Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a junior doctor in a&e

40 replies

User6777000 · 04/10/2021 21:09

One that’s just left university

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
applespearsbears · 06/10/2021 19:04

@HandforthParishCouncilClerk

No, many GPs are equivalent to a registrar, at least initially. As a GP trainee you still have to do your initial training on ward rotation, as all other JDs do.

Most junior doctors have years of experience and are very qualified.

Just avoid hospital on the first Weds in August!

Smile
olympicsrock · 06/10/2021 18:12

I’m 43 and qualified 17 years ago, about to become a consultant, on the specialist register , do big operations on my own. I am still a junior doctor Smile. It is a very broad term.

Both consultants and GPs are fully trained professionals. A GP is a generalist and consultants are specialists. We respect each other’s skills. Consultants generally have much longer training....

theDudesmummy · 06/10/2021 18:06

I was a junior doctor for thirteen years. The term covers a lot of different people at different stages and doing different things.

sleepyshiftworker · 05/10/2021 16:23

I'm more concerned OP that your chronic health complaints are landing you in the ED. Perhaps inappropriately?

Pythonesque · 04/10/2021 22:54

The terminology is hugely problematic. "Doctors in training" can be equally misunderstood. "Trainee doctor" is perhaps the worst as can sound like still a medical student ...

TroublesomeTrucks · 04/10/2021 22:42

I’ve been a qualified doctor for 11 years and a registrar for 5 years. I’m still a ‘junior’ doctor and will be for at least another 2 years. The term is a little misleading, I think.

Fwafwafwa · 04/10/2021 22:34

A GP is equivalent to a consultant, qualified GPs are also called "GP consultants". If you ever see a "GP registrar" that's someone in their final (ST3) year of training, which they spend in general practice.

There will obviously be a difference between a newly qualified GP and one who has worked in the role for many years. They also differ in their training experiences and special interests. It's not uncommon for GPs to be partially or fully dual qualified in another specialty. They work as team, so any GP coming across a problem they don't feel confident ought to be able to ask their GP colleague for help, and obviously they can also telephone or write to hospital specialties for advice.

It must be a very difficult and intimidating thing becoming a qualified GP after such a relatively short training programme, with possibly no first hand experience in key specialties. Imo, the training programme is short not because GP requires less training (far from it I believe it is one of the most challenging specialties there is) but sadly because of the need to keep supplying the dwindling GP workforce. Increasingly it's going to be even less qualified allied health professionals doing as much GP work as possible. In most instances that's perfectly fine, but then this cherry picking of the more straightforward stuff to AHPs does leave ever more challenging / complex work for GPs whose appointment times and admin sessions haven't increased in length accordingly... Another matter for another thread.

countbackfromten · 04/10/2021 22:29

I’m 12 years in and still a junior doctor and will be for another 2 years. I’m also the most senior anaesthetist in the hospital at night, unless I have to get my boss in. Nothing junior about me bar the title!

HotMummaSummer · 04/10/2021 22:27

Most A and E departments have locum (bank) doctors working for them. There are always loads of shifts going in A and E and they pay from £35 to £75 per hour through agencies.
This may explain why there you end up seeing different doctors...

pianolessons1 · 04/10/2021 22:20

@HandforthParishCouncilClerk

No, many GPs are equivalent to a registrar, at least initially. As a GP trainee you still have to do your initial training on ward rotation, as all other JDs do.

Most junior doctors have years of experience and are very qualified.

Just avoid hospital on the first Weds in August!

A GP trainee is equivalent to a registrar

A GP (by which I mean a doctor who has their certificate of specialist training (CCT) in general practice) is equivalent to a consultant.

HandforthParishCouncilClerk · 04/10/2021 22:14

No, many GPs are equivalent to a registrar, at least initially. As a GP trainee you still have to do your initial training on ward rotation, as all other JDs do.

Most junior doctors have years of experience and are very qualified.

Just avoid hospital on the first Weds in August!

DontBiteTheBoobThatFeedsYou · 04/10/2021 22:09

Yes, a GP is equal in seniority to a consultant.

Really? I was misinformed or not listening when told then.

DontBiteTheBoobThatFeedsYou · 04/10/2021 22:08

@SmellyOldOwls

So are GPs all consultants then?
No.
pianolessons1 · 04/10/2021 22:07

@SmellyOldOwls

So are GPs all consultants then?
Yes, a GP is equal in seniority to a consultant.
SmellyOldOwls · 04/10/2021 21:59

So are GPs all consultants then?

YourFinestPantaloons · 04/10/2021 21:56

@LeroyJenkinssss

No. A lot of A&Es won’t have F1s (who are immediately post graduation) and the term covers almost all doctors that aren’t consultants.

Why do you ask?

This sums it up pretty well!
INeedNewShoes · 04/10/2021 21:53

I have found that in the clinic for my chronic medical condition that junior doctors come and go so frequently that I've actually only ever seen the same junior doctor on two separate appointments once (if that makes sense!) but they're all there under the supervision of the lead consultant.

Of the many hospital doctors I've seen for this condition plus a couple of other ongoing conditions over the years, three stand out as having provided exceptional care, and two of those three were juniors.

WoodchipNightmares · 04/10/2021 21:52

The term is very misleading. It's a bit like calling everyone other than the prime minister a "junior politician"

Isabellabasil · 04/10/2021 21:49

Almost all doctors you see in hospital are going to be junior doctors. My DB is training to be an anaesthetist. He did 5 years at uni, 3 years foundation (working in hospital) and has done 4 years of specialism as an anaesthetist. He still has 3 years to go until he may become a consultant and stop being a 'junior' doctor. He is 42 years old and extremely experienced. The term junior doctor is very misleading, no other profession where you have nearly 15 years under your belt and often head teams, would call you a junior.

Fwafwafwa · 04/10/2021 21:48

After graduation the standard full time training pathway is:

  1. FY1 (foundation year 1), 3 rotations of 4 months each (usually in the same hospital). Theoretically an FY1 could be called a "JHO" (junior house officer), but no one does ever.

  2. FY2, 3 more rotations of 4 months each (usually in the same hospital, usually a different hospital to FY1 though). FY2s are the first/lowliest "SHO" (senior house officer) grade.

  3. Enter either a "core" training or run through training programme. These are called "core training" or "specialty training" or "GP speciality training" so eg in the first year of these programmes you would be known as CT1/ST1/GPST1, in the 2nd year CT2/ST2 etc. At this stage you remain an SHO. Core programmes end after 2-3 years then you apply for a further higher specialty training programme, run through programmes the 2 are joined together effectively and you just apply at the start after completing foundation. During this time rotations are usually 6-12 months, more often 6 months. Not usually at the same hospital.

  4. Become a registrar (also shorthanded to "SpR" for Specialist Registrar) - (happens automatically with progression in a run through training programme, or if you have finished a core training programme you will have gone through a further application as above). This tends to be everyone who's badge says ST3-ST4 and above. Registrars are quite senior doctors "on the shop floor" who in some specialties might lead a resuscitation or might carry out surgeries independently etc. Usually rotations are 6-12 months, not usually at the same hospital.

  5. Consultant.

Training lasts a really variable length of time depending on specialty, so eg GPs are a registrar for 1 year (ST3) after being an SHO for 3 years (FY2/ST1/2), paediatricians are typically a registrar for 5 years (ST4/5/6/7/8) after being an SHO for 3 years (FY2/ST1/2).

Some programmes you keep very much to your specialty (eg once in surgery you won't do medical rotations, once in paediatrics you won't do adult rotations) even during SHO years. In others (particularly GP training), you do a mish mash of different specialties during SHO years. Registrars are generally only within their destination specialty though (including GPs hence the "GP registrar" at your local surgery).

In your local ED department the registrars will be emergency medicine trainees working toward EM consultant, possibly some anaesthetics trainees (? Not totally sure), and staff grades not in training (who may have worked in EM a very long time). The SHOs will be a mix of FY2, GPSTs, and STs from EM and anaesthetics (they share a core training pathway). Plus doctors from other specialties (medical, surgical, obstetrics, paediatrics etc) will visit to see their own specialty patients, sometimes planned via GP and sometimes on request from the emergency dept doctors. There are a lot of junior doctors working there, most of whom rotate hospital every 6-12 months, so it's no wonder you may not see the same one twice!

Additional to this doctors often also take years out of training or between programmes to do things like clinical fellowships, extra qualifications, research etc.

All doctors below consultant are called "juniors" even though quite a lot of them are actually very senior / experienced. It can take 10-15 years from graduation to become a consultant and not every doctor chooses to become a consultant. Some will leave training at registrar level and remain registrars as a "staff grade" for many years/decades.

Ilikeanimalsmorethanpeople · 04/10/2021 21:45

in my trust:

F1 brand new dr usually on a 4 month rotation

Junior dr:

F2 next year usually on a 4 month rotation but could also be 6

CT: Higher than a Junior but not a registrar 4/6 month rotation

Trust Junior: Employed by the Trust so they don't rotate

Smile
TableFlowerss · 04/10/2021 21:45

@negomi90

I'm a junior doctor. I qualified 8 years ago and I'm the most senior paediatrician in the hospital at night (unless I decide to call in the consultant). The F1 is also a junior doctor and they finished uni in June.
That’s crazy that you’re considered a junior doctor.

I thought there was a House Officer, Senior Ho, Registrar then consultant. I would have thought the HO was the junior Dr only.

ISpyCobraKai · 04/10/2021 21:38

Unfortunately I've never had a good experience with a Junior Doctor.
One tried to send me home and I flatly refused to leave, rightly as I had five broken bones in my back.

negomi90 · 04/10/2021 21:32

I'm a junior doctor. I qualified 8 years ago and I'm the most senior paediatrician in the hospital at night (unless I decide to call in the consultant). The F1 is also a junior doctor and they finished uni in June.

theDudesmummy · 04/10/2021 21:23

Yes a registrar is a junior doctor