Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Extinction Rebellion co-founder says he would block an ambulance carrying a dying patient

267 replies

sst1234 · 05/10/2021 07:10

How can anyone support this bunch of nasty idiots who are willing to commit what can only be described as murder. How can anyone justify this? Imagine how you would feel it was one of you family members in that ambulance, this man would not hesitate to cause their death.

OP posts:
Generallystruggling · 05/10/2021 12:43

@Confrontayshunme

I think the justification is that the imminent threat to life of millions of the poor and children justify the present inconvenience (and I agree in theory), but trotting out the usual "This isn't the right way to go about it." is actually warranted here.
Agree.
SammyScrounge · 05/10/2021 12:36

They have already done that. There was an
ambulance carrying a lady who had a stroke. They were held up by these smug idiots. The story upset me because time is of the essence in these cases.My own mother had a massive stroke. The ambulance came in record time and went up the road with lights flashing . The hospital were waiting for her and whisked her away for scans.
We were dreading going up to see her next morning. She had been unable to speak or move. But when we arrived, she was sitting up in bed, smiling and chatting. 'can you move, mum?' 'course I can' she said.
She had been given a clot-buster. It was a new treatment. The consultant was thrilled with such a good outcome. He told us there was a window of time when the clot-buster could be administered
I remembered that when I heard about the ambulance being blocked. The patient was paralysed. If the ambulance had got through in time, maybe she wouldn't be.
How dare these Insulate Britain people disregard
the rest of us. Why aren't they being arrested? Why aren't they in jail where they can't hurt other people.

katnyps · 05/10/2021 12:17

hamstersarse apologies, that wasn't what I was trying to imply. I think the debate is well worth it - though you can probably guess I would be on the side of the latest IPCC data

LikeACatInTheDark · 05/10/2021 12:00

It really feels like IB are going to end up with their own Jill Phipps incident, except deliberately this time.

hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 11:58

@katnyps

hamstersarse what needs to be debated and if there was to be such a debate how would you engage, what platform would you expect to see it on and what would be required for you to take action as a result?
You imply there is no debate worth having here

As pp said, that is disingenuous. The data is nowhere near Fact.

TheFoundations · 05/10/2021 11:53

@Lostmarbles2021

not caring about the environment is no longer an option

Of course it is. It's not a good option, but the reality of the human race is than if the sofa we're sitting on is burning, we'll won't do anything about it until our own hair is actually on fire.

How are the methods currently being employed going to convince our leaders to take drastic action?

The protestors need to first find a way to convince the public, and then the public will be willing to organise a mass mass mass protest that the leaders will have to respond to, or risk a much more immediate collapse of society than that offered by climate problems.

Current protest methods are alienating people who agree with their cause, and having no positive impact on any leaders. How could they?

DdraigGoch · 05/10/2021 11:50

@katnyps

Jumper yeah I know what you mean. I struggle to see how any of us can really be persuaded to take action though - what would actually get people to change their behaviour? The climate debate is all about making it someone else's problem "no point me doing anything when corporations aren't" and "well I didn't have any kids so I can go on long haul holidays 3 times a year and drive the 5 minutes to the shops every day in my petrol car"
Just like XR and IB are all about someone else doing something. Many of the leaders of XR are the very people who drive cars on even the shortest journey and take multiple flights a year. Apparently pollution is all the government's fault, the whole premise of XR is not blaming individuals, even though the whole problem with climate change is a collection of individual actions.
branchlight · 05/10/2021 11:50

If they actually believed in this, they'd be bombing refineries, power stations, picking up guns and putting their lives on the line. But no: they only want other people too for for their beliefs, while they get the protections of the justice system. I'd still despise them for their violent crimes, but at least I'd believe they possessed genuine conviction in their beliefs. I certainly don't believe it of these privileged, performative wankers

"Privileged, performative wankers" is exactly the phrase I was looking for. Sitting in the middle of the road looking smug and looking forward to seeing themselves in the local paper is not convincing anyone. If they just thought a little bit more about it and weren't so bothered about patting each other on the back about how "radical" they are being, they could get so much more done. How can you seriously stand there looking sadly at a woman who is pleading with you to let her get to her ill mother and not think "Hold on, I wonder if this is the right way to go about this?" Thick as mince as well as everything else

All of this.

BelleOfTheProvince · 05/10/2021 11:46

And the sad thing is when the experts, scientists, government, people in industry solve the problems causing climate change terrorist groups like this will claim the credit, when I'm reality they do zero practical towards the cause.

DdraigGoch · 05/10/2021 11:45

@JumperandJacket

One of the problems with XR is that they don't believe in hierarchical structures so any idiot can claim to speak for them.

I feel I'm in a minority on here as I do think that some targeted disruption is justifiable if it gets people to focus on climate change. Simply signing petitions and asking people nicely is achieving feck all. However, there's a balance to be struck as once you start alienating the general public to this extent it's counter-productive.

It's worth remembering that the Sufragettes weren't generally popular either and that people would point to the disruption they caused as evidence that women shouldn't have the vote. Being amenable doesn't change the world.

And the suffragettes didn't get women the vote as a result, the Kaiser did that. Plenty of evidence that women would have had the vote sooner if it hadn't been for the extreme tactics (letter bombs etc.)
DdraigGoch · 05/10/2021 11:42

@katnyps

So to pose the question a different way - what action WOULD the majority support to raise awareness and stimulate action on climate change?
I'm quite happy with whoever was blockading Farnborough. I bet that the owners of many of those private jets have a larger footprint in a week than I have in a year.
darklady64 · 05/10/2021 11:37

@MephistophelesApprentice

Most people are SELFISH and would prioritize their kid over humanity. We need people willing to risk being beaten to a pulp or going to prison; people willing to make huge self-sacrifices for the greater good.

If they actually believed in this, they'd be bombing refineries, power stations, picking up guns and putting their lives on the line. But no: they only want other people too for for their beliefs, while they get the protections of the justice system.

I'd still despise them for their violent crimes, but at least I'd believe they possessed genuine conviction in their beliefs. I certainly don't believe it of these privileged, performative wankers.

Yes! Or if they had gone down to the Conservative Party Conference and glued themselves or otherwise generally blocked the access roads to that, or heckled the speakers, or abseiled down the outside of the building with banners, that would be one thing - and would probably get way more people on side.

"Privileged, performative wankers" is exactly the phrase I was looking for. Sitting in the middle of the road looking smug and looking forward to seeing themselves in the local paper is not convincing anyone. If they just thought a little bit more about it and weren't so bothered about patting each other on the back about how "radical" they are being, they could get so much more done. How can you seriously stand there looking sadly at a woman who is pleading with you to let her get to her ill mother and not think "Hold on, I wonder if this is the right way to go about this?" Thick as mince as well as everything else.

LemonTT · 05/10/2021 11:31

@JumperandJacket

One of the problems with XR is that they don't believe in hierarchical structures so any idiot can claim to speak for them.

I feel I'm in a minority on here as I do think that some targeted disruption is justifiable if it gets people to focus on climate change. Simply signing petitions and asking people nicely is achieving feck all. However, there's a balance to be struck as once you start alienating the general public to this extent it's counter-productive.

It's worth remembering that the Sufragettes weren't generally popular either and that people would point to the disruption they caused as evidence that women shouldn't have the vote. Being amenable doesn't change the world.

Can you evidence that direct action and violence brought about sufferage?

The Sufferage Act was passed in 1918. The Sufferagettes stopped direct action and violence in 1914. Instead they worked with the political establishment as part of the war effort and widened their political base and support.

History sort of puts a hole in argument.

Democracy is slow and imperfect but democracy is best system we have. Use it, don’t abuse it because the alternatives are never worth it and won’t save the world.

BelleOfTheProvince · 05/10/2021 11:28

What @PlanDeRaccordement says is interesting and an example of how people are not doing nothing about climate change, as much as alarmists like marbles would like you to believe.

The climate change crisis is evidenced as being tackled by people working on alternatives etc. Groups like ib have no plan, long or short term but rely on emotive abstract idealism.

branchlight · 05/10/2021 11:25

[quote PurpleParrotfish]Thought so - Extinction Rebellion have put out a statement saying Roger Hallam does not speak for them and is not in any way a ‘leader’ of XR. extinctionrebellion.uk/2021/10/05/5th-october-statement/[/quote]
How nice to them to kindly let emergency vehicles through!

How unfortunate for the people waiting for those vehicles, that the significant delay caused in the protest and needing to be ' escorted through', and who suffer death or disability as a result of the delay.

They are fucking emergency vehicles, you idiots. They are blue lighted as they can't afford ANY delay - people's lives depend on it.

katnyps · 05/10/2021 11:20

PlanDeRaccordement

This is the kind of debates we need, and I think are happening for the most part.
Regarding electric charging points, these are relatively cheap and easy to retrofit so for new housing developments, whilst a good idea, not a massive issue if retrofitted.
The Maersk example sounds like a good one! I'm no expert on the shipping industry but it sounds like a step in the right direction.
As for biofuels - I think this is a bit of a grab by a fossil fuel company and, from what I understand, pretty awful for the environment from a biodiversity perspective (e.g. driving the palm oil boom).
As for zero carbon planes, it sounds good, but unfortunately a significantly large proportion of the greenhouse effect is actually from the contrail and this is, I think, going to be just as much of an issue with hydrogen burning engines?

FuckingFlumps · 05/10/2021 11:18

The current direct action, at times may have crossed a line, I don’t know the facts, but direct action is now the only course of action - everything else has been tried and we are in an emergency situation.

What a load of nonsense. I'm sorry but the direct action of sitting in roads, targeting public transport and openly admitting you would let someone die rather than let an ambulance through is not going to do shit to help the climate issues our world is facing.

It's no more bloody useful than standing there with a petition. Pretending direct action is the only way left to tackle the problem is the biggest load of rubbish I've ever heard.

MephistophelesApprentice · 05/10/2021 11:16

Governments can act but they don't, they're the real enemies here.

Then why aren't they attacking the government instead of the public?

Oh yeah, because that would involve genuine danger and sacrifice, rather than being roughly manhandled out of the way.

Lazy, pathetic cowards, lying to reach other and themselves about their bravery.

If they stuck themselves to a ministers car, I'd find that hilarious! I'd applaud! Or an oil executive, or a banker. But no, they'd rather punish the powerless like the ideological bullies they really are.

UsedUpUsername · 05/10/2021 11:13

They're going on the data OP, that our grandchildren could be living through hell because of current irreversible environmental damage. Still noone is really doing anything. That data holds and it's so frightening. Our generation won't suffer though, not like the next generations, and he's thinking about that - desperate changes are needed now, to protect future generations

A lot of the science is very uncertain and it’s disingenuous to imply otherwise. For some of the climate models, it’s really garbage-in-garbage-out. Yes, the earth is warming, but how that’s going to affect our environment is really very uncertain.

I’m not willing to put people in poverty over these uncertainties.

If he can feel that way about people that don't exist yet, he's clearly an empathy filled person that cares about others, but feels like people now need to be forced to change. Of course he isn't a psycho who wants to stop ill people get to hospital

He doesn’t care about others. Oh sure he cares about some innocent, idealised other, but not real-life people and their very real problems.

Lostmarbles2021 · 05/10/2021 11:12

Whatever our different views on what he said, not caring about the environment is no longer an option.

It simply is too late now for choice. May be what this man said was outrageous and awful, may be he did do harm to the public perception of ER and IB, may be he is scum or any of the other words used, may be it has forced the government to put in stronger measures to combat direct action. May be. May be not.

The fact is drastic action needs to be taken. There is no longer any choice and using it to negate our own individual responsibility is just pointless. Cutting your nose off to spite your own face comes to mind. I understand the outrage and anger but not the ‘so to hell with it’ attitude of some PP

For DECADES there has been peaceful, polite, measured and responsible campaigning but governments have not listened. Instead, they have tied themselves closely to the very industries that cause the most harm.

If after decades of awareness raising, campaigning and educating, after you g people took to the streets to plead for us to do something, our leaders are still not taking the drastic action needed, then there is a moral imperative to take direct action (that has minimum risk of harm to others).

The current direct action, at times may have crossed a line, I don’t know the facts, but direct action is now the only course of action - everything else has been tried and we are in an emergency situation.

katnyps · 05/10/2021 11:12

livpool just to clarify I'm not an XR supporter - I could actually lose my job for being a member (small print of the ethics policy I had to sign recently! something about not being a member of any organisation opposed to the core business of the company). I also don't agree with stopping ambulances. BUT I'm not sure who's having the alternative, well-mannered debate that people are actually listening to? That debate exists - and the rational arguments to support it - but sadly mostly aren't sitting around reading the latest IPCC reports...

PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 11:09

@katnyps

So to pose the question a different way - what action WOULD the majority support to raise awareness and stimulate action on climate change?
To be brutally honest, I think a tick mark and note of “done to death” can be put by “raise awareness” and for “stimulate action” I would advise looking for real gaps between what is being done and what can be done and start petitions, draft legislation, lobby MPs.

For example,
The U.K. Government has a goal of banning petrol and diesel cars by 2030. Simultaneously U.K. Government is pushing the construction of new housing developments to address the housing crisis. Yet none of the developers are required to build these homes with charging sockets/charging stations. Nor is there any government effort to retrofit electric charging sockets or stations for older homes, especially those that only have on street parking. So my advice is look at the Government goals to combat climate change and start finding and addressing the pitfalls that will prevent this goal from being a reality.

Another example, is not to blindly assume investment in fossil fuel based companies is investment into using more fossil fuels. XR has criticised London for investing billions in “carbon polluters” such as Maersk. Maersk has largest fleet of cargo ships in the world, so yes they are currently carbon polluters. But do you know why £1.3bn was invested in them? To convert their entire fleet of cargo ships to carbon zero ships. XR also protested the British Museum for allowing Shell to contribute to its exhibits, they assumed all Shell does is sell petrol. But Shell is also a world leader in bio-fuels and developing carbon zero aircraft. Many many companies are in fact going green, and protesters need to let go of old prejudices and actually do their research before kicking up a fuss.

Livpool · 05/10/2021 11:08

@katnyps and how are they helping exactly?!

katnyps · 05/10/2021 11:07

I think it's actually convenient for people to have a hateable figure - it is an excuse to ignore the whole issue... though I hope most of the responses on here are just facetious

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/10/2021 11:06

It's worth remembering that the Sufragettes weren't generally popular either ...

Worth remembering too that it wasn't their screaming and stamping which got women the vote in the end, much as it's pretended it was

That was down to the war, when afterwards it came to be appreciated that a group who'd done so much really couldn't be refused the vote any longer

Swipe left for the next trending thread