Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Extinction Rebellion co-founder says he would block an ambulance carrying a dying patient

267 replies

sst1234 · 05/10/2021 07:10

How can anyone support this bunch of nasty idiots who are willing to commit what can only be described as murder. How can anyone justify this? Imagine how you would feel it was one of you family members in that ambulance, this man would not hesitate to cause their death.

OP posts:
UsedUpUsername · 06/10/2021 11:34

XR want to override far more democratic rights. They refuse to acknowledge that the population as a whole has a say in government and laws. We have robust and effective democratic processes that need to be protected. They ignore any voice speaking against them. Even the overwhelming majority

It’s because they know they will have to press governments to use fascist, authoritarian tactics to make the kind of societal changes for carbon zero to happen. It won’t happen otherwise (thank fuck)

Bythemillpond · 06/10/2021 10:49

Whenever a person or group starts saying that they are doing things for the greater good.
Anyone’s first thought is Hot Fuzz.

In Insulate Britain’s case I am unsure what they want that wasn’t already in place up to March of this year.
Only withdrawn because very few people claimed their £5000.

BelleOfTheProvince · 06/10/2021 10:40

I never heard of a fascist group that didn't think the means justify the ends. Surely you gotta question yourself when you and Voldemort both use for the greater good as your motto.

LemonTT · 06/10/2021 10:03

@tenredthings

Lemon "You propose a road map to despotism. I expect you don’t even know these are the tactics of the fascist.*" * Direct action is also used by the oppressed. Our government is currently removing our right to peacefully protest, is that ok because they were democratically elected ?

I'm not condoning XR but I do admire the fact they are passionate enough to care. I personally think it's way too late to save our planet. Our 'civilisation' is a flawed model and there's way too much inertia and greed to make the changes needed.

XR want to override far more democratic rights. They refuse to acknowledge that the population as a whole has a say in government and laws. We have robust and effective democratic processes that need to be protected. They ignore any voice speaking against them. Even the overwhelming majority.

Their tactics are those of the fascists.

We are not even vaguely oppressed in this country. I speak from experience. If protesters can sit in front of ambulances day after day without any serious police intervention, you are very lucky. The police are actually stopping attacks on the protesters. You statement is a joke. The threat to rights comes from organisations and supporters who behave this way. Because of the threat they pose to others. It’s how it all starts.

Just because democratic processes don’t give you what you want when you want them doesn’t you have the moral right to put lives at risk. And then say that those lives are insignificant in terms of your greater good.

You are praising and justifying the tactics of the fascists. Who no doubt thought they were right and doing good.

BelleOfTheProvince · 06/10/2021 09:06

Direct action is also used by the oppressed. Our government is currently removing our right to peacefully protest,
Which is this and xr only achievement to date.

So proof they do more harm than good, even when putting blue light collateral aside.

UsedUpUsername · 06/10/2021 07:00

I'm not condoning XR but I do admire the fact they are passionate enough to care. I personally think it's way too late to save our planet. Our 'civilisation' is a flawed model and there's way too much inertia and greed to make the changes needed

You need to live somewhere without civilisation so you can understand just how good you really have it and how bad … really bad … things can be.

Let’s start with not freezing in winter.

tenredthings · 06/10/2021 06:52

Lemon "You propose a road map to despotism. I expect you don’t even know these are the tactics of the fascist.*"
*
Direct action is also used by the oppressed. Our government is currently removing our right to peacefully protest, is that ok because they were democratically elected ?

I'm not condoning XR but I do admire the fact they are passionate enough to care. I personally think it's way too late to save our planet. Our 'civilisation' is a flawed model and there's way too much inertia and greed to make the changes needed.

DdraigGoch · 06/10/2021 00:56

The UK's biggest sector for emissions is transport (27%). Almost all of this is road transport with most of the remainder being aviation.

Electric cars won't solve this, most people will need to move to public transport. So XR should campaign for railway electrification, high speed rail (look what HS1 did to poach London-Paris passengers from the air), tramway expansion and conversion of urban bus routes to trolleybuses. Battery-electric vehicles then fill in the rural gaps.

Then let's look at the next biggest sector - energy generation (21%). We need nuclear on the scale they do it in France. There is no alternative way of getting large amounts of power without emitting CO2. So XR must campaign for nuclear power.

If XR are serious about reducing emissions, this needs to be their focus. Or is it more fun just sitting in a road doing yoga?

LemonTT · 05/10/2021 19:41

@tenredthings

In being controversial XR are opening up a dialogue. Look at how we are discussing it on mumsnet ! Making trouble is an effective tool for getting a subject into the news and prompting action. Look at the poll tax riots, they were extremely effective. In contrast look at the passive, well behaved March against Brexit where millions of protesters made not a jot of difference.
Being controversial to grab headlines is the tactics of the extremists. Used by the hard right, Trump et al to crowd out normal debate and lobbying.

The poll tax riots didn’t change the mind of Margaret Thatcher. The poll did. The March against Brexit should never be able to overturn a democratic mandate.

You propose a road map to despotism. I expect you don’t even know these are the tactics of the fascist.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/10/2021 18:47

@LimitIsUp

I predict that unfortunately one or more of Insulate Britain are going to meet a sticky end soon - there are some hot headed people with anger issues out there, and some of them will be stuck in the queues of traffic held up by these 'protestors' - at some point one of them is going to lose it big time.
Surely it would be their own fault.
WouldBeGood · 05/10/2021 18:21

@hamstersarse yes! Exactly that

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 05/10/2021 17:59

They are a bunch of stupid cunts !

hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 17:52

@ZoeCM

Oh yes I have! I think the term is 'luxury beliefs'.

People who have the luxury of thinking these things that don't really impact them directly, but they can use them to signal their moral superiority

Harry and Megan are the kings and queens of this.

ZoeCM · 05/10/2021 17:48

Anyone else struck by how blindingly white both Extinction Rebellion and Insulate Britain are?

BelleOfTheProvince · 05/10/2021 16:50

Look at how we are discussing it on mumsnet !

There's no such thing as bad publicity right?
Wrong.
Fyi, everyone already knows about climate change. Where have you been living, under a rock?

The only way xr and co could be considered a success is if they are government plants designed to curb right to protest.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/10/2021 16:42

I'm afraid you're kidding yourself, tenredthings, though it's probably what you want to believe

The "dialogue" is already there and has been for ages, but XR (while trying to latch onto it in their own interests) are merely alienating people and derailing what can otherwise be a worthwhile message

WouldBeGood · 05/10/2021 16:38

It’s actually made me wholly uninterested in any climate change activism, can’t be arsed.

MephistophelesApprentice · 05/10/2021 16:38

In being controversial XR are opening up a dialogue.

The only dialogue they've opened is how far the public will be willing to let the government go in the suppression of protest rights.

tenredthings · 05/10/2021 16:35

In being controversial XR are opening up a dialogue. Look at how we are discussing it on mumsnet ! Making trouble is an effective tool for getting a subject into the news and prompting action. Look at the poll tax riots, they were extremely effective. In contrast look at the passive, well behaved March against Brexit where millions of protesters made not a jot of difference.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/10/2021 16:26

They could be drumming up support for projects which don't currently have a funding subsidy program in place

Yes, but compared to a nice little demo, some self-glueing and a bit of drumming and dancing that's boring

Unfortunately these idiots enjoy what they're doing - or at least the attention it brings - as we see from the "job done" smirks of those carted away. The pity of it is that some pay them the compliment of engaging and listening to their silliness instead of treating them as the criminals many are

LimitIsUp · 05/10/2021 16:17

I predict that unfortunately one or more of Insulate Britain are going to meet a sticky end soon - there are some hot headed people with anger issues out there, and some of them will be stuck in the queues of traffic held up by these 'protestors' - at some point one of them is going to lose it big time.

Covidworries · 05/10/2021 16:13

Blocking an ambalance that may or may not have a critically ill person inside who may live regardless of being blcoked or may die if left through. How is that any different to the people who say they wont test their kids for covid because they prob wont even have covid and even if they do most people are goin to fine.

I dont agree in blocking ambalance btw but its interesting as people put ither people life at risk all the time

waybill · 05/10/2021 16:09

Yes, well I don't suppose he'd block the path of an ambulance carrying one of his close family members, would he?

Hypocritical bastard.

BelleOfTheProvince · 05/10/2021 15:35

people know, they just don't care enough to do something simple like stop eating beef.

Well the xr and ib lot are the worst examples of this. Hardly any of them reducaterian, vegetarian or vegan. Yet again, it's someone else's problem to solve.

And actually, if anything, they are a terrible advert for reducing meat as people (wrongly) assume all these stupid attention seekers are vegan.

Findwen · 05/10/2021 15:18

@katnyps

findwen Electricity generators are already doing all that and with the financial, management, engineering and legal expertise to do it properly and efficiency so I'm not sure XR getting involved is going to help. They could be drumming up support for projects which don't currently have a funding subsidy program in place (carbon capture and storage, large scale pumped storage) but we're talking billions for those projects so it really needs the public to get behind, and then government to but the funding mechanisms in place - not really a crowd funding opportunity
Research grants for basic science are really hard to come by - crowd funding them is certainly in the realms of possibility and means of such groups. Research into reducing emissions from the building industry is certainly not well funded right now.

That said it seems we have an agreement on the rest of your comments, that XR could drum up support for existing projects rather than glue themselves to trains or block roads.

I really wish they would stop trying to raise awareness though - people know, they just don't care enough to do something simple like stop eating beef.

Swipe left for the next trending thread