Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To intervene with someone's parenting skills?

107 replies

parentinghelp1 · 04/10/2021 22:44

Has anyone ever had a situation where they think someone close to them is failing as a parent?

Do you intervene when you feel the children are at risk of having poor outcomes when they're older (they aren't in danger but I feel they could have issues as adults)

I don't have kids so I know mentioning anything is going to lead to 'you don't know anything because you haven't got kids'

What do you do? Just let people carry on potentially hurting their children and them growing up hurt because of their childhood?

I'm no way is this a judgmental post - I am just worried for the children.

It makes me sad.

Also very scared of ruining relationships by intervening.

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 05/10/2021 08:13

[quote parentinghelp1]@YouMakeShitTea it definitely isn't a social services issue.

Doesn't mean it isn't an issue though I don't think it's that black and white [/quote]
How do you know it isn't a social services issue.
You've noticed it
You're concerned by it
Why wouldn't you report it???

What does have to be enough for them to intervene, to offer support and help?? A child being physically injured? How do you know that it hasn't already happened?

Call them and let the professionals do their job. The kids may thank you in later life for making that phone call.

Bellringer · 05/10/2021 07:50

Speak to school, this may be part of a pattern
Keep in touch with family, offer childcare, befriend

Muttly · 05/10/2021 07:49

It does sound like there is emotional and to a lesser extent physical abuse. I would very gently try to support the parent and children as best I can. In the main though there is almost nothing you can do because this will not meet the threshold for intervention. I would not say anything remotely critical to the parents, nothing after a criticism will be heard. So the support would have to come from a place of understanding.

I think that there is no way we can get through life without seeing many situations of less than ideal parenting. Even people who truly pour themselves into parenting make serious mistakes and carry through less than ideal stuff from their past.

Underamour · 05/10/2021 07:36

To turn this around:- you are a single parent living in overcrowded conditions. Your children always have to look perfect and get to school on time because single parents get judged and people call SS on them (a commonly held belief where I live). You’ve cleaned the house at 6am because the kids wrecked it again, ironed the uniforms and you need to get them to school before work even though you were up half the night with the baby. Little Jimmy doesn’t want to go so you go down to his level and tell him 3 to see his friends(a note of desperation in your voice). Little Jimmy’s wails grow louder and you think about getting into trouble for being late again. You can’t afford to
Lose this job because benefits barely even cover rent and food and the kids are growing so fast. You feel sick with stress. JIMMY GET THE FUCK OUT OF THE DOOR you shout because you don’t have the energy to ask politely. You pull on Jimmy’s arm a little too hard, finally get to school a minute late (ignoring the judging looks of the other parents) then run to work.

I am not this parent btw but I can see how hard it can be and how parents fall into doing this through stress and exhaustion. What a lot of parents actually need is a break. Also some positivity from friends and family because if you are listening to crying and arguing all day it drains you.

Practicebeingpatient · 05/10/2021 07:31

@parentinghelp1

Has anyone ever had a situation where they think someone close to them is failing as a parent?

Do you intervene when you feel the children are at risk of having poor outcomes when they're older (they aren't in danger but I feel they could have issues as adults)

I don't have kids so I know mentioning anything is going to lead to 'you don't know anything because you haven't got kids'

What do you do? Just let people carry on potentially hurting their children and them growing up hurt because of their childhood?

I'm no way is this a judgmental post - I am just worried for the children.

It makes me sad.

Also very scared of ruining relationships by intervening.

All children grow up to have issues as adults no matter how exemplary the parenting. I have yet to meet an issue free human.

If the children are being damaged by neglect or abuse you should report it. I agree that you should consider ringing the NSPCC to discuss this before making a decision. That way you can give examples without outing yourself or the family.

Goldbar · 05/10/2021 07:17

I presumed the "unnecessary physical force" was things like grabbing, dragging with one arm, picking up and generally manhandling when the child is misbehaving. All things which you might occasionally have to do with little children but it's very worrying if they're happening all the time. If it's more than this, imo it's probably abuse.

swanswallow · 05/10/2021 07:17

Just echoing what others have said, I would suggest phoning the NSPCC to discuss the situation in full to get advice anonymously.

rrhuth · 05/10/2021 07:10

@parentinghelp1

Ok an examples - constant shouting and I have seen physical situations, never an actual punch or slap but just unnecessary physical force.
I think you have to be clear about what is happening in your own mind, as what you describe could easily be abuse, and therefore need to be flagged.

There is shouting and there is shouting - the volume of the voice is less of a deal than what is said. Also what do you mean by unnecessary physical force? This sounds concerning.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 05/10/2021 07:06

@parentinghelp1 I have a friend who provides everything her children need materially but emotionally is a disaster. I've tried to intervene but it falls on deaf ears. Her children are crying out for her love and attention but she can't see it. I don't know where it will end but I can't see it ending well.

Goldbar · 05/10/2021 07:06

@SummerInSun is spot on, I think. People rarely set out to parent like this. Sounds like they're giving from an empty cup. However, regardless of the reason, bringing children up in a constant cycle of negativity, criticism and blame is emotional abuse. I've often thought myself that a large part of parenting is plastering on a smile, pretending some fake enthusiasm and giving them love and security even while everything else is going to shit around you. That's one of the most precious things you can give your kids but of course it requires you to have some emotional resources left yourself.

I once saw a parent behaving in this way in the playground with their little boy. Everything was his fault. The exasperation with him was palpable. The smallest misbehaviour was met not with a gentle reminder not to do it but being physically dragged away and told he would never have any friends. I found it very sad Sad.

Newusernamelalala · 05/10/2021 07:05

If someone is shouting, using force etc as a parent it sounds as if they’re angry generally, not just in the moment. Can you ask them if they are ok and or need some support? Ultimately If the parent is ok the child probably will be too. It sounds like the parent is very unhappy

lottiegarbanzo · 05/10/2021 07:03

Are you friends with the parents? Are you friends with, or in a position to befriend the children and be an 'unofficial aunty' character, a reliable adult outside the immediate family, in their lives?

Most people will benefit more from friendship than judgement.

Lostmarbles2021 · 05/10/2021 07:02

parentinghelp1

Ok an examples - constant shouting and I have seen physical situations, never an actual punch or slap but just unnecessary physical force.

OP it’s great that you are asking for thoughts about this and you care enough to do that.

What you’ve described here is likely to lead to psychological difficulties if it’s constant, however, even as a professional with many years experience I would be unsure with this whether to refer to SS. I’d certainly be finding out more and I’d certainly discuss the option of more support with the family and see if they would be willing to get support from SS (SS are there to support families to make helpful changes not to tell them off and children are only removed as a last resort). SS support a wide range of families including families that are loving but are just having a hard time parenting. The fear many people have is that children will be taken away but this is always a very last resort and there is usually a very long process of trying, and failing, to effect changes before that happens. There are also low level teams within SS that aren’t Child Protection teams but support services that offer some great help, like parenting groups.

This is a grey area in terms of whether I would HAVE to refer to SS so there is no wonder you are uncertain what to do for the best. Use of physical force is a tricky one. Picking up a screaming toddler under your arm to get them to the safety of a car seat is one thing, shoving a child in anger is another. But all parents can react in ways that are out of character and unhelpful to their child. No parent is perfect. There is nothing like having a child to find buttons that can be pushed that you never knew you had! But parents have a responsibility to work on this if it’s damaging to their child of course.

As a friend of the family you are in a difficult position. In your shoes I think I would call the NSPCC to anonymously (you don’t need to give your name or theirs) get advice. That way you can describe what is happening in more detail.

You can also be a huge protective factor for the DC by being someone who takes an interest in them, gets to know them, bigs them up, shows them that even though you don’t need to, you want to spend time with them and care about them. Just one person in a child’s life can make a big difference.

Good luck. It’s great you are thinking about this and not just accepting it without a further thought. Sorry you’ve been given a bit of a hard time here. Smile

Underamour · 05/10/2021 06:38

The way to do it is to befriend and offer help. Nobody is going to take criticism well, especially is they are super stressed, overcrowded, living in poverty or not getting enough sleep. So be cheerful, positive and praise the good. Offer tips without being condescending , send your kids to take their kids out to
Play keeping the kids busy and happy. If they refuse help, do not push it because you will alienate them.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 05/10/2021 06:37

Well you have to inform the authorities. You would be deemed complicit if you knew things were happening that harmed a child, did nothing but then blabbed about it all over social media - which is a public space.

If a child was being hurt there would be no question, the friendship with the parent is over.

Tianatiers · 05/10/2021 06:35

@SummerInSun

Do you have the sort of relationship with the children where you can be someone they go to for extra support/comfort/nurturing? Give them some of what they aren't getting from their parents?

Also, do you have any sense of why the parents are so stressed and shouty? That doesn't sound like a deliberate choice of parenting style, but rather people who are super stressed. Are they under financial pressure, in very stressful jobs or at risk of unemployment, for example? Do they just never get a break? Just wondering if you could identify the underlying cause and help with that?

I love this. One of the most beautiful pieces of advice I’ve ever seen on here.
ImustLearn2Cook · 05/10/2021 06:19

Agree with LovinThisStuff and BrainPotter too Smile

marykitty · 05/10/2021 06:19

I think you need to consider the specific circumstances.

What do you mean with shouting?
The mother going outside on the terrace and shouting to the boy in the garden "I TOLD YOU TO LEAVE THE TREE ALONE, 1000 TIMES!!! STOP IT!!!"
Or is it them shouting nasty things to them undermining their confidence?

What do you mean with unnecessary force?
Is the mother wrestling the toddler while changing the nappy or holding him strongly by the hand to avoid him running across a busy street?
Or something more serious?

ImustLearn2Cook · 05/10/2021 06:17

The Burnout We Can't Talk About: Parent Burnout
New research demonstrates parental burnout has serious consequences.

www.google.com.au/amp/s/www.psychologytoday.com/au/blog/targeted-parenting/201909/the-burnout-we-cant-talk-about-parent-burnout%3famp

Self-Care IS Child Care:
So many times, when I’m teaching parenting classes, I ask the participants what their self-care was that week. I get responses like this:
Self-care? Who has time for that? I am so consumed dealing with my son. Besides, he needs so much. How can I justify taking time away from something he needs, just to pursue something I like?

Based on this research, I ask parents how often they have escape fantasies, and all agree that they fantasize about their parenting load being lightened. Because this is an interactive class, we’ve already all spoken about the times that stress has led to less-than-optimal parenting strategies, like yelling, or a harsh consequence.

@parentinghelp1 The above is copy and pasted from above link. Before I became a parent I had underestimated just how hard it can be especially when there are additional stressors or lack of support. I previously had a lot of experience with children and families and thought I knew what it would be like to a parent. Then I became one. 🤣

Family and the bonds we have to one another are sacred. No two families are the same. People outside of the immediate family are not going to fully understand or appreciate the family dynamics.

If these parents love their kids then be a supportive friend and help them out. And I suggest practical support. Babysit, cook them a nice meal so they can have a night off, invite mum to a spa day, lend a listening ear where you just listen and empathise and refrain from trying to solve their problems. Sometimes it’s nice just to be heard and understood.

Also, notice all the good stuff your friends do as parents and acknowledge it. Positive feedback builds people up. This works for the kids as well. Acknowledge the kids when they make an effort or do something well.

BrainPotter · 05/10/2021 06:03

You are kind OP to worry about a little one. I will say, I was an excellent parent…before I had kids!! Now my advice would be that unless it is abuse (physical or mental) don’t say anything BUT you can lead by example. Behave with this child appropriately and hopefully their parent will follow suit.

LovinThisStuff · 05/10/2021 05:56

If he / she is a friend then perhaps arrange a drink with them, away from the children? You could just 'check-in' to find out they are, how they are doing? Do not mention the children at all.

Parenting is VERY, very challenging at times. Some people struggle more than others. Your friend may be depressed; may be struggling with the constant demands that having children brings; with having lost her 'freedom' of life before.
With respect, unless you've been through it yourself you wouldn't appreciate anything that they are going through.

Never, never criticise. The friend will simple shut-down and that will be that.

Perhaps you could offer to help? to babysit etc. Go for walks with her and the children? Perhaps she's just missing adult company and conversation?

ImustLearn2Cook · 05/10/2021 05:48

SummerInSun

Do you have the sort of relationship with the children where you can be someone they go to for extra support/comfort/nurturing? Give them some of what they aren't getting from their parents?

Also, do you have any sense of why the parents are so stressed and shouty? That doesn't sound like a deliberate choice of parenting style, but rather people who are super stressed. Are they under financial pressure, in very stressful jobs or at risk of unemployment, for example? Do they just never get a break? Just wondering if you could identify the underlying cause and help with that?

@parentinghelp1 I agree with SummerInSun.

SaltySheepdog · 05/10/2021 05:45

Babysit and have fun with the kids. It will also enable you to keep a close eye on the kids welfare and get help if needed.

You can confidentially ring the nspcc and get their advice. They know legislation, processes and can advise on how to help. They will have a good grasp of when action needs to be taken

onelittlefrog · 05/10/2021 05:40

NSPCC advice line - 0808 800 5000

SaltySheepdog · 05/10/2021 05:39

Can you offer to take the kids for a while each week? Give the parents some respite and have some.

You could also anonymously put some parenting books through their door.