Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for ‘normal average’ salaries?

393 replies

Mamacita191 · 04/10/2021 09:33

After seeing loads of posts recently about what people earn, I feel like it’s a completely different world to what I am living in. I live in the midlands and a good salary is 30-40k which is what most people comfortably sit at. I certain rarely see jobs advertised for £60k or more (even 6 figures which I’ve read is what some people make!). Even the jobs that people advise to go into such as lawyers and accountants in a good firm etc don’t make 3 figures as I’ve read on here.

Is it just me who thinks 30-40k is a normal salary that a lot of people sit comfortably at? Am I missing out on something?

OP posts:
Thedishwasherstacker · 04/10/2021 13:39

Of course it is all relevant to your outgoings. Between us dh and I earn around £48k but we don’t have much of a mortgage and our cars etc are paid for, we have more disposable money than many of our friends who earn more for they simply have higher outgoings like huge mortgages and new cars each. I used to work for the NHS and the surgeon in our department was married to another surgeon and between them they were on a joint income of something like £200k+ but they were perpetually skint. I used to have more money in my pocket then him, he was forever scrapping up money from others to pay the sandwich lady lol!

Weirdlynormal · 04/10/2021 13:35

I have seen my role advertised at £45k, but I pay my assistant more than that. You'd very rarely see my role advertised at the level that I and my colleagues earn though as you can't enter the industry at that level.

I see what people earn all the time and I'm often surprised how much some accountants earn (usually an FD but still, BIG salaries).

Earnings are like anything else, only part of the story. There are plenty of people not 'earning' much, but their incomes are very high from other investments etc.

ZenNudist · 04/10/2021 13:33

I think you're right that lots of people done earn big money. Well apart from the comment that lawyers and accountants in the Midlands don't earn 6 figures that's not true. Are you coming at this from a 20 something perspective?

Salaries are lower in your 20s but rise a lot in your 30s in some professions.

In my late twenties (15 years ago) I was targeting £50k but that rose swiftly to 60k when I was early 30s at a big 4 firm not London. I wasn't a senior manager and felt I was being underpaid. Lawyers always seems to earn more than accountants but maybe they just dress and live better!

No one is going to tell you what they're on and jobs don't get advertised with a salary. You rely on recruiters to tell you what a reasonable salary expectation would be.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 04/10/2021 13:30

@Xenia

It does not really matter what other people earn if you are happy with your own earnings. There will always be people with more salary.
This is how I feel. I'm on £22k pro rata but what is important to me right now is flexible hours, an understanding boss and nice colleagues. Our household income has ranged from £45k to £60k in the last 5 years (SW) but when your mortgage on a 4 bed is £650pcm with only 15 years left on it, that feels like plenty!
bobsholi · 04/10/2021 13:27

DH earns 30k full time and I earn 11k part time. We are in the SW and it's a comfortable household income for here. In London I think it would be a struggle for a family of 5 to live on 41k.

thaegumathteth · 04/10/2021 13:24

I'm a sahm but dh earns almost 60k. You wouldn't often see a job like his advertised widely though as it's quite niche. If I was still working I'd probably be on about 30k as was in the charity sector.

I think most people I know earn (at a guess!) between 30-45k

Cottagepieandpeas · 04/10/2021 13:22

I'm on 34K for 4 days per week. Was earning 52k (full time) 18 months ago. It's quite hard to deal with the drop to be honest.
I work in London but live in the shires. I haven't had to pay travel for past 18 months but am now having to commute so that's really eating in to the monthly pay packet. I do look for similar roles locally but £34k seems like a pipe dream outside London for the sort of work I do.

Bigoldhag · 04/10/2021 13:19

£30.5k here. Considered above average locally - life is cheaper here too. In my circle of friends I’m probably one of the top 3 earners. Acutely aware this is not a lot compared to other places!

Xenia · 04/10/2021 13:17

I am from Newcastle. My doctor father (consultant there and with a private practice) earned pretty well as does my Yorkshire doctor sibling. Even lawyers up there can do well. These people in Newcastle Whinn solicitors did or do pretty well for example and I am talking about much better than many lawyers in London www.business-live.co.uk/professional-services/newcastle-law-firm-winn-holdings-16768358

NHS doctor consultant salaries are available on line as are salaries for trainee and newly qualified lawyers in many areas including Bristol which I think was mentioned above so is not a secret - basically the harder it is to do something and the fewer people can do it the higher the pay - it applies from surgeons to footballers, opera singers to top lawyers and these days HGV drivers - it was ever thus.

MatildaIThink · 04/10/2021 13:17

@Mamacita191

After seeing loads of posts recently about what people earn, I feel like it’s a completely different world to what I am living in. I live in the midlands and a good salary is 30-40k which is what most people comfortably sit at. I certain rarely see jobs advertised for £60k or more (even 6 figures which I’ve read is what some people make!). Even the jobs that people advise to go into such as lawyers and accountants in a good firm etc don’t make 3 figures as I’ve read on here.

Is it just me who thinks 30-40k is a normal salary that a lot of people sit comfortably at? Am I missing out on something?

Higher income jobs are not usually advertised in the same way as low and middle income jobs, that can create a situation where you don't often see those high income jobs advertised. This might be medical positions, doctors, high pay band nurses etc. will not be advertised on normal job sites, quite a few large companies only advertise through their own careers portals rather than on jobs site, especially larger firms with high wage positions.

Lawyers and accountants don't make six figures by default, they especially will not in entry level positions which are usually the ones you see advertised, but a good corporate accountant or experienced lawyer can get up into those figures later in their career.

It also what you depends by "normal", the average salary is £31,500 pa for full time employees, but that includes everyone from the school leaver in an entry level position to the company CEO approaching retirement, income comparisons need to be age appropriate. As an example it is around £18k for 18-21 year olds, it is just under £39k for people 40-49. On top of that you have to factor in regional differences.

The other thing is you might just not realise what they earn, I know people who are on £100k a year but you would not know it, they are putting half their income into their pension and the first sign you might get would be when they retired in their fifties.

My husband and I both earn six figures, I drive a seven year old car, my husband a twelve year old car, neither of us is bothered about cars. I don't wear much jewellery, my engagement ring, wedding ring, usually small earrings and occasionally a bracelet which was my nans. We don't wear expensive clothes, my husband does not have expensive watches etc. We do have a reasonably nice four bed house and both make high pension contributions, have savings and are massively overpaying our mortgage, but outwardly you would not really be able to tell if we earned £100k between us and spent it all every month, or the real situation where there is more.

GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 04/10/2021 13:16

I live in the South East in a naice place outside london and rent is astronomical. You couldn't be here on less than 50k you genuinely wouldn't be able to afford it. A two bed is 2k/month
Raising a family would take two incomes of over 40k I would say
I grew up here so I am used to it but it is shocking to compare wages and prices ... standard of living here is great but no better than places in the north or South West

onlychildhamster · 04/10/2021 13:15

@TeacupDrama the stats in London are skewed by the fact that by a certain age, many of the people on middling salaries (50k and above) but not crazy would have moved out of London to the Home Counties as they can afford the commute fares to their jobs in London and desire a bigger house and garden, leaving the ethnic minorities (who on average still earn less than white people with the exception of Indian/Chinese), the young, the poor and the uber rich (whose money is derived from wealth rather than income). And even the ethnic minorities are increasingly moving to the commuter towns nowadays. But those people's income is still derived from London salaries, even though they are scattered all over the SE!

This shows it: www.uhy-uk.com/insights/stockbroker-belt-dominates-top-ten-towns-biggest-income-tax-bills None of the top ten towns for tax are in London but in places like Esher, Beaconsfield and Sevenoaks. These places are not really cheaper than London for housing as you can buy a terraced in London for £1 million or so but its just much smaller than whatever you can get in those towns.

fashionSOS · 04/10/2021 13:15

@Mamacita191

After seeing loads of posts recently about what people earn, I feel like it’s a completely different world to what I am living in. I live in the midlands and a good salary is 30-40k which is what most people comfortably sit at. I certain rarely see jobs advertised for £60k or more (even 6 figures which I’ve read is what some people make!). Even the jobs that people advise to go into such as lawyers and accountants in a good firm etc don’t make 3 figures as I’ve read on here.

Is it just me who thinks 30-40k is a normal salary that a lot of people sit comfortably at? Am I missing out on something?

You'll probably feel better if you ask for salary plus how much it costs to buy a starter flat and a starter house in a part of town that the poster isn't scared to walk in.

High salaries aren't all they're cracked up to be if they don't get you a better standard of living overall.

REDHERO · 04/10/2021 13:14

@yippyyippy

DH earns 35k and I work part-time for about 8k! We have what I consider a nice comfortable lifestyle with 2 kids. I’m always a bit thrown by the threads where lots declare how tight it is to live on a 60k salary. I guess a lot of it is very subjective though..
I think some people ate great at money management and others really poor no matter what they earn. Hearing people whinge and struggle on £60,000 is laughable
Xenia · 04/10/2021 13:13

It does not really matter what other people earn if you are happy with your own earnings. There will always be people with more salary.

YerAWizardHarry · 04/10/2021 13:13

We are also in Scotland for context

YerAWizardHarry · 04/10/2021 13:11

I’m a teacher and earn around £40K. DP doesn’t have a degree but works in the energy sector and earns £36K base but does a fair bit of overtime. We are on the higher end of wages within our friendship group/close family

FinallyFluid · 04/10/2021 13:10

We go onto a retirement pension income next August, of £47k which will be fine, but feels tight in my head at the moment.

XingMing · 04/10/2021 13:09

My DS was a chef (now at university) but does cheffing PT for a few hours. The rates for competent chefs (not frying or microwaving ready meals) have gone from £9-11 ph for a commis, to average £16 ph in the South West this summer, and more if you are good enough to work through an agency. And there is still a skills shortage. But hospitality isn't popular because of the hours and the conditions.

TeacupDrama · 04/10/2021 13:01

only 25% of people pay any higher rate tax which kicks in at roughly 50K the median is about 30K even in London the median is less than 40K so obviously half the population of london are somehow managing on that
how rich, comfortable poor you feel depends on living costs everyone needs to pay rent or mortgage until mortgage free needs food and heating but although these are unavoidable they are not fixed you can live in a smaller house or flat in a different area so choosing expensive accommodation doesn't make you intrinsically poorer it is a choice to live in an expensive area buying a 500K house is a choice so is renting at £1600 a month but someone on 30K with £600 rent is going to feel a lot more comfortable than someone paying £1000 or £1500 out of the same income
we have slightly below median household income but are mortgage free and have savings so don't feel poor at all in fact are financially secure. obviously I can't buy just anything but I don't worry about food heating or fuel for car or any other regular expenses and have more than enough for emergencies but I fully appreciate someone else on same income with rent childcare and no savings would feel completely differently

julieca · 04/10/2021 13:00

@PileOfBooks the refusal to take responsibility infuriates me. As if someone makes people buy more expensive houses or a more expensive car. I don't understand why seemingly intelligent people won't take responsibility for their spending decisions.
DP and I are not high-earners but are better off than we should be for our salaries. That is because we haven't increased our spending as our income has increased a bit except on discretionary spend like holidays. I now earn £28k, DP £25k. But we take responsibility for our own spending.

julieca · 04/10/2021 12:57

@FatOaf

It therefore seems that there are a lot of considerably higher than average earners on mumsnet then from reading previous threads!

There are also lots of fantasists on Mumsnet, just like on all social media.

This is very true. A friend went to a MN social meet up expecting it to be full of women whose families were very well-off. In reality, it was a very ordinary group of women who were a good laugh.
PileOfBooks · 04/10/2021 12:55

Snap julieca! It amazes me people don't see this.

julieca · 04/10/2021 12:54

@Pipsquiggle

Income is only half the story. The other half is outgoings.

I've just been looking at household income at work. As mentioned above average household income is circa £36k, however, higher earning families may have less disposable income due to higher outgoings - this could be mortgage, car, school fees etc.

Just because they earn more doesn't mean they have more disposable income

Of course they have more disposable income. They are choosing a nicer house to buy, a nicer car, to pay school fees. I could earn a million pound a year and have it all committed on a massive mortgage, running costs for a mansion, top private schools and day and night time nannies. After a basic base amount, you CHOOSE your outgoings. At least take responsibility for that.
MrsBobDylan · 04/10/2021 12:54

Income is only relevant within the context of location, property, home ownership and relationship status.

A single parent earning 50k renting a two bed house in an expensive area, with a child in full time childcare, running a car will struggle.

However, couples where both work and have a mortgaged property in a cheaper area, with family nearby, are going to be much better off.

It is pointless saying what you earn unless you give the context.

My dh earns above the national average but we live in an expensive area and have disabled children who need a full time carer. We struggle. If I have been able to keep my job, we wouldn't struggle.