Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that meat eaters...

410 replies

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 11:26

Should be comfortable to slaughter animals if they are happy to eat them?

The 'cheap chicken' threads have got me onto this and I'm at home with covid so be gentle!

My own personal background is that I am vegetarian and have been since I was 7. Own decision. I cook meat for my children and my husband because I believe, like i was given, it's a choice that can be made for themselves.

My husband is from farming background and has proactively raised and slaughtered animals. His conscience is entirely clear because he very much has the farmer mindset of raise the animal, give them a good life, dispatch and consume.

It's coming up to 'Turkey time' on the family farm and with the so called shortages forecast this year, I've found myself having more conversations with colleagues about the food chain/supply etc.

We live in an affluent area and we have lots of farm shops, butchers etc. However, I'm shocked that most people I know have said while they couldn't give up meat, they also wouldn't be happy to raise animals for slaughter themselves or to witness their slaughter.

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Just to say, what I've tried in a long winded way above is that i'm not a preachy veggie and I'm not vegan.

OP posts:
SuperstarDog · 04/10/2021 16:50

Also I am bored to the back teeth with militant veggies and vegans guilt tripping meat eaters. We clearly make different choices to you. I couldn't care less what another person eats because it's none of my business!

I’ve said already that I don’t believe OP has posted in good faith. Her post makes no sense and is designed to make vegetarians look bad which leads on to posts like yours. And before you know it all vegetarians and vegans are preachy and militant. Job well done by OP. Yawn.

As for what other people eat being no one's business, I do feel that someone has to defend animals. I don’t feel their exploitation is right and the way humans feel they have the right to kill animals and use the farming practices they do doesn’t sit right with me at all. That’s why I campaign for animal rights and will comment on threads like these. It is my business to defend those without a voice.

FluffyBooBoo · 04/10/2021 16:48

Also I am bored to the back teeth with militant veggies and vegans guilt tripping meat eaters

I'm also sick of meat eaters trying to undermine veggies and vegans by declaring them to be hypocrites because they aren't eating to some ridiculously high standard that I suspect they themselves don't live up to.

Basically everyone should stop judging people based on where they sit on the carnivore to fruitarian scale!

forinborin · 04/10/2021 16:46

but would those vegetarians remove a calf from the cow, and milk it themselves?
In a non-industrial / traditional setting it is actually not such a grim scenario. The calf still gets enough milk, even non-dairy breeds vastly over-produce milk compared to the needs of a calf. The body produces milk according to demand. Many of us actually experienced it ourselves with that strange urge to fill the freezer with expressed milk "just in case". Well I know I did, had probably a couple of gallons frozen at the end.

On the topic, I agree with the sentiment to an extent. Slaughtering a large animal requires skill and likely to cause unnecessary suffering if performed by an amateur. Backyard slaughter of poultry is probably quite the opposite- more humane when small-scale.

twirlinginthesnow · 04/10/2021 16:37

@Fernie6491

I'm of the mindset that just because I want something, doesn't mean I have to produce it myself. I can knit and sew, to make clothes, others wouldn't be able to (without some training or difficulty). And I still need someone to produce the fabrics for that.

We all need others to provide services - builders, farmers, doctors, and so on. should we not use them if we can't do their jobs ourselves?

Same with meat production. I'm not giving up eating meat because I'm not keen on raising then slaughtering animals.

Couldn't have put it better myself.

Also I am bored to the back teeth with militant veggies and vegans guilt tripping meat eaters. We clearly make different choices to you. I couldn't care less what another person eats because it's none of my business!

Fernie6491 · 04/10/2021 16:34

I'm of the mindset that just because I want something, doesn't mean I have to produce it myself. I can knit and sew, to make clothes, others wouldn't be able to (without some training or difficulty). And I still need someone to produce the fabrics for that.

We all need others to provide services - builders, farmers, doctors, and so on. should we not use them if we can't do their jobs ourselves?

Same with meat production. I'm not giving up eating meat because I'm not keen on raising then slaughtering animals.

boobot1 · 04/10/2021 16:33

Well its as simple as this for me. I am an omnivore therefore I eat both vegetables and meat. If I had to kill my own food, I would, just like all the generations before me.

MadamMedea · 04/10/2021 16:22

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Like, I find this attitude really weird when you buy and cook meat. The fact that you don’t personally eat is is surely irrelevant from a moral standpoint? Why are you exempt from the need to be ok with slaughtering the animals you’re cooking…?

MadamMedea · 04/10/2021 16:20

I’m a veggie. My husband isn’t but I don’t cook meat for him because my beliefs mean more to me than his tastebuds.

FluffyBooBoo · 04/10/2021 15:53

I have some further thoughts on this.

I do wonder why some people hold others to such ridiculous standards.

For example.

If you do meat-free Monday, that's seen as a positive. Cutting down on meat is a good thing

But if you cut meat out, but not dairy or eggs, you are a total hypocrite. How very dare you choose not to eat meat. Calves died for that milk you know!

And if you are a vegan - but you dare eat an almond or an avocado, well you clearly don't care about the planet at all!

Why is it not ok to do things imperfectly? Surely cutting down on meat out cutting meat out altogether are both good things? Surely lots of people doing a bit is better than the very few people that can do veganism in such a way that nobody calls them out for not being perfect?

And why do some people choose to seemingly get so offended that other people don't do things exactly the same way they do?

If you harangue people because they choose to eat an egg or an avocado, I really suggest you look at your own actions. Are you really so perfect yourself?

MintLampShade · 04/10/2021 15:52

You are clearly VERY VERY bored, OP! Do you go to the fields and pick all your fruit & vegetables? I think you should lead by example and start right away. Well, when you are not infectious anymore , of course 🙏🏻🙈

LobsterNapkin · 04/10/2021 15:50

@Cattenberg

When it comes to carbon emissions, the type of food consumed is far more impactful than the distance it has travelled.

You might think that a vegan dessert made from South American bananas would have a bigger carbon footprint than a main meal made from organic beef from a nearby farm. But surprisingly, you’d be wrong.

Meat has the highest carbon footprint, followed by dairy, followed by fruit and veg.

It's really not just about food miles.

In part it' s about food security, and there are also issues around people having more ability to influence local regulations, see what happens locally, as opposed to a banana plantation half way around the world, where, even if it's certified organic, you really have no idea what is going on.

But mostly it's about synergies in complex systems. The best, most efficient and sustainable agricultural systems almost always involve integrated plant and animal husbandry. You can't separate them out and say "this potato has this carbon footprint, and this pork a totally separate footprint." The two are intertwined at a basic level.

When you try and separate out these components, which is what industrial ag does, you end up with systems that are environmentally damaging, non-sustainable, inefficient in terms of real energy use, and often petroleum dependent as well.

pigsDOfly · 04/10/2021 15:47

The idea that people shouldn't eat meat unless they're prepared to slaughter the animals doesn't really make much sense to my way of thinking.

I don't eat meat for a number of reasons but I do eat fish and no I don't think it makes me a hypocrite that I don't go out and catch and kill my own fish, I do clean and gut them though.

Slaughtering animals for food is a job that has to be learnt. You can't just pop into a field of sheep, pick the one you like and dispatch it, well you could but you'd probably make a god awful mess of it. How exactly are all the meat eaters going to be trained to do it properly.

At some point, hopefully not for a very long time, I'm probably going to have to ask my vet to put my dog to sleep, as I did with my cats, are you suggesting OP, that if I'm prepared to end my pets life, then I should be prepared to administer the lethal injection myself instead of getting someone else to do my 'dirty work for me'?

SuperstarDog · 04/10/2021 15:43

I don’t think OP has posted this in good faith I’m afraid. The argument was a silly one, almost like it was designed to make vegetarians and vegans look silly. And the last post of ‘some good points have been made and she’s going to think about them’....yeah right. Total bollocks.

grasstreeleaf · 04/10/2021 15:42

@Bananaman123, yes. Equally, I've had surgery but would not be particularly confident in performing it on someone myself.

LobsterNapkin · 04/10/2021 15:42

But meat eaters don't only eat locally so that's not really fair.
The reason some vegans think their diet is more eco is because that is largely what the scientific community have been saying for a while now. So your beef would be with them.

The point is that if people are going to be moralistic about the best way to eat, maybe they should look at their own plate first.

Vegetarianism isn't more "eco" unless you are starting from the perspective of globalized, industrial ag, and then even vegetarianism is quite destructive. So not much of a win.

Bananaman123 · 04/10/2021 15:36

I think you can be OK to consume meat and in turn understand the animal has been slaughtered but not many people would want to watch the slaughter.

grasstreeleaf · 04/10/2021 15:35

Meat has the highest carbon footprint, followed by dairy, followed by fruit and veg.

Unsubstantiated.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 04/10/2021 15:33

I think its difficult to really unpick which foods have the worst environmental inpacts as most people who quote facts have a particular point they are trying to make and will pick and choose their facts to fit their agenda. Cattle drink vast amounts of water but is that really a problem in the UK which has plenty of rain. California grows most of the worlds almond crop, less water is needed than is needed for beef production but California does have a water supply problem, is this taken into account when comparing the two.
Using antibiotics to boost growth in beef cattle was banned in the EU in 2006 but this is still sometimes quoted as a reason not to eat beef rather than advise to eat meat produced in the EU or UK.
Yes I am bias, as I said finding anyone who is truely neutral to supply these facts is difficult.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 04/10/2021 15:28

I have in the past and I would again, but with a job and a family I don't really have time to be plucking birds and skinning rabbits on a regular basis.

gogohm · 04/10/2021 15:26

I prepare fish including gutting (trout farm down the road) and have defeathered and gutted game and chickens in the past. I'm not in farming but have no issue with butchering animals with the correct tools and guidance (no idea how to do it)

NantesElephant · 04/10/2021 15:23

I have raised and slaughtered chickens and rabbits as humanely as I can, but every time it makes my heart heavy. I still eat meat because I felt gradually unwell as a vegetarian, but small amounts of the highest welfare meat. As a family, if we ate chicken as our only meat, we would consume around 40 per year. That is 40 lives taken for our benefit. I sometimes think I should buy a sheep for the freezer then it would be only one life per year taken to feed the family.

PissedOffAgain · 04/10/2021 15:10

@BelleOfTheProvince

Vegans aren't the only people who eat avocados by the way.
Well, if you're planning on saving the planet, avocadoes aren't the way to go
Cattenberg · 04/10/2021 15:04

When it comes to carbon emissions, the type of food consumed is far more impactful than the distance it has travelled.

You might think that a vegan dessert made from South American bananas would have a bigger carbon footprint than a main meal made from organic beef from a nearby farm. But surprisingly, you’d be wrong.

Meat has the highest carbon footprint, followed by dairy, followed by fruit and veg.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 04/10/2021 14:54

I wonder how many vegans grow and harvest their own grain, nuts and beans.

EerieSilence · 04/10/2021 14:54

@REDHERO - if someone can't explain their children the difference between herbivoures such as sheep, cows, rabbits and birds such as chicken, ducks and geese which have been bred and modified for centuries for a particular purposes - which is to provide us with fur, wool, feathers, meat, eggs etc. and cats and dogs which were bred for a completely different purpose, then it's the adult's problem and ignorance, not the child's one.
I love the vision of vegans as everybody being the happy, healthy living and woke being because they can afford it. In reality, people will end up being fed the likes Gregg vegan sausage, full of palm oil and additives crammed into a factory produced funghi mass.