Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that meat eaters...

410 replies

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 11:26

Should be comfortable to slaughter animals if they are happy to eat them?

The 'cheap chicken' threads have got me onto this and I'm at home with covid so be gentle!

My own personal background is that I am vegetarian and have been since I was 7. Own decision. I cook meat for my children and my husband because I believe, like i was given, it's a choice that can be made for themselves.

My husband is from farming background and has proactively raised and slaughtered animals. His conscience is entirely clear because he very much has the farmer mindset of raise the animal, give them a good life, dispatch and consume.

It's coming up to 'Turkey time' on the family farm and with the so called shortages forecast this year, I've found myself having more conversations with colleagues about the food chain/supply etc.

We live in an affluent area and we have lots of farm shops, butchers etc. However, I'm shocked that most people I know have said while they couldn't give up meat, they also wouldn't be happy to raise animals for slaughter themselves or to witness their slaughter.

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Just to say, what I've tried in a long winded way above is that i'm not a preachy veggie and I'm not vegan.

OP posts:
DumplingsAndStew · 04/10/2021 12:05

I've never chopped down a tree, so I don't wipe my arse.

InTheNightWeWillWish · 04/10/2021 12:05

I think there is a different mindset between those from farming backgrounds and the average person. Those from a farming background tend to have pets but they are serving a purpose, they have cats for ratting purposes, dogs are usually working dogs. Farmers are not likely to be the ones referring to their pets as their fur babies, letting their pets sleep on the bed (maybe with cats because you can’t control what a cat does). They might have a pet and then working dogs, with the pet being allowed special treatment that the other dogs aren’t but most animals will serve a purpose. They raise livestock to the highest standards they can, knowing they’ll be slaughtered. It’s something farmers learn at a young age from their parents. Most of the rest of the population falls into having fur babies and if you give them chickens to raise with the view of being slaughtered they get too attached. The chickens become pets, not food. However, people will make a distinction between their pets and the chicken in the shop. I don’t have butchery skills and if I tried to slaughter an animal it wouldn’t be a humane death. However, with training I could probably slaughter an animal on a farm but I would struggle to detach myself from chickens I’d raised.

This isn’t to say that farmers are detached or uncaring by the way. It’s just the mindset of farmer, it’s different. I think it’s the same mindset in which they keep farming even when the farm isn’t profitable because they’re a farmer and that’s what farmers do.

DistanceCall · 04/10/2021 12:03

I eat meat. I haven't slaughtered animals myself, but my family used to have a farm, and I have often watched animals be slaughtered (and then eaten them). As long as it's done as humanely as possible, I have no problem with it.

And yes, I wouldn't mind slaughtering an animal myself if I was taught to do it properly.

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 04/10/2021 12:03

I think there's a difference here actually between willingness to carry out (or witness) the slaughter vs animal welfare standards during the creature's life. I think life is more important than the brief moment of death, and i think there must be so much cognitive dissonance involved in buying cheap meat (and eggs/dairy) and things which contain them as ingredients.

I think there's something in our advanced economy, where as consumers (decision makers) we're removed from the processes of production and we can ignore SO MUCH of the shit we're funding as a result. Poor animal welfare, air-freighting fruit, production processes with an extraordinary carbon footprint etc.

Do I want to go back to an agrarian society - no.

Do I think I'm perfect on this myself - definitely not.

It's scary stuff when you sit and contemplate it though. So much of the damage we're directly responsible for is out of sight and out of mind.

KylieKoKo · 04/10/2021 12:01

@hashbrownsandwich the egg industry grinds up up male baby chicks at one day old as it's not profitable to keep them as they don't lay eggs. You eat eggs as a vegetarian, so surely you should be ok doing this yourself.

jewel1968 · 04/10/2021 12:01

Yes I think people should eat whatever they eat consciously. Meat eaters should be aware of slaughter and welfare and vegetarians should be alert to treatment of workers that pick their veg. We should all be aware of the impact ultra processed food has on the environment which includes vegan and vegetarian.

I grew up on a farm so yes I am a bit like OP's DH.

itsgrand · 04/10/2021 12:00

I do agree there needs to be more awareness and understanding of where our food comes from overall tbh, not just meat.

LukeEvansWife · 04/10/2021 11:59

I freely admit that I wouldn't eat meat if I had to slaughter it. I come from a farming family who have no issue with it but I couldn't do it.

If I was a vegetarian and didn't eat dairy products, I would be an unhealthy one as I wouldn't be able to have alternative protein.

We are all hypocrites in some way.

itsgrand · 04/10/2021 11:58

@hashbrownsandwich

Should be comfortable to slaughter animals if they are happy to eat them?

The 'cheap chicken' threads have got me onto this and I'm at home with covid so be gentle!

My own personal background is that I am vegetarian and have been since I was 7. Own decision. I cook meat for my children and my husband because I believe, like i was given, it's a choice that can be made for themselves.

My husband is from farming background and has proactively raised and slaughtered animals. His conscience is entirely clear because he very much has the farmer mindset of raise the animal, give them a good life, dispatch and consume.

It's coming up to 'Turkey time' on the family farm and with the so called shortages forecast this year, I've found myself having more conversations with colleagues about the food chain/supply etc.

We live in an affluent area and we have lots of farm shops, butchers etc. However, I'm shocked that most people I know have said while they couldn't give up meat, they also wouldn't be happy to raise animals for slaughter themselves or to witness their slaughter.

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Just to say, what I've tried in a long winded way above is that i'm not a preachy veggie and I'm not vegan.

I get what you are saying but it's like saying oh you eat potatoes so go out to the field and dig them yourself. Or you like coconuts go climb the tree and get them yourself. In our modern society we pay a lot of people to do things that we don't want or cant do. Hairdressers, caterers, coffee shops, nail bars, pubs, cleaners, laundromats, dog groomers, dog walkers, taxi drivers, massages.

I am a veggie and don't eat meat. Cannot bear the thought of animal slaughter. Breaks my heart. Gives me nightmares just thinking about those animals going into the slaughter house.

However I do think it is a bit preachy to say if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter to the point of doing it yourself.

daisyjgrey · 04/10/2021 11:56

Yes, this is why my partner is veggie and I'm not. We have different background and different experiences.

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 04/10/2021 11:56

@HangingOver

What meat eater doesn't cook meat?

Labrador?

Lol it was this I'm referring to "I would expand your opening statement to include people who are happy to cook meat."

So which people don't cook meat?

knittingaddict · 04/10/2021 11:56

No one has to pass some kind of test devised by you to eat what the hell they like, so I'll be declining thank you.

Wazzzzzzzup · 04/10/2021 11:56

@Learnthroughplay3

I have never understood why most people love their pet who has a brain heart feelings but can eat other animals bacause its the norm
It's different when is your pet. Kind of like when it's your spouse you care a lot, but you don't really give a fuck about other' spouses. Because they are not yours and be with you all the time and have connection.

We never named our animals bread for meat (and fur, rabbits).

EllieSattler · 04/10/2021 11:55

This is a daft argument really. It didn't stop people eating meat though the ages. People would get used to it pretty fast. I would do it if I had to, but I'd rather not, much like I'd rather not perform brain surgery but would accept it if I needed it.

Charlotte2020 · 04/10/2021 11:55

Sounding a bit preachy. Would you watch footage of the modern slavery/ sweatshops that make your clothes and tech?
I fully admit I eat meat- but try to buy the best welfare standards I can.

HangingOver · 04/10/2021 11:55

What meat eater doesn't cook meat?

Labrador?

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 04/10/2021 11:54

So... a 5yo wants to make a chicken sandwich... they have to be the one to kill the chicken?

When my dad was 5 he used to be sent out to kill a chicken for the dinner. He said he'd trot out with his knife (1940s childhood!), grab the chicken, pull its head back and cut it's throat. And wouldn't think twice about it. He's in his 80s now and has definitely softened and become more squeamish and wouldn't have the stomach to do it now.

HangingOver · 04/10/2021 11:54

BeastOfBODMAS you're speaking my language. Followed by some of those nice chocolate cakes made by Oggs.

Plus I get to call the neighbor's cat a "bloody furry murderer" with a clear conscience whenever she brings me a mouse. Grin

mustlovegin · 04/10/2021 11:53

Nobody and nothing will guilt trip me (or my family) into not eating meat OP (if that's what you are trying to do)

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 04/10/2021 11:53

@SoupDragon

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Surely if you are happy to cook meat for your family, you should also be OK with animal slaughter. I would expand your opening statement to include people who are happy to cook meat.

What meat eater doesn't cook meat?
LBOCS2 · 04/10/2021 11:52

@Learnthroughplay3

I have never understood why most people love their pet who has a brain heart feelings but can eat other animals bacause its the norm

It's a big assumption to make that people wouldn't do that in extremis. Come the zompoc and our guinea pigs are the first things on the barbecue 🤷🏼‍♀️ we have the luxury of keeping animals as pets because we have an abundance of food; if the situation changed then I suspect people's attitudes to pets would too.

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 04/10/2021 11:52

@Learnthroughplay3

I have never understood why most people love their pet who has a brain heart feelings but can eat other animals bacause its the norm
Well you answered it already. Because it's the norm. 🤷 I'm not attached to a chicken that's been farmed for slaughter. I would be attached to a dog that lives with me and that I have to feed to keep alive and walk and play and get fusses from. Etc
lughnasadh · 04/10/2021 11:51

I'd happily raise, be fond of, and kill anything I wanted to eat.

Unless we're all given a plot of the extortionately expensive British land to keep those animals on though, it would be tricky.

I'd probably be arrested if I rolled up to an abatoir and started after the cow I wanted.

SparryG · 04/10/2021 11:50

I am comfortable with farmers or whoever to kill animals for me to buy then eat. I get what you are saying but its pretty pointless. I suspect most meat eaters are happily ignorant and if they had to kill their food first probably would be reluctant. But then again if we didn't have shops selling food I don't suspect any of us would turn our noses up, we would get on with hunting and gathering. Do u see what I mean?!

BeastOfBODMAS · 04/10/2021 11:50

@HangingOver exactly! A full day out in the elements line catching a suitably sustainable fish or beans on toast and a nice sit down? Grin