Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that meat eaters...

410 replies

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 11:26

Should be comfortable to slaughter animals if they are happy to eat them?

The 'cheap chicken' threads have got me onto this and I'm at home with covid so be gentle!

My own personal background is that I am vegetarian and have been since I was 7. Own decision. I cook meat for my children and my husband because I believe, like i was given, it's a choice that can be made for themselves.

My husband is from farming background and has proactively raised and slaughtered animals. His conscience is entirely clear because he very much has the farmer mindset of raise the animal, give them a good life, dispatch and consume.

It's coming up to 'Turkey time' on the family farm and with the so called shortages forecast this year, I've found myself having more conversations with colleagues about the food chain/supply etc.

We live in an affluent area and we have lots of farm shops, butchers etc. However, I'm shocked that most people I know have said while they couldn't give up meat, they also wouldn't be happy to raise animals for slaughter themselves or to witness their slaughter.

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Just to say, what I've tried in a long winded way above is that i'm not a preachy veggie and I'm not vegan.

OP posts:
godmum56 · 04/10/2021 13:32

yes yabu.

ChamberofSecrets69 · 04/10/2021 13:31

Do you really think that's fair to ask though? Most people (through no fault of their own) didn't grow up caring for animals that were only being raised for slaughter, therefore we wouldn't have the ability to disassociate the kill with the food if we had to kill them. Obviously we aren't, therefore, capable of killing for food. Your husband is used to that environment, yet still chooses to eat meat, so it hasn't put him off.

If we had grown up in that environment, it would be very much a normal thing to us, and therefore we wouldn't bat an eyelid. It's very unfair to ask that of people who aren't used to it.

Animals eat animals, we always have and probably always will.

RedToothBrush · 04/10/2021 13:30

Vegetarians should volunteer 2 weeks a year in the fields of the UK to increase our harvest and so we don't have to fly in hundreds of Eastern Europeans who are exploited by modern slavery in British agriculture.

Just yesterday I was watching a news report on the subject and how the new visa scheme isn't working and how recruiters are misleading those who are looking to come work here and how poor the conditions are for humans.

Or they could knock off the sanctimous crap about how other people should do x, y and z in a nasty puritanical confrontational manner, rather than just exposing poor practices in our food supply chain.

HarrietsChariot · 04/10/2021 13:29

I'd quite like to give hunting and slaughtering my own animals ago, it looks like it would be a lot of fun. Thing is, it's illegal in this country to hunt and butcher animals, even wild ones like deer.

I think the idea that "meat eaters should be comfortable slaughtering animals themselves" is missing the point though. While I'd love to kill my own meat, others are not, but so what? I'm happy to call the fire brigade if my house is burning down, but not to run into a burning building myself. I'll undergo surgery in hospital if I need to without worrying that I wouldn't be able to return the favour to the surgeon.

Different people have different skills. That's how a society works, everyone does their job and each job feeds into other what other people do.

Anyway, if it were wrong for a meat eater not to slaughter their own meat, it would be equally wrong for a vegan to eat food they haven't grown themselves, or to buy from a shop that sells meat, or buy (vegan) food that has been transported in a lorry by a potential non-vegan.

StoppinBy · 04/10/2021 13:29

I agree with you. We have raised several batches of chicks and we always cull out the roosters ourselves.

On the other hand, in my personal opinion, vegetarians are hypocrites. Animals are still killed along the way so that you can have your egg and dairy products.

Are you prepared to kill a baby bull calf so the milk can be taken from the mother? Are you prepared to cull out the male chicks so only the egg laying hens are kept to produce your eggs?

If not then you should hardly be asking this question of 'meat eaters'.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 04/10/2021 13:28

People will continue to eat meat no matter what. Posts like this won’t stop that and however we’ll intentioned it does come across a bit preachy. I think more focus on animal welfare and campaigning for acceptable standards would be more productive.

BelleOfTheProvince · 04/10/2021 13:28

I knew a farmer who was an absolutely vile piece of shit who gave no thought to his livestock's quality of life. If he took 30 cattle to slaughter, at least 4 or 5 would be sent away because they had eye abscesses, broken legs or god knows what else wrong. On the one hand it was good that abattoirs had health standards but the fact he was just sent home, no investigations or follow ups meant that it was just him losing out financially when the beast died at home or he was forced to treat it enough to get it to a killable state. And when he'd leave his ewes in a cattle building for days without food the RSPCA were as much use as a chocolate teapot

I'd also be interested to know if both your livestock get the same 'label' after slaughter , as that's quite a stark difference but I imagine that they still meet the requirements for a label of some sort.

HalzTangz · 04/10/2021 13:28

@hashbrownsandwich

Should be comfortable to slaughter animals if they are happy to eat them?

The 'cheap chicken' threads have got me onto this and I'm at home with covid so be gentle!

My own personal background is that I am vegetarian and have been since I was 7. Own decision. I cook meat for my children and my husband because I believe, like i was given, it's a choice that can be made for themselves.

My husband is from farming background and has proactively raised and slaughtered animals. His conscience is entirely clear because he very much has the farmer mindset of raise the animal, give them a good life, dispatch and consume.

It's coming up to 'Turkey time' on the family farm and with the so called shortages forecast this year, I've found myself having more conversations with colleagues about the food chain/supply etc.

We live in an affluent area and we have lots of farm shops, butchers etc. However, I'm shocked that most people I know have said while they couldn't give up meat, they also wouldn't be happy to raise animals for slaughter themselves or to witness their slaughter.

So AIBU to to believe, if you're going to eat meat, it's your moral duty to be ok with animal slaughter?

Just to say, what I've tried in a long winded way above is that i'm not a preachy veggie and I'm not vegan.

Would your children slaughter?

You are preaching, you are in a long winded way saying if you want meat, breed and slaughter it yourself.

If we all did that what would farmers do for a living?

FluffyBooBoo · 04/10/2021 13:25

So... a 5yo wants to make a chicken sandwich... they have to be the one to kill the chicken?

You are talking to the wrong person! I was kinda making a facetious point about the ops beliefs and how someone could have a belief that the op was in the wrong for cooking meat.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 04/10/2021 13:25

Well by that reasoning if you cook meat for your family to eat then you are complicit. Does that mean you would be willing to slaughter animals?

wanttomarryamillionaire · 04/10/2021 13:22

I know it's awful and very hypocritical but I couldn't do it! I wouldn't be able to eat it if i had seen what happens to it. Im one of those people who like my meat to be all pre packed so it doesn't actually look like an animal if that makes sense. Ive tried being vegan before and lasted 5 days, its so restrictive and the alternatives are nothing like meat.

Xenia · 04/10/2021 13:20

Yes, fine by me.

anon12345678901 · 04/10/2021 13:19

If I had to, I would, it wouldn't stop me eating meat. I'm not attached to a farmyard animal and would look at it as a food source only.

Waternoice · 04/10/2021 13:19

I'd have no issue with dispatching an animal for consumption, my main concern is I would make a hash of it, and cause the creature undue stress whilst wrangling it into position, ready to be stunned and killed.
But my views are informed by growing up on a farm, raising livestock for slaughter and subsequently working in the food industry where I saw the meat processing industry from farm, to abatoir and ultimately to fork.

PinkiOcelot · 04/10/2021 13:17

Ahhh FFS!! What a load of crap!

DismantledKing · 04/10/2021 13:17

I’m not sure that a bunch of amateur slaughterers hitting pigs over the head with hammers, or chasing chickens round the garden with their heads hanging off due to incompetence, is going to advance animal
welfare standards.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/10/2021 13:16

Ps again though I would want training in how to do it as humanely as possible/minimise suffering to the animal.

BelleOfTheProvince · 04/10/2021 13:16

@HuhWhatNow yes, I do think it would be better all round if there was more transparency.
It would mean people actually providing a lot higher welfare than the bare minimum would get business, rather than those just hiding behind confusing welfare labels and technicalities.

It would mean consumers would be making an informed choice, either to eat higher welfare, not eat meat or decide welfare is not important to them.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/10/2021 13:16

I'd be ok with slaughtering an animal for consumption. I've butchered a deer before and am not squeamish about the realities of raising livestock for food.

onedayiwillmissthis · 04/10/2021 13:14

I keep hens for eggs and have considered raising chickens for meat. However, I would only do this if I could be taught how to kill them with the minimum suffering to the bird. I'm not prepared to just 'have a go' after reading a book or watching a video. I would need an experienced person to show me and be able to swiftly assist while I learnt. I think this would be my main concern with slaughtering any creature.

Chewbecca · 04/10/2021 13:14

That is quite preachy IMO.

I would prefer not to slaughter myself, no. But I am well aware that's what happens.

YABU

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 13:12

To add, I'm totally not judging those who do eat meat, I live in a house of meat eaters. My sons often like to remind me 'who' we are eating. I guess I'm a cop out because I know my husband can and does do the slaughter.

There have been some very good points made on here and I'll be thinking a lot of them over.

OP posts:
easterndreaming · 04/10/2021 13:12

@NellWilsonsWhiteHair

I think there's a difference here actually between willingness to carry out (or witness) the slaughter vs animal welfare standards during the creature's life. I think life is more important than the brief moment of death, and i think there must be so much cognitive dissonance involved in buying cheap meat (and eggs/dairy) and things which contain them as ingredients.

I think there's something in our advanced economy, where as consumers (decision makers) we're removed from the processes of production and we can ignore SO MUCH of the shit we're funding as a result. Poor animal welfare, air-freighting fruit, production processes with an extraordinary carbon footprint etc.

Do I want to go back to an agrarian society - no.

Do I think I'm perfect on this myself - definitely not.

It's scary stuff when you sit and contemplate it though. So much of the damage we're directly responsible for is out of sight and out of mind.

I think these are some very good points. To be honest, this topic is the same as any other issue. Some people will have a fuller grasp into how they work and other people, either because they don't want to acknowledge or aren't able or capable to process all the relevant information will not understand how the world works. Sometimes we also choose to not think about issues because, as individuals we cannot solve everything in this world, and who is to say what is the correct way anyway. We also run the risk of mental fatigue, our lives have become so complex. There was a scene on the good place which talked about how the world was so difficult, that making ethical choices was almost impossible, unless you maybe lived as a hermit. I don't have the answer basically
Just10moreminutesplease · 04/10/2021 13:11

I think you would have a point if you included people who buy and cook meat in your argument.

Surely once you’ve paid for it and served it up you might as well be eating it for all the good it does?

hashbrownsandwich · 04/10/2021 13:10

@FourTeaFallOut

Actually I don't consume eggs. I'm not vegan but I chose not to eat eggs. All our eggs are from our own chickens.

So you don't eat the eggs from the chickens that you have? Confused

Not personally no, the family do because again they like them and that's their choice.

OP posts: