Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we can make having a second child work?

39 replies

SalemWitchCraft · 05/10/2021 10:28

Hello,

I just wanted a bit of advice about this so we have a 9 month old ds and dh and I got to talking about a second child in the future and we were talking about reasons for and against and he was really hammering on about the financial aspect of it and how he wants to give our son the best possible life as in holidays, extra curricular activities etc he was the youngest of three so did end up with hammy downs and maybe missed out on a few things which is completely understandable and I completely agree re giving him a good life however we have about £1700-2100 (live in a low cost area) a month after food and bills are paid, we won't have any childcare costs as I work part time and we're very lucky that we have family help ( I have talked to family about a second child and they are still happy to provide care) so don't really understand where DH is coming from.

AIBU to think this is enough to cover two children and well I guess two adults for everything other than food and bills or is dh right and we should stick to one to ensure we can provide enough?

(I know it's hard to answer as everyone's spending habits different but I guess it would cover holidays, haircuts, clothes, extra activities eventually and birthday and Christmas presents).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yarqueen · 05/10/2021 14:33

I'd say ask him again when DS is 18 months. A 9month old is still really full on and some people find it difficult to imagine having any freedom ever again, whereas once the little one is talking and a bit more independent I think some reluctant second time parents start seeing another one as a more attractive prospect. If DH is anything like mine, he wont want to commit yet until things feel more manageable and money is an easy excuse.

Somethingsnappy · 05/10/2021 14:11

To answer your question OP, I have 2 years between all my 4 children. It's a nice gap. It's harder work when they're young to have a newborn and a toddler, but they are great playmates for each other as they get older, and that makes things easier. I don't need to entertain them so much!

As for hammy-downs, I love it! I think I'll adopt it from now on Grin

HumunaHey · 05/10/2021 12:59

@Joystir59

I'd flip it round and afk why you want a second child? Like you've already done conception pregnancy childbirth and parenting? Would you like to move on and spend your time and energy doing something new and different? I never understand why people have more than one tbh. Providing existing child with a sibling isn't any kind of reason.
It definitely doesn't always work out this way but many people have more than one to offer there child a richer quality of life. Some people see expensive holidays,private school etc. as a good quality life (I think that's what OP's DH was getting at) but others see it as a large family with hustle and bustle.

I speak from a very biased point of view, but I cherish the memories I have growing up with my siblings, even the fights. For example, I once snuck into my sisters room when she was out and discovered her mascara. I put some on my eyelashes then wondered what it'd look like on my eyebrows, so I brushed them in. Well I heard her coming back and I couldn't wash the wretched stuff of my eyebrows or eyelashes and everything started to sting. I hid in my room and heard my sister get very angry and go stomping downstairs to my mum. They both come up to my room and asked if I'd been through my sisters stuff. I shook my head and denied everything with my red stinging eyes, eyebrows as thick as caterpillars and gunky eyelashes. Me and dsis laugh alot about it now but she was livid at the time. I slept with one eye open!

There's also the fact that things just aren't as fun when it's just you and your parents or even when your being looked after by relatives. Not once you're a bit older anyway. My DGM used to look after me sometimes on a weekend. It was just me without my sisters and I remember it being an absolute snoozefest compared to when we (sisters) were together. Even when we argued, I appreciated the company of having more "non-adults" around.

That reaaon for having more is, of course, framed around the child's happiness. You have to consider your own happiness to. If you highly value peace and tranquility, sticking to one is a no brainer. I'm not sure how my mum put up with me and my sister's antics.

SalemWitchCraft · 05/10/2021 12:29

@Joystir59

I'd flip it round and afk why you want a second child? Like you've already done conception pregnancy childbirth and parenting? Would you like to move on and spend your time and energy doing something new and different? I never understand why people have more than one tbh. Providing existing child with a sibling isn't any kind of reason.
That's true, I just worry for my ds but maybe like you say that's not a good enough reason.
OP posts:
SalemWitchCraft · 05/10/2021 12:20

@FreeBritnee

I think it’s a bit early to be talking about no.2 and expecting your husband to be keen on the idea 🤭
It was just a general chat, I don't expect anything from him but just thought either him or I was being unrealistic about finances and wanted a third opinion from people who know a bit more about multiple children then we do and apparently to find out my life has been a lie and it's not hammy downs Grin, that's all.
OP posts:
FreeBritnee · 05/10/2021 12:19

@Joystir59

I'd flip it round and afk why you want a second child? Like you've already done conception pregnancy childbirth and parenting? Would you like to move on and spend your time and energy doing something new and different? I never understand why people have more than one tbh. Providing existing child with a sibling isn't any kind of reason.
Funnily enough my eldest was out the house on Saturday all day and OMG our parenting experience was a 180 degree turn. We were happy, laughing, relaxed. There was no fighting, no crying, it was pure bloody bliss!!!
FreeBritnee · 05/10/2021 12:18

I think it’s a bit early to be talking about no.2 and expecting your husband to be keen on the idea 🤭

HarebrightCedarmoon · 05/10/2021 12:15

2 to 3 children can be a massive jump. But 1 to 2 - sure. Sometimes you get a shock with a second if DC1 was an easy baby but more often than not second children just have to go with the flow. It's pot luck whether they will get on and play together. Mine have a bigger gap of 3.5 years but have always got on well, with some squabbling, obviously. They are really different personalities but compliment one another.

Joystir59 · 05/10/2021 12:14

Ask, not afk

Joystir59 · 05/10/2021 12:14

I'd flip it round and afk why you want a second child? Like you've already done conception pregnancy childbirth and parenting? Would you like to move on and spend your time and energy doing something new and different? I never understand why people have more than one tbh. Providing existing child with a sibling isn't any kind of reason.

Joystir59 · 05/10/2021 12:11

Hammy downs? Hand me downs 😃

SalemWitchCraft · 05/10/2021 12:04

@Iwonder08

Perhaps your DH wants a better quality of life? It is also possible he doesn't want a wife who is working part time and not earning enough. It is also likely he doesn't want more dependants /responsibilities. Most people decide not to have another child for financial reasons and it is not 'making excuses'
I'm working part time because he wanted the first child and wanted me to be around the baby more, I always have the option of going back full time - I'm in a very fortunate position that my part time wage equates to a full time wage around this area if I were to go full time then I'd be the main earner which I'd be happy to do if he asked so please don't assume I'm living the high life off of his wages because that's what I'm getting from this post but if not then I apologise for my mistake.

Financial reasons are a very valid reason to not have any children but to simply say £2k a month isn't enough is a bit of an excuse without explaining further imo like pp said if he has plans for the future etc then that's fine.

OP posts:
Iwonder08 · 05/10/2021 11:56

Perhaps your DH wants a better quality of life? It is also possible he doesn't want a wife who is working part time and not earning enough. It is also likely he doesn't want more dependants /responsibilities. Most people decide not to have another child for financial reasons and it is not 'making excuses'

SalemWitchCraft · 05/10/2021 11:55

Just to address some of the posts:-

I'm not dismissing my husbands feelings if he said he doesn't want another one then that's fine with me, I love him and wouldn't want to make him unhappy especially with something as serious as another child as that could disrupt the whole family, I meant I'd rather he explain his reasons rather than using excuses like " we don't have enough money" when we do even if he just said I don't want another that would be okay but I appreciate we have time to make a final decision, we'll probably have more conversations about it but just wanted to make sure I wasn't being unreasonable because I think it's a very fortunate position to be in but didn't know if I was being unrealistic.

You're all absolutely correct that we can't rely on family members for childcare (although my mums only 46 Grin) but I was thinking if we were going to have a second then TTC when DS was around two so baby would be here when he got free hours (not sure how that works though so would need to look into it) but that would lessen the financial strain if we did need childcare for number 2 but appreciate that might not be the case.

And I genuinely thought they were called hammy downs and now I feel really silly, glad I was corrected before having another or id be passing it through generations BlushGrin

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 05/10/2021 11:51

Also having a giggle at "hammy downs" :p

Agree with others, it sounds as if finances aren't the real issue for your DH

RowanAlong · 05/10/2021 11:40

That’s plenty for daily life - is he thinking longer time, I.e. savings, private schools, university help, house deposit? And lots of slack so a worry-free life? Is he happy in his job?

Or as pp have said he might be just happy with one child.

RosieLemonade · 05/10/2021 11:38

Also DS is only nine months. You have plenty of time to have another.

RosieLemonade · 05/10/2021 11:33

You have more left over than we start with each month. You will be fine.

MadamMedea · 05/10/2021 11:31

hammy downs

I love this, change approved Grin

Plenty of people manage on less than you with more children. It’s hard though when one party only wants one - their views always trump those of the person who wants more, even when that’s very upsetting and feels unfair.

Stompythedinosaur · 05/10/2021 11:26

Financially you are fine. It sounds like there is something else going on here.

There are advantages to having a sibling too.

Aprilx · 05/10/2021 11:22

I’d just rather he come out and say that rather than make excuses

Of course it is possible to raise two children on your incomes. But there is no reason to believe he is making excuses either. Perhaps he genuinely wants to be able to provide a particular kind of childhood, such as good holidays, activities, private school maybe, and thinks can only do it once.

I am from a larger family and we never did any extra curricular activities that needed to be paid for, didn’t go on holidays and there is no doubt that we did without because my parents could not afford it for all children. So I can sort of see where your DH is coming from, I never had children in the end, but I always thought I would want to give them a childhood with nicer things, opportunities and experiences than I had.

On the other hand, I think a sibling is a greater blessing. But I guess I just wanted to say, don’t dismiss your husbands feelings as being just an excuse.

Mamamamasaurus · 05/10/2021 11:20

Just remember that caring for one child is very different to looking after two. I don't mean for you, I mean for family doing the childcare. Plus they're getting older (as are we all, but the point is that they may not actually, realistically, want to or be able to care for two young children). Is your financial position such that you could afford childcare for both children at some points?

And hammy downs, that's MN gold 😁

ACNHMAMA · 05/10/2021 11:17

You have more than we do at the end of each month and we have two DC.

I agree that childcare is the biggest expense to factor in with two DC. Especially two preschoolers if you're having the conversation now.

I can appreciate where DH is coming from. I am one of four kids as is my DH and it was tight at times. I never went on holidays abroad as a kid etc. But I look back on my childhood fondly and I wouldn't swap the fun I had with my siblings for any of the material things. For us it was more important for our kids to have that family relationship than material things.

CoastalWave · 05/10/2021 11:16

You have £2k a month for what you want? ie. luxuries, new clothes, hair cuts, going out, birthdays etc. And you're not sure it's enough? Have I read that right?

Sounds like husband just doesn't want a second child.

We manage with 2 adults and 2 kids on 800 a month (and this has to include food, and they still both do hobbies)

Moonlaserbearwolf · 05/10/2021 11:14

YANBU, it sounds like you’re very well set up for a second child.
It may be too soon for your DH to be thinking about child number 2. I was exhausted after my first child and would have come up with all sorts of reasons not to have another when my first was under 1! Another year and I was ready to think about it. I definitely always wanted 2. We have a 3 year age gap and it’s brilliant. Just close enough for the children to play together and far enough apart that they don’t compete.
If you feel you aren’t getting anywhere with DH, I’d leave it 6 months and try again when your baby is a bit older.