Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for ‘normal average’ salaries?

393 replies

Mamacita191 · 04/10/2021 09:33

After seeing loads of posts recently about what people earn, I feel like it’s a completely different world to what I am living in. I live in the midlands and a good salary is 30-40k which is what most people comfortably sit at. I certain rarely see jobs advertised for £60k or more (even 6 figures which I’ve read is what some people make!). Even the jobs that people advise to go into such as lawyers and accountants in a good firm etc don’t make 3 figures as I’ve read on here.

Is it just me who thinks 30-40k is a normal salary that a lot of people sit comfortably at? Am I missing out on something?

OP posts:
Xenia · 05/10/2021 17:20

That was the point I was trying to make. Women often limit their aspirations because their family thinks £30k is a high salary etc. One job in Wales got no women when the pay was £50k as they thought they were not good enough but at £35k suddenly women started applying for it.

daffodils123 · 05/10/2021 16:54

@MerlinsButler

To be honest a lot of posters are being a little disingenuous here. Talking about joint incomes of over £150k+ but "feeling poor". That kind of income is obviously not poor and would put them in top 1 or 2% in the UK using the link previously shared.

It is obvious £150k is a great level of income and far from poor! The choices they make regarding outgoings and keeping up with their social group etc should not detract from that.

I don't think it's being disingenuous - everyone has completely different ongoings. If you have a salary of £150k and 4 kids v 1 kid, or live in London v North of England, or you make the decision to go private with schooling, then of course you might "feel poor".

I think aspiration is a huge thing when it comes to salary - I have only ever thought of 30k as a "starting salary". If a young person chooses a career etc with the mindset that it's a "huge" salary they will (1) continue to be paid less than their peers even if their role could be paid more; and (2) they won't be as selective about which careers they go into. I've mentored juniors before who took a job without even negotiating the salary because they were earning more than their parents earned, when that's not really relevant.

Consistently frustrated that women especially are pushed towards more of the low paying careers despite their academics or potential. Fair enough if that's what they genuinely desire to do, but many go into professions because their school careers advisor suggested it aged 15.

Newmumatlast · 05/10/2021 16:06

Depends what you think good money is - as you say some people think 30k is huge - and also your prospects of earning that. Run of the mill uni without any contacts or good work experience and without good grades, plus going for an area of law which attracts less pay (i.e. crime) and no, you are highly unlikely to ever earn good money and will have spent a hell of a lot of money getting there. Top uni, top grades, contacts or great work experience and your prospects are a lot better at securing a TC or pupillage in a good firm/chambers and in a more competitive area of law which is higher paying. Then I think good money is on the cards. I think it would be difficult to argue 6 figures isn't good money given where that places you in % of population.

TractorAndHeadphones · 05/10/2021 15:45

[quote onlychildhamster]@TractorAndHeadphones Dh is working in middle office in an investment bank and has a law degree. He is earning more than our friends in london high street firms.

IB and Magic circle law firm would be just as hard to get into. The reality is that the vast majority of law graduates would not get into Magic circle. But they would probably be able to get a regular finance job which would still pay 6 figures/close to 6 figures esp as VP/ED. I can't say the same for all solicitors who work for high street firms.[/quote]
Yeah that makes sense. Especially if Finance grads start in Big4. Even audit (which is easy to get into it’s a body count) , put in 3 years of time and you’re looking at 80K by 25.

I also agree with you in that I don’t know why people go into law hoping to make big money. But then again some people think that 30K is a huge salary in which case It’s probably good enough.

onlychildhamster · 05/10/2021 15:37

@Newmumatlast The difference of course is DH is not from privilege and neither are those friends. But did get into RG/Cambridge.

onlychildhamster · 05/10/2021 15:36

@Newmumatlast we (DH and I) were from RG law too. And one of our friends is from cambridge law but working in a small law firm. Another of our friends was from RG but did law conversion, working for a high street firm. We have friends in Magic circle but most of our classmates were international students

Newmumatlast · 05/10/2021 15:33

[quote onlychildhamster]@TractorAndHeadphones Dh is working in middle office in an investment bank and has a law degree. He is earning more than our friends in london high street firms.

IB and Magic circle law firm would be just as hard to get into. The reality is that the vast majority of law graduates would not get into Magic circle. But they would probably be able to get a regular finance job which would still pay 6 figures/close to 6 figures esp as VP/ED. I can't say the same for all solicitors who work for high street firms.[/quote]
The thing is a lot of people from privilege wouldn't see it that way as to them almost everyone they know who studied got into Magic Circle firms. I am not from privilege but the law people I knew from my RG uni almost all got TCs from top firms - Magic Circle or regional but high paying. I don't think anyone had to pay for their own training and some got given lump sums to go off travelling if they deferred (economic crash).

onlychildhamster · 05/10/2021 14:32

@TractorAndHeadphones Dh is working in middle office in an investment bank and has a law degree. He is earning more than our friends in london high street firms.

IB and Magic circle law firm would be just as hard to get into. The reality is that the vast majority of law graduates would not get into Magic circle. But they would probably be able to get a regular finance job which would still pay 6 figures/close to 6 figures esp as VP/ED. I can't say the same for all solicitors who work for high street firms.

MerlinsButler · 05/10/2021 14:27

To be honest a lot of posters are being a little disingenuous here. Talking about joint incomes of over £150k+ but "feeling poor". That kind of income is obviously not poor and would put them in top 1 or 2% in the UK using the link previously shared.

It is obvious £150k is a great level of income and far from poor! The choices they make regarding outgoings and keeping up with their social group etc should not detract from that.

TractorAndHeadphones · 05/10/2021 13:55

[quote onlychildhamster]@TractorAndHeadphones Yes that was kinda my point. All the non IB analysts earn more than high street solicitors (and high street solicitors would have needed to get a training contract for 2 years in order to qualify). On the other hand, you would be an analyst straight out of university.[/quote]
Not exactly a like for like comparison though - as there aren’t many opening for IB specific jobs that aren’t crazy competitive. Traders, equity research or similar grad schemes take only a handful of people every year. Some banks don’t even recruit for all roles every year.
The rest like finance, HR, etc aren’t ‘IB analyst’ jobs. They’re HR or finance jobs just working for an investment bank.
From what I know TC’s for magic circle law firms are as competitive as IB but not the rest.

The easiest way to high earning without undue effort is to join a Big4 firm as it’s a body count in many specialties, once you qualify you’ll be fighting off offers from recruiters….

onlychildhamster · 05/10/2021 13:35

@TractorAndHeadphones Yes that was kinda my point. All the non IB analysts earn more than high street solicitors (and high street solicitors would have needed to get a training contract for 2 years in order to qualify). On the other hand, you would be an analyst straight out of university.

OnceUponAThread · 05/10/2021 13:15

[quote TractorAndHeadphones]@OnceUponAThread a lot of the couples with one kid are likely to have a lower paid part-time earner? The figures don’t really make sense tho[/quote]
@TractorAndHeadphones yeah it was the couples with no kids that I found alarming. Does coupling up somehow mean you earn less?

Rosebel · 05/10/2021 13:14

My husband is on £18,000 before tax working full time on a little above NMW. I work part time and earn around £12000 before tax.
We get by on it but I won't pretend it's always easy, especially with rising prices.

Bulblasagnes · 05/10/2021 13:09

@Royalbloo I’m the same as you. My salary has almost tripled in 3 years and at the same time I’ve just stopped paying childcare costs (apart from after school club). I was already on a good salary but renting and paying childcare expenses in London. I lived very frugally for many years. Now we own our own home, the mortgage is much cheaper than rent, the after school club costs are peanuts, and all the extra income is disposable because my day to day living expenses haven’t increased. I find it completely mind-boggling and I can’t talk about it to anyone except my husband and we are both just “how???”. His income has more than doubled during the same period. Obviously it’s really nice but it’s also very strange and I find it hard to get my mind around it all.

addictedtotheflats · 05/10/2021 13:01

I earn 40K and my DP 25K. We live very comfortably (in Yorkshire). I can't imagine our salary would go very far in London though, our mortgage is only £300 a month.

TractorAndHeadphones · 05/10/2021 12:50

[quote Nanananani]**@Voldr* why? I think @Xenia* point is valid - young girls should definitely be given the visibility and information required to set their sights higher. How can you dream big if you don’t have all the options and some role models.

I really wish my careers advice at school in the early 2000s had better ideas for girls than hairdresser, teacher, nurse, doctor, accountant, dentist, nursery nurse, care assistant. The world of possibilities and highly paid possibilities at that is huge and the advice was so outdated.[/quote]
Exactly!
There are plenty of people in niche roles making lots of money - roles the general public don’t know about. Or even consider.
Of course not everyone can make lots etc but when you grow up believing that making such amount isn’t possible you won’t even bother trying. So many people in their 30’s retraining. Imagine how much time and effort they’d have saved if they were correctly advised!

Nanananani · 05/10/2021 12:40

@Voldr why? I think @Xenia point is valid - young girls should definitely be given the visibility and information required to set their sights higher. How can you dream big if you don’t have all the options and some role models.

I really wish my careers advice at school in the early 2000s had better ideas for girls than hairdresser, teacher, nurse, doctor, accountant, dentist, nursery nurse, care assistant. The world of possibilities and highly paid possibilities at that is huge and the advice was so outdated.

Voldr · 05/10/2021 12:27

@Xenia

You really do live on another planet.

Xenia · 05/10/2021 12:22

Sofia's post is good and it also illustrates the issue of raising expectations. If pupils in a a school in a deprived area think a teacher on £30k is very well paid and they try to become a teacher - nothing wrong with that BUT someone should also tell them a god few women earn over £100k so why not set sights higher?

Someone mentioned Cherie Blair (Booth's ) childhood. Her father left when she was young in Liverpool and she went to the local Catholic school. Of course she was better off than some but it would not be fair to imply she was from any kind of a rich home (other than rich in love or attention or religion).

SofiaMichelle · 05/10/2021 12:17

@Newmumatlast

Completely agree with this. I am in a high earning profession (in my opinion - most people I come across on 6 figures or very close) but come from a working class background. Most people I know on a personal level either from school or family or friends from my teens are on the national average wage or below. My husband is on around 40k and I consider him a high earner - because statistically he is. Each year my income increases I feel like it must be a fluke because to me it is an unusually high sum compared to what I ever thought I would earn. I have felt like I was ridiculously comfortable since I bought my house with my husband when our combined income was about 45k.

On the other hand there are many people in my line of work from backgrounds where it isnt unusual to earn the sort of money they do. Many of those on 6 figures act like it is very mundane run of the mill stuff - but then they have friends in high places, went to some of the top public schools etc. One colleague told me at the start of our career that he would be devastated if he only ever earned 50k. I honestly said I would be made up because that is more than my Dad earned and I feel I had a comfortable and very happy childhood.

Great post. Every word of that resonates with me. Especially the part about some people's expectations compared to others.

I feel incredibly lucky to earn what I earn - I work in consulting after decades in multinationals - but some of my colleagues have, and apparently always had, huge expectations about what they'd earn.

We're only a small company and it was started 20 years ago by a guy who was in a senior, but not partner, role in one of the biggest consultancies and felt he wasn't paid enough(!) and I know for a fact he was was well into 6 figures when he quit.

Of the senior people in our company now, there's just me - humble working class background - and one other colleague - from a rough, Glasgow estate - who aren't 'monied'.

The others are all from extremely privileged backgrounds and wouldn't even know where to start with 'only' 30-50k per year; they would freely admit that. One has played polo competitively since he was at boarding school. Another's family is a household name in their line of business (food) and I imagine one day she'll do a great job as a board member there.

Don't get me wrong, these colleagues are clever, well educated and work as hard as the rest of us, but they were brought up with a level of expectation far, far above 'normal' people's expectations of their working life and salary.

When I was in industry I worked with many people for whom £30k would be a dream, even those working night shifts who received a premium. It really is a different world.

It honestly feels like pure luck that I now earn several multiples of all my close friends' salaries as I don't for a minute believe I actually work any harder, other than the travelling I have to do and the late/early calls with clients in USA and Asia.

MegBusset · 05/10/2021 10:59

I'm just about to start a new role at £30k after eight years of earning peanuts in part-time roles (charity sector) and six years before that of earning zero as a SAHM.

After so many years of seeing less than £800 a month take home pay, I feel absolutely minted.

Won't be changing lifestyle though. The extra is all going in savings for if/when the DC go to university. It will be nice to be able to save.

Zenithbear · 05/10/2021 10:57

@julieca

Sure babysitter costs would mean you can get over £100 for a night out easily. But as from the example given many people are just talking about taxis, drinks and food. We go out two or three times a week and spend under £100 a week on that for both of us. I would rather go out more often and see friends, than only go out once every two months and splash the cash.
Same here. We go out several times a week for a lot less. Usually go to the pubs, gigs, weekly, cinema once a month, meal once a fortnight etc. We have lots of stuff locally so don't need taxis very often.
julieca · 05/10/2021 10:54

@TractorAndHeadphones yes it is the alcohol and taxis. No wonder cocktail bars are always opening up if people spend so much on them. I buy a pint of beer for £4 and that lasts the night Grin
I haven't changed since being a student, although then it would be a pint of cider.

TractorAndHeadphones · 05/10/2021 10:50

@OnceUponAThread a lot of the couples with one kid are likely to have a lower paid part-time earner? The figures don’t really make sense tho

TractorAndHeadphones · 05/10/2021 10:47

@julieca

Sure babysitter costs would mean you can get over £100 for a night out easily. But as from the example given many people are just talking about taxis, drinks and food. We go out two or three times a week and spend under £100 a week on that for both of us. I would rather go out more often and see friends, than only go out once every two months and splash the cash.
It’s not expensive if you only go out for dinner. It is if you buy lots of drinks. @Nanananani has illustrated it quite well It depends on your circles bar hopping etc is quite normal among one group, others prefer to come home and drink