Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP sheltering since covid running London marathon

167 replies

justasking111 · 03/10/2021 13:06

OH raging that our GP working from home since March last year is running the London marathon today is he being unreasonable. He's spitting feathers here. This is the senior partner owner of the building practice

OP posts:
privateandnhsgp · 03/10/2021 22:55

[quote Zilla1]@privateandnhsgp Suspect the intended destination will be large scale corporate primary care by entities large enough to be able to be investable, fund political donations and employ the great and the good as NEDs using a healthy dose of off-shore remote consults at a lower cost base. Then everyone will struggle to see GPs F2F unless they go fully private. Will make the (English as health is a devolved policy) Government's key stakeholders happy, though perhaps not all the voters who voted for them.[/quote]
This is why I set up my own private practice with a colleague.

Setting up CQC etc was a breeze with the experience we have, we have a modern clinical system that's not constantly throwing up QOF alerts and there is plenty of time to listen to patients and practice good medicine. Earnings are proportional to how hard you work - it seems fair.

Of course, one appointment costs nearly a year's worth of GMS and that's not something that everyone can afford. Private days are a breeze in comparison to the warzone that is NHS General Practice at the moment.

Last Monday over 10pc of our entire NHS list called us on the same day for appointments or prescriptions - we have over 10000 patients. It's totally unsustainable.

RosesAndHellebores · 03/10/2021 22:53

Do we have too few GPS? Or too many part-time GPs?. I'd love to see some data on the headcount compared to FTE.

Dfhugdhvdnjrs · 03/10/2021 22:52

@Stuckhere2021

Bookmark

Today 21:59 SW1amp

Dfhugdhvdnjrs
Diagnostics are utterly appalling in this country and lack of face to face is only making it worse. It is a disgrace and people who rightly lost all confidence in the system.
But what’s that got to do with a doctor going for a run..?

🤣🤣🤣🤣

Yes hilarious for those who have died from cancer due to lack of FTF.
Dfhugdhvdnjrs · 03/10/2021 22:51

Basic fact is that lack of FTF means higher A&E attendance which will reach unacceptable levels in winter. It is a matter of time before GPs will be forced to resume a normal service.

Stuckhere2021 · 03/10/2021 22:51

Bookmark

Today 21:59 SW1amp

Dfhugdhvdnjrs
Diagnostics are utterly appalling in this country and lack of face to face is only making it worse. It is a disgrace and people who rightly lost all confidence in the system.
But what’s that got to do with a doctor going for a run..?

🤣🤣🤣🤣

Stuckhere2021 · 03/10/2021 22:44

OH raging that our GP working from home since March last year is running the London marathon today is he being unreasonable. He's spitting feathers here. This is the senior partner owner of the building practice

I’m not sure what is the point you are making OP? Why is your DP spitting feathers? What direct impact of Dr WFH has had on him? Why is the GP owning the building of note?

Zilla1 · 03/10/2021 22:42

@privateandnhsgp Suspect the intended destination will be large scale corporate primary care by entities large enough to be able to be investable, fund political donations and employ the great and the good as NEDs using a healthy dose of off-shore remote consults at a lower cost base. Then everyone will struggle to see GPs F2F unless they go fully private. Will make the (English as health is a devolved policy) Government's key stakeholders happy, though perhaps not all the voters who voted for them.

Dfhugdhvdnjrs · 03/10/2021 22:42

[quote Zilla1]@Dfhugdhvdnjrs Not sure what you are disagreeing with but to clarify, the first two sentences in my post was a quote from a PP that I disagreed with hence the "". The remainder was my response.[/quote]
Yes I was the PP. what you describe is not representation of the service received in most of the country.

Zilla1 · 03/10/2021 22:36

@Dfhugdhvdnjrs Not sure what you are disagreeing with but to clarify, the first two sentences in my post was a quote from a PP that I disagreed with hence the "". The remainder was my response.

privateandnhsgp · 03/10/2021 22:36

The BMA are a union and should be defending Doctors' T+Cs - unfortunately much of the time they seem to see it as their role to defend the NHS (or to pontificate on boxing or road safety or something)

Many of the GPs that I know are beginning to realise that the NHS's interests and Doctors' interests actually no longer align. It's not good for patients, it's not good for Doctors.

Anyway, this won't be decided by the BMA. Unless something big changes (like a new contract) it will be decided by the declining number of GPs with a likely move to a model of ANP/Nurse led care with GP oversight (NHS, not private). Of course, no government can overly state this, it would make them unelectable.

SW1amp · 03/10/2021 21:59

@Dfhugdhvdnjrs

Diagnostics are utterly appalling in this country and lack of face to face is only making it worse. It is a disgrace and people who rightly lost all confidence in the system.
But what’s that got to do with a doctor going for a run..?
Dfhugdhvdnjrs · 03/10/2021 21:55

Diagnostics are utterly appalling in this country and lack of face to face is only making it worse. It is a disgrace and people who rightly lost all confidence in the system.

Dfhugdhvdnjrs · 03/10/2021 21:54

@Noogar

We should all be angry because otherwise more and more of us will die from preventable/curable illnesses.

More people are going to die if the DR has to take twice as long getting through appointments waiting for people to come and go, have a natter, cough all over them and give them covid.

They should do face to face appointments where needed.

Sorry this is ridiculous. NHS funding should be refused to practices who do not provide a pre-Covid service.
Dfhugdhvdnjrs · 03/10/2021 21:52

@Zilla1

"It is pathetic that it is simply impossible to call let alone get an appointment. The only people who can use the NHS these days are the unemployed who have hours to sit on hold." This is the type of disinformation I have in mind. Charitably, that might be someone's view of their own surgery but stretched to the whole of the GP estate in the NHS. FWIW, we have never had a day when we've not seen patients F2F. For the different surgeries at which I and my DC are patients, I've been seen F2F in a timely manner when appropriate and with telephones answered in a couple of minutes after having to listen to the COVID messages. I see the call statistics at my practice so see how long people have to wait. I know this is not the same at all GP practices
It certainly is not.
gardeninggirl68 · 03/10/2021 21:28

way to go that GP!!!

its a lonely sport, but marathon day makes it ALL worthwhile! what was his time?

Did you sponsor him?

Neonplant · 03/10/2021 21:23

Does he normally have issues controlling his emotions? Seems an odd thing to be so enraged about.

I'd also ask if the GPs are actually working from home or working from the surgery and doing telephone triage. Which is a very different thing.

RosesAndHellebores · 03/10/2021 21:09

@FelicityBennett we have a home in France and I can put my hand on my heart and say health services in France are head and shoulders above those in the UK. They are responsive, respectful and generally more honest.

If you assert that GPS would prefer to work within a Continental Heslth System rather than the UK's outdated and inadequate NHS may I respectfully suggest that GPS and the BMA start lobbying government to effect the change.

Becca19962014 · 03/10/2021 19:36

none of this is good enough, if the NHS is going to survive it needs to be overhauled and properly funded

A conversation I was a part of along side clinical and medical staff back in 2008. The general consensus was that it'd be fine and was someone else's problem.

Which was more or less the answer to everything.

Our waiting times due to removal of services from two thirds of the hospitals in our health board are now up to three years (that's neurology) and that's just my conditions; others may be more.

FelicityBennett · 03/10/2021 18:39

No it’s not ok but complain to the right people. Primary care is drowning and instead of help and support from government level we’re being told it’s because we’re lazy.
I know all GP surgeries to us locally and are all doing f2f as needed , our surgery you have a choice when you book. The problem is that demand massively exceeds capacity despite increasing staffing ( we cannot employ a GP as nil available so we have 2 new ANPs) our capacity still means that all appointments have gone by 845 . We have urgent slots reserved but again these go quickly. We see above the recommended ‘safe’ level of patients and provide above the recommended percentage of appointments to list size
But all of this is of no use to the patients who ring at 9 am and then abuse our reception team .

We have the lowest level of GP to patient numbers in Europe and hence there is no way we can provide the same service

I would love to be able to my job properly, I would love to be able to properly support my palliative care patients I would love that patients are seen quickly but I cannot physically give anymore to the NHS and nor can any of our colleagues

The service is under huge pressure and I think most GP’s would agree. A practice close to me handed back their contract 2 weeks ago , no one wants to take this over , this leaves 3000 patients with no service

Outside of 2ww our waiting times for secondary care are 6-12 months depending on specialty.

None of this is good enough , if the nhs is going to survive it needs to be overhauled and properly funded .

privateandnhsgp · 03/10/2021 18:28

@TheWeeDonkey

Well good for you Zilla1. Thats not the experience for most. As I say, I know friends within the NHS who're treating patients who're now terminal because they couldn't get FTF appointments and were misdiagosed.

My own DH was lucky that he works for a company that provides private health insurance because his GP was still telling him it was probably nothing to worry up to the point that the tumours removed from hs kidney were diagnosed as cancer.

The experience for most patients has been poor, and the outcomes for some will be devestating and its not okay.

You don't know what the experience for "most" patients has been, this simply hasn't been measured. So you're flat out making this up.

In terms of what other HCPs think, they have no context for knowing what proportion of patients were or were not seen F2F without knowing how many patients each individual practice saw.

Our NHS practice has had a 50pc increase in demand since the start of the year compared to baseline 2 years ago. We've increased capacity more then 30pc despite having fewer staff and no increase in funding. But there is still that increased demand that we can't possibly meet and therefore there are more people that won't be seen F2F (or remotely) and yes some of these will have pathology they could have been treated earlier. This doesn't mean that we're not working hard.

TBH we're not far away from reducing our service back to baseline if the abuse doesn't stop soon - then patients will really get the service that they're paying for (and £150/year doesn't stretch that far in healthcare terms).

TheWeeDonkey · 03/10/2021 18:10

Well good for you Zilla1. Thats not the experience for most. As I say, I know friends within the NHS who're treating patients who're now terminal because they couldn't get FTF appointments and were misdiagosed.

My own DH was lucky that he works for a company that provides private health insurance because his GP was still telling him it was probably nothing to worry up to the point that the tumours removed from hs kidney were diagnosed as cancer.

The experience for most patients has been poor, and the outcomes for some will be devestating and its not okay.

Zilla1 · 03/10/2021 17:49

"It is pathetic that it is simply impossible to call let alone get an appointment. The only people who can use the NHS these days are the unemployed who have hours to sit on hold." This is the type of disinformation I have in mind. Charitably, that might be someone's view of their own surgery but stretched to the whole of the GP estate in the NHS. FWIW, we have never had a day when we've not seen patients F2F. For the different surgeries at which I and my DC are patients, I've been seen F2F in a timely manner when appropriate and with telephones answered in a couple of minutes after having to listen to the COVID messages. I see the call statistics at my practice so see how long people have to wait. I know this is not the same at all GP practices

Zilla1 · 03/10/2021 17:41

FWIW given the previous posts by PPs about GPs not offering F2F or doing COVID boosters, we've never has a single day in 2020 or 2021 when we haven't seen patients F2F. I know not every practice has the same circumstances. The environment of primary care in England is difficult. I think there is an orchestrated campaign to attack GPs for political purposes. We've seen whole practices return contracts and close which is something I've never seen before. We saw the single handed practices close on retirement but have not seen the wholesale voluntary closure then have individual GPs change career entirely, emigrate or locum.

PErhaps your DP might like to retrain, OP.

Does he have an interest in the hobbies of other professions?

ADreadedSunnyDay · 03/10/2021 17:36

I would be a bit miffed about this as well I think some GPs have seized on Covid as a way to reshape practice long term - for their benefit. But not all ...