Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

cycle helmets

141 replies

Orangejuicemarathoner · 04/10/2021 21:28

I can't bear to see my nephew set off for school by bike in busy traffic, and poor visibility without a cycle helmet. I can't understand his parents allowing this. I know it's none of my business and there is nothing I can do, but I really wish this wasn't allowed

OP posts:
DecadentlyDecisive · 06/10/2021 21:16

Source saying that helmet wearing causes worse injuries than not wearing one?

I didn't say that, I said that in some cases the helmet has made injuries worse.

Plenty out there to read for those of us that can use Google and who like to make an informed decision.

Cycle helmets and rotational injuries

Effects of bicycle helmet wearing on accident and injury rates

Cycle Helmets - do they really save lives?

Etc...

NumberTheory · 06/10/2021 20:48

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

"They create a false sense of security for both drivers and cyclists alike..."

Where are people getting this stuff from? When there are proper statisticians who study the effects of helmets. How would someone measure a sense of security? How would you prove it was false given actual studies have proved it is safer? Has anyone ever heard of an average run of the mill road cyclist saying they are going to weave between a bit more traffic because they remembered their helmet today?

Yet again people think a video they have seen on Facebook should have as much weight as a proper peer reviewed statistical analysis of data

People get this stuff from proper statisticians and researchers. And they don't ask cyclists "Will you weave a bit more if you wear a helmet?", or motorists "Do you care less about cyclists in helmets?" they observe what motorists and cyclists actually do.

e.g.
Study showing motorists give less room to cyclists with helmets.

Study showing cyclists prepared to take more risks (in a lab experiment) when wearing helmets

There's still plenty of room for error, since these aren't the most robust studies and there appears to be neither the budget nor the ethical framework to do really robust ones, and since these are single studies and good science design requires a bit more than that. They are just here to show that people aren't just making this stuff up because they don't want to wear a helmet. They get it from reading research.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 06/10/2021 20:35

"They create a false sense of security for both drivers and cyclists alike..."

Where are people getting this stuff from? When there are proper statisticians who study the effects of helmets. How would someone measure a sense of security? How would you prove it was false given actual studies have proved it is safer? Has anyone ever heard of an average run of the mill road cyclist saying they are going to weave between a bit more traffic because they remembered their helmet today?

Yet again people think a video they have seen on Facebook should have as much weight as a proper peer reviewed statistical analysis of data

NumberTheory · 06/10/2021 18:57

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@lljkk
I found the 2020 bn miles for pedal cycles in 2020. It was 5 bvm, so 8 bn km!!! (This is fun)
assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/981967/road-traffic-estimates-in-great-britain-2020.pdf

So that changes things a bit. NLs did almost 2x as many km as U.K. so we divide the 6.4 by 2 instead of 3 and NL cyclist 3x more likely to die than U.K. cyclist.[/quote]
If I've read these posts right, between the two of you the maths seems to have got screwed up somewhere.

There were 229 deaths in NL for 15 bn km cycled

And 140 deaths in UK for 8 bn km cycled

In NL that's one death for every 65.5 million km cycled (15bn/229).
And in the UK one death for every 57.1 million km cycled (8bn/140).

So not much difference but NL coming out slightly better.

PlanDeRaccordement · 06/10/2021 14:31

Oops forgot attachment. They are 2019 numbers.

cycle helmets
PlanDeRaccordement · 06/10/2021 14:30

@Nonamesleftt

Pedestrians account for most fatalities per mile travelled.
No, they are third behind cyclists and motor cyclists (see attached)

So why not make everyone wear a helmet?
I think it’s because pedestrians are not sharing the road with motor vehicles like cyclists are. Pedestrians are commonly hit while crossing a road, so safety measures should focus more on low speed limits, safe road crossings, and separation of foot paths from roads.

After all the study you linked to recommended the following
“The findings of high injury risks suggested that in the area with high frequency car-pedestrian accidents, the vehicle speed limit should be 40 km/h, while in the area with high frequency car-cyclist accidents the vehicle speed limit should be 50 km/h.”

Nonamesleftt · 06/10/2021 13:50

I understand why people are calling on cyclists to wear helmets, but I don't understand why they only call on cyclists to wear helmets. Car occupants account for most UK road fatalities. Pedestrians account for most fatalities per mile travelled.

Comparing head injury data for pedestrians and cyclists involved in car collisions, pedestrians were found to have (on average) more severe head injuries than cyclists: doi.org/10.1016/j.ssci.2012.03.005

So why not make everyone wear a helmet?

PlanDeRaccordement · 06/10/2021 13:45

has been proven that drivers act more dangerously around people with helmets on (although they'll happily yell at people not wearing one).

Snort. No it hasn’t been proven not by a long shot and please don’t link me to that study of 1 cyclist on his bike estimating close passes when he was wearing a helmet vs when he wasn’t. A sample size of 1 is an anecdote, insufficient to prove anything.

PlanDeRaccordement · 06/10/2021 13:43

@lockdownmadnessdotcom
Yes the science and statistics DO show that cycle helmets saves lives and reduce serious head injuries. They also DO NOT reduce number of cyclists. Look at the references I provided.

Cycling U.K. is not a source I would trust. Even their evidence brief is a litany of denying the evidence they make silly speculations like “injuries went down but that’s because probably fewer cyclists on the road” they are convinced by outdated research that helmet laws result in excess deaths due to physical inactivity...which they estimated themselves...and they’re not scientists by any stretch of the imagination. They totally ignore later research which shows no reduction in cycling after compulsory helmet laws are passed.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 06/10/2021 13:30

@RunningFromInsanity

Honestly what chance do you have convincing a child when there are grown women on here who don’t think wearing a helmet is safer Hmm Crazy.
Because they are not! They are not worn properly and people keep them far too long after the materials in them have perished. They create a false sense of security for both drivers and cyclists alike and it has been proven that drivers act more dangerously around people with helmets on (although they'll happily yell at people not wearing one).

I would suggest that people look at their driving before they moan about people not wearing helmets to ride bikes.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 06/10/2021 13:27

[quote Nottheduchess]@Macncheeseballs I think the anger is because all the stats and science is there to show how important helmets are in regards to saving lives and preventing serious head injuries yet some people are still arguing against them and coming up with a load of shite to back up their opinions.[/quote]
But all the stats and science don't show that at all. Cycling UK (which you'd assume are bigger experts on this than you or I) consistently say that helmets should not be compulsory.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 06/10/2021 13:26

@Macncheeseballs

Separate cycle lanes are by far the greatest life saving thing you can give a cyclist
Yes.
AnnieSnap · 06/10/2021 13:14

@Pemmican

I am going to have to live with this awful dread about it for the next 6 school years Hmm

Your nephew will be fine. You need to butt out and find something else to worry about. Ideally something that actually is your business.

This is unnecessarily rude and offensive. She is worrying about a loved family member! What is wrong with you? 🤷‍♀️
Nomoreusernames1244 · 06/10/2021 13:11

If a truck clips the back of your head with its wing mirror you're fucked, helmet or no helmet. Arguably you're better off being killed outright than having to live in a PVS.

I got hit by a car. Went over the bonnet, landed on my head which rebounded and then on my back.

2 vertebrae fractured, split and bashed helmet, sore neck, but head intact and no significant brain injury.

A friend at school fell off his bike playing. No helmet, severe head injury and he died a week later. That’s why I was wearing a helmet. We all did after that.

PlanDeRaccordement · 06/10/2021 12:16

@HarrietsChariot

Helmets help in minor incidents but don't do much for higher speed accidents. The test is do they protect the user from serious injury if they fall off a stationary bike and hit their head on the ground.

If a truck clips the back of your head with its wing mirror you're fucked, helmet or no helmet. Arguably you're better off being killed outright than having to live in a PVS.

If you want proper protection you need a motorcyle helmet, open face is ok as long as your chin is covered.

That may be how they test helmets, I don’t honestly know, but it is not true that helmets do nothing in collisions with motor vehicles, ie the mirror on a vehicle clipping your head example you have given.

The effectiveness of helmets in bicycle collisions with motor vehicles: a case-control study. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23377086/
“There were 6745 cyclist collisions with motor vehicles where helmet use was known. Helmet use was associated with reduced risk of head injury in bicycle collisions with motor vehicles of up to 74%, and the more severe the injury considered, the greater the reduction. This was also found to be true for particular head injuries such as skull fractures, intracranial injury and open head wounds. Around one half of children and adolescents less than 19 years were not wearing a helmet, an issue that needs to be addressed in light of the demonstrated effectiveness of helmets. Non-helmeted cyclists were more likely to display risky riding behaviour, however, were less likely to cycle in risky areas; the net result of which was that they were more likely to be involved in more severe crashes.”

kowari · 06/10/2021 12:11

@SnackSizeRaisin

Yabu. Cycle helmets are no use against being hit by a car. They are a thin bit of polystyrene tested with a 12 kg weight, cars weigh hundreds of kilos. Why do people think cycle helmets are some kind of magic forcefield to stop all accidents Anyway cycling is an inherently safe activity. He's much better off cycling than sitting in a car , both mentally and physically.
My grandfather likely would have survived if he was wearing a helmet. He was knocked off his bike and hit his head.
HarrietsChariot · 06/10/2021 12:11

Helmets help in minor incidents but don't do much for higher speed accidents. The test is do they protect the user from serious injury if they fall off a stationary bike and hit their head on the ground.

If a truck clips the back of your head with its wing mirror you're fucked, helmet or no helmet. Arguably you're better off being killed outright than having to live in a PVS.

If you want proper protection you need a motorcyle helmet, open face is ok as long as your chin is covered.

PlanDeRaccordement · 06/10/2021 12:08

@bonbonours

I believe they should be compulsory for all cyclists which would maybe help with the embarrassment factor.

I think part of the fault lies with adults who don't wear them (sometimes while cycling with kids who are wearing them). This implies the kids need to wear them due to not being as proficient at cycling. Therefore teenagers, who think (probably correctly) they are just as good at it as an adult, are offended at the idea of wearing one. In fact anyone, no matter how proficient can be knocked off by bad car driving or a person opening a car door into them.

You don't decide whether to wear a seatbelt based on how good a driver you think you are. A helmet won't prevent all injury but it could save your life or make the difference between severe and slight injury.

Agree completely. We always wore helmets when cycling with our children. On road or on cycle paths. No helmet, no cycling. My youngest is 17 and eldest is 24....and yes they have never stopped wearing helmets. I truly believe it is because we modelled helmet wearing as adults that it was normalised for them.
NewLifePending · 06/10/2021 12:07

My sons helmet saved his face a few weeks back. He went over the handlebars and landed straight down on his face. The front of his helmet hit the ground and cracked and his only injuries were a grazed his chin and a bit of a fat lip. It would have been a lot worse without his helmet

PlanDeRaccordement · 06/10/2021 12:03

@Macncheeseballs

Planderacordment, why does it make you so angry though? surely it's individual choice to make one's own risk assessment. Do you get as angry with smokers?
It makes me angry that you are saying patently untrue false things to give the impression that a child is safer not wearing a helmet. You admit that smoking, drinking is unsafe, but you’re literally saying falsehoods about bicycle helmets to score points on an Internet forum- you are forgetting a living breathing 12yr olds safety is at the heart of this.
HuhWhatNow · 06/10/2021 08:32

I watched my son come of his bike going down our road. Every millisecond of it has been burned into my memory like I watched it in slow motion. He hit the road and his body bounced, slamming his head. As he rolled, his head slammed into the road two more times. He was wearing a helmet and the only damage to his head was lost skin on his chin.
He lost so much skin (on his covered body) that we had to put him in a bath to clean the wounds rather than tackling each one. Thankfully none were too deep and it wasn't an A&E trip. Not one part of his body escaped some damage.

I absolutely know that the now smashed helmet saved his life.

OP, YANBU but this is an argument most won't win. My kids have never been allowed on bikes without a helmet so it's a given that they will continue. However, a kid who hasn't been made to will probably not change their mind and start to do so.

Swimmingwiththefishes · 06/10/2021 08:29

Oh god, there are some proper twats on this thread and things like this make me so angry

My sister was in a low speed collision with a car on her bike early last year

18 months later she has had to learn to walk and talk again. Her short term memory is terrible and each time I bring my son to see her I have to reintroduce them as he was born after her accident so she doesn't remember him.

The car had a minor bump and my sister suffered a broken arm too. But she wasn't wearing a helmet and hit her head on the kerb. I have absolutely no doubt that if she was wearing a helmet she would have had concussion and a short hospital stay.

OP YANBU and I wish it was something more people did

Nomoreusernames1244 · 06/10/2021 07:35

Bonbon, the more people cycling, the safer it is for cyclists. Compulsory helmet use lessens the amount of people cycling, so perhaps it cancels out

Someone has posted stats upthread that shows this hasn’t happened in countries where compulsory helmets have been introduced. Injuries are reduced, but don’t correlate with reduced numbers of cyclists.

So why do you still think compulsory helmets will reduce cycling?

Crabapple04 · 06/10/2021 07:34

How about a skater style one, my term wears one - might that be a bit "cooler"?

bonbonours · 06/10/2021 07:32

@LadyGAgain.
I wish I'd saved a photo I saw of a teen with severe permanent brain injury following a bike accident with no helmet, who now has special needs and has to be tube fed. It had a caption something to do with "embarrassed to wear a helmet, wouldn't you be more embarrassed to look like me?"