Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to buy DS's maths workbook and let him go through it with a calculator?

108 replies

TamponSupport · 05/10/2021 11:03

DS is 11 and struggles in maths. I suspect dyscalculia but the school say not and it's because he has ASD. They will not let him use a calculator until he is at secondary school, whereas I remember having one when I was 9!
He can't hold numbers in his head and mixes up place value.
After another batch of count the petals (one petal; 10 petals to a flower; ten flowers to a bunch) which he keeps getting wrong and has resulted into two days of tantrums and screen time bans, I think he is also bored with it and hates that he can't do it. We've tried writing it down, but he has difficulty with getting everything into he right columns.

I also think he's been very limited in his exposure to maths because the TA won't move on to the next topic until he has learnt the one he has done. then spends so long on the next topic he's forgotten the one he did before and they have to start from the beginning again

Would it be totally crazy to buy the school books, and let him go through them at home with a calculator so he can see that a) being able to count in your head is not the be all and end all and b) there is more interesting stuff out there than petal counting?

YANBU buy the damned book
YABU the TA knows what's she's doing

OP posts:
CuriousaboutSamphire · 06/10/2021 13:16

@TamponSupport

Is this mental maths? Even if it is, encourage him to write down the numbers instead of holding them in his head. I do this at home, but he's not allowed paper for his working at school. So e.g. in a times table test he can't write out the times table somewhere, he has to count every single one out for each question.
Ye gods! I eded my teaching career teaching maths... and I ALWAYS used pencil and paper.

You nee to discuss this with the school, they are setting him up to fail/find it increasingly impossible to care, let alone catch up.

Mean time, yes, buy him a book. Give him pen and paper, calculator and let him experience success, find his own way to success. You can always focus on removing the calculator for some work later - he will ALWAYS have pen and paper in any assessment, any age, any level.

And agan yes, maybe a tutor who can help him find small successes and build up his coping strategies.

But mostly - get the school to hear you and him.

Heronwatcher · 06/10/2021 13:13

I don’t think the school are right but what you’re suggesting would be extremely unhelpful to him. Regardless of technology he has got to find a way to learn mental arithmetic- at least the basics. The school and the TA need to change their approach or you need to fork out for a tutor. Letting him use a calculator is just going to give school the impression that he can do it when he can’t. I know it’s difficult but I would avoid battles at home and try to work this out with school/ a tutor.

drspouse · 06/10/2021 13:07

Which program are you using? Both of mine like the more spatial aspects (shapes, tables, bar charts, symmetry) and Doodle intersperses these with number work.
Before Doodle we used Maths 4-6 but they could both game that after a while.

BrunelsBigHat · 06/10/2021 13:02

@Toomanyradishes

I would just get the lad a calculator and go for it. I cant do maths (or spelling) in my head, I have to see it written down. I also have a very poor 'minds eye' as in I think in words not pictures, so I cant see the spelling of a word I have to physically see it to get it. The only reason I can do my times tables is because I am good at repetition but I used to get into trouble with verbal spelling tests at school because they didnt understand how I could do written spelling tests well and verbal ones badly.

I now work in a heavily maths based profession (data and analytics) and have a science degree and I am part way through a masters. I have to count on my fingers, recite the times table to get the right value, and I have no idea if I have the right change or not. It literally makes no difference to my job as I use coding and spreadsheets and calculators to do maths.

If he can do things written down but not in his head then the teaching approach is crap and needs to allow for that. And if he needs a calculator let him have one, if he builds his confidence and self belief that he can do maths he may improve a little anyway.

Honestly we are almost in a cashless society as it is, who knows when he grows up if he will even need to check his change etc.

This is me. Almost exactly. Except I have (just) finished my maths—based masters

I was in the naughty group for maths. Always in trouble. Shouted at endlessly for being ‘thick‘ (yeah. Helpful)

The trouble with the approach kindly suggested bd 2bazookas is that will work brilliantly IF the pupil is capable of learning. Alas for me, saying ‘try it this way..try harder…practice MORE‘ didn’t work for tasks that I didn’t have the cognitive ability to do it just made me hate myself.

It is honestly like removing someone’s prosthetic leg and then telling then to run, try harder… you just need to practice.

It is really hard for anyone neurotypical to grasp, but there is a bit missing in my head (figuratively) I CANNOT add up in my head, I cannot hold onto numbers. There is no way I can make it happen, any more that a limbless person can will a leg into existence.

OP, I don’t know what to suggest to help now. I just struggled like shit till I could use a spreadsheet then I FLEW. I’m now in a sciencey maths based career, excelling and bloody loving it. I just wanted to tell you there IS hope, there are lots of us. Please just help him to hang on in there.

TamponSupport · 06/10/2021 12:41

drspouse we have a program that is not dissimilar to Doodle, but more visual and with less words. We've had the most success with this, he will agree to use it!

Inim we have tried! We can concentrate on one for a few weeks, but then he doesn't remember the one we were working on the few weeks before.

If you're just trying to get him to work through the book so he can fake his way at school, then you're screwing him over.
He won't be able to fake his way at school, because he won't be allowed a calculator at school

Key question: is working with this TA closing the learning gap for your DS and moving him closer to age-expected goals? If yes, ask to be shown concrete evidence of his progress. If no, what are they proposing to do about it?
No it's not and the proposal is to carry on as he is.

How is he at other areas of maths? Shape? Measuring? Drawing bar charts?
Well, he's not allowed to progress to the more advanced book without mastering the basics, so he's not allowed to do the stuff with bar charts etc. He seems to understand it when I've done some with him and on the computer program he uses. He's very visual so shapes etc are more successful than the basics.

His TA is a qualified teacher who has taken on a TA position for the few years before she retires.

It’s all well and good giving him the calculator now, but why about later on? When he’s in secondary school half of his maths exams will be non-calculator— no exceptions.
Then hopefully he'll be able to pass half his exams....

I wonder if anyone has ever tried teaching him strategies rather than just learning nine eights are seventy two with no context.
Yes, I have tried.

OP posts:
footiemum3 · 06/10/2021 11:46

If the purpose is to teach him maths can be more exciting than what he is doing at school choose different books than he is using at school. By buying the same as the school books you may be hoping he will will remember the answers, if he is struggling as much as you indicate he is not going to remember the answers, if anything he will be more disheartened as he recognise the questions and realise he still doesn’t know the answers.

noblegiraffe · 06/10/2021 11:38

Is dyslexia real then?

Not my area. However I know many children each year with diagnosed dyslexia and despite being a maths teacher for 15 years, I don’t see children diagnosed with dyscalculia. It’s not a thing that is routinely assessed for and diagnosed, and as I said, when people have studied children who have difficulties with maths, they have found explanations such as poor teaching at primary or other SEN such as poor working memory that explain their difficulty with maths, rather than some particular maths-based SEN.

PizzaBreath · 06/10/2021 11:37

My mum did this for me, it worked really well. I didn’t get bored in lessons, I was mainly relieved I could follow and do the work without struggling to keep up.

Inim · 06/10/2021 11:33

TamponSupport- I didn’t mean it rude? But if he’s trying to work them out but can’t hold numbers in his head that’s clearly not working for him? My son has SEN, and his working memory is in the 5th percentile, for things like times tables he does what the Ed psych called over learning , so it’s really not necessarily a case of if he could then he would, not if he isn’t learning them in a way that he can. I’m aware that it’s not a case of just easily learning them by heart. It was only an idea because times tables are used throughout all of schooling so it might br worth a try. Even if it’s just one set of times tables per month or whatever

Coronawireless · 06/10/2021 11:23

Poor kid. How frustrating for him.
I second an online maths site eg Ixl.com which can make things more visual and fun…based on an award after completing a section.
Also could he recite his tables while throwing a ball, jumping on a trampoline, set them to music…?

drspouse · 06/10/2021 11:17

It's perfectly possible for dyslexia (specific difficulty with reading) to be real (and not due to e.g. not being able to see, not being able to understand English, never having been taught properly)) while dyscalculia isn't (it can be explained by other difficulties - in this case working memory difficulties that also affect other areas of life).

It would be like saying that ASD (difficulty with social communication) exists but a specific learning difficulty in tidying up doesn't (a child can't tidy up but that's because they've never practiced, never learned, or have a much more general organisational difficulty that leads to difficulty remembering to pack their bag for school, writing a passage of text and other things).

WhoWearsShortShorts · 06/10/2021 10:33

@noblegiraffe

The school are in no way qualified to say he doesn't have dyscalculia unless they have had an ed psych in to assess him

Dyscalculia isn’t really a thing (I’m a secondary maths teacher). Any investigation into dyscalculia usually concludes it is poor foundations in maths leading to shaky understanding, or some other SEN such as poor working memory which manifests in maths as a particular difficulty with mental calculation/holding numbers in your head.

He won’t be allowed a calculator in primary because the SATs are heavily based around arithmetic and written calculations.

I think denying him paper to jot down workings is stupid though - there’s no exam where this will happen.

How is he at other areas of maths? Shape? Measuring? Drawing bar charts?

Is dyslexia real then?
HarrietsChariot · 06/10/2021 10:14

It's not cheating to look up the answer and work out how to do it.

It's not cheating to ask someone to show you how to do it.

Cheating is when you pretend to know something you don't, that's when you're cheating yourself.

So read the poster in my maths classroom at school. If you get him the book and calculator and work through with him so he understands everything to the point he can remember it even after moving on to something else, that's fine. If you're just trying to get him to work through the book so he can fake his way at school, then you're screwing him over.

NewlyGranny · 06/10/2021 10:03

Talk to the school. Why is a child who struggles and needs teaching the most handed over to the less qualified TA? Let the TA take the top group regularly so she gets a feel for how the most able think and work - what good learning looks, feels and sounds like - and give the less and least able a fair share of the teacher's skill, experience and creativity.

Teachers TAs and Headteachers often look stunned when this is suggested but it makes perfect sense! Now, you can't shake them up like that, OP, but you certainly can ask a probing question or two about how much time your DC has being taught by the actual teacher, not the TA, and what his entitlement is to being taught - by an actual teacher! It might make a huge difference.

Key question: is working with this TA closing the learning gap for your DS and moving him closer to age-expected goals? If yes, ask to be shown concrete evidence of his progress. If no, what are they proposing to do about it?

Meanwhile, check out online resources as PPs have suggested and consider getting him some tutoring if you can afford it. But give school a chance to answer your questions and think about their provision.

In a nutshell, what do people think is going to happen if the brightest and quickest get the top provision from the most expensive professional and the slower strugglers get shunted onto a slow track with someone less well-trained on £15 ph if they're lucky? It's not rocket science.

The best TAs are wonderful and can really accelerate learning; the worst hold children back by plodding unimaginatively or doing the work for the children.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 06/10/2021 09:44

Wow this sounds a really complex situation - your poor son.

Also may be that his stress/anxiety /shame around this is further complicating learning - no one can learn when they're panicked /bored /

Clearly he needs some specialist support... Not the TA!! ... If she/they have had 5 years with hardly any learning...

This is completely unethical.

Unsurprising he's got thoroughly bored /frustrated and shamed.

Keep on keeping on!

I learnt my times tables by making up tunes.... I still mentally go through these if it's an element I dobt use frequently.

drspouse · 06/10/2021 08:58

finally The early stages of teaching multiplication do exactly that - use arrays and counting.

noblegiraffe · 06/10/2021 08:56

The school are in no way qualified to say he doesn't have dyscalculia unless they have had an ed psych in to assess him

Dyscalculia isn’t really a thing (I’m a secondary maths teacher). Any investigation into dyscalculia usually concludes it is poor foundations in maths leading to shaky understanding, or some other SEN such as poor working memory which manifests in maths as a particular difficulty with mental calculation/holding numbers in your head.

He won’t be allowed a calculator in primary because the SATs are heavily based around arithmetic and written calculations.

I think denying him paper to jot down workings is stupid though - there’s no exam where this will happen.

How is he at other areas of maths? Shape? Measuring? Drawing bar charts?

ThinWomansBrain · 06/10/2021 08:52

if he can't do anything without a calculator, how will he cope with mon'y and change (assuming we continue to use it)

I'm not the best at mental arithmatic, but do have a sense of when the number is correct/in the right ballpark - I find it quite scary when colleagues do something on a calculator or spreadsheet, miskey, forget a decimal or use the wrong formula... and come up with a result that is totally implausible.

Tilltheend99 · 06/10/2021 08:51

Based on your scathing reply to perfectly sensible suggestions it sounds like you hold everyone in the same level of disdain not just the poor TA!

PurpleDaisies · 06/10/2021 08:49

There’s such an over emphasis on just remembering times tables off by heart. Most adults don’t actually know them like this. They’ve got strategies for working them out quickly. I wonder if anyone has ever tried teaching him strategies rather than just learning nine eights are seventy two with no context.

2Two · 06/10/2021 08:45

It sounds like you may well be right about the dyscalculia. Can you get your own assessment? It sounds as if your son is simply not going to learn without expert tuition from a specialist in dyscalculia/dyslexia. I'd strongly advise looking at books by Steve Chinn, probably starting with this one

FinallyHere · 06/10/2021 08:42

This might be a bit far out as a solution, have you ever tried your son with a spreadsheet rather than a calculator?

Would be interesting to see how he did with finding out that to multiply 4 by 5, in one row, you just type each number in a cell and then to write the calculation in another cell.

Let him have bricks or something to arrange in the pattern to produce the right number. Then encourage him to change the numbers and then to change the calculation, to see the connection

This would take away the memory part and let him concentrate on the calculations.

Then start using the opposite calculation (first add, then subtract) or first multiply then divide to 'check' the result in the spreadsheet.

I'm closer to retirement age than primary school and always have a spreadsheet open on my desktop for just these things.

Not an immediate help for school but certainly a big help for me. Apologies if this is no help at all, the problem just sounded a bit familiar and the school does not sound particularly supportive. Good luck.

Ozanj · 06/10/2021 08:30

Send him to Kumon. DN has Dyscalcula (takes after me) and it has turned it around. It uses Indian / Asian mental maths arithmetic techniques eg reciting to help embed it. My gran taught me in a similar way and I credit the technique for being the reason why I could eventually pass a maths A Level.

alrightfella · 06/10/2021 08:25

My dd is dyslexic and never managed to learn her timetables off by heart and still managed to get a 6 in her maths gcse.

There are three gcse exams for maths and at least one of them is non calculator. It nay even be two.

Even in secondary there are many topics that they aren't allowed to use a calculator for in maths unfortunately.

XelaM · 06/10/2021 08:20

My daughter is in secondary and they are allowed (in fact encouraged) to use calculators 🤷‍♀️

I would stop torturing your poor son and absolutely get him to use a calculator for the school book