Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask MEAT EATERS if you buy free range or standard chicken?

283 replies

Granllanog · 04/10/2021 11:03

I got attacked on my last thread for saying I buy standard supermarket chicken. Considering only 4% of all of the chicken produced in the UK is free-range and only 1% is organic I don't think I am unusual in doing this?

YABU = I'm a meat eater and only ever eat/buy free-range chicken.
YANBU = I buy standard chicken.

OP posts:
thegcatsmother · 04/10/2021 12:27

Free range chicken as I can now afford it; however, I would not judge anyone who didn't if they are on a budget and have a family to feed. I think it's more important to feed your kids than anything else.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 04/10/2021 12:27

Broiler chickens are a difficult one. They don't really get a chance to have what we would call a 'natural' life, given it is so short and they are living in massive flocks in large barns.
Even free range chickens often don't like to go outside, they are originally forest birds and don't like to roam far in exposed fields. So even with access to the outside, they don't make the most of it.
The vast majority are also fed on concentrate food with imported soy.

The biggest benefit i see from organic, is that if we can increase consumer demand for organic meat, it should have an impact on antibiotic use in meat production and also on the importing of soy livestock feed. Which applies to chicken, pork and beef.

When I do buy a chicken I try for organic free range if it is available, but mostly it's just simple red tractor UK chicken on the shelves in co-op. I find it easier to source and buy high-welfare grass fed beef.

I very rarely buy pork as a joint or cut, but do buy lots of sausages and bacon, but definitely go as high end as I can afford with those.
I have a lot more guilt over pig & chicken consumption than I do over dairy and beef, as I have more opportunity to wield consumer power through choice in the latter.

Hdhdjejdj · 04/10/2021 12:25

@Claudethecat. Red Tractor standards are not as high so always look out for the RSPCA Assured symbol. It means the animals have been given more space and allowed to act in a natural way, and grow normally.

IsabellesMissingSock · 04/10/2021 12:23

Free range/organic/best standards possible for the shop in question, on the very rare occasion that I buy chicken. Why would anyone not do that? If you can't afford it, why eat it? Or do you not care about the livings standards of animals beyond those that you created/live with/are related to?

Claudethecat · 04/10/2021 12:22

[quote Hdhdjejdj]@Claudethecat Aldi meat is RSPCA Assured so is ok.[/quote]
Thanks!

EmmaGrundyForPM · 04/10/2021 12:21

I've voted YABU but I don't think you are. We buy FR chicken but then, we can afford it. I think its very patronising if I say to people that they should only buy FR chicken when non FR is so much cheaper.

There is a whole cultural shift which needs to be made with regard to cheap food and particularly cheap meat. But criticising people on strict budgets isn't the way forward.

Lobelia123 · 04/10/2021 12:21

To the poster who posted so blithely 'who cares' and that these are just labels to fool wealthy people. Im not wealthy and I care. I care that that animal that has feelings and life should have a fair quality of life to enjoy before it does so I can enjoy mine. I dont always buy organic but the free range label is very important to me and I agree with all the poncy tv chefs that it actually DOES make a difference to the taste. And I feel good about my purchase and my meal and that Im supporting farmers trying to farm ethically.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 04/10/2021 12:20

I used to buy free range or organic chickens because I thought they were much better treated, turns out they aren't. They're a bit better than the caged hens but not as well treated as it's made out they are.

I now only buy chickens from a friend who raises them and has them roaming around his paddock. I know they've been looked after but I don't eat chicken that often anymore and meat in generally now I'm thinking about it

Hdhdjejdj · 04/10/2021 12:20

@Claudethecat Aldi meat is RSPCA Assured so is ok.

Fridafever · 04/10/2021 12:20

Yes only organic here and don’t eat meat in restaurants for that reason.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 04/10/2021 12:19

It depends. I will only buy higher welfare meat, which generally means organic or free-range. The only exception I make is Waitrose whose welfare standards are high anyway, even for their Essential range. Having looked into their policies, including those relating to slaughter (so often people look at how an animal has lived and not how it has died), plus their Good Chicken awards from Compassion in World Farming, I'm happy to eat that and support a shop that's making the effort on the animal welfare front.

I'd love to buy from our local - and excellent - butcher but they can't always tell me what living/slaughter conditions the animals had (and I get the impression they'd rather I wasn't talking about slaughter methods in front of other customers!) so I limit meat purchases to schemes that are guaranteed.

I've seen poultry farms and as long as the overall standards are high enough I am OK with chicken not necessarily being free range (the birds I saw regularly were in huge airy barns with open sides, so plenty of natural light and air, but the farmer couldn't call them free range as the birds were never technically outside).

LastToBePicked · 04/10/2021 12:19

Free range if I am buying fresh chicken on its own, but various ‘standard’ chicken slips through in ready meals, food boxes etc.

But it’s hard though - if I don’t eat chicken, I might eat beef, but then think of the carbon footprint. Or fish but then worry about over fishing. Or veggie/vegan but worry about how highly processed most meat alternatives are. Or try to persuade my fussy kids to eat actual vegetables which they won’t and then I worry about food waste. You can’t win.

Claudethecat · 04/10/2021 12:18

Spottybluepyjamas we eat a lot of lentils I love them, so versatile.

Claudethecat · 04/10/2021 12:16

Free range or organic. If I could not afford it, I wouldn't eat chicken.

Aldi do cheap free range chicken, about £6 a chicken. I have bought it in the past but I don't entirely trust that is really is properly free range at that price, does anyone know?

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 04/10/2021 12:15

I don’t eat meat but I buy normal chicken for the family.

I always snap up free range/organic if it’s reduced but unfortunately we just simply can’t afford to replace all our meat with FR.

We do however eat substantially less meat as an entire household than we did 5 years ago so I suppose every little helps.

Spottybluepyjamas · 04/10/2021 12:15

ALWAYS free range. Organic if I can. Never battery chickens. We'd rather eat less meat than buy caged animals - on our non meat days we eat lentils or something similar for protein.

Hdhdjejdj · 04/10/2021 12:14

I buy both, depending on where I am shopping. If I buy from a butcher’s or somewhere like M and S or Waitrose I buy standard. I know that the welfare for these birds will still be high. Yesterday we had a free-range corn-fed chicken from Aldi which cost about £6. I occasionally buy the organic chicken from M&S because they are incredibly good.

CustardySergeant · 04/10/2021 12:14

@AuntieMarys

Always free range. Would do with out otherwise
Same here.
SW1amp · 04/10/2021 12:13

@RobertaFirmino

Is there a minimum standard that has to be met before chicken can be described as 'free range'? I've always wondered what these birds have free range of. Do they have free range of a tiny yard or a massive field?
Yes, there are standards There is a minimum amount of space per bird that they have to have access to, so many hours per day where their hatches are open to let them out into the field (they are obviously closed at night to stop foxes getting them)

Just like free range eggs…
Organic means they get fed on organic corn and feed, plus have to access to more space per bird in the field

I’m sure the full list of rules is available to Google but it’s a balance between keeping birds safe from predators but allowing them to express natural behaviour and have space to roam around

‘Standard’ chickens never see daylight and have lamps on all the time to make them think it’s daytime so they eat more and put on more weight

It’s a grim existence, compared to their free range cousins

MarthaJonesPhone · 04/10/2021 12:12

I'm a single mum on a low income. I buy free range or organic, I just buy less of it and less often.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 04/10/2021 12:12

@Shehasadiamondinthesky

I bought a lidl extra large £5 chicken once. It was truly vile. There was so much water in it it boiled in its own juice in the oven instead of roasting. Even the cat wouldn't eat it. Id rather not eat meat at all than cheap stuff.
I tried Lidl chicken once too and it was pretty unplesant.
Dixiechickonhols · 04/10/2021 12:10

I try and buy meat reduced and freeze and will buy organic if it’s there but day in day out I buy from Lidl, Aldi or the 3 for £10 type meat in Asda or local butchers - so a chicken, 5% mince etc. The majority of chicken we eat is standard.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 04/10/2021 12:10

I bought a lidl extra large £5 chicken once. It was truly vile. There was so much water in it it boiled in its own juice in the oven instead of roasting. Even the cat wouldn't eat it. Id rather not eat meat at all than cheap stuff.

LubaLuca · 04/10/2021 12:10

I agree with a pp - these types of threads are unlikely to give a representation of what is known to be true. Most people who buy chicken buy intensively-reared, but perhaps they're less likely to want to think or talk much about it.

SummersOverSeasideTown · 04/10/2021 12:10

I only buy British meat for the family (I am vegetarian) whilst I know this isn't free range it does have higher welfare than European meat .