Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

2nd Met Police officer has been charged with rape

467 replies

Rinoachicken · 03/10/2021 23:04

He worked in the same dept as WC.

It’s being very widely reported, except by the BBC.

AIBU to be sickened and wonder WHY the BBC are not reporting this?

Link: www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/oct/03/metropolitan-police-officer-charged-rape-hertfordshire?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

OP posts:
Felix125 · 06/10/2021 01:13

thedancingbear

"....If this attitude is typical of serving police officers' attitude - 'it is what it is, we can't do better' - then we are fucked.

And a nice little side order of 'but women make false allegations too!'. Despite even CPS official figures showing that these are vanishingly rare.

So ignorant. So dismissive of women...."

So, what do you suggest - from a police point of view. Bearing in mind that the police's roll is to gather the evidence and present it to the prosecution body ie CPS?

How do you want me to increase the charge rate? Because I would genuinely love to have the conviction rate as high as i can get it.

False allegations do occur - it may be a difficult pill for you to swallow, but its true. Most don't go to a prosecution of 'making a false allegation' so CPS will not be aware of them. These will just be closed before they reach any part of CPS. We have had CCTV evidence proving things haven't happened, mobile phone recordings etc etc

I'm not ignorant or dismissive of women

Like i said - i would love to have the conviction rate as high as possible and get rapists and other such deviants off the streets and behind bars. Believe me, I have worked with survivors of rapes to know the devastation that it causes. I'm first responder to such incidents and have been for some time.

And just to stop any further confusion - I'm a male officer of 20+ years service and no where near London or the Met.

Felix125 · 06/10/2021 00:57

@YourFinestPantaloons

So, from my perspective, we do as much as we can to help the victims/survivors of rapes and obtain a successful conviction

If that's the case how come 99% of rapists get away with their crime? And why do y think the conviction rate is SO much lower than any other type of violent crime?

".....I agree that a 2% conviction rate is awful, but if we have a stand point in law of 'proving beyond reasonable doubt' I'm not sure how this conviction rate can be effectively elevated to a much higher percentage.

Other offences such as assaults etc will have other evidence to prove the conviction - CCTV, other witnesses BWV etc etc

Burglaries will have forensic evidence putting the suspect on scene.

Rape offences do not usually have this. Its often word-against-word as to the point of consent. And if its not enough to convict on, then generally there will not be enough to charge with....."

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 06/10/2021 00:06

No real point in waiting for the latest trial to end before any inquiry.

There's always another case.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 05/10/2021 18:20

@thedancingbear

It's very interesting that the handful of police that have posted here, such as @Felix125 have displayed very 'male' attitudes, even though they are presumably women.

Indeed. IME, some of the worst misogynists are other women. The difference, of course, being that they do less harm to other women because they don't rape and kill them.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 05/10/2021 18:17

Rape is not legal and never will be. There are loads of people in jail for rape following successful convictions for the offence.

I agree that a 2% conviction rate is awful, but if we have a stand point in law of 'proving beyond reasonable doubt' I'm not sure how this conviction rate can be effectively elevated to a much higher percentage.

Your second paragraph directly contradicts the first. 'A 2% conviction rate is awful'. Your words. I would agree.

Directly above that you write 'there are loads of people in jail for rape following successful conviction'.

No, there are not. That's precisely the point I raised, the point with which you are apparently in direct agreement. So, which is it?

Incidentally, the precise words I used were de facto legal. I never said rape was legal. That's your own inventive spin.

Rape is a serious crime. Beyond reasonable doubt rather than a balance of probabilities is therefore a reasonable bench mark. What I thoroughly despise is the way the crime of rape is tried in court. The victim was wearing a thong. There was an exchange of text messages (as if that disqualifies her from saying 'no' at any point). You should try reading some of the threads on this site posted by victims of rape, on which patriarchy has done such a serious number that they're not even sure what they've suffered qualifies as rape, or that the benchmark must be low because other women have suffered worse.

Character assassinations on women in court are fair game during rape trials. If the defendant is guilty of similar, prior convictions, the jury is not allowed to know.

The truth is that the system is twisted, misogynistic, and stacked against women from the very first. And that's allowing for the vanishingly few cases that ever make it into a courtroom in the first place. It's woeful. It's inadequate. It needs addressing. And it's not just about supporting victims: it's about obtaining justice for them.

The fact that you apparently see it otherwise shows much about why women don't trust the police, and also shines a bright spotlight on the kind of misogynistic attitudes which pervade so many constabularies. Thank you for illuminating this.

Spiindoctor · 05/10/2021 16:44

Rather than changing the laws I think we should demand they get up to date on the rape accusations/prosecutions. So accused of rape - your up in front of the magistrate fast, also if you're accused it shoudl stay on your file for x years - there are so many rapes and sexual assaults that some men MUST be serial rapists but perhaps getting away with it due to lack of evidence. But if you get accused 5 times by different women then something would have to be done.

Rinoachicken · 05/10/2021 16:11

Link: Boris Johnson does not support making misogyny a hate crime www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-58800328

Misogyny hate crime in Nottinghamshire gives 'shocking' results www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-nottinghamshire-44740362

OP posts:
Rinoachicken · 05/10/2021 16:10

I read on the BBC that 11 out of 43 police forces in Britain have independently started recording misogyny as a hate crime since 2016, and research has shown ‘shifts in attitudes’ as a result.

Pity then than Boris Johnson said this about making misogyny a crime:

"I think, to be perfectly frank, if you simply widen the scope of what you ask the police to do you'll just increase the problem. "What you need to do is get the police to focus on the very real crimes, the very real feeling of injustice and betrayal that many people feel."

Basically he’s saying that the everyday misogyny women face is not a ‘real’ crime. Even though misogyny is a spectrum from wolf whistling to rape and murder - so surely tackling it at the ‘lower’ end may help prevent things escalating?

Interesting also that his main concern seems to be that if you make misogyny a crime to en the police would be overwhelmed with reports.

So apparently the way to reduce crime is to…pretend it doesn’t exist by not reporting or recording it?

OP posts:
thedancingbear · 05/10/2021 15:53

@YourFinestPantaloons

Just seen this on social media, for anyone asking what can be done
That's interesting. The one thing that seems to be missing, and which would surely effect real cultural change, is 'replace male coppers with female coppers'.

It's very interesting that the handful of police that have posted here, such as @Felix125 have displayed very 'male' attitudes, even though they are presumably women.

YourFinestPantaloons · 05/10/2021 15:12

Also, just seen this - 216,000 children abused by Catholic Priests in France since 1950

bbc.in/3uIZ3Qt?fbclid=IwAR3w5GCWGNAPloIMFz9AtCG13X3ogIfrR9xzkamECLfMIhHBGkFEa0MVDoA

Unfortunately not many convictions - @vivainsomnia - are these children lying too? Should we be really mindful that the priests may well be innocent? And does everyone agree that there's nothing further that can be done????

Or do we only make excuses and accusations when it's women, not children, who are abused?

YourFinestPantaloons · 05/10/2021 14:57

Just seen this on social media, for anyone asking what can be done

2nd Met Police officer has been charged with rape
Pumperthepumper · 05/10/2021 13:17

@skodadoda did you ever share your ideas for lowering the already very, very low number of false accusations?

FourTeaFallOut · 05/10/2021 13:07

@PicsInRed

A 6 month enquiry.

They're hoping women will forget.

Does the open case from the police officer in WC whatsapp group who is accused of rape need to close prior to the inquiry so as not to prejudice the case?
skodadoda · 05/10/2021 13:03

@Felix125

MarieIVanArkleStinks

Rape is not legal and never will be. There are loads of people in jail for rape following successful convictions for the offence

I agree that a 2% conviction rate is awful, but if we have a stand point in law of 'proving beyond reasonable doubt' I'm not sure how this conviction rate can be effectively elevated to a much higher percentage.

Other offences such as assaults etc will have other evidence to prove the conviction - CCTV, other witnesses BWV etc etc

Burglaries will have forensic evidence putting the suspect on scene.

Rape offences do not usually have this. Its often word-against-word as to the point of consent. And if its not enough to convict on, then generally there will not be enough to charge with.

How to change this - I don't know. Unless we lower the burden of proof and use 'balance of probabilities' as the bench mark.

But then you will always have the problem of the false accusations. And i know its really small, but it does exist.

From a police point of view - first responders to a rape (rape trained officer) will always believe the victims account. So we immediately look to obtain evidence (their account, seize clothing, medical samples etc). Then they will be put with a support network (who are brilliant). The incident is crimed and passed to and investigating team.

So, from my perspective, we do as much as we can to help the victims/survivors of rapes and obtain a successful conviction - from an emergency response point of view. But then you drop back into the problems of legally achieving this.

That’s a very rational argument, unlike some of the responses that have been made. If you think it’s ok to take away the presumption of innocence then please make the case - rationally.
PicsInRed · 05/10/2021 12:57

A 6 month enquiry.

They're hoping women will forget.

YourFinestPantaloons · 05/10/2021 12:48

Priti Patel has announced a formal inquiry into the failures in the policing system that led Wayne Couzens to get away with so much.

This will be very interesting

case www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-58804984

YourFinestPantaloons · 05/10/2021 12:46

So, from my perspective, we do as much as we can to help the victims/survivors of rapes and obtain a successful conviction

If that's the case how come 99% of rapists get away with their crime? And why do y think the conviction rate is SO much lower than any other type of violent crime?

thedancingbear · 05/10/2021 12:42

@Felix125

MarieIVanArkleStinks

Rape is not legal and never will be. There are loads of people in jail for rape following successful convictions for the offence

I agree that a 2% conviction rate is awful, but if we have a stand point in law of 'proving beyond reasonable doubt' I'm not sure how this conviction rate can be effectively elevated to a much higher percentage.

Other offences such as assaults etc will have other evidence to prove the conviction - CCTV, other witnesses BWV etc etc

Burglaries will have forensic evidence putting the suspect on scene.

Rape offences do not usually have this. Its often word-against-word as to the point of consent. And if its not enough to convict on, then generally there will not be enough to charge with.

How to change this - I don't know. Unless we lower the burden of proof and use 'balance of probabilities' as the bench mark.

But then you will always have the problem of the false accusations. And i know its really small, but it does exist.

From a police point of view - first responders to a rape (rape trained officer) will always believe the victims account. So we immediately look to obtain evidence (their account, seize clothing, medical samples etc). Then they will be put with a support network (who are brilliant). The incident is crimed and passed to and investigating team.

So, from my perspective, we do as much as we can to help the victims/survivors of rapes and obtain a successful conviction - from an emergency response point of view. But then you drop back into the problems of legally achieving this.

If this attitude is typical of serving police officers' attitude - 'it is what it is, we can't do better' - then we are fucked.

And a nice little side order of 'but women make false allegations too!'. Despite even CPS official figures showing that these are vanishingly rare.

So ignorant. So dismissive of women.

Felix125 · 05/10/2021 12:10

MarieIVanArkleStinks

Rape is not legal and never will be. There are loads of people in jail for rape following successful convictions for the offence

I agree that a 2% conviction rate is awful, but if we have a stand point in law of 'proving beyond reasonable doubt' I'm not sure how this conviction rate can be effectively elevated to a much higher percentage.

Other offences such as assaults etc will have other evidence to prove the conviction - CCTV, other witnesses BWV etc etc

Burglaries will have forensic evidence putting the suspect on scene.

Rape offences do not usually have this. Its often word-against-word as to the point of consent. And if its not enough to convict on, then generally there will not be enough to charge with.

How to change this - I don't know. Unless we lower the burden of proof and use 'balance of probabilities' as the bench mark.

But then you will always have the problem of the false accusations. And i know its really small, but it does exist.

From a police point of view - first responders to a rape (rape trained officer) will always believe the victims account. So we immediately look to obtain evidence (their account, seize clothing, medical samples etc). Then they will be put with a support network (who are brilliant). The incident is crimed and passed to and investigating team.

So, from my perspective, we do as much as we can to help the victims/survivors of rapes and obtain a successful conviction - from an emergency response point of view. But then you drop back into the problems of legally achieving this.

Pumperthepumper · 05/10/2021 10:43

@Siameasy

Pumper It’s IMO disproportionate; your response is spiteful and isn’t going to happen anyway because any decent system set up to improve behaviour does not rely on arbitrary punishments.

They’re human beings like us. You and I could apply tomorrow if we wanted to. The macho culture and men sticking together does not exist solely within the police and the police didn’t invent it. It’s everywhere.

It’s comfortable for people to think “oh I would never do XYZ, I would say something, oh those horrible officers etc etc”. That’s dangerous because you are treating them as “other”. If we treat them as “non-human but oh so special human” guess how they’ll treat the public.

It’s a unique and broad job for which many forces have been happy to recruit any old nodding donkey rather than invest in training and getting the right person.

And I’ve already said this on here this week but I’m genuinely considering joining the police. I’d love my job being so cosseted, if I so much as raised my voice to one of the people I have authority over, I’d be in a lot of trouble. Plus my pension is shit.
Pumperthepumper · 05/10/2021 10:42

@Siameasy

Pumper It’s IMO disproportionate; your response is spiteful and isn’t going to happen anyway because any decent system set up to improve behaviour does not rely on arbitrary punishments.

They’re human beings like us. You and I could apply tomorrow if we wanted to. The macho culture and men sticking together does not exist solely within the police and the police didn’t invent it. It’s everywhere.

It’s comfortable for people to think “oh I would never do XYZ, I would say something, oh those horrible officers etc etc”. That’s dangerous because you are treating them as “other”. If we treat them as “non-human but oh so special human” guess how they’ll treat the public.

It’s a unique and broad job for which many forces have been happy to recruit any old nodding donkey rather than invest in training and getting the right person.

I’m not arguing that it’s not everywhere - it is. But the police is a very specific type of profession with a huge amount of power that no other profession has. That’s why they need to be so far above it that the very idea they’d send a racist WhatsApp is absolutely abhorrent- not only to the general public but to every single one of their colleagues.

I’d rather be spiteful than a rape apologist, which is a overwhelmingly the narrative of the police force this week.

Siameasy · 05/10/2021 10:21

Pumper It’s IMO disproportionate; your response is spiteful and isn’t going to happen anyway because any decent system set up to improve behaviour does not rely on arbitrary punishments.

They’re human beings like us. You and I could apply tomorrow if we wanted to. The macho culture and men sticking together does not exist solely within the police and the police didn’t invent it. It’s everywhere.

It’s comfortable for people to think “oh I would never do XYZ, I would say something, oh those horrible officers etc etc”. That’s dangerous because you are treating them as “other”. If we treat them as “non-human but oh so special human” guess how they’ll treat the public.

It’s a unique and broad job for which many forces have been happy to recruit any old nodding donkey rather than invest in training and getting the right person.

Pumperthepumper · 05/10/2021 09:47

@Siameasy

I think speeding is a bit harsh to lose your job and pension Pumper. I’m pretty sure an officer convicted of an assault would be sacked these days? In any case they would never lose their own pension contributions (quite significant compared to some other pensions) and what they would’ve made had they instead invested that contribution elsewhere would have to be accounted for.
It is harsh. Too bad.
Pumperthepumper · 05/10/2021 09:46

@Siameasy

They are like us. They’re not a different type of human. We are a herd species. It’s a big mistake to treat them like super heroes. As I said, it’s an important job and requires the right person but with the “bums on seats” attitude you get out what you put in

Afaik they don’t even interview anymore? Perhaps someone can clarify?

We see the sexist etc behaviour often in male-dominated environments - the army and the fire service are the same but I’ve seen it in the private sector too. It’s a man problem compounded by the fact that police have authority so it has more potential to do damage to the public

Except the police then has the authority to act on that sexist behaviour. So we need them to be better than that, and they’re not.
Siameasy · 05/10/2021 09:43

I think speeding is a bit harsh to lose your job and pension Pumper. I’m pretty sure an officer convicted of an assault would be sacked these days?
In any case they would never lose their own pension contributions (quite significant compared to some other pensions) and what they would’ve made had they instead invested that contribution elsewhere would have to be accounted for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread