Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else feel fed up about finances and living situation?

141 replies

Benjaminbutton12 · 04/10/2021 08:07

I am 31 and live with my partner. We live in a small rented studio flat, which has our living room, kitchen and bedroom in one room, then a small bathroom tacked on.
The inside is nice enough but it’s far too small for two, a lot of our stuff is still in bags as we just don’t have the space. We moved here just after Christmas as it was with the same agency I had previously been with, and it was faster and cheaper than starting again.

We pay £800 per month including all bills and council tax, and I guess we’re being ripped off.

I know we need to move ASAP and just feel down. Most people our age now seem to own nice houses and all seem to have a ‘spare room’ they’ve offered us to stay in. We don’t even have anywhere for guests to sit. I shouldn’t care what people think but I do feel some pressure.
We’re in the North West.

I don’t drive, I commute by bike or public transport and that’s another issue I feel down about. Again, most acquaintances of our age or younger seem to have pretty decent cars now. I can’t afford driving lessons plus a deposit for a home. My partner doesn’t drive either.

I have a degree and a qualification in a ‘professional’ career. I believe it was the wrong career choice for me, teaching, my behaviour management skills were very poor. I look young for my age and don’t think I was taken seriously by the children.
I work in social care, a career which I really enjoy but I earn £9.30 an hour. My partner earns slightly less in kitchen work. I shouldn’t do but I feel embarrassed and that people will judge me for being degree and PGCE-qualified but then going on to be a carer. Some people have made comments, even though it’s a rewarding career, but I will never make a lot of money from it.

This month has been a struggle. We’re paid four weekly, due to the date I started I was paid for 3 weeks, and despite me stating that this was my main job I was put on BR tax code and therefore taxed too much. I came out with £930 net whereas it should have been almost £400 more.

I get paid again on Friday but it’s been a struggle.
Sorry for the long rant, not sure what it’s going to achieve. I just feel stressed and down a lot of the time, and like I ‘should’ be in a better position by my age.
I don’t see a solution other than ‘get a well-paid job’?

OP posts:
makinganavalon · 04/10/2021 18:54

Ah, OP, you sound how I feel.
I'm in a place I don't like and seemingly no way out of it at the moment.
I don't really have much to say except I truly sympathise.
I'm struggling to change my life with a toddler so I've put any changes on hold and am just grinning and bearing. I wish I had the entrepreneurial skills some others have.
I truly hope things go the way you want them Flowers

Seesawmummadaw · 04/10/2021 17:52

While you are busy comparing yourself to others someone will be comparing themselves to you.

Notdoingthis · 04/10/2021 17:42

If you are bringing home £1300 and you only pay £400 for rent and utilities you should be able to save easily. Be patient. I was in this position on minimum wage a few years ago. And I was a qualified teacher. I lived like that for 2 years and we saved a lot between us. Now we own a house and I am teaching again. Oh, and I couldn't drive but I learnt and bought a very cheap car. We share a car. Good luck.

FedNlanders · 04/10/2021 17:14

Yep. We pay 1000 a month. No spare. It's shit.

Jemsi · 04/10/2021 17:13

I live in GM however I’d say tbh if it includes bills that £800 a month isn’t that bad. Someone has suggested Bury- even a flat is going to set you back £600ish a month without bills and then you’ve reduced your access to many jobs. I would recommend NOT moving until you’ve future planned.

I would echo what @TrollsAreSaddos has said about social work. I work in mental health- I’m happy to be told I’m wrong- but as a support worker / carer it’s seems you just get to be your patients advocate but when you are the social worker you’ve sometimes got to give people a reality that’s hard to face. Funds and housing are hard to come by and often you will have to bluntly tell people they are entitled to nothing, or nothing like they probably expected or deserved. You need to have a thick skin, and you will get abuse worse than any teenage child could hit you with. There are rewarding parts but also lots of targets, pressures, and challenges too.

I say this not to be unkind but because I think you need to think really carefully about your next step and go in eyes open. You are at least earning and safely housed- you have time to consider your next step. Would you be able to access careers counselling through your university alumni?

A suggestion for free training I have made to some are these digital boot camps- might not be up your street but thought I may as well share www.greatermanchester-ca.gov.uk/what-we-do/digital/digital-talent-pipeline/digital-skills-bootcamps/

Look at www.greater.jobs at what roles are available. There are quite a few education delivery jobs for the fire service, and roles involving youth work, which would all pay more than you earn now and strengthen future applications if you wanted to consider social work.

It’s good you’re saving money on a car but a driving license is a requirement for a lot of social care jobs- I would prioritise getting a license over saving for a deposit. If you increase your earnings you will be able to save for a deposit then.

TrollsAreSaddos · 04/10/2021 15:12

I’m not so sure becoming a social worker would work though. You need to give it some serious thought. If you are worried you aren’t taken seriously and are thought of as young and ‘cute’ as a teacher then I’m not sure why it would be different if you were a social worker.

It’s funny that your user name is ‘Benjamin Button’ 👀

Benjaminbutton12 · 04/10/2021 13:46

I’m going to discuss it with him this evening about moving to a larger rented place. I think a social worker role is something I’d be highly interested in and definitely a paid training course. appreciate all the suggestions on here, got to get myself into gear now

OP posts:
FallingRussetLeaves · 04/10/2021 12:06

@GreenLunchBox

OP said £800 inc bills, so I presume a 50/50 split with her partner ie £400 per month for everything. If the council tax in a studio is maybe £100 a month, water £50, gas and electric perhaps £90 and then broadband too, that means rent alone is likely in the £500ish region and there are definitely better properties than a tiny studio to be had for that in GM, even assuming they need to stay close to good public transport links.

I don't think you can rent much for £500 in GM these days.

There are dozens of properties on rightmove for £500 or less, most of which were either cheaper or larger than what OP has now. Granted I don't know how quickly lets are going etc, but the way OP describes her housing situation it's likely they could spend less for the same accommodation quality or get more for their £500ish rent.
8dpwoah · 04/10/2021 11:37

Loads of good ideas here, I second the suggestions about working in education/care jobs that aren't mainstream teaching (plenty of different options).

Just a thought that occurred to me- I know your DP doesn't want to move but psychologically do you think you'd feel happier in a one bed place just so you've got that bit of extra space, I can't imagine the running costs would be that much more depending on area although I appreciate you'll be limited a bit by transport options. That said I don't think driving needs to be a priority for you at the moment as you seem to be managing as you are with that side of things.

I just think I'd struggle with living out of bags too whereas even a small one bed gives you quite a bit more space and a bit more of a rooted feeling if your stuff is in cupboards rather than bags.

unluckyinlife · 04/10/2021 11:28

2k including my rent!! x

unluckyinlife · 04/10/2021 11:27

I live in a rented 3 bed in Greater London. I pay 1450 a month. My household bills total around 2k per month. It is tight each month but I am desperate to get out of the cycle of renting and feeling like I have nothing to show for it. Its awful xx

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 04/10/2021 11:22

Could you move further out of town op?
Say to Bury, but central and then cycle/ tram or cycle/bus . To save on rent

MoreStuffingMatron · 04/10/2021 10:58

If you enjoy social care can you retrain as a social worker. The pay and prospects are much better

GreenLunchBox · 04/10/2021 10:51

OP said £800 inc bills, so I presume a 50/50 split with her partner ie £400 per month for everything. If the council tax in a studio is maybe £100 a month, water £50, gas and electric perhaps £90 and then broadband too, that means rent alone is likely in the £500ish region and there are definitely better properties than a tiny studio to be had for that in GM, even assuming they need to stay close to good public transport links.

I don't think you can rent much for £500 in GM these days.

TrollsAreSaddos · 04/10/2021 10:40

@Benjaminbutton12

The paid social work training looks great. I really don’t think I should be a teacher, I am just not strict, I’ve been called ‘cute’ by pupils and I get told I’m too nice. I’ve no idea how I passed the pgce. Adult education could be good in a college, the social work paid courses also look great, just looking at them now.
Those aren’t good reasons not to be a teacher. 😕. You wouldn’t have passed your pgce if you weren’t capable of teaching.
Wazzzzzzzup · 04/10/2021 10:39

Well above NMW, not just above, of course

NotQuiteUsual · 04/10/2021 10:39

It seems a shame to give up teaching over that. There's loads of styles and shouting or being very strict aren't always the right approach anyway. Have you considered teaching at a special needs school? A lot of pupils there won't tolerate strict behaviour management and instead need consistency and gentle understanding. You probably aren't bad at behaviour management, just haven't found your style. Maybe read into PACE? Really interesting ideas that don't work for everyone's style hut could resonate for you.

I struggled with behaviour management too, but once I found my style it was fine. I know older teens don't particularly respond to me the same way preteens do and now I know that it's easier to work with it. It's so hard starting out though.

Wazzzzzzzup · 04/10/2021 10:39

Your DP in a kitchen. What does he do? Because kitchen wages have risen above NMW now. Even for porters in most cases. If he cooks, he can really get better deal asap

FallingRussetLeaves · 04/10/2021 10:37

Your OP says £800 but later you mention £400 I gather less bills

OP said £800 inc bills, so I presume a 50/50 split with her partner ie £400 per month for everything. If the council tax in a studio is maybe £100 a month, water £50, gas and electric perhaps £90 and then broadband too, that means rent alone is likely in the £500ish region and there are definitely better properties than a tiny studio to be had for that in GM, even assuming they need to stay close to good public transport links.

Maroon85 · 04/10/2021 10:29

One of my friends is a senior carer. She does have a lot more responsibility and has had to do extra training but she earns £14/hour (that is in the South though - might be less further North).
Alternatively if you want to stay in your current job could you rent a large 2 bed flat/house and sublet a room out (not all rental contracts let you do this but lots do)? You'd have a lot more living space and someone else to share the bills with.
If you don't need a car you shouldn't feel bad about not having one! It's easy to compare yourself to others but with virtually no debt and managing each month you're doing a lot better than some people

SarahDippity · 04/10/2021 10:26

Sounds like with some upskilling you could be ready to make a move after Christmas. Could be ideal timing for some private tutoring, pre-exam. Could you specialise in particular subjects for GCSE or A-Level?

Redsquirrel5 · 04/10/2021 10:25

I retired from Education recently and in the last few years I have seen lots of young people leave in there. NQT or the next year. Behaviour is a problem in a lot of schools but there are easier ones too. My neighbour has left too and she now has a job working for a charity. Another colleague had already started there and they both love it. Might be worth looking at family and children’s charities.

Your OP says £800 but later you mention £400 I gather less bills. My daughter was in the south west and 4 years ago was paying £850 rent for a two bedroom semi then the rent was put up to £900 and they couldn’t afford that. They were struggling as it was and both graduates with an old car and she had a bike. It is difficult.

Could you live further out or further north where it is cheaper? Good luck you have lots of suggestions to think about.

Benjaminbutton12 · 04/10/2021 10:21

Thanks for all these replies, I’m going to start applying to courses this week, I am really motivated having read these posts and I am confident we will be able to do better.

OP posts:
FallingRussetLeaves · 04/10/2021 10:20

Those housing costs are on the dear side for a very crappy studio in an unlovely area of GM. The beauty of living in this region is that you don't have to pay that kind of money for shit housing. Especially if you're willing to be outside the Didsbury/Heatons/Prestwich/Alty type bubble and don't mind somewhere more working class, which it sounds like you are. There are other options.

Problem is, the areas ringing the city centre are often particularly bad value for money, because you're paying for proximity to town but the housing stock usually isn't that great and the social deprivation problems still remain. It's the worst of both worlds really, especially as I'm assuming you don't work in the city centre given that you're a carer. You can get cheaper whilst still on decent public transport routes if you move a bit further out. Does DP work in town? If he doesn't, you have even more choice really.

bowlingalleyblues · 04/10/2021 10:09

It’s so hard but you have to ignore what other people have got and are doing. They may be in terrible debt, or hate their jobs but have to do them to maintain their lifestyle, or have family helping them.

Your accommodation sounds quite expensive and your pay is quite low. Any movement on either of those would help you, and if you’re struggling with the underpayment I’m assuming that you haven’t got money saved for a deposit anyway, so maybe you could look at lodging or house sharing to get more space and lower bills?

Positives:
Have jobs we enjoy
Have good level of skills that can be transferred into other jobs
Have ability to do tutoring, adult education, supply, learn more classroom management or go into a different role that uses care skills.
Able to walk/cycle to work.
No debt and good credit.
Don’t have an expensive lifestyle.

Cons:
Not much living space
Low pay
Financial insecurity