Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child not reading at school.

68 replies

Karleeb30 · 04/10/2021 18:48

Dd has sen and an EHCP meaning she should be being supported at school more than she is.

She is speech delayed and reading has not come naturally to her. She can barely read. I appreciate that a teacher has potentially 30 kids so reading with 30 kids individually must be hard. I remember we all read individually with teachers/ta's at primary school quite often or out into small groups based on ability. Maybe things have changed (I am late twenties). There are two ta's in her class.

However, I am not happy with the lack of reading. I know a lot of reading is done at home with the parents - but in Dd's case she is really struggling. She is 6 and the youngest in her year 2 class.

Aibu to think based on the fact that she has an EHCP and should have a ta supporting her (which half the time she doesn't) she should be reading more at school?

Older DS has sen too and his ta read with him every damn day to get where he is (same school too).

I don't expect special treatment but I'm so angry that her learning needs outlined on her EHCP aren't being met half the time!

Wwyd? EHCP review is very soon. Wait it out until then? Complain? Complain to the EHCP sen people and say her needs aren't being met?!

OP posts:
Tal45 · 04/10/2021 19:53

Things move quickly in school in my experience and if you don't pick up letter sounds as they are taught and are still not confident in Y2 you would need extra help with a TA because the rest of the class would not still be working on this. Not sure if you mean individual letter sounds when you say phonics but that's what I am assuming. I know a teacher who would keep children back from assembly in a little group to work on this sort of thing, digraphs etc with them every day and it made a huge difference. She really needs something like that that happens very frequently IMO, even reading her book once a week would not be anywhere near enough.

Do you know the letter sounds? I would spend your time working on these every day with her rather than reading her one word book over and over - but do read to her every day and let her watch you read the words.

What I did with my son when he was learning was to cut pictures out of magazines for a few letter sounds at a time. Then write a letter on the top of a sheet and get him to find the pictures that began with that letter sound (obviously you wouldn't want a phone for the letter 'p' it has to be words that obviously begin with the 'puh' sound.) Then I would get him to stick the pictures on and we made a huge poster of all the letter sounds and things that began with them. If yo ucan find pics of favourite toys etc this can help with engagement.

ForPingsSake · 04/10/2021 19:52

Arrange a meeting with her teacher to discuss the support that she is actually getting in school. Then you can take it from there. Unfortunately, IME as a TA, staff are always really stretched trying to provide support to all the children that need it so it's not unusual for children not to get all the support they need. Also, the emphasis tends to be on supporting the children who are nearly at the expected level because schools are judged by how many children they get across an arbitrary line. Children who are never going to meet that threshold become a lower priority (which is obviously all wrong). I'm sure some schools are better than others for this but they are all under the same pressure to get the most children they can up to a specific level.

As a parent, you need to be the squeaky wheel. Ask the difficult questions. Push for them to provide the support that your child needs and is entitled to. Go through the EHCP with a fine-toothed comb to make sure you are happy that all the support she needs is on there. You also need to do as much as possible at home. Ask the teacher to guide you with things that will help if you do them at home. I'd even consider getting a tutor. You shouldn't have to but I feel like the system is stacked against the children that struggle.

niugboo · 04/10/2021 19:49

Is there any provision relating to reading in her ehcp?

An ehcp doesn’t entitle her to anything that isn’t clearly specified within section F if her ehcp. If there is an identified need, provision and outcome they will do the same amount with her as everyone else.

Karleeb30 · 04/10/2021 19:46

[quote Mumofsend]@Karleeb30 at her review ask if the EP can advise re her reading/phonics.

I asked for an update on this specifically when it became apparent reading was also an issue. My DD is in year 2. LA were happy to ask for this advice[/quote]
I will be doing this. Her annual review is very soon. The problem is my local authority tee forever to send out paper copies. I was sent her last EHCP copy by the senco digitally but now I've tried to get into it has expired (if I knew it would do that I would have printed it out). I will chase up another copy tomorrow!

OP posts:
BiLuminous · 04/10/2021 19:44

Can she consistently identify a letter sound when you read with her like /s/ ? She needs to be secure in those to then move onto trying to blend.

Guided reading with her more often in class might not be as useful as you might think. The phonics work they do in class as a whole would be more productive to helping her read than trying to get her to do something she might not be ready for yet, iyswim?
Its always okay to raise concerns and ask for an explanation. After all, you're her only advocate and she should be getting what she needs. You should be clear on where she is, and how they are working towards her goals.

Mumofsend · 04/10/2021 19:44

@Karleeb30 at her review ask if the EP can advise re her reading/phonics.

I asked for an update on this specifically when it became apparent reading was also an issue. My DD is in year 2. LA were happy to ask for this advice

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 04/10/2021 19:43

How many hours is the EHCP for if there is no one to one?

Karleeb30 · 04/10/2021 19:40

The problem is that her EHCP was last updated not long after finishing eyfs with time off due to covid. Her EHCP needs to be updated and have more focus on her phonics I think. She knows all her phonics individually but cannot blend them yet!

OP posts:
Mumofsend · 04/10/2021 19:40

Should it not be part of her EHCP?

My daughter has on her plan

1-1 for 30 minutes SALT daily.
1-1 for 15 minutes twice per day reading/phonics
1-1 delivery of a literacy intervention throughout literacy lessons.

When was her last EP report? That may need updating in line with her reading difficulties.

School should also be supporting her reading difficulties even without it is specified in her plan

itsgettingwierd · 04/10/2021 19:38

@Jangle33

How often do you think she should be reading at school? You’ve not answered that yet
This would be set by the professionals who should be outlining how much she needs to be reading at school to meet her needs
Karleeb30 · 04/10/2021 19:37

@Jangle33

How often do you think she should be reading at school? You’ve not answered that yet
I don't know what's the norm but I would expect her to be reading her book at some Point during the week!
OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 04/10/2021 19:36

My aim with this AR would be to get section F quantified and specified. It legally has to be.

So what does she need help in? I'm assuming English, reading. Phonics and her SaL?

Get her professionals to worse how much needs to be done daily, by whom, when it's reviewed and who sets the tasks and who delivers them.

Reports must state this. Do not allow "recommended". It needs to say "DD needs 10 minutes reading practise 1:1 daily with a Ta".

Get it all tightened up in AR and clearly tell them your intention will be to take it to tribunal if they don't write it correctly as Sendcop states and this is in no ones interests - there's either as they costs to them will be greater as they'll have to recommission further reports.

User5827372728 · 04/10/2021 19:36

I would ask to speak to the school SENCo and raise your concerns

cherish123 · 04/10/2021 19:35

She will be doing phonics - which will teach her to blend (or slide) sounds together to read words. If you have concerns that she cannot read, speak to her school. If she has speech and language issues, does she have access to a sp therapist?

toocold54 · 04/10/2021 19:33

I don’t know why you think she’s not reading at school. School for that age is 90% learning to read so just because she’s not changing her reading book doesn’t mean she’s bot reading other things.

Honestly I think you are expecting too much from her. You think she should be more advanced than she is but honestly some are just slow at learning how to read.

You can have a chat to the school and let them know your concerns but the best thing you can do is read to her and let her follow the words. When she is more able she will be able to read parts to you too.

Jangle33 · 04/10/2021 19:32

How often do you think she should be reading at school? You’ve not answered that yet

2Two · 04/10/2021 19:30

The local authority has a clear duty to ensure that your child receives all the support set out in section F of the EHCP, and the school must use its best endeavours to do so. If that isn’t happening it can be enforced by a threat of judicial review or a formal complaint, but that really depends on whether the support is sufficiently detailed. LAs have a habit of writing EHCPs in very vague and waffly terms that mean they aren’t realistically enforceable.

I’d suggest you get advice from SOS SEN or IPSEA to see if your child’s EHCP is precise enough and, if not, how to get it amended

Karleeb30 · 04/10/2021 19:29

@liveforsummer

She's only 6, how much reading for you expected to be doing. I work in a p2 class of 6 year olds and even the better readers are only on stage 1 books. Usually some wound be further on but covid has a lot to do with that.
By stage 1 I mean she's on single word books (assuming that's stage 1 Without grabbing her book out too look) She was on books with short sentences last year but they've changed their books this year and she's ok the very first books!

Some of her friends are much further ahead.

I'm guilty or comparing. I was a 'free reader' by year 3 or 4 and reading Jacqueline Wilson books. So I don't know what's normal or not 😏

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 04/10/2021 19:20

She's only 6, how much reading for you expected to be doing. I work in a p2 class of 6 year olds and even the better readers are only on stage 1 books. Usually some wound be further on but covid has a lot to do with that.

Karleeb30 · 04/10/2021 19:19

@MrsWhites

Does she have a decent grasp of phonics? What level reading books are they giving her? Is it that she isn’t grasping it because she is struggling to blend sounds if the books are too difficult?

I would request a chat with her class teacher as a starting point but would definitely raise it.

Phonics is her real struggle. She knows quite a few high frequency words. school have recently changed their books but she's on the first level.
OP posts:
Sirzy · 04/10/2021 19:18

You need to look what’s in section f and ask them if that is being provided. What is the specific wording around the SALT provision? Sadly unless it’s very very clear schools often won’t do it

I wouldn’t necessarily expect reading as in sitting with a book to be part of that but if that’s an identified area of needs then their should be work around that identitied to help her.

MrsWhites · 04/10/2021 19:17

Does she have a decent grasp of phonics? What level reading books are they giving her? Is it that she isn’t grasping it because she is struggling to blend sounds if the books are too difficult?

I would request a chat with her class teacher as a starting point but would definitely raise it.

Karleeb30 · 04/10/2021 19:16

She is under speech therapy. She's her once every term I believe but speech therapy is so over stretched here it's often less. Her speech therapist is generally amazing though and has has helped us a huge deal. Her speech is improving all the time, she talks all the time now but it's still young for her and and unclear.

My eldest is autistic. Dd has been seen by Ed psych (about 2-3 years ago) who doesn't believe she is too but I can't help feel she is and masks

OP posts:
Embracelife · 04/10/2021 19:15

If she can "barely read"
She maybe needs something different
Other approach
Not "more reading" since she can barely read

Ask their plan and approach

BiLuminous · 04/10/2021 19:14

Her speech delay should be the priority as trying to read when you might have phonological delay would be painful for the child and counter-productive. Therapy would be the thing Id be concerned with over reading.