Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that meat eaters...

410 replies

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 11:26

Should be comfortable to slaughter animals if they are happy to eat them?

The 'cheap chicken' threads have got me onto this and I'm at home with covid so be gentle!

My own personal background is that I am vegetarian and have been since I was 7. Own decision. I cook meat for my children and my husband because I believe, like i was given, it's a choice that can be made for themselves.

My husband is from farming background and has proactively raised and slaughtered animals. His conscience is entirely clear because he very much has the farmer mindset of raise the animal, give them a good life, dispatch and consume.

It's coming up to 'Turkey time' on the family farm and with the so called shortages forecast this year, I've found myself having more conversations with colleagues about the food chain/supply etc.

We live in an affluent area and we have lots of farm shops, butchers etc. However, I'm shocked that most people I know have said while they couldn't give up meat, they also wouldn't be happy to raise animals for slaughter themselves or to witness their slaughter.

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Just to say, what I've tried in a long winded way above is that i'm not a preachy veggie and I'm not vegan.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 04/10/2021 12:55

So anyone who doesn’t want to drive because they’re too nervous or find it too difficult should never travel in a motor vehicle then? How about having an operation if you’re squeamish or needle phobic? What about being a pilot? Or a nanny? Or refuse collector? Or working in sewers? Or deep sea diving? We exist as societies so that we can work together to use different skills and tolerances. I think it’s a silly argument myself

Goldbar · 04/10/2021 12:55

This is a ridiculous argument.

I'm happy to have heart surgery if I need it but there's no way I'm volunteering to perform it on anyone else any time soon (nor would I be permitted to!). Does that make me a hypocrite?

We all perform different roles to make society function. Very few of these roles can be performed without some sort of training. Slaughtering animals humanely is hardly unskilled work.

Also, aren't we trying to reduce the number of guns in circulation? I'm not sure requiring meat-eaters to go out and kill their dinner themselves is going to achieve this.

Yes, we should all be trying to reduce our meat consumption, but that's a different argument.

Suitcaseseverywhere · 04/10/2021 12:54

Head = rope.

I wasn’t in danger

Suitcaseseverywhere · 04/10/2021 12:53

I’ve done a job where I saw the kill lines.

It’s not nice but I wasn’t squeamish about it and if it was the only job I could get, I’d do it.

Also have seen injured animals get the bolt gun close up (held the head of one)

Is this what you wanted to hear @hashbrownsandwich or doesn’t it fit with your narrative?

FourteenSixteenTwentyTwo · 04/10/2021 12:53

My husband is from farming background and has proactively raised and slaughtered animals. His conscience is entirely clear because he very much has the farmer mindset of raise the animal, give them a good life, dispatch and consume.

Whilst I understand your sentiment, I don’t see from the above why people who source ethical meat from a good farm can’t equally have a clear conscience. Not everyone has the technical know-how to slaughter an animal. I’m sure if I tried to slaughter a sheep or a cow I’d just end up causing it more suffering.

ShrikeAttack · 04/10/2021 12:53

I've shot pheasants, dispatched a chicken, killed lobsters, shucked oysters, caught fish and collected shellfish to eat, but I'm not about to go into the field next door and wrestle a cow to the ground.

Am I still allowed to eat beef?

DismantledKing · 04/10/2021 12:52

But in extremis the cats would be eaten before I starved or started snacking on the neighbours!

I wouldn’t eat my neighbours. One would taste of dope for one thing.

FourTeaFallOut · 04/10/2021 12:51

@DismantledKing

The preachy vegetarians are active in AIBU today
It's definitely Vegans Assemble today on aibu.
Talipesmum · 04/10/2021 12:51

Yes, I’m fully aware of where meat comes from, and I’m not squeamish about it. I make sure the children are (age appropriately) aware too. No “eeeww raw meat is too disgusting for me to touch or think about” here.
If I was properly trained and / or had to, yes I’d do it myself. But obv I’m not.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 04/10/2021 12:51

@PissedOffAgain Grin I stopped getting a veg box because I didn’t want to have to wash off that much mud from my potatoes!

NoYOUbekind · 04/10/2021 12:51

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@hashbrownsandwich I kind of agree.

If everyone was made to kill their own animal before they could get the meat, 99% of people would be vegetarians!!![/quote]
I don't think the population of Tudor England, say, was 99% veggie.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 04/10/2021 12:50

But in extremis the cats would be eaten before I starved or started snacking on the neighbours!

I definitely prefer cats to my neighbours Blush

PissedOffAgain · 04/10/2021 12:49

I love salad but would be less keen/probably wouldn't eat it if I had to pick it myself

NoYOUbekind · 04/10/2021 12:49

I hate threads like this because they reek of privilege. Someone slaughtered that bit of meat you're eating (or cooking for someone else) and that someone doesn't actually deserve to be the target of internet snootiness and othering. They're people too, not machines, doing a horrible job for not a lot of money so our supermarkets can have food on the shelves.

I guess no-one was clapping for the abattoir workers though, eh? Just the nice, clean keyworkers.

LobsterNapkin · 04/10/2021 12:48

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@hashbrownsandwich I kind of agree.

If everyone was made to kill their own animal before they could get the meat, 99% of people would be vegetarians!!![/quote]
That's clearly not true from a historical perspective though.

In fact you could argue it's the other way around. In societies where there are historically groups of vegetarians, they are typically well off and high in the class system, and certainly are not farmers. The farmers they depend on raise and eat meat.

SuperstarDog · 04/10/2021 12:46

I’m a vegan and I just hope that one day we stop treating animals the way we do. I think a lot of people don’t realise what animal farming involves. For example I’m involved with various animal rights groups and it’s very clear when talking to the public that what free range and organic actually mean are very different to public perception. Most people are genuinely shocked when they see footage or hear about farming practices.

I try not to preach as I don’t think it’s helpful. I think most people are uncomfortable with animals being killed and exploited, it’s unpleasant and most people would rather it didn’t have to happen but they’re often just not ready for big changes yet. But we are seeing people cut down their meat consumption, use plant alternatives to milk and being more aware of the issues, which is a good thing.

The things I’ve seen break my heart though. I struggle with people who say they don’t care, they just want meat regardless but to be fair there’s not many of those around. Most people care, it’s just getting them to care more.

firstimemamma · 04/10/2021 12:46

I absolutely hate eating meat and am much, much better suited to a life of vegetarianism but for the 9 short months that I'm pregnant I'm eating meat 1-2 times per week for nutrition reasons.

DismantledKing · 04/10/2021 12:46

The preachy vegetarians are active in AIBU today

Horst · 04/10/2021 12:45

I could and would have have done it. We have brought in day old female chicks and raised them on. We also grow our our fruit and veg.

I’d love to keep some pigs tbh but it’s paperwork.

pointythings · 04/10/2021 12:44

Wouldn't bother me. I would and I have killed animals - always injured ones who had been run over, but still. There's nothing wrong with taking responsibility for one's food choices, we should all do it.

BFrazzled · 04/10/2021 12:43

You write in your own op that you feed your children meat. How is it morally different in your mind from eating meat yourself? You choose to have children and this directly causes animal slaughter, because you then choose to feed them meat...So are you yourself ok with slaughtering animals to give your children meat? If not, what are you asking?

LobsterNapkin · 04/10/2021 12:43

I don't know, should vegetarians be comfortable with the problems of industrial plant agriculture and lab grown food? Yes, in a way.

Most people today don't have much opportunity to be really connected to their food production, of any type. For that matter a lot of people now have very little real experience with death up close at all. Having a pet put down is about as far as it goes, all handled very cleanly.

In the not so distant past though, many did deal with death of people and animals, more people were directly involved in farming, many people who were not farmers still had some productive or working animals, and most people found that when their livelihood depends upon it, they can in fact slaughter an animal.

I would say the reason so many now find the idea difficult has nothing to do with their convictions, or hypocrisy, it's caused by the fact that modern urban living is so isolated from nature and the roots of its own sustenance.

BelleOfTheProvince · 04/10/2021 12:39

Not going to rtwt (sorry) as it will be full of the usual vegan bashing.

However, I do think it is a shame that although even though most meat eaters want a better quality of life for animals, instead of delivering this they are sold labels which misrepresent what they are actually buying/supporting.

If you look at the actual requirements animals raised for meat have to meet to make even 'high welfare' labels such as RSPCA, the standards are a lot lower than what the actual consumer thinks is even standard practice.

Obviously there are a lot of things that would need to change to push up animal welfare as a whole, but if I was a meat eater I think I would be annoyed at being deceived as a consumer.

I also think that those who work in animal slaughter are hugely underpaid, have very poor health and safety and are often very vulnerable. Very few people do that job out of anything but necessity. Of course, making it a safer and more fair work environment would push up meat prices and I would hope people are willing to pay that.

It's an industry that does very well by hiding away the unpleasant bits, whereas warehouse workers in Amazon are less taboo.

HuhWhatNow · 04/10/2021 12:39

I was raised around farming and a few times my family had small holdings with a little livestock. We raised our lambs ourselves and took them to the slaughterhouse ourselves. I have never personally dispatched an animal but I don't believe I am a hypocrite because of that. I am morally okay with having my own meat slaughtered for me. The real hypocrites to me are those who balk at the idea of having any knowledge of the processes but still want the meat. Those telling their children that meat comes from a supermarket and not from the body of a dead animal.

I raised my kids to be fully aware of where meat comes from and to buy better meat, buying free range and supporting home raised meat rather than imported stuff where farming and slaughtering standards are questionable (and yes, I know that the UK still has some awful farmers and abattoirs who break the rules, but they are breaking actual rules. When discovered they are subject to prosecution)

I'm all for vegetarianism (I get it. Eating the flesh of a dead animal. Ew) but ethics and berating meat eaters shouldn't come into it if you still eat dairy. Dairy is linked so strongly to the meat industry that you would not have dairy without it.
And even wearing wool? Wool shearing is perfectly harmless to the sheep (and is actually a requirement for health) but without us eating lamb, there'd be nothing to shear.

I don't need to kill my own food, I just shouldn't be ignorant of it.

MyPatronusIsACat · 04/10/2021 12:38

@hashbrownsandwich I kind of agree.

If everyone was made to kill their own animal before they could get the meat, 99% of people would be vegetarians!!!