Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that a roast dinner isn't necessarily an expensive meal to cook?

337 replies

Granllanog · 03/10/2021 17:51

Just been chatting to a newish friend, she asked what we were eating today and I said I had cooked a roast chicken dinner........she said she loves a roast but considers it an expensive meal. I asked her what she was having today and she said they were having fresh pizzas from Morrisons (£10).
I told her my roast dinner cost less than that to make!!!

Obviously, if you buy a very expensive cut of meat then the cost will be higher but a roast doesn't have to break the bank surely? Today we had a simple chicken dinner, roast potatoes, roast parsnips, swede, peas, carrots, stuffing and gravy.

Breakdown of today's simple roast
Chicken .........1.4 kg £3.33 (part of a multibuy offer)
Potatoes .......... 30p (taken from a large 7.5 kg bag)
Carrots 25p
Peas (frozen) 30p
swede 45p
parsnips 30p
homemade stuffing 25p onion, fresh herbs, my own breadcrumbs
homemade gravy 10p spoon of flour and some gravy browning

OP posts:
BorlandRd · 04/10/2021 10:04

@Comedycook

If all I could afford was a £3.33 chicken I think I would rather become vegetarian

Well that's easy to say but if you were actually in that position, you might feel differently. Oh and I reckon a lot of restaurants, unless they specify otherwise, use bog standard non organic meat. And what about supermarket sandwiches and the like? So chances are you eat factory farmed meat without even knowing.

I have a teenage ds...he wants to eat meat. If I served up chickpeas and other vegetarian delights, he'd not be very impressed.

Well we aren't exactly rolling in money ourselves, hence why we eat mostly vegetarian food, and don't buy things like supermarket sandwiches, and rarely eat out, so that point is not really valid - I really don't think I am consuming factory farmed meat without knowing.

I personally choose not to feed my DC cheap meat, but that's my choice - if your DS has issues around food, then fair enough. It's more important for him to not to starve than take a stand for animal welfare in that kind of situation. I'm grateful that my DC out grew the 'fussy' eating stage, but I am well aware that some children don't for all kinds of reasons that are nothing to do with being 'fussy'!

HarrisMcCoo · 04/10/2021 08:43

@FourTeaFallOut

Bollocks to all this thread. The poor are about to get hammered from every angle this winter and posters running on to say how you'd rather live in a cave than bring yourself to eat a cheap chicken.

Go for you. I reckon you could sustain yourself on bullshit and smugness and have a bit of tone deaf left over for dessert.

Well said.
Comedycook · 04/10/2021 08:35

@cushioncovers

Low income families I am one of them that eat meat every day at every meal have to buy cheap meat. Low income families that eat meat occasionally can buy high welfare meat. I am the latter. It's all about choices. A chick pea curry is a fraction of the price of a meat curry, so many people are obsessed with having meat at every meal I find it baffling. People who regard lentils & beans as some sort of Oliver Twist meal are missing the point.
A chickpea curry is s totally false economy if your DC refuse to eat it.
bigbeachedwales · 04/10/2021 08:33

@cushioncovers

Low income families I am one of them that eat meat every day at every meal have to buy cheap meat. Low income families that eat meat occasionally can buy high welfare meat. I am the latter. It's all about choices. A chick pea curry is a fraction of the price of a meat curry, so many people are obsessed with having meat at every meal I find it baffling. People who regard lentils & beans as some sort of Oliver Twist meal are missing the point.
I have meat once a week. My kids love roast chicken. I can still only afford a £3 chicken for them. But it makes them feel happy and fed and normal and loved. That's more important to me than the chicken's welfare. Go on then, keep judging me, though...
Hdhdjejdj · 04/10/2021 08:30

@FourTeaFallOut very well said. I totally agree.

cushioncovers · 04/10/2021 08:29

Low income families I am one of them that eat meat every day at every meal have to buy cheap meat. Low income families that eat meat occasionally can buy high welfare meat. I am the latter. It's all about choices. A chick pea curry is a fraction of the price of a meat curry, so many people are obsessed with having meat at every meal I find it baffling. People who regard lentils & beans as some sort of Oliver Twist meal are missing the point.

bigbeachedwales · 04/10/2021 08:22

[quote WhatsTheEffingPoint]@bigbeachedwales if that's they way you see me fine. Likewise in that you know nothing about me or my life but we're rude to me initially.
I work for a wealthy couple who go shopping without looking at any prices, and spend way more then I do, and then come and talk to me about what meals they've had, bottles of wine (that cost more then my beef) etc should I be rude to them because I can't do the same ? No I just get on with things.[/quote]
Oh ok. I'll just get on with things then. It's that easy. Thank you for your words of wisdom to someone so obviously beneath you.

bigbeachedwales · 04/10/2021 08:20

@FourTeaFallOut

Bollocks to all this thread. The poor are about to get hammered from every angle this winter and posters running on to say how you'd rather live in a cave than bring yourself to eat a cheap chicken.

Go for you. I reckon you could sustain yourself on bullshit and smugness and have a bit of tone deaf left over for dessert.

👏
WhatsTheEffingPoint · 04/10/2021 08:19

@bigbeachedwales if that's they way you see me fine. Likewise in that you know nothing about me or my life but we're rude to me initially.
I work for a wealthy couple who go shopping without looking at any prices, and spend way more then I do, and then come and talk to me about what meals they've had, bottles of wine (that cost more then my beef) etc should I be rude to them because I can't do the same ? No I just get on with things.

FourTeaFallOut · 04/10/2021 08:14

Bollocks to all this thread. The poor are about to get hammered from every angle this winter and posters running on to say how you'd rather live in a cave than bring yourself to eat a cheap chicken.

Go for you. I reckon you could sustain yourself on bullshit and smugness and have a bit of tone deaf left over for dessert.

bigbeachedwales · 04/10/2021 07:44

@Comedycook

A lot of people on here really have no idea about the real world.
Eye opener, isn't it...Hmm
Comedycook · 04/10/2021 07:37

A lot of people on here really have no idea about the real world.

bigbeachedwales · 04/10/2021 07:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Comedycook · 04/10/2021 07:25

If all I could afford was a £3.33 chicken I think I would rather become vegetarian

Well that's easy to say but if you were actually in that position, you might feel differently. Oh and I reckon a lot of restaurants, unless they specify otherwise, use bog standard non organic meat. And what about supermarket sandwiches and the like? So chances are you eat factory farmed meat without even knowing.

I have a teenage ds...he wants to eat meat. If I served up chickpeas and other vegetarian delights, he'd not be very impressed.

Aorh · 04/10/2021 03:40

We’re fortunate enough to be able to afford slightly higher welfare. £8 fir a chicken, we stick to cheaper veg , and make sure it’s bulked up with veg. Roast over 2 nights, sometimes enough left for a third meal, plus soup for lunch from the veg. It’s not cheap, but I think our most economical meat meal (assuming you apply similar welfare standards to all meat in line with your budget). I’d do them more often if I had time.

owlbethere · 04/10/2021 03:37

And I’ll add to that I make all my own food from scratch, (see previous allergy/coeliac/crohns fun times) and we eat some veggie meals, but when you need protein for muscle repair and to keep you healthy and your sources of protein are limited , can’t have nuts- allergic to most, can’t have legumes in any great quantity, they set off the crohns, lactose isn’t a friend either, allergic to shellfish…

owlbethere · 04/10/2021 03:31

[quote Loveshelly]@FourteenSixteenTwentyTwo
Everybody has a choice.

We as a country are simply happy to ignore all the problems that eating cheap meat produces.[/quote]
Everybody does not have a choice. I have multiple allergies, coeliac disease, Crohn’s disease with triggers and a child with severe ARFID. One of the very few foods that we can both safely eat is chicken. I can’t afford to pay £13 for a chicken on a single parent of 4 wages.

1forAll74 · 04/10/2021 03:19

Roast dinners don't have to be expensive, and are going to be much better to eat, than rubbish pizzas.

Hdhdjejdj · 04/10/2021 02:52

@CatKittyCatCatKittyCatCat you said some people may not be inclined to have things in a kitchen which allowed them to cook food. I think that would be odd if you are a parent. You are also saying that they could be two bus rides away from any shops. Maybe, but some people have to go shopping at some time, whether it’s for food or other essentials. Chances are they’ll encounter somewhere that sells pans. On my local freecycle people often want household items, including kitchen items. There’s always that option.

BorlandRd · 03/10/2021 23:32

@KilljoysDutch

All these people with the luxury of buying organic free range chickens need to remember that it is a luxury and for a lot of us the cost of your chicken needs to cover 2 or 3 meals.
We don't eat loads of meat but when we do it's organic and from a farm shop - and is definitely a luxury. If all I could afford was a £3.33 chicken I think I would rather become vegetarian. That £3.33 chicken would not have had a good life and the thought of that would take away any enjoyment I got from it with each mouthful.

OP I guess your friend isn't into eating cheap factory farmed meat and that's why they consider a roast an expensive meal, which I'm sure a lot of people do.

WhatsTheEffingPoint · 03/10/2021 23:29

@bigbeachedwales you chose to have children I chose not to but have my dog instead!

My post is making a point that you can make a meal as expensive/cheap as you want, yes I chose to have an expensive piece of meat today but that will last 2 (3inc dog) of us all week used in various meals, so divided cost wise probably not that much. Yes the dog will get some so it's all used. A few weeks ago we had a supermarket chicken and the dog got the remnants of that too, again so it was all used and nothing wasted (how many of them posts do you see on here...how many meals can you make from one chicken?!...we only use the breasts, what a waste etc)

I also bulk buy chicken breasts from a wholesaler and freeze them down that's probably the only real meat we eat (dislike pork and lamb), does that make me 'proud' no it makes me look around to get the best meat possible for the money I spend. As I also said its not an everyday thing its a rare treat.

CatKittyCatCatKittyCatCat · 03/10/2021 23:15

[quote Hdhdjejdj]@CatKittyCatCatKittyCatCat If you have no inclination to make your dc decent food, I have no sympathy. That’s quite a different matter to lack of money. I understand the issues of child poverty but I didn’t think we were talking about that on this thread, given the OP’s friend can afford £10 for 4 pizzas.[/quote]
How the on earth did you get to “no inclination to make your DC decent food” from my post. Because I said people might not be inclined to go thrifting for casseroles if it involves two buses?

Livpool · 03/10/2021 23:08

@gunnersgold

You do have a choice , you don't have to eat meat ! We have a roast dinner with just veg and it's lovely ! Humans are so used to eating animals we don't stop to think about wetter we actually should and how much we should pay for their lives ! Sad really !
Oh yes all those poor people who don't want to serve lentils and beans for every meal.

Mumsnet is in a world of it's own

Livpool · 03/10/2021 23:00

@CarrotSticks23

A free range organic chicken from Morrisons is £13 It depends how much you want to compromise on animal welfare for your roast really. Maybe she's not prepared to buy a £3 chicken?
It maybe it is how much money you have?!
BreadInCaptivity · 03/10/2021 22:46

I don't think it's a massively expensive meal, but I don't think it's cheap either.

As pp's have said a lot depends on the meat you buy and it's quality. I'm not a fan of cheap meat for reasons of both taste and ethics.

It is cheaper than a lot of pre-made meals assuming you make everything from scratch and depending on the size of your family a roast will often suffice for more than one meal (though I'm not a proponent of the MN endless chicken).

I don't actually find making a roast a chore either - but after 20 years I've got it down to an art and I figure given I get two meals (possibly 3 at a push by which I mean 2 meals and a few sandwich's or enough meat left for a pasta dish or soup) out of it I'm saving some time there (there's only 3 of us though).

Rather than cheap, I'd regard it as a good value meal per serving and one that rewards your efforts with easy leftover options.