Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Extinction Rebellion co-founder says he would block an ambulance carrying a dying patient

267 replies

sst1234 · 05/10/2021 07:10

How can anyone support this bunch of nasty idiots who are willing to commit what can only be described as murder. How can anyone justify this? Imagine how you would feel it was one of you family members in that ambulance, this man would not hesitate to cause their death.

OP posts:
seaandsandcastles · 05/10/2021 11:04

If he can feel that way about people that don't exist yet, he's clearly an empathy filled person that cares about others, but feels like people now need to be forced to change.

@Polkadots2021 Nope. He’s a selfish cunt.

I hope they don’t get what they want, and I will deliberately do everything I can to enable that. I won’t be changing for the likes of them.

This is how you alienate people.

katnyps · 05/10/2021 11:04

Jumper yeah I know what you mean. I struggle to see how any of us can really be persuaded to take action though - what would actually get people to change their behaviour? The climate debate is all about making it someone else's problem "no point me doing anything when corporations aren't" and "well I didn't have any kids so I can go on long haul holidays 3 times a year and drive the 5 minutes to the shops every day in my petrol car"

MyChemicalMummy · 05/10/2021 11:03

@tenredthings

ER are doing everything they can to get climate change in the front of peoples thoughts. Climate Change is a huge tsunami approaching us and people don't want to look at it. We are running out of time !

The ambulance comment is straight out of the Trump schoolbook of what the fuckery. Say something super controversial and outrageous, everyone talks about it in an outraged manner but the core message Climate Change will hopefully enter people's consciousness enough to promote the action needed. The fact is the protesters do get out of the way of ambulances. Their goal is to promote change. Being outrageous gets media coverage and sometimes negative coverage gets the core message out there faster.

But they haven't been getting out of the way for ambulances though that's why the general public had to manhandle them to move yesterday.
katnyps · 05/10/2021 11:01

hamstersarse what needs to be debated and if there was to be such a debate how would you engage, what platform would you expect to see it on and what would be required for you to take action as a result?

mumwon · 05/10/2021 11:00

doing a crime to protest against another crime
This is not a reasonable protest but - as pp stated - terrorism
There was a one chap who was an insulation installer who was held up in an earlier blockage! The irony he had to cancel his installations for that day!
Imagine the amount of pollution caused by this stalled traffic - hospital or other clinical or care staff being held up from going to work. personal stories of people trying to get to families for many urgent reasons. Ambulances going to individuals in danger or taking them to hospital. Fire engines or police. people being held up from attending much waited appointments - dc being transported to school or school based journeys. & trucks
People are naturally wary of using transport systems (old friend covid) & many of these journeys can not be done by public transport anyway
To discount causing death or injury caused directly by their actions is amoral - even if they claim their action might (really?) save millions.
No they won't - they are not doing some ethics experiment of balancing family members against stopping a train crash -because their actions are actually antagonising people & not helping their cause in the slightest.

JumperandJacket · 05/10/2021 10:57

One of the problems with XR is that they don't believe in hierarchical structures so any idiot can claim to speak for them.

I feel I'm in a minority on here as I do think that some targeted disruption is justifiable if it gets people to focus on climate change. Simply signing petitions and asking people nicely is achieving feck all. However, there's a balance to be struck as once you start alienating the general public to this extent it's counter-productive.

It's worth remembering that the Sufragettes weren't generally popular either and that people would point to the disruption they caused as evidence that women shouldn't have the vote. Being amenable doesn't change the world.

hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 10:54

That data holds and it's so frightening

This is the sort of statement that turns me right off. The data is often cherry-picked, exaggerated and is always presented as Fact.

It definitely has an ideology vibe not a science vibe.

hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 10:52

@katnyps

So to pose the question a different way - what action WOULD the majority support to raise awareness and stimulate action on climate change?
I am not sure you can say we need more awareness - climate change is pumped out of the media every single day.

What might help though is honest debate and not the ideological virtue signaling hypocritical unrealistic dogma that surrounds it at the moment.

Polkadots2021 · 05/10/2021 10:52

@sst1234

How can anyone support this bunch of nasty idiots who are willing to commit what can only be described as murder. How can anyone justify this? Imagine how you would feel it was one of you family members in that ambulance, this man would not hesitate to cause their death.
They're going on the data OP, that our grandchildren could be living through hell because of current irreversible environmental damage. Still noone is really doing anything. That data holds and it's so frightening. Our generation won't suffer though, not like the next generations, and he's thinking about that - desperate changes are needed now, to protect future generations.

If he can feel that way about people that don't exist yet, he's clearly an empathy filled person that cares about others, but feels like people now need to be forced to change. Of course he isn't a psycho who wants to stop ill people get to hospital.

It's just a sad situation all round but data is very frightening and extreme action is needed. Governments can act but they don't, they're the real enemies here. Ext Reb are forcing change because they feel they have no other option. That's not going to be comfortable.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/10/2021 10:50

Most people are SELFISH and would prioritize their kid over humanity. We need people willing to risk being beaten to a pulp or going to prison; people willing to make huge self-sacrifices for the greater good

Ah yes, the screaming and stamping, "we've all got to do such-and-such NOW!!!" mentality.
I've chaired so many meetings with people like this, all of whom say the same things - but come the day when something actually has to be done which requires effort they're nowhere to be seen - especially if the weather's poor

Funny, isn't it, that ER and their associated rabble are seen much less in the winter? Presumably it's no fun banging drums and glueing themselves to things in the rain and slush ...

katnyps · 05/10/2021 10:49

So to pose the question a different way - what action WOULD the majority support to raise awareness and stimulate action on climate change?

Whammyyammy · 05/10/2021 10:47

I have zero support for them. Hopefully the law is changed and they can be removed and locked up

UsedUpUsername · 05/10/2021 10:45

@MephistophelesApprentice

Most people are SELFISH and would prioritize their kid over humanity. We need people willing to risk being beaten to a pulp or going to prison; people willing to make huge self-sacrifices for the greater good.

If they actually believed in this, they'd be bombing refineries, power stations, picking up guns and putting their lives on the line. But no: they only want other people too for for their beliefs, while they get the protections of the justice system.

I'd still despise them for their violent crimes, but at least I'd believe they possessed genuine conviction in their beliefs. I certainly don't believe it of these privileged, performative wankers.

I think they would start doing this if there’s no consequences for their current actions. Imo
hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 10:44

They just make me want to rip out the insulation in my house, which I presume is not the reaction they were hoping for.

Absolute psychopaths

Squellyolwelly · 05/10/2021 10:42

@PurpleParrotfish

But when Extinction Rebellion block roads they do let ambulances through. It’s a huge diverse group of people and I think pretty much all of them would be shocked by RH’s statement as well. Whatever you think of their tactics of causing inconvenience to draw attention to the fact we are fucking up our planet’s life support system, they are not signed up to kill people. I know RH is one of the founders but he should have been booted out of XR when he went to Germany and trivialised the Holocaust. By the way, Insulate Britain, the M25 lot, are a different group.
www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/cambridge-news/extinction-rebellion-ambulance-addenbrookes-hospital-16741207.amp

XR do not always let ambulances through. Just because it wasn’t a blue light situation at that moment doesn’t mean it wouldn’t have become a blue light situation, and forcing them to go the long way around could have made all the difference in that scenario.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/10/2021 10:42

If you are being blue lighted in an ambulance I’d say every second counts. Let alone if a fire truck is sitting in traffic waiting for the protestors to be unglued...

I know, Kitten, and it's why I also mentioned this

I liked being reminded of the "blue steam" we were all supposed to disappear in though - I always thought it a pretty way to go, but admit I wondered why it should be blue and whether a spangled violet or something wouldn't have been nicer Wink

MephistophelesApprentice · 05/10/2021 10:38

Most people are SELFISH and would prioritize their kid over humanity. We need people willing to risk being beaten to a pulp or going to prison; people willing to make huge self-sacrifices for the greater good.

If they actually believed in this, they'd be bombing refineries, power stations, picking up guns and putting their lives on the line. But no: they only want other people too for for their beliefs, while they get the protections of the justice system.

I'd still despise them for their violent crimes, but at least I'd believe they possessed genuine conviction in their beliefs. I certainly don't believe it of these privileged, performative wankers.

HarrietsChariot · 05/10/2021 10:36

They're scum plain and simple. The argument that they're "just" killing one person but climate change "will" kill millions is nonsensical. Humans have great ability to adapt, the species will survive in one form or another. Many of the people who "will" be affected aren't even born yet! You may as well argue that a man who masturbates is a mass-murderer because of all those potentially fertilising sperm are going to waste.

Also, the IB/XR clowns claim that history shows the only thing that works is direct action. Bullshit. Direct action works when the majority support the demonstraters, even if they don't take part in the rioting themselves. People don't support the IB/XR twats. Seeing that poor woman wanting to visit her mother in hospital yesterday, seeing paramedics pleading for the protestor scum to let the ambulance through, hardens me against the protestors and their cause. I'd rather Boris Johnson decided to build coal power stations and ban electric cars than to cave into these people. "You don't negotiate with terrorists" - look what happens when they did in Afghanistan, we don't need that shit here.

The only positive of this situation is that it is gaining support for the governments plans to crackdown on protests generally. There was an outcry about this earlier in the year when the government wanted to prevent "disruptive" protests, but people happily killing others to make their point is persuading many that a tightening of the rules and the threat of serious prison time for protestors is a good thing indeed.

I've always thought that if you can't persuade people through debate and rational argument then perhaps your cause isn't as justified or important as you think.

katnyps · 05/10/2021 10:34

Xenia the issue is it's not just us dying off a bit sooner.
I'll also admit I'm selfish in that I don't think the human race is any less important than the rest of the animals / plants on this planet - I'd rather we find a way that as many of us (all of us) survive as possible! Grin

LemonTT · 05/10/2021 10:34

@LaetitiaASD

That is the whole point OP.

"I’m glad you get his point. The rest of us are just clearly dense: Wonder if you would get it if it was your family member in an ambulance. No, thought not."

Most people are SELFISH and would prioritize their kid over humanity. We need people willing to risk being beaten to a pulp or going to prison; people willing to make huge self-sacrifices for the greater good.

He’s not self sacrificing. He is putting a life in jeopardy. If he can’t value one life then he can’t value all life.

As to your call to action, sounds a lot like the sacrifices asked by the Hitlers and Stalin’s of this world of common people. People who didn’t value a life either and then didn’t value life at all.

whynotwhatknot · 05/10/2021 10:33

says it all doesnt it theyre going about it the wrong way

insulate britain yesterday blocked paramedics who dragged them off themselves-theyve lost mst of their support now

Wowthisisreal · 05/10/2021 10:31

@Franklyfrost

Ecocide is genocide. He’s not doing himself any favours by saying it out loud but he’s right. The dying person in the ambulance has human drama. But the fact that the dying person could be one of the 50,000 deaths a year in the uk from air pollution (house of commons air audit 2010) isn’t as dramatic.
But blocking that person from getting medical care isn't furthering their cause.
Xenia · 05/10/2021 10:31

kat I am not on their sides at all. I would rather we stayed as we were, kept our gas boilers, my diesel car, continued as is and humans died off a bit sooner. I only meant I understand their position on the "greater good" in their eyes.

forinborin · 05/10/2021 10:30

@Xenia

I can see their point of view as they believe billions will die and if you weigh that up against 1 or 2 dying through road closures they think they are right. However I do not agree with them and was so pleased to see those Wandsworth lads next to the ambulance driver lift them up and move them off the road - that should be done all the time right away by motorists to remove them immediately so a long hold up becomes a very short one indeed.
I think this is likely to be the default solution from now on. I don't know if they glue / tie themselves through?
bruffin · 05/10/2021 10:30

@FreeBritnee

Let’s not forget we’ve got a whole loads of new crazies with the anti vaccine mob. They’ve started to protest now. They were outside a TV doctors house yesterday hassling him because he is pro vaccine.

The common denominator of most of these extremists is a personality disorder. The rest of us are just trying to get through the day.

We have had those crazies around since the invention of vaccines back in the 1800s, unfortunately the invention of the internet has let them spread their voice further and wider. But agree these people are never really interested in vaccines/or climate change, just want to be in the middle of something causing trouble
Swipe left for the next trending thread