Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for christ's sake NHS

210 replies

lolliwillowes · 05/10/2021 00:49

Why are you still advising people to choose low fat margarine over butter?
The entire food plate thing is a disaster, encouraging people to stay healthy long term by substituting natural fats for Frankenstein-fats.

Surely I am not BU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
MummyJ12 · 05/10/2021 16:45

Margarine is much more heavily processed than butter. It goes through various phases of production where it is emulsified, pasteurised and crystallised. Emulsions and chemicals are added throughout and sometimes the product goes through this cycle more than once.
There are strict regulations on the presence of antibiotics and other medications in milk. Samples are taken and tested before positive release of the product so I dispute that milk is ‘processed in the cow’. Unless you count lactation 🤷🏻‍♀️. Milk is usually pasteurised before the mass production of butter, it isn’t necessary to use homogenised milk as the butter churning homogenises the milk so it’s a waste of time, money and equipment. Artisan and small scale butter producers such as Jersey butter use raw milk so this butter has been processed very little. In no way is butter more process heavy than margarine.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 05/10/2021 16:45

Palm oil in bread does my head in.

Why on Earth? I mean, I know why, it stays “fresh” for longer, but still.

lolliwillowes · 05/10/2021 16:38

And to add, here are the ingredients in a slice of Warburtons white bread. How are so many of these even necessary?

Wheat Flour [with Calcium, Iron, Niacin (B3) and Thiamin (B1)], Water, Yeast, Salt, Vegetable Oil (Rapeseed, Sustainable Palm), Soya Flour, Preservative: Calcium Propionate, Emulsifiers: E481, E472e, Flour Treatment Agent: Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C)

OP posts:
lolliwillowes · 05/10/2021 16:34

Interesting points about plant oils, such as rapeseed, etc.
I read about omega 6 and some studies regarding the issues surrounding hydrogenated oils and poor health outcomes. As with most stuff these days, I have literally no idea anymore which damn food is good or bad for me, with so many conflicting studies floating around.

I dod do a small experiment though. I looked up a large variety of non-raw foods on Ocado one evening and almost everything contained these hydrogenated oils, and quite a few other, unnecessary ingredients that boggle the mind - and a massive amount of these were in foods that claimed to be healthy or organic.

Some examples were : Wholegrain pitta bread, organic mayo, some spreadable butter, all meat and fish coatings/crumbs, sauces, most gluten free stuff, crackers (apart from ryvita, which were curiously pure, haha!).
It was very difficult, unless buying raw ingredients, to find any food without rapeseed oil. I guess it depends on how bad it is, and whether it is fine in moderation.

My GP is pretty ok, not perfect, but does recommend moderation in all things, rather than dropping entire food groups. She even admitted cheese was innocent....

What is it with cheese and cholesterol checks? Im fond of cheese but it can stack the weight on whether it's healthy or not!

OP posts:
Smashingspinster · 05/10/2021 16:28

The whole NHS advice to food and weight management is seriously poor.

MyPatronusIsACat · 05/10/2021 16:13

@lolliwillowes YANBU. I would rather have delicious FULL-FAT REAL BUTTER, and have less of it, than have low fat tasteless muck...

SpindleWhirl · 05/10/2021 16:07

"Stick to food your grandmother would have recognised". The last one needs to be relative; my grandmother wouldn't have recognised quinoa if she'd tripped over it in the dark, but she'd have recognised natural grains.

I really like this.

My grandmas cooked a lot with barley and oats. The oats wrapped fish. Barley for soup and stews.

LaurieFairyCake · 05/10/2021 15:47

Yes I disagree with you factually

And so does the government who decide what is processed and what is HIGHLY processed

You said it was highly processed

It is NOT

It is processed

Wroxie · 05/10/2021 15:30

@LaurieFairyCake

I'm taking issue with your inflammatory language - they're obfuscating the real issue which is that margarine is much further away from natural food than butter is

Processed and highly or extremely processed are different

So you can't disagree with anything I've said, factually, so you're going to go for my "inflammatory language" instead. Good tactic!

I grew up on a dairy farm. I've been to processing facilities, on a field trip in school and again as an adult when looking at some IT systems for a major producer. Milk is highly processed before it even leaves the cow - hormones and all kinds of medication. Then it's pasteurised and homogenised. The milk is processed in all kinds of ways at every stage and yes even with "chemicals" that you don't see on the packet because they're either washed away or they remain in only trace amounts in the final product. So, yes, dairy products including butter are highly processed unless you're buying them all fresh-churned from your local dairy maid or whatever. In some ways it's more process-heavy than margarine, because there is so much potential variability in the base ingredient (milk changes based on season, weather, general mood of cows) that has to be managed and accounted for.

RandomLondoner · 05/10/2021 15:14

When I was a kid I used to refuse margarine because I thought it tasted like plastic. As an adult I discovered that their chemical formulae only differ by something like an atom

Whereas butter differs from plastic by two atoms.

OK I made that up. But I doubt that two products that have such similar properties are massively different from each other, from an organic chemistry point of view.

LaurieFairyCake · 05/10/2021 15:05

I'm taking issue with your inflammatory language - they're obfuscating the real issue which is that margarine is much further away from natural food than butter is

Processed and highly or extremely processed are different

LaurieFairyCake · 05/10/2021 15:00

No

You said butter is EXTREMELY processed

It's processed, NOT 'extremely' or 'highly'

It does not meet the definition of highly processed- it contains 2 ingredients

Wroxie · 05/10/2021 14:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/10/2021 14:46

Regarding processing, have a look at the Nova system in the article above. It covers the four different types of processing and the effect is has on food.

As an example, if I had milk and drank it in the form in which it came out of the cow, that's stage 1. Pasteurising it, where it's briefly super-heated but is still recognisably milk, is stage 2. Turning it into yogurt by souring it with lemon juice would be stage 3. Adding stabilisers, emulsifiers, preservatives and artificial flavouring to make a commercial yogurt is stage 4.

Stage 1 is a natural product, stages 2 and 3 are processed but recognisable and relatively un-modified and/or still using recognisable ingredients, stage 4 is ultra-processed.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/10/2021 14:41

@Ratched

I saw the nurse at my practice last week. I am 60, weigh 9st 4lbs and am living with cancer. I walk 7 or 8 miles a day and swim 3 days a week. I wear size 10 jeans and a size 12 top ( sometimes a 14). I was told that my ideal weight was 7st 4lbs and to eat lots of low fat foods, fruit and vegetables. And asked if I needed dietary advice. I was actually really upset when I came out then thought sod it! And not being funny, but when that sage advice is given by a young woman who is at least several stones overweight, it jars.
@Ratched That is shocking. No wonder you were upset, you had every right to be.

I think ultra processed food is going to be the next realisation; that tinkering with food to make it cheap and taste/smell/look/feel the same but doing so by filling them with substitutes, isn't a good thing. The food companies aren't going to like it because there's little money to be made in developing foods made from unprocessed ingredients. Their argument seems to be "Well, we need cheap food because otherwise poor people can't afford it". So it's OK to expect them to eat food that's bad for them? Hmm

This is an excellent article (and the Nova system it references is something I use a lot when choosing foods) www.theguardian.com/food/2020/feb/13/how-ultra-processed-food-took-over-your-shopping-basket-brazil-carlos-monteiro

Two rules I live by: "Eat food, not too much, mostly plants" and "Stick to food your grandmother would have recognised". The last one needs to be relative; my grandmother wouldn't have recognised quinoa if she'd tripped over it in the dark, but she'd have recognised natural grains.

8dpwoah · 05/10/2021 14:36

😂 just checking!

LaurieFairyCake · 05/10/2021 14:33

Goodness no Grin

Was to Wroxie

8dpwoah · 05/10/2021 14:27

Do you mean me? I was agreeing with you... Read it again.

LaurieFairyCake · 05/10/2021 14:17

Highly processed foods have additives that go beyond sugar and salt

According to the definition

LaurieFairyCake · 05/10/2021 14:14

Butter is NOT highly processed Hmm

Highly processed food contains loads of ingredients, E numbers etc, multiple processes

This butter from M and S is milk and salt - that's IT

Why the hell are you derailing this thread with this utter bullshit ?

for christ's sake NHS
for christ's sake NHS
for christ's sake NHS
8dpwoah · 05/10/2021 12:20

@LaurieFairyCake

Butter is MILK SHAKEN

It's not 'processed' Confused

I've actually made butter and that's ^^ all I did (you don't have to add salt - I did though because salted butter is the best)

EXACTLY. Butter is technically processed but it's so low-tech, low-input that you can do it at home yourself if you want. It's one step up from saying squeezing oranges means the juice is processed 😂

I don't think I could whip up a tub of Flora or whatever in my kitchen.

theDudesmummy · 05/10/2021 12:13

My DH was highly delighted by that article, he said "well we are having steak twice a week now!".

Leftbutcameback · 05/10/2021 12:07

@theDudesmummy thank you for sharing that guardian article. It's really useful! It just shows that one or two badly carried out studies, publicised well, will stick in our minds for generations. Off to have some more cheese now

LemonSwan · 05/10/2021 11:57

@Wroxie

Oh yes definitely!

And this is why real bread and real dough is just so bloody good!

I am currently living out of a microwave and temporary stove as in a house renovation. But I cannot wait to get my new kitchen with an oven and a proving drawer.

fiveleftfeet · 05/10/2021 11:13

@Etinox

Any fancy staring a Change.org petition or petition parliament?

Change.org

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/check (needs 5 emails)

I would but I don't really know much about it, bar an atavistic disgust response- that's such crap advice, eugh transfats Envy and it needs a more reasoned blurb.

Great idea!

I reckon a Government petition seeing as they have to respond if we get enough signatures.