Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for christ's sake NHS

210 replies

lolliwillowes · 05/10/2021 00:49

Why are you still advising people to choose low fat margarine over butter?
The entire food plate thing is a disaster, encouraging people to stay healthy long term by substituting natural fats for Frankenstein-fats.

Surely I am not BU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
KisstheTeapot14 · 06/10/2021 17:50

YANBU

Marg is the devil's own spread.

Butter all the way here.

NHS does need to seriously look at diet advice. Tis poor.

lljkk · 06/10/2021 15:31

tbh, this thread is reminding me why I like UPF so much. Long live them in my diet. And carbs. mmmmmm yum.

cakeintherain · 06/10/2021 11:41

I’m thoroughly confused now. I thought the olive oil was healthy when used cold but not so good for you when heated:
www.healthline.com/nutrition/is-olive-oil-good-for-cooking
Whereas rapeseed oil has a high smoke point and so is supposedly healthier to cook with
www.jamieoliver.com/features/change-to-rapeseed-oil/

herculesoffline · 06/10/2021 04:22

@8dpwoah

I think I've missed a few steps in my undergraduate of this discussion- how have we gone from hydrogenated fats are bad (surely yes?) to vegetable oils are bad (surely not?).

Genuine- what train of thought have I missed in this discussion?

Why are vegetable oils fine but not margarine (made from vegetable oils)?

What's the significance of margarine being one molecule away from butter? How different are the chemical compositions of butter and margarine? They both contain hydrogen, carbon and oxygen. Plastic contains carbon and hydrogen. I suppose they are similar in the same way margarine and water are similar..

AlphabetAerobics · 06/10/2021 04:20

@RandomLondoner

When I was a kid I used to refuse margarine because I thought it tasted like plastic. As an adult I discovered that their chemical formulae only differ by something like an atom

Whereas butter differs from plastic by two atoms.

OK I made that up. But I doubt that two products that have such similar properties are massively different from each other, from an organic chemistry point of view.

Ok bear with me because my 30 year old a-level chemistry is somewhat rusty and there will be REAL chemists around.

They are very different by composition. Saturated and unsaturated fats are common parlance - and in its simplest form, this is what it means.

CO2 (carbon dioxide) - carbon had four electrons and oxygen had two. That means if you join a carbon atom it “needs” two oxygen atoms to be “saturated”.

CO (carbon monoxide) is an oxygen atom short - ergo it’s unsaturated.

Saturated is like going to a dinner party full of couples.

Unsaturated is going to a dinner party with one single.

Poly-unsaturated is BEING that single on a group holiday and expected to look after all the couples’ kids.

“Shitstorm”. Grin

Fwiw my mum was type I diabetic, was told to fill up on toast, cereal and plenty of healthy fruit juice.

I’ve struggled with my weight and have been told lots of pasta, tatties and bread (with marg natch).

One of my best friends is a medic and was taught the carbs first mantra - she truly believes it. As for the uni dietician degree - imagine the disappointment to have spent 3 years being fed BS - whatever happened to higher education encouraging independent thought?

herculesoffline · 06/10/2021 03:53

@knittingaddict

Whip cream/milk, you get butter.

Hardly a processed food, is it?

The whipping is the processing. Its not an ultra or highly processed food but its had a change made from its natural form. A cut up apple is a processed food.
Orangejuicemarathoner · 05/10/2021 22:15

@Fordian

What oil should I be cooking with, please?
olive oil or butter
Fordian · 05/10/2021 21:56

What oil should I be cooking with, please?

8dpwoah · 05/10/2021 21:09

I think I've missed a few steps in my undergraduate of this discussion- how have we gone from hydrogenated fats are bad (surely yes?) to vegetable oils are bad (surely not?).

Genuine- what train of thought have I missed in this discussion?

TheKeatingFive · 05/10/2021 21:06

Are posters trying to argue that butter is as processed as margarine.

Really? What an extraordinary argument to try to make.

Orangejuicemarathoner · 05/10/2021 21:04

OK I made that up. But I doubt that two products that have such similar properties are massively different from each other, from an organic chemistry point of view.

They are totally different

butter is food

margarine is toxic waste

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 05/10/2021 21:00

I dont care what the advice is. I love butter.

Simonjt · 05/10/2021 21:00

Try being a type one diabetic, my diabetes nurse advises me to increase my carbs and that fruit juice is an option for one of my five a day…genuinely worried she is trying to kill me

C8H10N4O2 · 05/10/2021 20:58

@hamstersarse

I've seen Nina Teicholz's stuff before - she is very good *@lolliwillowes*

I saw this the other week which I though was a really good explanation of where we are with it all.

I really think these oils are absolutely toxic

I'm sure Teicholz's views are entirely independent of the fact that she is part of a lobbying organisation supported by the meat and dairy industries.
Perhaps its based on her rigorous scientific training which I'm sure she gained alongside her actual degrees in American studies except I can't quite find evidence or that training or qualification.
C8H10N4O2 · 05/10/2021 20:51

I saw an advert on the side of a McDonald's lorry the other day bragging that they recycle their vegetable oil into biodiesel for their lorries. I mean, even at a very basic level of knowledge and intuition, if the oil is basically diesel that's surely not very appealing

Seriously? You think that because an organic product can be converted into fuel its automatically harmful to health?

Well bad news - biodiesel is also be made by converting animal fats so better scrap all that butter, cheese and red meat. I mean you might as well drink petrol right?

That rat study was feeding the rats a diet which was 20% rape oil. I wouldn't recommend any diet to be 20% one ingredient. Your mitochondria won't be seeing that rape oil until its broken down to constituent fatty acids, just like any other fat.

Modern rapeseed oil is extremely low in erucic acid but high in omegas making a rich source of unsaturated and monosaturates. You will find more studies of size (and on humans) which show rapeseed on the good side of the pendulum than bad.

MyPatronusIsACat · 05/10/2021 19:58

@Rainbowsew

I agree! Much rather eat butter and milk and cream immoderation than that processed fake butter stuff, always made me feel rough. The whole low fat diet thing is.out of date. Sugar is much more evil than pure fat like butter or olive oil.
Exactly this. ^ I would much rather eat full-fat, full-sugar stuff, (and eat less of it,) than eat tasteless crap.
Rainbowsew · 05/10/2021 18:19

I agree! Much rather eat butter and milk and cream immoderation than that processed fake butter stuff, always made me feel rough. The whole low fat diet thing is.out of date. Sugar is much more evil than pure fat like butter or olive oil.

hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 18:06

I've seen Nina Teicholz's stuff before - she is very good @lolliwillowes

I saw this the other week which I though was a really good explanation of where we are with it all.

I really think these oils are absolutely toxic

lolliwillowes · 05/10/2021 17:48

@hamstersarse

core.ac.uk/download/pdf/19629931.pdf

There are loads of studies about rape seed oil. But basically it is about the amount of erucic acid they contain creating mitochondrial oxidative stress.

My reading of this is that our mitochondria need some good protective fat to stay healthy. Animal fats, butter and olive oil have low oxidation and so protect the mitochondrial functioning - but these highly processed Poly and Mono unsaturated fats / processed thermally produced seed oils do not and are actually toxic for their functioning, perhaps leading to chronic disease, as they are seeing in animal studies.

I saw an advert on the side of a McDonald's lorry the other day bragging that they recycle their vegetable oil into biodiesel for their lorries. I mean, even at a very basic level of knowledge and intuition, if the oil is basically diesel that's surely not very appealing.

Malcom Gladwell did a great podcast about McDonald's being pressured into changing their fat from beef dripping to vegetable oil, and what a travesty that was for health (and taste!) podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/mcdonalds-broke-my-heart/id1119389968?i=1000390869555 There is lots of good info about our disaster around fat in this podcast.

thanks this is interesting!
OP posts:
lolliwillowes · 05/10/2021 17:47

very interesting lecture on the history and issues with hydrogenated/veg oils

OP posts:
hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 17:44

@lolliwillowes

And to add, here are the ingredients in a slice of Warburtons white bread. How are so many of these even necessary?

Wheat Flour [with Calcium, Iron, Niacin (B3) and Thiamin (B1)], Water, Yeast, Salt, Vegetable Oil (Rapeseed, Sustainable Palm), Soya Flour, Preservative: Calcium Propionate, Emulsifiers: E481, E472e, Flour Treatment Agent: Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C)

It is barely even a food, let's face it!
hamstersarse · 05/10/2021 17:41

core.ac.uk/download/pdf/19629931.pdf

There are loads of studies about rape seed oil. But basically it is about the amount of erucic acid they contain creating mitochondrial oxidative stress.

My reading of this is that our mitochondria need some good protective fat to stay healthy. Animal fats, butter and olive oil have low oxidation and so protect the mitochondrial functioning - but these highly processed Poly and Mono unsaturated fats / processed thermally produced seed oils do not and are actually toxic for their functioning, perhaps leading to chronic disease, as they are seeing in animal studies.

I saw an advert on the side of a McDonald's lorry the other day bragging that they recycle their vegetable oil into biodiesel for their lorries. I mean, even at a very basic level of knowledge and intuition, if the oil is basically diesel that's surely not very appealing.

Malcom Gladwell did a great podcast about McDonald's being pressured into changing their fat from beef dripping to vegetable oil, and what a travesty that was for health (and taste!) podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/mcdonalds-broke-my-heart/id1119389968?i=1000390869555 There is lots of good info about our disaster around fat in this podcast.

lolliwillowes · 05/10/2021 17:27

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

Palm oil in bread does my head in.

Why on Earth? I mean, I know why, it stays “fresh” for longer, but still.

it never feels fresh to me, just damp!
OP posts:
IrritableBitchSyndrome · 05/10/2021 17:02

Food companies make billions from shelf stable long life ultra processed foods. Food companies donate large amounts to the Conservative party, and pay lobbyists to make damn sure their interests are represented. Any attempt to sort out the diet of the nation, or the US, runs aground on this.

ChrissyPlummer · 05/10/2021 16:58

There used to be a margarine factory just outside Liverpool. My ex used to say if you ever smelled the smell from that factory, you’d never eat it. It’s ‘natural’ colour is grey, it’s dyed yellow as no one would spread grey mush on their toast.

I went into my GP a few years ago about weight loss. They gave me a few printouts, one of which was on the ‘Mediterranean diet’, this one didn’t involve lots of fresh fish and veg but ‘starchy carbs’. Strange.