Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that vigilante justice should be back on the table?

88 replies

Dutch1e · 04/10/2021 15:50

We give up the right to take personal revenge in exchange for being protected by institutions like police and courts.

When these institutions spectacularly fail women and children, can we consider the social contract broken?

At this point I'm struggling to see any other way to resolve male violence apart from a wide-sweeping free-for-all on every cat-calling, bantering, beating, raping murderer out there.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Eaumyword · 05/10/2021 11:32

Oh god, I do hate the share the hell out of this posts!Grin
I agree, the police have a huge job on their hands rebuilding national trust and confidence and it's not the best start with the whole if in doubt, flag a bus down idiocy.

FaceForRadio1973 · 05/10/2021 08:27

I think it's safe to say that the Metropolitan Police have catastrophically f**ked up on this one, and they have got a long way to go to rebuild trust. I can also see why some people are worried and don't feel safe.

Having said that, if anyone is still interested in vigilante "justice" please bear in mind that I could easily destroy the life of any random person, just by posting their photograph on social media, along with any old unsubstantiated guff about what they do to animals, along with the phrase "Share the hell out of this!!!!!"

Cue the knuckle-draggers and their pitchforks...

PookieHook · 04/10/2021 21:01

@DroopyClematis

Yep... it's a no-no from me.

Still unable to comprehend the paedophile hunters descending on a paediatrician's home.

Don't worry about comprehending it because it didn't happen, as the Press Gazette explains

www.pressgazette.co.uk/a-tale-told-too-much-the-paediatrician-vigilantes/

WhoIsPepeSilva · 04/10/2021 20:26

@Dutch1e

I think there are a lot of us on this thread imagining large groups of roving men playing sheriff against other men. I was thinking more about a cheerful brick to the face of the next sleazy man who says "how about a blowjob, love?" And imagining it en masse every day.

The recommendation upthread of voting and writing stern letters made me smile in a sad way. If that was going to work it probably would have centuries ago.

I do absolutely understand where the anger comes from and I sometimes imagine righteous retribution too but in practice what would actually happen in this scenario ^ would likely be:

After blocking/collecting himself from the blow, the brick would quickly be taken out of my hand and I would be subjected to a violent assault myself.

Weapons in the hands of those unused to them/violence, and in the hands of generally smaller and weaker people is just asking for the aggressor to take them off you and use them against you.

It does make me sad that voting etc has only got us so far in so so very long but realistically they are the only sane ways to enforce change.

Violence only begets violence and we as the generally smaller/physically weaker sex will ultimately be at the receiving end of far greater injustice and far likelier chances of being assaulted and killed than we already are should we as a society descend to mob rule and vigilantism.

Kleptaklunky · 04/10/2021 20:14

@Yankey812

no but maybe they should bring back the rope
Here we go
Kleptaklunky · 04/10/2021 20:10

What absolute toss OP

Siameasy · 04/10/2021 20:00

Oh yeah that’s going to go well. Women attacking men I’m sure a bad guy is not going to retaliate at all

StoneofDestiny · 04/10/2021 19:40

No, I definitely do not want vigilante 'justice', as it rarely ever is 'justice'. It's just thugs justifying being thugs.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/oct/29/vigilante-murder-paedophile-bristol-bijan-ebrahimi

Rosesareyellow · 04/10/2021 19:09

Have you seen Law Abiding Citizen… it’s a bit of a shit film really but also illustrates nicely why this sort of thing is a fucked up idea.

Siablue · 04/10/2021 18:30

No it wouldn’t work. How could you legalise personal revenge.

Whenever people have suggested alternatives to police and prisons it has been basically been a version of get someone to do the same job for free and get the criminals to say sorry to the victims. This just makes the vulnerable even more vulnerable.

If we allowed vigilante behaviour there would be awful racist attacks on black people and immigrants. It would just be whoever has the most power could harm who they liked.

I do fantasise about having powers like Matilda or eleven from Stranger Things and using them against all the men who have hurt me.

StrongSunglasses · 04/10/2021 18:25

I haven’t got any pitchforks, and baying is an ugly practice. So no. YABU.

knittingaddict · 04/10/2021 18:16

You're coming across as a bit of a psychopath op. There are people |I know who I would love to see getting what they deserve, but I don't thibk I have it in me to physically hurt anyone. Not many do really, unless it's in the heat of the moment.

As to your example, it goes like this:

Man - "how about a blowjob, love?"

You - brick in face.

Man ?????

I can guess that it ends up with you getting considerably more than a brick in the face back. Once things get physical women have no defence against an adult male.

I know you're just playing with us op, but this is very badly thought through.

Betty000 · 04/10/2021 18:08

Do you mean like the A-Team, a team of vigilantes driving round the UK doing vigilante stuff or do you just mean a free for all, for example you see the neighbour letting their dog shit on your lawn so you can bash their brains out? Or do you mean controlled with appropriate levels of punishment for the crime committed? Also who gets to decide if a crime has been committed, would you just trust any gossip or would you require proof?

sweeneytoddsrazor · 04/10/2021 18:07

I am to old to get harassed nowadays but I found that usually a go fuck yourself arsehole was a fairly adequate response to a what about a blow job comment.

Mybalconyiscracking · 04/10/2021 18:06

Did we miss the bit where the police caught and arrested Couzens and the court then locked him up for the rest of his life, very likely in solitary confinement?
That sounds like a form of justice to me, maybe we should have raffled tickets to let people set about him with bricks?
Tempting as it sounds it’s not a society I ultimately want to live in.

PlanDeRaccordement · 04/10/2021 18:06

I never said mob, I said vigilante. As in personal revenge. Outsourcing to a mob is about as effective as outsourcing to the police

That’s the point OP. Personal revenge never stops at a lone attacker, violence is contagious. Read some studies about violence. It spreads and that lone revenge attacker sets off multiple counter revenge attackers. Which then becomes mobs/gangs going after each other and over time, engrained hatred with no one really knowing how it all started only that a member of group x is to be attacked/killed on sight.

Dutch1e · 04/10/2021 18:00

@AlternativePerspective

So a man attacks me and my dh and his mob of mates go out and beat the crap out of him. So essentially the mob attack someone, so the attacker gets a mob to go out there and attack my dh, so they’re now the attackers, so another mob of DH’s friends go out and attack the 3rd attack mob, and before you know it you have complete anarchy where nobody knows who attacked who first any more and the whole village has descended into a place where no-one is safe from attack any more because everyone is guilty of having attacked someone…

And so the cycle goes on.

Not very intelligent thinking there… Hmm

I never said mob, I said vigilante. As in personal revenge. Outsourcing to a mob is about as effective as outsourcing to the police
OP posts:
Merrymumoftwo · 04/10/2021 17:59

I went to school with two really nice boys, friendly kind and went out of their way to help others. All that changed when their brother was shot and killed. Soon after they joined a gang and went and got revenge. On killing the person responsible that person’s gang came after the members of the gang that the brothers were in. I say were, as both are now dead along with numerous others. This is not an isolated picture it is echoed in every gang across the world. Do you really want more of this?

Dutch1e · 04/10/2021 17:55

@mustlovegin

I hope you are not serious OP.

The world has gone mad

I'm not sure.

I'd like to think I was just making a point about the total failure of our institutions to stop male violence against women and kids... but there are rare moments when I am absolutely certain that the next one to catcall me, grope me, harass or assault me will die at my hands. It's an ugly feeling to be pushed that far.

OP posts:
Rosesareyellow · 04/10/2021 17:55

I was thinking more about a cheerful brick to the face of the next sleazy man who says "how about a blowjob, love?" And imagining it en masse every day.

Isn’t that in itself losing sight of justice though… I mean, harassing comments are bad - but is it as bad as someone throwing a brick in someone’s face for saying it?? Especially if that person does it in a ‘cheerful’ manner.
As much as I don’t like living in a world where men make such in appropriate comments, I don’t think I’d be keen to live in a world where people get their faces smashed in with bricks en masse…

DroopyClematis · 04/10/2021 17:54

Yep... it's a no-no from me.

Still unable to comprehend the paedophile hunters descending on a paediatrician's home.

PlanDeRaccordement · 04/10/2021 17:48

@IsleofRum

I amold enough to remember the guardian angels. Copied in London from the US. Uniformed civilians who would "patrol" the underground die to the polices inability to stop muggings. Don't know if it's still working in the US, but there's a need in the UK.
Speaking of US and vigilantes, this also increases racist violence against nonwhite people. Don’t forget that Trayvon Martin was an innocent black teenager murdered by a US vigilante basically for being black, male, in a hoodie and whose only crime was walking through the vigilante’s neighbourhood to buy some skittles from a corner shop.
AlternativePerspective · 04/10/2021 17:48

So a man attacks me and my dh and his mob of mates go out and beat the crap out of him. So essentially the mob attack someone, so the attacker gets a mob to go out there and attack my dh, so they’re now the attackers, so another mob of DH’s friends go out and attack the 3rd attack mob, and before you know it you have complete anarchy where nobody knows who attacked who first any more and the whole village has descended into a place where no-one is safe from attack any more because everyone is guilty of having attacked someone…

And so the cycle goes on.

Not very intelligent thinking there… Hmm

Orangejuicemarathoner · 04/10/2021 17:44

vigilante justice = another name for violent crime

IsleofRum · 04/10/2021 17:44

I amold enough to remember the guardian angels. Copied in London from the US. Uniformed civilians who would "patrol" the underground die to the polices inability to stop muggings. Don't know if it's still working in the US, but there's a need in the UK.