Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for christ's sake NHS

210 replies

lolliwillowes · 05/10/2021 00:49

Why are you still advising people to choose low fat margarine over butter?
The entire food plate thing is a disaster, encouraging people to stay healthy long term by substituting natural fats for Frankenstein-fats.

Surely I am not BU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Greyrootszerohoots · 05/10/2021 08:51

@Etotheipiplus1equals0 I think a lot of the advice given by our local hospitals is related to chemo and doesn’t account for newer drugs with different side affect profiles. It’s good to hear a dietician was giving advice though - we don’t seem to have to at luxury in our area, just a stack of outdated leaflets!

MatildaIThink · 05/10/2021 08:48

@JemimaTab

Their diabetes diet advice is also seriously out of date.
So out of date that for most diabetics and pre diabetics it makes it worse or actually causes diabetes.
Etotheipiplus1equals0 · 05/10/2021 08:47

@Greyrootszerohoots I didn’t get that advice with my cancer diagnosis, I was just told to eat a normal diet. Actually it’s hard during chemo as your appetite and tastes are all over the place. I did see a dietician advising a woman to add butter and cream to soups etc as she was losing a worrying amount of weight which can be dangerous for treatment.
Evidence is really mixed on the best diet for cancer avoidance - there are studies that show dairy is a concern for breast cancer, there are others that show it can prevent it. It’s very hard to know the best thing to do when so much evidence is conflicting and a bit flimsy (participants are self reporting their diet which may not be accurate). Being a healthy weight does seem unequivocally important. But my mum was slim and healthy and died of a brain tumour at 62- a lot of it is down to luck.
For me I find sticking to a low GI/ healthy carbs and lots of protein diet is the most effective way to lose weight. 16/8 fasting too.

hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 08:45

Cholesterol is another disasterous policy and statins are also on extremely shaky evidence

The government policy on all things lifestyle are pretty disastrous. Lose weight by exercise? Also a disaster.

Lalliella · 05/10/2021 08:44

When I was a kid I used to refuse margarine because I thought it tasted like plastic. As an adult I discovered that their chemical formulae only differ by something like an atom. Lurpak all the way for me. Or the Aldi version Nordpak.

amusedbush · 05/10/2021 08:44

My mum (a chronic Weight Watcher since the 80s) brought me up on skimmed milk and "lighter than light" margarine, which looked like melted plastic Envy

As soon as I moved out I switched to butter and whole milk, and my life is much happier for it Grin In all seriousness though, a little bit of the good stuff fills me up easily, keeps me mentally satisfied and tastes better.

SpindleWhirl · 05/10/2021 08:43

Is she a actual qualified dietician? Or just the HCP lumbered with the annual checks ticking of a check sheet when looking at areas outside their expertise?

The practice phlebotomist got lumbered with my last annual 'review of a long term condition'. Neither of us had a clue which condition she was reviewing for.

One of the questions she read off the screen was, 'Do you have a good diet?' I said yes, and she ticked the box. That was it.

At least she didn't mention cheese.

butterpuffed · 05/10/2021 08:43

@Cazzovuoi

Their diabetes advice is criminal. Type 2 diabetes can be easily and quickly reversed with a very low carb diet.
That's incorrect. It cannot be reversed, it can go into remission. I'm in remission but if I went back to eating sweet food, bread, pasta, rice, potatoes, [all carbs turn to sugar in the blood] then my blood sugars would soon be back into the diabetic range.
godmum56 · 05/10/2021 08:43

@lljkk

Why is margarine a "frankenstein fat" ?

Most foods are processed, btw, wholemeal flour is processed, plain unsweetened yogurt is processed, tomato puree is processed, etc.

thats why there is now the description of "ultra processed" for what used to be called "processed"
ChiefInspectorParker · 05/10/2021 08:42

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 08:38

I think the pushing of processed seed oils will be a scandal in the future.
Vegetable oil, rape seed oil, sunflower oil…..extremely processed ‘foods’ all pushed on the back of the mistaken policy that saturated fat causes heart disease….these oils destroy mitochondria and lots of research now about how these oils are responsible for a plethora of chronic disease.

If you do one thing….take these processed fats out of your diet. Today.

(Problem is you’ll see how hard it is to do that….they are in EVERYTHING!)

SpindleWhirl · 05/10/2021 08:37

One thing they just automatically assume is that as we get older, our bone density and muscle decrease so we 'ought' to weigh less. But those of us around 60 who lift weights and do a lot of exercise have very dense muscles and bones which are very heavy

That's such a good point, @leavesthataregreen (and @Ratched).

So many of us around-60somethings have a much better awareness these days of fitness, exercise, bone health, HRT to help reduce osteoporosis, and the importance of calcium etc in our diets.

Our mothers' and grandmothers' generations, on whom these statistics are presumably based, very often seemed to fade away in front of our eyes - they literally shrank.

At my arthritis clinic I got handed a leaflet for 'armchair exercises for the over 60s' (I'm 60) showing a much older person sitting down holding a ball. But at home, I already have weights, shock horror.

LemonSwan · 05/10/2021 08:36

YANBU

I had to go to A&E once with an ear infection because no one does ear clearances yet and I hadn't figured out about private micro suction yet.

I was told I need to stop eating cheese.

No it turns out I have genetically small ear canals and genetically sticky wax; and if you had bothered to look in my ears you would have known that!

Instead 3 courses of antibiotics before I started ringing private in pure desperation. Apparently the infection never would have shifted unless it has cleared - instant relief and cleared 48 hours later.

But the cheese?!

Allywill · 05/10/2021 08:33

Rats won’t eat margarine. They do not recognise it as food as it’s is basically plastic. It was developed by the (French?) army as they wanted a foodstuff that would not go off (and presumably not eaten by rodents or maybe that was an unexpected benefit). And it doesn’t. Ever. Butter all the way for me.

Lotusmonster · 05/10/2021 08:33

I disagree.I think if something irresistible is in the house or fridge, it will get repeatedly dipped into…..and there the problems begin. The problem is that most people CANNOT moderate very well.
My grandparents ate a diet of saturated fats (butter, dripping to fry), they also grew vegetables and walked a dog. Grandfather has angina at 40 and was on massive heart tablets for years before having a heart attack at 70. Didn’t smoke.
I’m sure saturated animal fats had a huge part in this. Today we should be trying to learn from the past and not have such a dependence on big farting, burping dairy cows tbh.

Cakeofdoom · 05/10/2021 08:32

Butter all the way...I make my own and have done for years

CandidaAlbicans2 · 05/10/2021 08:28

I agree OP, the NHS must have a dire lack of nutritionists

The NHS mainly employ Dietitians (which is a protected title unlike "nutritionist") who have been trained on NHS bursary courses at uni. As a PP said, anyone can call themselves a nutritionist which is worrying. The NHS do recognise, and sometimes employ, those who have an Association for Nutrition registration (requiring at least a BSc on a science/evidence based approved course), and I can tell you they are taught to critically appraise any dietary recommendations, even the NHS's. Governments are often slow to change with the science unfortunately, and Dietitians have to follow government advice.

C8H10N4O2 · 05/10/2021 08:27

@Ratched

I saw the nurse at my practice last week. I am 60, weigh 9st 4lbs and am living with cancer. I walk 7 or 8 miles a day and swim 3 days a week. I wear size 10 jeans and a size 12 top ( sometimes a 14). I was told that my ideal weight was 7st 4lbs and to eat lots of low fat foods, fruit and vegetables. And asked if I needed dietary advice. I was actually really upset when I came out then thought sod it! And not being funny, but when that sage advice is given by a young woman who is at least several stones overweight, it jars.
Is she a actual qualified dietician? Or just the HCP lumbered with the annual checks ticking of a check sheet when looking at areas outside their expertise?

Unless she is a dietician she will have had precious little training in diet and nutrition, especially for specialist areas such as cancer care. I would hope your cancer centre as actual dieticians and advice available for people in your situation.

MrsWooster · 05/10/2021 08:26

@MarleneDietrichsSmile

Nobody pays any attention to the nHS guidelines anyway

Not a soul

Also, people won’t die of a bit of low-fat spread, many regularly eat junk/ takeaways with 100x the fat

Nobody heeds their advice anyway (just look around you)

The Eatwell plate is still being taught as gospel in school. My 8 yo daughter is currently making my life a living hell with her ‘nutritional advice’; I try and kindly point out that as someone who had a lifelong weight problem and T2D, I have painstakingly acquired a lot of knowledge about food in the last few years, and NONE of it accords with the NHS advice. Don’t know why I waste my breath though, because “Miss says…”
SpindleWhirl · 05/10/2021 08:25

What I was told to stop eating by my practice nurse: cheese

What I in fact stopped eating: sugary processed crap

Family medical history I told her about: osteoporosis

kwiksavenofrillsusername · 05/10/2021 08:19

I remember getting an Eatwell book from DS school. It was pretty rubbish. It had advice on swaps you should make like instead of a slice of cake, have a tea cake with margarine. Instead of a chocolate bar, have a cereal bar. But those things can still be packed with sugar. Then there were a load of shit recipes that sounded like they came out of a 70s school dinners menu.

Lovemusic33 · 05/10/2021 08:17

Both my grandfathers lived into their 90’s, one had a fry up every day, ate real butter but also grew his own veg and ate traditional meals (meat, potatoes and veg), the other had a sweet tooth and lived on honey sandwiches or sugar sandwiches, also grew his own veg and had a very active life.

I do use low fat spread but only because I can’t eat much dairy.

knittingaddict · 05/10/2021 08:13

Whip cream/milk, you get butter.

Hardly a processed food, is it?

Leftbutcameback · 05/10/2021 08:12

YANBU - they are very out of date with their advice. I suspect it's lack of resource to update properly rather than anything else. Butter only for me since about five years ago. Love having it in a butter dish too.