Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

cycle helmets

141 replies

Orangejuicemarathoner · 04/10/2021 21:28

I can't bear to see my nephew set off for school by bike in busy traffic, and poor visibility without a cycle helmet. I can't understand his parents allowing this. I know it's none of my business and there is nothing I can do, but I really wish this wasn't allowed

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 21:27

@lljkk

ooh, glad you found UK deaths. I gave a link for NL deaths already.

Netherlanders cycled 15 bln km . 3x as much as UK populace.

Cycling Uk says 3.45 billion miles cycled in Uk in 2019, so 5.55 bln km.

I think that means divide that 6.4x estimate by 3 to compare relative risk per km cycled -- still 2.13x as much in NL, tbf.

People on mopeds in NL don't wear helmets. Cycling is the least of their risk tolerance...

Thanks, so if reading it right, a NL cyclist is twice as likely (2.13x) as a U.K. cyclist to be killed when calculated on a per/km cycled basis.
PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 21:21

Active travel plummets when helmets are made compulsory.

Well, not really. Australian activists claimed the compulsory helmet laws would do this but years later, studied and zero evidence....authors of this paper also looked at US and Canada helmet law impact too...no evidence there either.
:
From
The impact of bicycle helmet legislation on cycling fatalities in Australia . International Journal of Epidemiology, Volume 48, Issue 4, August 2019, Pages 1197–1203, doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyz003

“Conclusions
In the absence of robust evidence showing a decline in cycling exposure following helmet legislation or other confounding factors, the reduction in Australian bicycle-related fatality appears to be primarily due to increased helmet use and not other factors.”

“Some authors argue that bicycle helmet legislation deters cycling and that reductions in cycling head injury are due to fewer cyclists and not to the effectiveness of helmets to mitigate head injury. A US study estimated a slight reduction of 3–5% in children cycling, however, several international studies have found that helmet legislation is not a major barrier to cycling uptake, and another found mixed results of small magnitude for US children. Furthermore, to overcome the lack of robust exposure data, previous studies have compared head injuries with other cyclist injuries, e.g. arm and leg injuries.8–11,27 Trends in other injuries from these studies are inconsistent with reductions in cycling.” (Studies references are listed below)

Carpenter CS, Stehr M. Intended and unintended consequences of youth bicycle helmet laws. J Law Econ 2011;54:305–24.

Macpherson A, Parkin P, To T. Mandatory helmet legislation and children’s exposure to cycling. Inj Prev 2001;7:228–30.

Dennis J, Potter B, Ramsay T, Zarychanksi R. The effects of provincial bicycle helmet legislation on helmet use and bicycle ridership in Canada. Inj Prev 2010;16:219–24.

Olivier J, Boufous S, Grzebieta RH. No strong evidence bicycle helmet legislation deters cycling. Med J Aust 2016;205:54–55.

Carpenter CS, Warman C. Do ‘all-age’ bicycle helmets work? Evidence from Canada. NBER Working paper 24644. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research, 2018.

Radun I, Olivier J. Bicycle helmet law does not deter cyclists in Finland. Transp Res F 2018;58:1087–90.

Huybers S, Fenerty L, Kureshi Net al. . Long-term effects of education and legislation enforcement on all-age bicycle helmet use: a longitudinal study. J Community Health 2017;42:83–89.

Kraemer JD. Helmet laws, helmet use, and bicycle ridership. J Adolesc Health 2016;59:338–44.

RunningFromInsanity · 05/10/2021 21:18

Honestly what chance do you have convincing a child when there are grown women on here who don’t think wearing a helmet is safer Hmm Crazy.

lljkk · 05/10/2021 21:15

ooh, glad you found UK deaths.
I gave a link for NL deaths already.

Netherlanders cycled 15 bln km . 3x as much as UK populace.

Cycling Uk says 3.45 billion miles cycled in Uk in 2019, so 5.55 bln km.

I think that means divide that 6.4x estimate by 3 to compare relative risk per km cycled -- still 2.13x as much in NL, tbf.

People on mopeds in NL don't wear helmets. Cycling is the least of their risk tolerance...

PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 20:57

@lljkk

Well let’s compare apples to apples. Same year. Number of deaths. Per capita.

NL 2020 cyclist fatalities were 229 (take your word for it)

U.K. 2020 cyclist fatalities were 140 (40% higher than 5yr avg. 100)

Per capita of 1m cyclist mortality rate
NL 13.47

U.K. 2.09

So, no UKs cycling mortality rate is actually 6.4x lower than the NL’s cycling mortality rate. As you say, helmet wearing is “very low” in NLs. Perhaps it is a factor for their much higher cycle deaths per capita?

U.K. numbers from
www.statista.com/statistics/866642/road-fatalities-cyclists-great-britain/

lljkk · 05/10/2021 20:19

By nature of injury, hospital admissions stats will only be about the severe injuries that need treatment.

The time I bruised my rib or got road rash -- won't be counted. A lot of minor bike crashes won't be there.

Active travel plummets when helmets are made compulsory. i don't want helmets compulsory.

U.K. numbers In 2019, 16,884 cyclists were injured in reported road accidents, including 4,433 who were killed or seriously injured.

Netherlands numbers: 2020 saw the highest number of cycling casualties in the last 25 years with 229 deaths reported.

population UK = 67 million
population NL = 17 million

Total annual cycling km in NL is probably literally >> 10x higher than UK, and that's with a population that is 30% of UK. But their cycling mortality/accident rate is hugely smaller. Now why is that? It sure isn't because of cycle helmet use which is very low in NL. Let me think, what could it be....

cycle helmets
Orangejuicemarathoner · 05/10/2021 20:16

thank you @PlanDeRaccordement

I am going to show your post to my sister and BIL

OP posts:
Psychonabike · 05/10/2021 20:04

@Nomoreusernames1244

Apologies, I misread your post.

PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 17:43

@Macncheeseballs

Of course bicycle helmets are effective at preventing head injury during head impact, , but how many bike accidents involve head impact, and how many cyclists have bike accidents, surely its up to the rider to make their own risk assessment
U.K. numbers.

“In 2019, 16,884 cyclists were injured in reported road accidents, including 4,433 who were killed or seriously injured.”

“Some of the shortcomings in STATS 19 data, such as serious injuries caused by non-collision accidents, are overcome using hospital admission statistics. These statistics show that cyclists suffered a greater number of serious injuries than other road users in 2016/2017, accounting for 16,780 hospital admissions. Second in number were car occupants”

“Per billion vehicle miles, the casualty rate of pedal cyclists that are killed or seriously injured is 1,284, compared to a rate of 31 for car drivers”

“Head injuries, ranging from fatal skull fractures and brain damage to minor concussion and cuts, are very common injuries to cyclists. Hospital data shows that over 40% of cyclists, and 45% of child cyclists, suffer head injuries. A study of 116 fatal cyclist accidents in London and rural areas found over 70% of the cyclist fatalities in London had moderate or serious head injuries in London, and over 80% of those killed in collisions on rural roads.”

www.rospa.com/media/documents/road-safety/cycling-accidents-factsheet.pdf

PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 17:35

Most helmets are complete rubbish and there is evidence that they can cause additional neck trauma.

Nope, been studied no evidence, see my post above.

poohaloo · 05/10/2021 17:35

Buy him a cool scooter helmet.. skater boy Style?

www.skatehut.co.uk/protection/helmets/skatehut-pro-helmet-matt-black-red.htm

Macncheeseballs · 05/10/2021 17:34

Of course bicycle helmets are effective at preventing head injury during head impact, , but how many bike accidents involve head impact, and how many cyclists have bike accidents, surely its up to the rider to make their own risk assessment

PlanDeRaccordement · 05/10/2021 17:30

Most people don't wear helmets correctly and they don't work at impacts of over about 12mph. They are worn to make drivers feel better, not to make the cyclists safer.

This is misleading rubbish that has been repeatedly debunked by scientific studies. Here are a few...

The effectiveness of helmets in bicycle collisions with motor vehicles: a case-control study. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23377086/
“There were 6745 cyclist collisions with motor vehicles where helmet use was known. Helmet use was associated with reduced risk of head injury in bicycle collisions with motor vehicles of up to 74%, and the more severe the injury considered, the greater the reduction. This was also found to be true for particular head injuries such as skull fractures, intracranial injury and open head wounds. Around one half of children and adolescents less than 19 years were not wearing a helmet, an issue that needs to be addressed in light of the demonstrated effectiveness of helmets. Non-helmeted cyclists were more likely to display risky riding behaviour, however, were less likely to cycle in risky areas; the net result of which was that they were more likely to be involved in more severe crashes.”

Bicycle helmets are highly effective at preventing head injury during head impact: head-form accelerations and injury criteria for helmeted and unhelmeted impacts. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24686160/
“In this research, our objective was to perform biomechanical testing of paired helmeted and unhelmeted head impacts using a validated anthropomorphic test headform and a range of drop heights between 0.5m and 3.0m, while measuring headform acceleration and Head Injury Criterion (HIC). In the 2m (6.3m/s) drops, the middle of our drop height range, the helmet reduced peak accelerations from 824g (unhelmeted) to 181g (helmeted) and HIC was reduced from 9667 (unhelmeted) to 1250 (helmeted). At realistic impact speeds of 5.4m/s (1.5m drop) and 6.3m/s (2.0m drop), bicycle helmets changed the probability of severe brain injury from extremely likely (99.9% risk at both 5.4 and 6.3m/s) to unlikely (9.3% and 30.6% risk at 1.5m and 2.0m drops respectively). These biomechanical results for acceleration and HIC, and the corresponding results for reduced risk of severe brain injury show that contemporary bicycle helmets are highly effective at reducing head injury metrics and the risk for severe brain injury in head impacts characteristic of bicycle crashes.”

Bicycle injuries and helmet use: a systematic review and meta-analysis
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27450862/
“Results: A total of 43 studies met inclusion criteria and 40 studies were included in the meta-analysis with data from over 64 000 injured cyclists. For cyclists involved in a crash or fall, helmet use was associated with odds reductions for head (OR = 0.49, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.42-0.57), serious head (OR = 0.31, 95% CI: 0.25-0.37), face (OR = 0.67, 95% CI: 0.56-0.81) and fatal head injury (OR = 0.35, 95% CI: 0.14-0.88). No clear evidence of an association between helmet use and neck injury was found (OR = 0.96, 95% CI: 0.74-1.25). There was no evidence of time trends or publication bias.

Conclusions: Bicycle helmet use was associated with reduced odds of head injury, serious head injury, facial injury and fatal head injury. The reduction was greater for serious or fatal head injury. Neck injury was rare and not associated with helmet use. These results support the use of strategies to increase the uptake of bicycle helmets as part of a comprehensive cycling safety plan”

Bicycle helmets - To wear or not to wear? A meta-analyses of the effects of bicycle helmets on injuries. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29677686/
“A meta-analysis has been conducted of the effects of bicycle helmets on serious head injury and other injuries among crash involved cyclists. 179 effect estimates from 55 studies from 1989-2017 are included in the meta-analysis. The use of bicycle helmets was found to reduce head injury by 48%, serious head injury by 60%, traumatic brain injury by 53%, face injury by 23%, and the total number of killed or seriously injured cyclists by 34%. Bicycle helmets were not found to have any statistically significant effect on cervical spine injury. There is no indication that the results from bicycle helmet studies are affected by a lack of control for confounding variables, time trend bias or publication bias. The results do not indicate that bicycle helmet effects are different between adult cyclists and children.”

Macncheeseballs · 05/10/2021 17:28

Ladyg, but the chances of that happening are fairly low to be honest

Nomoreusernames1244 · 05/10/2021 17:19

@Psychonabike *The "whiplash" forces you describe (you mean the effects of inertia really) that cause brain injury have been taking into account in new bike helmets that offer MIPS, or have crumple zones/linings which slow the skull more gradually.

You are making a really out dated argument here*

Outdated argument for what? My argument was serious head injuries at speed in vehicles (mostly whiplash) are different to serious head injuries on bicycle (impact and some whiplash), so you can’t compare the statistics and argue that more head injuries occur in vehicles yet helmets aren’t used when travelling in a car.

Which is the point a pp was trying to make.

It is good news that helmet technology has improved to cater for whiplash injuries, but I wasn’t arguing against cycle helmets Confused. Still doubt helmets would protect against the type of head injury you get in vehicle accidents but happy to be proved wrong.

And yes, i do know that I mean the forces of inertia “really” Hmm

LadyGAgain · 05/10/2021 17:03

@BakingOfTheFoodCats

How Old is he? Most teens would be too embarrassed to wear one
More embarrassing to have your brain splatted on the road though isn't it.
LadyGAgain · 05/10/2021 17:03

@SnackSizeRaisin

Yabu. Cycle helmets are no use against being hit by a car. They are a thin bit of polystyrene tested with a 12 kg weight, cars weigh hundreds of kilos. Why do people think cycle helmets are some kind of magic forcefield to stop all accidents Anyway cycling is an inherently safe activity. He's much better off cycling than sitting in a car , both mentally and physically.
What a totally stupid comment. Helmets can make the difference between a fatal or permanent brain injury and not. I'd worry too OP.
Psychonabike · 05/10/2021 16:56

@Nomoreusernames1244

The "whiplash" forces you describe (you mean the effects of inertia really) that cause brain injury have been taking into account in new bike helmets that offer MIPS, or have crumple zones/linings which slow the skull more gradually.

You are making a really out dated argument here.

Macncheeseballs · 05/10/2021 08:28

Nomoreusername, is this any better? www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2214140518302731

Nomoreusernames1244 · 05/10/2021 08:17

Nomoreusernames, the UK is also mentioned in that study

You didn’t link to a study, it’s a 2012 australia bloggers opinion piece.

None of the links work any more. I did try the link to supposed uk stats- but the link is broken and the address is another blog, not a study.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 05/10/2021 08:17

And the only time I've hit my head was when I stepped on some ice and slipped over. I had mild concussion. Yet nobody goes on about pedestrians needing helmets.

However cyclists AND pedestrians should definitely wear hi-vis. And no, it's not my fault, and I don't need to stop driving, if I can't see you easily without. Sometimes I only spot a cyclist all in black and with no lights because something on the bike glints. Get lights and wear hi-vis. And that goes for pedestrians too. Get bright coloured coats for winter, not black.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 05/10/2021 08:14

[quote gogohm]@SnackSizeRaisin

Rubbish! At slow speeds in town, wearing a helmet can save lives and perhaps more importantly reduce brain injuries. Tour de France riders all wear helmets for a reason, and they go far faster! My brothers helmet cracked in two when he was knocked off by a van - ambulance said if he hadn't have been wearing it the outcome could have been so different. [/quote]
They wear them because their insurance requires it, that's all.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 05/10/2021 08:13

@SnackSizeRaisin

Yabu. Cycle helmets are no use against being hit by a car. They are a thin bit of polystyrene tested with a 12 kg weight, cars weigh hundreds of kilos. Why do people think cycle helmets are some kind of magic forcefield to stop all accidents Anyway cycling is an inherently safe activity. He's much better off cycling than sitting in a car , both mentally and physically.
This.

Most people don't wear helmets correctly and they don't work at impacts of over about 12mph. They are worn to make drivers feel better, not to make the cyclists safer.

There will always be people who say they would have died if they had not been wearing a helmet but they don't actually know that as the helmet is much bigger than their head and the impact would be different.

I would wear one doing mountain biking because it's not great to hit a tree with your head. But the only reason I wear one on the roads is to be socially acceptable, not because it would help in any way if a driver squashed me.

Macncheeseballs · 05/10/2021 08:09

Of course cycling has its dangers but so do so many other things, I don't get why people obsess over the risks other people take with their body if its no risk to others, do you get upset seeing people smoking?

Macncheeseballs · 05/10/2021 08:07

Nomoreusernames, the UK is also mentioned in that study