbers have patterns too. Four people need four plates and four cups. Use concrete examples of numbers

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 15:58

Play shops.
He's 11, he hasn't played shops for several years!
Play card games like snap that develop visual recognition skills. Dice board games like snakes and ladders that develop a link between the number on the dice and the equivalent number of squares.
He won't. Refuses to join in, he thinks we're trying to trick him into doing maths. Same for cooking, he won't even read a recipe out any more.

According to school and the Ed Psych, his TA is the specialist. She's a former primary teacher who we suspect couldn't control a class and has now decided to take an interest in SEN children and go part time before she retires. We're counting down the days until that happens (Feb) tbh.
There is only one secondary he can go to. It had a bad reputation a few years ago, but people only have praise for it now, new head and proactive help for those who need it.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 05/10/2021 15:50

It;s really important he grasps place value. If he doesn't, then he's going to struggle with basic adult skills like reading prices. Simple addition and subtraction are essential skills .

Using a calculator still requires him to be able to understand the number on the screen. To understand the difference between £2.02 and £ 202.

Play shops. Play card games like snap that develop visual recognition skills. Dice board games like snakes and ladders that develop a link between the number on the dice and the equivalent number of squares. Dominoes (recognising and matching numbers). Once he grasps a single dice, play board games using two dice, simple addition.