Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that meat eaters...

410 replies

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 11:26

Should be comfortable to slaughter animals if they are happy to eat them?

The 'cheap chicken' threads have got me onto this and I'm at home with covid so be gentle!

My own personal background is that I am vegetarian and have been since I was 7. Own decision. I cook meat for my children and my husband because I believe, like i was given, it's a choice that can be made for themselves.

My husband is from farming background and has proactively raised and slaughtered animals. His conscience is entirely clear because he very much has the farmer mindset of raise the animal, give them a good life, dispatch and consume.

It's coming up to 'Turkey time' on the family farm and with the so called shortages forecast this year, I've found myself having more conversations with colleagues about the food chain/supply etc.

We live in an affluent area and we have lots of farm shops, butchers etc. However, I'm shocked that most people I know have said while they couldn't give up meat, they also wouldn't be happy to raise animals for slaughter themselves or to witness their slaughter.

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Just to say, what I've tried in a long winded way above is that i'm not a preachy veggie and I'm not vegan.

OP posts:
NotFrozen · 04/10/2021 13:09

If I had to kill an animal to survive, then of course I would do it.

This kind of thinking reminds me of an exercise when I was in year 6 on a school trip. We had to kill and cook a chicken. I took on the role of holding the chicken as its head was chopped off. Of course I was worried about hurting the chicken and didn’t hold it properly. In hindsight I think it was cruel for the chicken as it wasn’t the neatest execution.

I’m not sure what point the school was trying to make and it seems like a pretty ridiculous exercise- we all knew where chicken comes from and killing one didn’t change that!

HouseOfFire · 04/10/2021 13:08

@Miliao

I don’t think I could work as a sewage plant operator, does that mean I shouldn’t poo in my own loo?
of course, how can you take a shit in a toilet if you won't work in a sewage plant?
toolazytothinkofausername · 04/10/2021 13:08

YANBU! Meat is packaged so nicely you wouldn't know it was an animal if you were an alien. Same with dairy products Angry

malificent7 · 04/10/2021 13:08

Shot*

BelleOfTheProvince · 04/10/2021 13:07

@Couchbettato

Hugh fearnley-whittingstall did a series on showing people how to raise and slaughter their animals, and then how to cook with that food.

He also talked about not wasting any meat and appreciating that an animal gave it's life for that food.

That's a strong ethic I abide by, and I do think that we should understand what that animal went through if we are going to eat it's meat.

I don't think it would turn people vegetarian. I think it would teach people a new appreciation.

There's a lot of evidence that eating the whole animal(obviously in addition to a variety of vegetables and fruits) is a lot better for life longevity than the current 'prime cuts' people like.

In the first half of the Victorian era poorer people who made it past the high infant mortality danger lived lives similar in length to our own. Probably down to the 'no waste' elements of their diet, no processed food etc.

There's obviously not a meat free comparison as, in countries where this happened historically they tended to be a particular incomparable group. Like monks for example.

malificent7 · 04/10/2021 13:07

I'm a bad shoy so tbh it would prob be kinder for meat to be slaughtered humanely. That said I absolutely would hunt for meat if i was starving as would most people i rekon.
I'm an ex vegan btw.

LennyAndTheDucks · 04/10/2021 13:07

Some people just don't have that skill set and it's just one of those emotionally-loaded arguments used to make meat eaters feel guilty.

Nobody can make you feel guilty.

If you feel guilty then that is on you. Perhaps you should have a think about why.

EverdeRose · 04/10/2021 13:07

Will you be sending your kids out to work in the rice paddys OP? Are you aware of the cruelty done to small children and animals in many food industries like coffee, chocolate, rice, all vegan friendly.

Its an idealistic view of the world, there are far larger problems we take no accountability for.

I'd probably be happy to rear and slaughter an animal for food. I wouldn't be happy to send my child down a cobalt mine, but I use a mobile phone.

FourTeaFallOut · 04/10/2021 13:05

Actually I don't consume eggs. I'm not vegan but I chose not to eat eggs. All our eggs are from our own chickens.

So you don't eat the eggs from the chickens that you have? Confused

HuhWhatNow · 04/10/2021 13:04

@BelleOfTheProvince I agree with you here. The whole industry needs a bigger shake up than those attempted in the past. We still have too many slaughterhouses breaking the rules and it not coming to light. Farming methods in the UK are pretty good on the whole and a lot of my friends farm and the livestock are happy and healthy but there will always be room for improvement, even for the good ones.

I knew a farmer who was an absolutely vile piece of shit who gave no thought to his livestock's quality of life. If he took 30 cattle to slaughter, at least 4 or 5 would be sent away because they had eye abscesses, broken legs or god knows what else wrong. On the one hand it was good that abattoirs had health standards but the fact he was just sent home, no investigations or follow ups meant that it was just him losing out financially when the beast died at home or he was forced to treat it enough to get it to a killable state. And when he'd leave his ewes in a cattle building for days without food the RSPCA were as much use as a chocolate teapot.

I eat meat. I just want higher welfare standards too. I've raised my own and felt no guilt about taking them to be slaughtered and butchered. It's why we raised them, but they did live a happy life too.

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 13:04

@Georgyporky

There are a lot of "Pick Your Own" places. How about a "Kill your own turkey" for those farms with labour shortages ?

You've just saved Christmas Grin

OP posts:
onelittlefrog · 04/10/2021 13:04

@hangrylady

I'm a bit ashamed to say that even though I eat meat I don't think I could bring myself to do the killing. When I see meat in a butcher or supermarket I don't think of it as an animal, just food and I'd go vegetarian if I had to kill animals myself which is hypocritical. Just being honest.
It's not hypocritical. Many people are similar to you and it's the way our society works, it's nothing to be ashamed of.

I think it's a daft argument to say that if you eat meat you should kill the animal yourself. Some people just don't have that skill set and it's just one of those emotionally-loaded arguments used to make meat eaters feel guilty.

(For context I don't eat much meat myself, but this kind of argument frustrates me).

Even back in stone age/ neanderthal tribes, certain people would be hunters and others would not.

There has never been a human society where everybody who consumes meat has to be involved in its slaughter and preparation.

Societies distribute work according to who is the most capable and best suited for the job, and our current society is simply that on a larger scale.

amylou8 · 04/10/2021 13:01

Yes I agree completely. I am uncomfortable eating meat, and am 99% of the time vegetarian. I'll eat it occasionally for convenience, having dinner at MILs or abroad when there's no other choice. Unless I was actually starving I couldn't slaughter an animal, and that removes my right to eat one simply because it tastes good.

user1478172746 · 04/10/2021 13:01

In small farms it usually wasn't that every member of family butchered large animals. You need to have skills and strenght to do that. People would invite skillfull neighbours or professionals and then assisted them.

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 13:01

[quote KylieKoKo]@hashbrownsandwich the egg industry grinds up up male baby chicks at one day old as it's not profitable to keep them as they don't lay eggs. You eat eggs as a vegetarian, so surely you should be ok doing this yourself.[/quote]

Actually I don't consume eggs. I'm not vegan but I chose not to eat eggs. All our eggs are from our own chickens. I know somewhere along the line there have been male chicks killed in this process and I accept that, rightly or wrongly.

OP posts:
PissedOffAgain · 04/10/2021 13:00

[quote NeedAHoliday2021]@PissedOffAgain Grin I stopped getting a veg box because I didn’t want to have to wash off that much mud from my potatoes![/quote]
Grin My OH also has an allotment - am still not hauling my arse up there to pick things when the nice man from Sainsburys' brings me stuff (and judges me for my alcohol intake and smoking - I don't pick the tobacco or the hops either!)

HappyDays101010 · 04/10/2021 12:59

The only reason we wouldn't is that we're not used to it, and it's not part of our culture. In societies where people are used to it, they do it, no problem. So would we if we had to.

strawberrydonuts · 04/10/2021 12:58

Genuinely this was why I went vegetarian. My 7 year old brain couldn't work out why the dog was safe but the pig in the field next to me was now a sausage

I really don't understand vegetarians who preach about animal welfare. The dairy industry is just as bad if not worse in many ways.

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 12:58

@SoupDragon

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Surely if you are happy to cook meat for your family, you should also be OK with animal slaughter. I would expand your opening statement to include people who are happy to cook meat.

This is a good point, thank you.

OP posts:
Couchbettato · 04/10/2021 12:57

Hugh fearnley-whittingstall did a series on showing people how to raise and slaughter their animals, and then how to cook with that food.

He also talked about not wasting any meat and appreciating that an animal gave it's life for that food.

That's a strong ethic I abide by, and I do think that we should understand what that animal went through if we are going to eat it's meat.

I don't think it would turn people vegetarian. I think it would teach people a new appreciation.

onelittlefrog · 04/10/2021 12:57

@BungleandGeorge

So anyone who doesn’t want to drive because they’re too nervous or find it too difficult should never travel in a motor vehicle then? How about having an operation if you’re squeamish or needle phobic? What about being a pilot? Or a nanny? Or refuse collector? Or working in sewers? Or deep sea diving? We exist as societies so that we can work together to use different skills and tolerances. I think it’s a silly argument myself
Agree with this.

We all use the sewer systems, it doesn't mean we'd all want to work in them or deal with raw sewage ourselves.

It's pretty much the same thing.

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 12:57

@Learnthroughplay3

I have never understood why most people love their pet who has a brain heart feelings but can eat other animals bacause its the norm

Genuinely this was why I went vegetarian. My 7 year old brain couldn't work out why the dog was safe but the pig in the field next to me was now a sausage.

OP posts:
Mamadothehump · 04/10/2021 12:56

Oh, fuck off with your sanctimonious shit. I'll eat meat if I want.
Where exactly does this "argument" end? We all do/use/consume things that we haven't built, grown etc.
Why does this even bother you? If you don't want to eat meat then don't. End of story 🙄

Pheasantlysurprised · 04/10/2021 12:55

we are so glad you live in an affluent area, as I am sure many will flock to identify with, including myself, because who wants to appear 'pov' on mums net ? -

But, I agree with you about meat. Im all but down with it and getting tired of fucking mackerel with everything. More or less the entire food industry (and I am including organic shite aimed at the aspiring classes) is poison.

onelittlefrog · 04/10/2021 12:55

Im not sure you can necessarily conflate "morally ok with" with "happy to do it yourself

This really. They are not the same thing. Slaughter is a messy and unpleasant job. You can be morally OK with it happening but not want to do it yourself.

I don't do everything else in life myself because I live in 21st Century Western society.

If you consume dairy products you also have the same dilemma surely. The dairy industry is pretty horrendous.