Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not go mushroom foraging with my teenage son

134 replies

Patchwork21 · 04/10/2021 13:55

14ds has a fascination with mushrooms. He's researched and says he knows there are certain types that are 100 percent easy to identify as safe to eat. He wants me to go with him to pick some and them bring them home to eat. I said no, as I have no experience whatsoever with mushrooms. He says I'm irrational and lots of parents take their children mushroom picking 🍄

OP posts:
JennieLee · 04/10/2021 16:45

A lot of areas will have mycological societies/foraging groups. They welcome members - and there's often a good deal of experience there.

Sarah2384 · 04/10/2021 16:42

@samwitwicky

Wouldn't it be something nice / fun etc to do with your child, regardless of how much you know about them?

You don't have to eat them

Agree, but don't pick anything you've no intention of eating. Well, maybe just one of each species to bring home and identify properly.
tttigress · 04/10/2021 16:40

Another option would be to allow him to grow some mushrooms, that can't be dangerous.

tttigress · 04/10/2021 16:38

I think there are mushroom picking training course, can't you go on one of those together?

ChaToilLeam · 04/10/2021 16:32

It sounds a great idea to do a course together. I’ve done a little foraging but some edible mushrooms look really like the dodgy ones and I stick to the ones I’m confident with.

mayblossominapril · 04/10/2021 16:29

I go foraging but I stick to field, horse mushrooms and giant puff balls.
Giant puffballs are a rare find but impossible to mistake for anything else. My grandfather showed me where to pick and how to know which are field or horse mushrooms.
DP goes foraging as well and he is more adventurous than I am. Ive got a really good collins guide. Sometimes we enjoy identifying all mushrooms but only gather certain ones.

limitedperiodonly · 04/10/2021 16:27

I forgot. In the 1970s my parents used to take us blackberrying every Sunday in August/Septemberish. We ate my mum's apple and blackberry pies for weeks.

Even when we left home my parents loved to be out there. My dad died and a few years later my mum said how much she missed going. DH and I took her. My mum and I could both remembered the best places but bloody hell they'd changed. Aggressive professional blackberry pickers and also families who had clearly watched too many prepper/zombie apocalypse videos and were a bit over-keen.

My mum had given DH my dad's machete-type blade to chop down the brambles. He'd been given it by a friend who served with the Chindits in WWII and had to hack down jungle and other things.

It certainly kept the mad people away from us that day by us appearing as strangers not to be messed with. But we never went again. Forest foraging can be quite competitive...

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 04/10/2021 16:26

We went foraging once and I still go cold thinking about the subsequent food poisoning we got.

I would explain to him that you love his interest but you're nervous. Would he be open for you to both go on a foraging course? That way you can go mushroom picking but safely.

Tbh it's lovely he wants to include you.

JennieLee · 04/10/2021 16:18

Most books give good advice and also flag up when an inedible species and an edible one resemble one another. Spouse and I go foraging regularly. If you stick to a few very distinctive varieties - parasol mushrooms, shaggy inkcaps - you will be fine.

Doing spore prints, smelling mushrooms etc is also very much part of the process. It's not about visual evidence only.

A good guidebook/textbook - eg Roger Philips' 'Mushrooms' is also a must.

gospelsinger · 04/10/2021 16:15

If he's going to do it, you should research it yourself and go with him. It's better than him going alone and bringing them back and eating them anyway. Where they are found is a key part of identifying the edible ones. You will also be able to guage how confident he is in their identity. booking a course sounds like a good idea.

TonTonMacoute · 04/10/2021 16:11

It's not only about knowing the mushrooms it's about knowing the terrain really well. Some of the poisonous ones look almost identical to the harmless ones, if you are experienced then you know exactly where the good ones and the bad ones grow, and can be sure what you are picking.

I think its brilliant that your DS is into wild foraging though OP, and would definitely want to encourage it, but only under expert supervision.

Getabloominmoveon · 04/10/2021 16:10

I used to take my kids mushrooming with a Spanish friend who knew his mushrooms very well. You definitely need to be with someone with experience, not just with a book. We had some Eastern Europeans friends who'd been picking mushrooms since they were children - they also knew what they were doing and were able to point out subtle differences, what to avoid etc.
It's such fun once you feel safe. Take some bacon and a pan. cook them in the field. Yum!

limitedperiodonly · 04/10/2021 16:08

A friend offered to take us. He's Italian and has a restaurant and has done it since a child. We were interested because we're a bit foody.

But he became so cagey about his hunting grounds that we suspected he was going to blindfold us and put us in the boot of his car to make sure we couldn't find the place on our own.

It all sounded a bit cut throat and he wanted us to get up before dawn so we said: "No thanks, you're all right mate."

I've still got some dried porcini in the cupboard that I foraged from Sainsbury's last year.

EmKayEm · 04/10/2021 16:06

The old adage is that all mushrooms are edible, just that some of them you only get to eat once...

You have to be a bit more experienced and have gone out a few times with someone that knows their stuff before you can be confident in eating your what you forage.

My grandad taught me and my brother, and it has come in very useful and enjoyable over the years.

Patchwork21 · 04/10/2021 16:05

[quote TheFoundations]Could you get him to teach you how to identify them? If he shows you all his references, you might end up trusting him, or you'll be better equipped to tell him where he's going wrong. He might enjoy telling you all about how to do it, if he's really into it.

Has he done any spore prints yet? They're often quite crucial to make sure that you're not poisoning yourself... and they're quite beautiful too.

www.wikihow.com/Make-a-Mushroom-Spore-Print[/quote]
He was talking about spore printing. I'm up for that!! :-)

OP posts:
SaltySheepdog · 04/10/2021 16:03

Go to some sessions with a wildlife expert who has proper knowledge. Book yourself on a mushroom and nature course

Lanique · 04/10/2021 16:00

Ooo I'll go with him OP.

That said the only ones I dare eat are field and horse mushrooms, if I'm lucky enough to find them!

heathspeedwell · 04/10/2021 15:59

It's fantastic that your son wants to get involved in a healthy hobby which you can do together outdoors. You can both learn at the same time and there are loads of resources to help you. There are a few Facebook groups that can help with identification - Mushroom Spotters UK is the biggest and friendliest - they will give you lots of expert advice.

A great book for beginners is the River Cottage Mushroom Handbook by John Wright. He has decades of experience in teaching courses and is a hugely entertaining writer. If you order it for your son it will give you both the confidence to know what you can pick safely. Most importantly it lists all the lookalikes that you need to avoid. It's such a good read that you will find it hard to put down and you'll soon be able to enjoy cooking your own foraged food. Wright focuses on a selection of the more common and unmistakable finds and helps you to gain the proper identification skills you need.

As long as you don't eat anything before you are 100% certain of your ID this is a brilliant hobby. However, please don't trust phone apps - they are not good enough yet. Also this is one instance where I would advise against buying second-hand books until you are more experienced as mycology has moved on a lot in the last decade and mushrooms that were once believed to be edible have since been found to have cumulative toxins.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 04/10/2021 15:54

can you find an experienced local who might either come along or who would look at the mushrooms you bring back ?

TheFoundations · 04/10/2021 15:52

Could you get him to teach you how to identify them? If he shows you all his references, you might end up trusting him, or you'll be better equipped to tell him where he's going wrong. He might enjoy telling you all about how to do it, if he's really into it.

Has he done any spore prints yet? They're often quite crucial to make sure that you're not poisoning yourself... and they're quite beautiful too.

www.wikihow.com/Make-a-Mushroom-Spore-Print

EveningOverRooftops · 04/10/2021 15:49

A good bushcraft course will get you foraging AND cooking them.

We have such a business here and it’s good value.

Just explain to him very clearly that neither of you are eating anything without expert advice and arrange some expert advice!

ReggaetonLente · 04/10/2021 15:49

DH is eastern European, his parents forage mushrooms but he doesn't have much interest. FIL is very sure of his identifying skills, but I notice MIL checks everything very very closely before she cooks it. DH and I don't eat what they forage and the DDs certainly don't.

The blueberries they pick though, I'm all for them.

SylvanasWindrunner · 04/10/2021 15:44

After I read about Nicholas Evans a few years ago, I would never do this. It traumatised me! Plus I hate mushrooms anyway.

KittenKong · 04/10/2021 15:38

I once got horrible reaction after eating some of those weird looking funky mushrooms that they sell in supermarkets (thanks Tesco) for my ‘toadstool risotto’.

I woke up with my skin on fire, bright red, and with small blisters running all along where the seams of my PJs were. I ended up in a&e!

WellLarDeDar · 04/10/2021 15:38

I'd go out and play some sort of mushroom bingo game but I wouldn't be picking and eating wild mushrooms. He's probably read a wikipedia page online and thinks he's an expert. You can really easily mistakenly identify poisonous mushrooms and get really sick!