Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have wanted DS to have his birthday present on his actual birthday and not 2 months early

56 replies

couchparsnip · 04/10/2021 22:29

I think DH IBU but he thinks I am. I need other opinions please as I'm stewing about this.

DS will be 16 in December so we agreed with him that he could have a PC for a joint birthday/Christmas present and that it would go in his bedroom. DH agreed to put his bonus payment (which comes in his Sept pay) towards the PC. We share finances but I tend to do the banking admin. Which makes me think I might BU as maybe I am controlling things too much.

Anyway, Last weekend we moved a desk into DS's room and set his X Box up on there. This will be for the PC so he can do homework up there and chat to his friends.

DH has now taken the fact that his bonus has arrived and the desk is in place to mean he had to buy the PC and tell DS he can have it straight away.
I would have rather waited until the actual day as now DS's 16th birthday will be less special. He won't have a 'big' present.
Is it normal to give presents 2 months early? I didn’t think so.
We'll probably still buy DS some chocolate and a computer game for his birthday but I'm disappointed.

DS is obviously happy now but what about when his birthday and Christmas arrive and he doesn't get very much

We decided to move the desk because we were decorating the room it was in and thought we might as well move it now so it would be out of the way.

DH and I have disagreed about it and I'm not sure who is right? He thought we moved the desk so that the PC could go on it straight away and that was obvious. I thought it was obvious that people's birthday presents were generally given on their birthday- or at least near it.

DH told DS he was buying it then DS asked if he the plans were that he would get it as soon as it arrived or have to wait. DH said 'You'll have to ask your mother, but as far as I concerned you can have it now'. This is what annoyed me the most. He made the decision and backed me into a corner. I couldn't then be the mean mother who doesn't allow DS his PC.
So in a nutshell I'm annoyed because DH bought the PC too early for the birthday and then unilaterally decided to give it to DS 2 months before his birthday.
He says why wait and the desk is there so let him have it now.
Who is BU

OP posts:
Sn0tnose · 04/10/2021 22:42

I do think you need to talk to your DH about discussing things like this with you before he discusses it with anyone else though.

Hercisback · 04/10/2021 22:41

Why deny your son the joy of 2 extra months of his PC because of an arbitrary day?

My mum paid for a big Christmas present for me last week. It gets delivered next week and I will have used it loads before Christmas.

Hankunamatata · 04/10/2021 22:41

I'm with your dh. You have the money, why wouldn't you buy it now so ds can use it for school work and talking to his friends. He is 16 not 6 surely he will be happy with couple small things to open on actual birthday

Sn0tnose · 04/10/2021 22:37

I do see why you’re annoyed, but if it’s for homework, then he may as well get the benefit of it now. If it had been bought now but hidden away, you wouldn’t have known if it was faulty until it was too late to return it and come December, everyone will be after decent PCs for presents. I think there’s a shortage of chips somewhere too.

He’s 16, so old enough to understand that he’s had his big present. Just remind him closer to the time so he doesn’t get any expectations.

FWBNC · 04/10/2021 22:36

I would be very annoyed too!

I would discuss it with DH for a start, and I'd consider it for a present that was somewhat seasonal or a concert etc, but not for something you can buy at anytime.

But my main issue here would be with DH saying he could have it now, unless you say otherwise. If DS doesn't see you as a united front, it's going to make his late 'teens' much harder to navigate.

Chickychoccyegg · 04/10/2021 22:36

When asked you should have said no, you'll get it on your birthday, I'd have no problem being " bad mother" though, dh was silly buyinh it and giving ds it far too early