Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Extinction Rebellion co-founder says he would block an ambulance carrying a dying patient

267 replies

sst1234 · 05/10/2021 07:10

How can anyone support this bunch of nasty idiots who are willing to commit what can only be described as murder. How can anyone justify this? Imagine how you would feel it was one of you family members in that ambulance, this man would not hesitate to cause their death.

OP posts:
BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/10/2021 15:14

They could be drumming up support for projects which don't currently have a funding subsidy program in place (carbon capture and storage, large scale pumped storage) but we're talking billions for those projects so it really needs the public to get behind, and then government to but the funding mechanisms in place - not really a crowd funding opportunity

Of course they could, but where's the self-serving attention seeking drama in that?

katnyps · 05/10/2021 15:09

plan that's promising - and I think highlights that even in combustion engines producing CO2 it's the other byproducts (which you doing get from hydrogen) which help to nucleate the water vapour and create the contrails (isn't chem trails a term mostly used by conspiracy theorists rather than a term to describe exhaust gases??). It seems like, on balance, hydrogen would actually be a better alternative - though still better to fly less! There is a bit more up to date info in this recent UK fov publication too: <a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/813342/non-CO2-effects-report.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjZ18Wct7PzAhWIYMAKHRciBuAQFnoECDMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0PQ1ujLeNeG9RNdcC19uHV" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/813342/non-CO2-effects-report.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjZ18Wct7PzAhWIYMAKHRciBuAQFnoECDMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0PQ1ujLeNeG9RNdcC19uHV.

MyPatronusIsACat · 05/10/2021 14:56

@MephistophelesApprentice

They're a minority willing to use extreme, potentially lethal methods to force political change on a majority. They're terrorists who lack the conviction for full violence, so settle for a pathetic alternative that can cause just as much harm but let's them feel better about themselves.

What's worse is they're giving the bloody Tories the perfect excuse (and public support) to clamp down and reduce the right to legitimate protest. A blind, arrogant blunder that will have even worse consequences over time.

This. ^ They are scum, and so are insulate Britain, and they all need tasering or hosing down.. And nothing anyone says will make me say any different.
katnyps · 05/10/2021 14:53

findwen Electricity generators are already doing all that and with the financial, management, engineering and legal expertise to do it properly and efficiency so I'm not sure XR getting involved is going to help. They could be drumming up support for projects which don't currently have a funding subsidy program in place (carbon capture and storage, large scale pumped storage) but we're talking billions for those projects so it really needs the public to get behind, and then government to but the funding mechanisms in place - not really a crowd funding opportunity

PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 14:43

@katnyps

PlanDeRaccordement Yeah condensation trail = contrail = water - they mimic the effect of certain types of clouds and trap heat in the atmosphere and I think contribute to around a third of the greenhouse effect of aircraft engines (and would still be an issue with hydrogen engines)
Ah, but today’s airplane contrail is not just water vapour, that’s why it’s also called a chemtrail. For a contrail to form, at the 33,000ft most airplanes cruise at, it needs exhaust particles to trigger condensation. Exhaust particles include unburned fuel, VOCs, hydrocarbons, alcohol, ozone, soot, even engine wear particles. A NASA study showed that contrail formation was reduced by 50-70% due to fewer soot particles when using a 50% biofuel/50% jet fuel mix.

Yes, water vapor by itself is another greenhouse gas produced by the combustion of fuel, and although the radiative forcing (difference between the energy absorbed through the Earth’s atmosphere compared to the energy that is reflected back into space) is lower than that of CO2, it still contributes towards global warming.

Hydrogen combustion would produce about 2.6 times more water vapor than kerosene fuel. In a study about the climate change effects of hydrogen aircraft, Ponater et al. [7] evaluated the individual and accumulated effects of the emissions of a hydrogen-based flight to a kerosene-based flight. The study concluded that the positive effects of a zero-CO2 combustion, would offset the drawback of increased water vapor exhaust. Moreover, CO2 has a lifetime in the atmosphere of up to
100 years, while that of water vapor can go from a few days up to 1 year [4]. Regarding condensation trails, due to the absence in solid particles at the exhaust of the engine when burning hydrogen, ice crystals have no-where to nucleate, so the number of water crystals formed at the exhaust would decrease. Nevertheless, due to the increased amount of water vapor exhaust, the crystals that do nucleate, would have a larger size. The overall effect is expected to decrease the radiative forcing effect of contrails. The end result, according to the study would mean that the radiative forcing from aviation could be 20-30% lower by 2050 and 50-60% by 2100 if LH2 aircraft were introduced [7].
www.iata.org/contentassets/d13875e9ed784f75bac90f000760e998/fact_sheet7-hydrogen-fact-sheet_072020.pdf

Findwen · 05/10/2021 14:40

@katnyps

hamstersarse what needs to be debated and if there was to be such a debate how would you engage, what platform would you expect to see it on and what would be required for you to take action as a result?
Step 1: Stop trying to raise awareness. Everyone already knows.

Step 2: Generate funding for research grants into green causes: e.g. reduce emissions building, reduce transmission loss of electricity over long distances.

Step 3: Identify sites for solar & wind farms. Crowd fund to have the built legally following all planning laws. Use the return on capital to help fund the next project.

Actually aim to achieve something themselves rather than cause emissions through stopping roads, trains and access to workplaces.

Think that would be a great start.

brokenbiscuitsx · 05/10/2021 14:22

I’ve reported my double post

brokenbiscuitsx · 05/10/2021 14:20
  • You won’t want them to disrupt fossil fuel supplies in the depths of winter. That would kill people too.

Don’t know why big oil/fossil fuel companies are so hated when they keep you warm, grow your food, make your mass-produced stuff and take you farther than you could ever walk.

They are the foundation of civilisation.
Really.*

I know. I don’t want them to target anyone.

I just wondered why they thinking stopping someone getting to work is going to help? Lots of corporations need to become more sustainable, without them on board nothing will change. No point solely targeting the public.

This makes me think they are trying to just cause disruption. Who are they lobbying or talking to who can make a difference? What is their campaign, just lie in the road and piss people off? 😂

Lostmarbles2021 · 05/10/2021 14:16

PlanDeRaccordement

I have not been radicalised but thank you for your concern. I have a science background and whilst science doesn’t hold complete certainty there is now no doubt about the situation we are in. I have been aware of climate change as an issue since the 1980s. I sign petitions, I have changed my individual behaviour and been on the odd march but I don’t personally take part in direct action but can see that in the current situation and with the long history of little government action there is nothing else left to do if you care about the future of humanity.

Pazuzu · 05/10/2021 14:13

6% are saying YABU? What do these protesters have to do as well as this? Bugger the cat?

There is protest and then there is this selfish virtue signalling twattery. If you think that blocking an ambulance is acceptable you're a cunt.

Amazing too that they all seem to live or can afford to commute to the most expensive city in the country...

katnyps · 05/10/2021 14:13

PlanDeRaccordement
Yeah condensation trail = contrail = water - they mimic the effect of certain types of clouds and trap heat in the atmosphere and I think contribute to around a third of the greenhouse effect of aircraft engines (and would still be an issue with hydrogen engines)

Lostmarbles2021 · 05/10/2021 14:11

PlanDeRaccordement

Yes. Some action has been taken but there has also been a long history of minimising, denying and action that is counter to what is needed. Heathrow expansion was one such battle. There are countless others. The trouble is that taking action to minimise climate chaos means a decrease in quality of life and a loss of economic gain in some sectors and that’s not a popular thing to do.

BlackberrySky · 05/10/2021 14:09

I hate these people more and more every day.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/10/2021 14:05

That data holds and it's so frightening

This is the sort of statement that turns me right off. The data is often cherry-picked, exaggerated and is always presented as Fact.

I suggest listening to last week's More or Less (BBC Sounds) - it transpires Insulate Britain's claims are incorrect.

Well, colour me surprised Hmm

UsedUpUsername · 05/10/2021 14:05

@brokenbiscuitsx

What I don’t understand… why are they essentially ‘attacking’ and disrupting members of the public and not big oil/fossil fuel corporations Hmm
You won’t want them to disrupt fossil fuel supplies in the depths of winter. That would kill people too.

Don’t know why big oil/fossil fuel companies are so hated when they keep you warm, grow your food, make your mass-produced stuff and take you farther than you could ever walk.

They are the foundation of civilisation.
Really.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 05/10/2021 14:04

@Franklyfrost

Ecocide is genocide. He’s not doing himself any favours by saying it out loud but he’s right. The dying person in the ambulance has human drama. But the fact that the dying person could be one of the 50,000 deaths a year in the uk from air pollution (house of commons air audit 2010) isn’t as dramatic.
So if that was your child/parent/sibling in an ambulance being held up by one of his goons you would say what...."oh it's ok I don't mind the extra delay for my loved ones treatment, if they die they die as long as it saves 49999 other people their death will not matter"?
PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 13:37

@katnyps
but unfortunately a significantly large proportion of the greenhouse effect is actually from the contrail and this is, I think, going to be just as much of an issue with hydrogen burning engines?

No, hydrogen engines only byproduct is fresh water. Which the planet is actually in desperate need of.

PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 13:35

@Lostmarbles2021
For the good of humanity governments need to put in policy and legislation to force the people into action. They haven’t. For decades. Decades!! Direct action is literally all that’s left.

No that is eco-terrorist propaganda you have been fed in order to convince you to do whatever “direct actions” the leaders of XR or IB demand. You have been radicalised.

PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 13:33

@BelleOfTheProvince

And the sad thing is when the experts, scientists, government, people in industry solve the problems causing climate change terrorist groups like this will claim the credit, when I'm reality they do zero practical towards the cause.
Absolutely, just like the suffragettes claimed credits for what the suffragists accomplished.
PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 13:29

@Lostmarbles2021
For DECADES there has been peaceful, polite, measured and responsible campaigning but governments have not listened. Instead, they have tied themselves closely to the very industries that cause the most harm.

This is a complete and utter lie. Governments have listened and are making progress against climate change. Look up the Climate Change Performance Index which is run by an independent nongovernmental charity that tracks the actual performance of 57 countries and the EU since 2005.

On it, you will see that the U.K. is currently ranked second for the most progress.

elbea · 05/10/2021 13:15

@katnyps apart from if you are on qualifying benefits the energy companies will insulate your house and replace your boiler - so what are they even protesting about?

www.which.co.uk/reviews/home-grants/article/home-grants/free-loft-insulation-and-free-boilers-from-energy-suppliers-a85i81F3XKdd#npower-free-or-subsidised-insulation-and-boilers

BelleOfTheProvince · 05/10/2021 13:10

@brokenbiscuitsx

What I don’t understand… why are they essentially ‘attacking’ and disrupting members of the public and not big oil/fossil fuel corporations Hmm
I take it you are looking for an answer a bit more detailed than 'because they're fucking knobs!'?
brokenbiscuitsx · 05/10/2021 13:06

What I don’t understand… why are they essentially ‘attacking’ and disrupting members of the public and not big oil/fossil fuel corporations Hmm

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 05/10/2021 13:01

@Cabinfever10

Well having read the bs response from extinction rebellion all 8 can say is do they honestly expect people to believe them when we have seen the way they behave and heard their founders words. Tbh most of us who are old enough to remember the animal rights extremists and the harm that their behaviour (bombs, fire bombs etc) did to the cause are just waiting on XR destroying themselves in the same way
I definitely see your point, but I hope we don’t need to wait for them to destroy themselves. They’ve been horrible, selfish bastards from the very first day. Most people don’t seem to know Extinction Rebellion’s first action: it was an “occupation.” Must have been at a government office or some corporation, right? No. It was Greenpeace. Well, then was it because Greenpeace was doing something horrible and corrupt? No again. It was so they could blackmail Greenpeace into giving them access to Greenpeace’s resources! Greenpeace spends effort, goodwill, research, and their own ethics to develop a huge mailing list and other resources and Extinction Rebellion does a sit-in until Greenpeace will agree to send an email introducing them and their cause to everyone on the mailing list! They wanted everything Greenpeace had spent decades building for themselves, in a few hours, for free. It’s disgusting, and it’s indicative of how they’ve operated the whole time. Their first “occupation” was to demand another NGO’s hard-earned resources built by their own donors. So why the hell does anyone ever trust Extinction Rebellion again? And I don’t even support Greenpeace! And Greenpeace sure as fuck dont support Extinction Rebellion, no surprise, as an NGO that actually meets with governments, makes presentations and suggestions about climate change, not just blows at least half their yearly budget on a six-day protest festival.

Source re: their Greenpeace blackmail:
www.commondreams.org/views/2018/10/19/climate-activists-occupy-greenpeace-uk-headquarters-wait-cant-be-right

Source on Extinction Rebellion blowing half its budget for a short protest:
m.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/extinction-rebellion-protests-funding_uk_5da09183e4b02c9da0495bba

Oh and if you want to know the exact money? Extinction Rebellion made £3.1 million 2019-2020 and spent it all on protests. Guess that wouldn’t have bought any factories that could have been closed down in China (where the pollution is) or insulated any homes (since they’re still ACTUALLY supporting Insulate Britain with their resources, as shown in the Critic article):
Companies House for Extinction Rebellion dba “Compassion Revolution Limited” showing they only gathered £3.1 million from 2019-2020:
s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/document-api-images-live.ch.gov.uk/docs/zpsnniSW9fKA2PzNLHbT2vN_sp4N6kSX4e1zJY-PMA8/application-pdf?

Makes you wonder: could the £3.1 million Extinction Rebellion earned in a single year not save a SINGLE human life? I mean, really? In fact, with the way both organizations are going - stopping insulators from reaching appointments (and there may not be a second chance before winter), both Extinction Rebellion and Insulate Britain stopping people from reaching important hospital appointments - they will have spent £3.1 million and actually killed a few people. If people don’t think that’s the height of self-centred, entitled arseholes, I honestly don’t know what is.

Lostmarbles2021 · 05/10/2021 13:01

TheFoundations

Yes. But all of that has been done. I remember a massive protest March in London a few years ago for that very reason. The fact is lots of us don’t want to give up our comfortable lifestyles and won’t until we are made to. For the good of humanity governments need to put in policy and legislation to force the people into action. They haven’t. For decades. Decades!! Direct action is literally all that’s left. There is a long tradition of this in history. There were always those whose direct action was a step too far in many people’s eyes. Nevertheless we need radical and direct action.

Swipe left for the next trending thread