Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that a roast dinner isn't necessarily an expensive meal to cook?

337 replies

Granllanog · 03/10/2021 17:51

Just been chatting to a newish friend, she asked what we were eating today and I said I had cooked a roast chicken dinner........she said she loves a roast but considers it an expensive meal. I asked her what she was having today and she said they were having fresh pizzas from Morrisons (£10).
I told her my roast dinner cost less than that to make!!!

Obviously, if you buy a very expensive cut of meat then the cost will be higher but a roast doesn't have to break the bank surely? Today we had a simple chicken dinner, roast potatoes, roast parsnips, swede, peas, carrots, stuffing and gravy.

Breakdown of today's simple roast
Chicken .........1.4 kg £3.33 (part of a multibuy offer)
Potatoes .......... 30p (taken from a large 7.5 kg bag)
Carrots 25p
Peas (frozen) 30p
swede 45p
parsnips 30p
homemade stuffing 25p onion, fresh herbs, my own breadcrumbs
homemade gravy 10p spoon of flour and some gravy browning

OP posts:
Noogar · 03/10/2021 19:02

@Loveshelly

Do they even teach home economics anymore?
No its design and technology still i think.
HermioneAndRoger · 03/10/2021 19:02

It takes minutes to make stuffing

And how are you making your breadcrumbs? In a processor? Do you grow your fresh herbs in your garden?

I understand your approach. I do something similar - I blitz up stale bread crusts and freeze them, make stock from chicken carcasses, etc etc, but I also appreciate that these little frugalities are made a lot easier by my Magimix, decently sized freezer, and well-stocked pantry.

Immaculatemisconception · 03/10/2021 19:02

I always buy cheap cuts, like brisket, shoulder of lamb, shoulder of pork, or chicken. I get several meals out of the meat not mumsnet meals and use some of the meat for sandwiches. With roasties and Yorkshire pudding, you do end up with quite a cheap meal.

ElephantOfRisk · 03/10/2021 19:02

I can cook, sometimes I enjoy it and am prepared to invest an amount of time and energy doing it but I agree sometimes you can't be bothered and so might have supermarket ready made something. But I wouldn't be saying I was having that because cooking a meal was necessarily more expensive

Loveshelly · 03/10/2021 19:01

Do they even teach home economics anymore?

Noogar · 03/10/2021 18:59

It takes minutes to make stuffing and my gran taught me to make gravy when I was a girl. Cooking is a great life skill and one that can save you a fortune, skills I am now passing on to my dc.

Not if you make homemade bread it doesn't. But yes I get your point. You've kind of made my point with telling us about your gran. My mum told me how to make a roast but if she hadn't I'd have to look it up and it would take me ages as I wouldn't be sure of each step and I'd probably just buy gravy granules.

ElephantOfRisk · 03/10/2021 18:58

As long as you aren't opening the door really often, once the oven is heated it's maintaining the temperature rather than just blasting out more and more heat so it wouldn't cost significantly more to run it for an hour rather than 15 minutes cooking a pizza. Once you are finished then leave the oven door open so at least you get the benefit of the heat in the house.

limitedperiodonly · 03/10/2021 18:58

She probably doesn't cook. Lots of people don't because it is a faff. Even if you know how to cook it is still sometimes a faff. And pizzas are nice, especially the fresh ones - I like the ham, mushroom and mozzarella sourdough ones from Sainsburys for £4.50 for one large enough for two as long as they are not very hungry.

But your roast chicken would have worked out cheaper than her pizzas and wouldn't be too much of a faff to make. It would be equally tasty and more nutritious.

Tonight is a chicken casserole which is even easier than your roast made with a leg each (thighs and drumsticks), leeks, carrots, potatoes, mushrooms, broad beans and chicken stock, herbs and tomato puree. The chicken is not free range and I think was £4.50 for four leg portions.

I eat free range meat and often choose to make vegetarian or vegan food but I really can't be arsed with people saying: "Wow! Just wow!"

ElephantOfRisk · 03/10/2021 18:55

I agree it might cost more in fuel than a pizza but the beauty of a roast is that you have most of it in the oven at the same time and our smaller chicken today was just an hour and 20 mins in the oven. Roasties and yorkies in at the same time, just have to shuffle the shelves about.

Granllanog · 03/10/2021 18:54

@Noogar

*homemade stuffing 25p onion, fresh herbs, my own breadcrumbs homemade gravy 10p spoon of flour and some gravy browning*

And there's the time cost of doing all this. And if you don't know how to do it the time cost of finding out how.

It takes minutes to make stuffing and my gran taught me to make gravy when I was a girl. Cooking is a great life skill and one that can save you a fortune, skills I am now passing on to my dc.

I should have posted this next week as we will be having roast lamb, I bought a whole leg a few weeks ago when it was 8 kg and cut it into smaller joints,

OP posts:
iwannabelikeyouhoohoo · 03/10/2021 18:53

@BoreiPuriHagafen

I wouldn't buy or eat a chicken that cost 3 quid.
Me either. I’d be making serious cutbacks in other areas of my life and/or going veggie before I ate such cheap meat.
Moon22 · 03/10/2021 18:53

Hadn't considered the cost of running the oven. Perhaps slow cooker/air fryer type cooker would be a cheaper option. Mine cost pennies to run compared to the oven.

tsmainsqueeze · 03/10/2021 18:52

@BoreiPuriHagafen

I wouldn't buy or eat a chicken that cost 3 quid.
Some people have no choice if they want to cook a roast dinner.
FourTeaFallOut · 03/10/2021 18:52

[quote Loveshelly]@Eminybob
Wow that an animal lived, died, processed by people and it still only costs 3.33
There is something so fucked up about that.

Yet on my thread where I said food is too cheap everyone disagreed and said it’s too expensive and I’m some rich bitch.

3.33 for a living creature is too cheap IMPO[/quote]
How much for the chip on your shoulder?

Benjispruce4 · 03/10/2021 18:52

We had pork fillet roasted today. It’s around £3 from Aldi, lean and no waste.

notanothertakeaway · 03/10/2021 18:51

@Loubiemoo

I remember one of my uni lecturers talking about this years ago.

A women pointed out to her that she was on an electric meter and couldn’t afford to cook it all.

Yes that's a v good point. A roast takes time to cook. Also, on a tight budget, you want to cook food that is fool proof, as you can't afford waste if something doesn't work out as you hoped
Georgyporky · 03/10/2021 18:51

"We bought the beef from a farm shop, it was £62 (but will definitely do another meal out of it). A chicken from the place I usually get them is £16-£20 depending on size."

£82 would feed a large family for at least a week.

Where are you living/shopping?

ElephantOfRisk · 03/10/2021 18:51

I guess if you can't cook it properly or throw some away then you'd be better not buying meat to waste - not so much from a money point of view, but I was always brought up never to waste meat or eggs or milk products.

Loveshelly · 03/10/2021 18:51

I agree I think fuel poverty is a real thing. But I don’t think the op is implying her friend has this problem.
Having an oven on for hours is expensive.

underneaththeash · 03/10/2021 18:51

@Loveshelly it’s a chicken. It had no idea of itself as a chicken and as long as it’s had a nice chicken life and a quick death it’s not an issue. We keep chickens too. They’re sweet, but they have no concept of self.
What is a massive issue is parents not feeding their children essential amino acids due to their beliefs.

WombatChocolate · 03/10/2021 18:49

I agree that choice is a luxury, but also that animal rearing cruelty is accepted too easily and most people could change their eating habits.

Yes, lots of people have a tight food budget. It doesn’t have to mean zero meat or the cheap chicken, which has been bred so it puts on weight and it’s legs give way under it and it’s squashed in with others and it’s own urine is burning it’s legs.

A tight food budget could mean eating higher welfare chicken twice per week, instead of cheap chicken 4 times per week. It’s a different way if thinking about food and the budget and meat.

But yes, all of this also requires some ability to cook. It required having a cooker and some pans and knowing how to peel and roast potatoes and that a bag of carrots is easy and cheap.

It’s true that it’s far easier to make ethical choices if you have plenty of cash and also if you have plenty of cash that you’ll have the know-how and equipment to make a delicious Sunday dinner. At the same time, it’s true that many many of us on MN are buying cheap, low welfare meat and basically don’t care. Many if us don’t have unlimited budgets, but we could afford an extra £10 per week spend on higher welfare meat if we chose to spend our money like that, or we could re-think our menus and eat meat one or 2 days less per week and then afford the better stuff when we do eat it. But the reality is, people want a £3 chicken and the price point is more important to them than the other stuff. And that’s not just those on very tight budgets, but often those with moderate or high budgets too. It’s cultural and a mindset for many many people.

Moon22 · 03/10/2021 18:49

Like any meal, can be cheap or expensive as you like!
A lovely gammon is a nice cheaper option. Or, depending on how many you're cooking for/how snobbish you are, the frozen tinned joints from iceland are fine. They are 2 for £5 and I think are meant to serve 4. We are only 2 but always have leftovers for sandwiches on Monday!
Frozen veg/yorkshire are cheap and easy.
If you're going to whole foods or butcher, or going for more expensive cuts, naturally will cost more. It's down to what suits you, your budget and your family.
God I fancy a roast now!!

RAFHercules · 03/10/2021 18:49

I think fuel poverty is very under recognised. Its expensive to have an oven running for a few hours. When I was very hard up, I would use chicken portions so they cooked quicker.

Dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 03/10/2021 18:48

@sleepyhoglet

If she isn't much of a cook then she will be buying everything ready done which would be more expensive. A roast is usually a from scratch meal which is why it is affordable (depending on the meat).
Even a 'chicken in a bag' is only about £4.99. Frozen roast potatoes don't cost much. So still affordable ready done.
Loveshelly · 03/10/2021 18:47

I do fundamentally agree with the op though. The great thing about a roast is you can bulk it out with lots and lots of cheap veg and everyone loves a roast potato.

Swipe left for the next trending thread