Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that a roast dinner isn't necessarily an expensive meal to cook?

337 replies

Granllanog · 03/10/2021 17:51

Just been chatting to a newish friend, she asked what we were eating today and I said I had cooked a roast chicken dinner........she said she loves a roast but considers it an expensive meal. I asked her what she was having today and she said they were having fresh pizzas from Morrisons (£10).
I told her my roast dinner cost less than that to make!!!

Obviously, if you buy a very expensive cut of meat then the cost will be higher but a roast doesn't have to break the bank surely? Today we had a simple chicken dinner, roast potatoes, roast parsnips, swede, peas, carrots, stuffing and gravy.

Breakdown of today's simple roast
Chicken .........1.4 kg £3.33 (part of a multibuy offer)
Potatoes .......... 30p (taken from a large 7.5 kg bag)
Carrots 25p
Peas (frozen) 30p
swede 45p
parsnips 30p
homemade stuffing 25p onion, fresh herbs, my own breadcrumbs
homemade gravy 10p spoon of flour and some gravy browning

OP posts:
likeacandleinthewind · 03/10/2021 20:38

@KFCforTea

Interesting that hardly anyone on here will admit to buying intensively farmed chicken and yet that is what is being bought by the majority of people in the UK.....................Typical mumsnet!!!
I buy bog standard chickens from M&S or Waitrose. I presume so do the majority of their shoppers given by the amount on the shelves.
CuteGirlsWatchMeEatEther · 03/10/2021 20:36

I grew up in an extended family that valued cooking

But they didn’t value food?

KFCforTea · 03/10/2021 20:36

Interesting that hardly anyone on here will admit to buying intensively farmed chicken and yet that is what is being bought by the majority of people in the UK.....................Typical mumsnet!!!

C8H10N4O2 · 03/10/2021 20:34

[quote Granllanog]@HermioneAndRoger I have a magimix and grow herbs in the garden. I also make stock from bones and have a well-stocked freezer and pantry.[/quote]
Yes we get it. By dint of your virtue you have the money, space and equipment and skills to make your own bread, grow your own plants, buy in bulk to get portion sizes down, presumably also cooking on a decent tariff rather than the high per unit tariff paid by the hoi polloi and their prepay meters.

All of which begs the question - why did you buy factory chicken when you are so fabulously well organised and set up?

Shadedog · 03/10/2021 20:32

Maybe she means it’s expensive for what you get. Not everyone is fussed about a roast. If you don’t do that sort of cooking often you have to buy the extras like the flour etc. Not everyone will use the extra cabbage or carrots or spuds midweek because they prefer other types of food. Some people just prefer pizza. Roast is a big effort if you aren’t arsed about it. About a million things I’d rather eat. Some smug “mate” chiding me for not cooking one may get a similar response. Talk of money usually shuts people up whereas “I like pizza” keeps them dropping hints about your general vulgarity and inability to behave in polite society.

EmilySpinach · 03/10/2021 20:17

I'm not defending eating cheap meat. Or meat at all. I'm vegan, FWIW. But people do make different choices, the OP is entitled to make her choice, just as you are. If the OP wants to make different food choices she is more likely to look into doing so if she feels supported rather than harrassed & bullied. I do feel this thread has become rather a pile on TBH.

The original post was pretty judgey. Mean-spirited posts get mean-spirited responses.

OP was very keen to tell us the exact cost of every element of her wholesome home-cooked meal in comparison with her friend's ghastly pizzas. It's not unreasonable for posters to point out that her chicken has an ethical and an environmental cost as well as a financial one.

Noogar · 03/10/2021 20:14

I just stick to lasagne. So much cheaper and easier to freeze and can chuck loads of veg and lentils in to bulk out the mince.

LadyDanburysCane · 03/10/2021 20:10

I don’t do a roast every Sunday but today I did. There’s only three of us.

I went to the butchers yesterday and instead of my usual chicken or joint I liked the look of some stuffed and bacon wrapped free range chicken breasts (yes I know this can be done at home and I have done in the past but they looked nice and saved me time). The three breasts were £10 but the potatoes, Yorkshire puddings, roasted veg (carrots, parsnips, shallots, pepper, courgette), and gravy were probably no more than a £1 more per person (I get a veg box so just use what I get). Definitely a relatively cheap meal and there’s enough chicken left over for DHs lunch tomorrow.

limitedperiodonly · 03/10/2021 20:10

@Fridafever

Your post is odd to people I think because you seem quite into quality food in some ways (fresh herbs, making your own bread) but prepared to buy and eat horrible cheap meat. It’s a bit of an unusual combo.
It's not odd to me at all. I don't fetish "quality" food. I eat the things i like. Sometimes they are expensive and sometimes they are cheap.

I like to buy yellow sticker food when I see it. Yesterday there was a lot of reduced Sainsbury's Taste The Difference rump steak. That's their premium brand and loads of people would have been delighted. I let it go because I have tried their rump steak and didn't like it. If it had been sirloin or ribeye I would have bought it.

I buy what you would call "horrible cheap meat" and fish. It depends on what I am cooking. Frozen and tinned vegetables and fruit are often superior to fresh.

Same with herbs. I can't grow herbs because there isn't enough light in my garden. I buy fresh parsley every week and keep it in water because it is better than dried. Dried basil isn't very nice either. But I always use dried thyme because it makes no difference on the whole and dried oregano is usually better than fresh.

To me, cheap things are not value for money and expensive things are not necessarily a mark of quality. It's just what you know.

Noogar · 03/10/2021 20:10

@kateg27

Do some of the people on here not realise that some people can't afford to buy organic meat? Don't you realise a lot of families are struggling to get by. I would never judge somebody for buying a cheap chicken ffs! The important thing is they are feeding their families. Judgemental posts like some of these would make some others feel absolutely rubbish.
I'm not judging people for buying a cheap chicken. Just saying that OP's friend might only buy free range chicken so for her it is expensive .
KingsleyShacklebolt · 03/10/2021 20:08

It's amazing that the supermarkets sell any mass produced chicken at all. Given how everyone on MN is buying the organic, cornfed, free range, £15 ones.

Or maybe, most people really aren't that bothered about a chicken and where it's come from. That they have other priorities, and would
rather buy cheap chicken than lentils.

I really have no time for judgy vegans. I'm not a die-hard carnivore, but i'm not losing a lot of sleep over chickens.

iwannabelikeyouhoohoo · 03/10/2021 20:08

@BananaPB

It's surprising how many people don't realise that the meat toppings on their pizza are probably as low welfare as a £3 chicken.
No one has said that? I wouldn’t eat a cheap meat pizza either. I eat much less meat than I used to - I will choose vegetarian food unless I know the meat is higher welfare. You don’t HAVE to eat meat. There is plenty protein in other sources of food which don’t include battery farming chickens and screwing over farmers to sell a whole bird for £3.
Tornado70 · 03/10/2021 20:06

My roast dinner is pretty inexpensive. We have a lentil loaf, potatoes, veggies etc.
Nothing that's died for us to consume.

Fluffycloudland77 · 03/10/2021 20:04

I eat liver too. I make liver and mushroom stroganoff.

Not eaten pork in years.

Hdhdjejdj · 03/10/2021 20:00

Potatoes can be easily stored in most cool dark places. It isn’t really a luxury to have to room for a bag of potatoes.

ThanksItHasPockets · 03/10/2021 19:59

But people do make different choices, the OP is entitled to make her choice, just as you are. If the OP wants to make different food choices she is more likely to look into doing so if she feels supported rather than harrassed & bullied. I do feel this thread has become rather a pile on TBH.

Given that the original post is a precisely itemised sneer at someone who eats pizzas for Sunday lunch I think it would be fair to suggest that one reaps what one sows.

ADreadedSunnyDay · 03/10/2021 19:56

Hi OP
You haven't factored in cost of cooking in any of your posts, plus you clearly have storage space for things like 7.5kg of potatoes. I'm not saying it is unreasonably expensive but you need to be aware that costs mount up for example if you are buying a tin of peas rather than using frozen (because you only have a small freezer for eg).

hibbledibble · 03/10/2021 19:56

To have any garden you are fortunate. Many live in medium to high rises with no outdoor space whatsoever. You are also fortunate to have someone who can buy you such an expensive gift.

I don't eat any meat, and eat very cheaply.

Regardless of what others do, you can care about the ethics of your own actions. Cheap meat is very unethical. If you can't afford better meat, there is the option of eating no meat (which is clearly the best option ethically, but for someone eating battery farmed chicken is unlikely)

LemonSwan · 03/10/2021 19:56

I think it is an expensive meal, especially in our house where there is only 2 of us.

We love trimmings as well; So red cabbage, broccoli/cauliflower cheese, stuffing, Yorkshires, properly roasted potatoes with duck fat, swede mash, etc.

And obviously you have the condiments as well. Apple, Mint, Mustard, Cranberry etc.

So it does add up IMO. I would likely spend £10-15 on a roast but if it was from bare cupboard status its probably more like £25-£30 (if you have to buy all the gravy/stock cubes, condiments, bits and bobs for sides - flour/eggs for yorkshire puddings, breadcrumbs or stuffing, duck fat, star anise and apple juice for cabbage etc.

Megan2018 · 03/10/2021 19:51

We don’t buy cheap meat, so a chicken large enough to feed us all will be £9 or more.
I don’t buy non free range, we get ours from the farm shop. Roast chicken dinner is about £4pp when we do it.

Granllanog · 03/10/2021 19:51

@hibbledibble I wish I did have a big garden!!! You can grow herbs in pots you know...........As for my Magimix it was a present many years ago.........I use it all the time.
Considering 94 % of the chicken sold in the uk is from intensive farming I don't think I'm that unusual in buying it.

OP posts:
Melroses · 03/10/2021 19:50

I remember listening to someone on the radio whose mother used to make a roast out of sausagemeat.

It sounded rather nice.

liveforsummer · 03/10/2021 19:49

A roast definitely needn't break the bank. Gammon, pork and chicken can all be bought cheaply. Even beef can be a reasonable price in Aldi. Typical roast dinner veg is among the cheapest as long as you aren't buying all pre prepared. Shop bought pizzas are easier but both way less tasty and more expensive x

yummumto3girls · 03/10/2021 19:45

I think the amount of meat on a £3 chicken would barely feed my kids, how on earth do you get 3 meals out of it!

limitedperiodonly · 03/10/2021 19:45

[quote Hdhdjejdj]@ElephantOfRisk I think Jack Monroe would agree with that. She mentions frozen meat quite a lot which must mumsnetters would turn their noses up at, but it’s an important source of protein for dc.[/quote]
It would take a lot of soul searching for me to buy another fresh peeled prawn from the supermarket chiller cabinet. Especially a pink cooked one. My supermarket does frozen langoustines - how posh is that?

Because of Jack Monroe I always buy frozen mince and frozen chicken breasts or fish fillets and seafood if I'm making bolognaise, chilli or a curry or a fish stew or paella. She's right. You really don't need fresh stuff for that and we could all do with saving money.

I also buy frozen chicken livers. They're 50p for 250g opposed to £1.10 for exactly the same pack of fresh ones. I have them with fava beans and a nice Chianti. Grin