Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to feel sorry for this women?

168 replies

gingercatsparky · 03/10/2021 10:41

The other day I met with a friend for lunch and she was telling me about her friend who has been deeply unhappy for a long time. My friend always talks about her in a poor her way and like none of her unhappiness is her own doing etc. The friend has lots of money but gets used by guys for money a lot. My friend was slagging off this latest guy for doing just that. However, I asked if this guy actually asks her friend for all the holidays they go on etc and my friend confirmed no, it's her friend who suggests it. I didn't say anything but thought well he's hardly going to say no then and she can't blame him if she's suggesting it.

Then my friend starts saying how sorry she feels for her friend as she caught COVID when she had a new born and she ended up in hospital. Apparently she was scared and crying etc. I can understand this and it must have been scary but my friend went on to say she hadn't got her second jab. I thought this could have been because she was pregnant so reluctant but no she just didn't get it. There was a long pause where I think my friend was waiting for me to join the poor hers but I couldn't. She then went on to say her friend had turned up at a &e with symptoms at this point and complain about the reception she got from the receptionist who told her to leave. Cue more pauses waiting for me to agree about poor x. Every conversation we have about her friend is like this, how unhappy she is, how lonely and how she is in tears. I don't want to be Horrible but I find it hard to go along with the poor hers when she has brought the whole situation and especially the COVID episode on herself. Would you be able to sympathise with someone like this?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 03/10/2021 11:50

You don't have to agree with someone's life choices to have empathy.

Is she divorced or widowed?

Since then there's been a succession of men that she feels she has to spend money on to keep them - she sounds lonely and insecure

At some point in the last year she's had a baby by one of these men she feel only want her for money and shortly after giving birth she caught covid and serious enough to require hospitalisation AND TO LEAVE HER NEWBORN AT HOME.
It's v unusual for a woman her age to end up hospitalised with covid, even without the jabs. There's no "good" reason that YOU know of for her not having the second, it doesn't need there isn't one. And frankly unless she's actively stopping people from getting it, I have sympathy for anyone who ends up in hospital with covid, let alone having to leave their newborn at home, worrying if you've given it to the baby etc

However the difference between me who can feel empathy for her and you is that I'm not perfect. I make mistakes. I have insecurities. I'm "human"

georgarina · 03/10/2021 11:50

You're judging a person you've never met and now you want people on the thread to judge her. Seems like a lot of time spent on someone you don't even know!!

I rescheduled my second jab because I had a newborn and was too tired to make the original appointment. In your mind you'd probably say I 'didn't bother' but I was exhausted and would have been terrified if I'd caught and been hospitalised with Covid in the meantime.

It would be weird not to be sympathetic. The extra information you've added isn't relevant to that.

ImaBraveNhsHero · 03/10/2021 11:49

Jfc. Even if you really do feel so aimless that you're moved to start this weird wee thread, don't you have a jigsaw or something you can be getting on with instead?

shivawn · 03/10/2021 11:45

I'm puzzled as to why you have made this thread? About judging the life choices of someone you hardly know....perhaps it would be better to focus on your own life and find better things to occupy your mind with. I can't fathom being bothered enough by this to make a thread on a public forum to discuss it unless you're grasping on to this ladies problems to make you feel better about your own life choices?

gingercatsparky · 03/10/2021 11:44

I am not necessarily judging her although I don't think she's made good decisions. It's more that she constantly wants to play the poor me card with my friend. Ringing her up crying etc. Then my friend wants to pass that onto us.

I haven't really seen my friend as a gossip before as this is the only person she ever really discusses in this much detail about. I wonder if it's her way of offloading the burden her friend puts on her. It sounds like many of their meet ups aren't fun and must be quite draining for her. I think her friend sounds like a person who takes a lot from her emotionally.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 03/10/2021 11:44

The friend doesn't sound too bad to me, she's just expressing sympathy about the other woman who appears to be unhappy.

Dreamsupreme · 03/10/2021 11:42

@RantyAunty

You both sound miserable and insufferable.

I can only imagine how she talks about you to others when you aren't around.

This is so true , people who talk about others to you are definitely doing the same behind your back
RantyAunty · 03/10/2021 11:41

You both sound miserable and insufferable.

I can only imagine how she talks about you to others when you aren't around.

Dreamsupreme · 03/10/2021 11:40

What a mean judgemental thread Confused
Sure you’ve not lived life without making wrong decisions. You don’t actually know this woman. Please get a life!

Chikapu · 03/10/2021 11:39

I feel her morals aren't very high

Not to feel sorry for this women?
ChristmasFluff · 03/10/2021 11:38

OP, something to remember is that every time you judge someone else, you are actually judging yourself, because your unconscious hears you and applies the judgment to you.

And as Wayne Dyer says, when you judge another, you do not define them, you define yourself.

WorraLiberty · 03/10/2021 11:32

@AnotherName456

I've just seen your recent update and honestly, I'm not sure I even believe what you are saying. You are so desperate for this woman to come across badly that you have added that she has slept with married men to get pregnant and then carried on smoking and drinking throughout the pregnancy. I'm not buying it.
Yep, she'll be disemboweling small puppies with her bare hands in a minute Hmm
Stoppochoco · 03/10/2021 11:32

If your 'friend' is talking about this woman in this way and disclosing this kind of personal to you about her, then I would be seriously worried what she was saying about me.
The woman sounds chronically insecure and vulnerable, and she definitely does not deserve to be in hospital with a new born.

WorraLiberty · 03/10/2021 11:31

Why do I care? I guess because my friend seems to always want us to have sympathy for x and follow the poor her conversation which I can't do.

Then don't do it. You're a (presumably) grown woman.

This 'Oh, I'm only asking an innocent question' routine isn't washing with anyone Hmm

crispsarny · 03/10/2021 11:30

You’re both a pair of horrible gossips, I wouldn’t trust your friend as she’ll be gossiping about you behind your back & well you’re no better. I used to have a two faced friend like you & your friend……..

gingercatsparky · 03/10/2021 11:30

@AnotherName456

I've just seen your recent update and honestly, I'm not sure I even believe what you are saying. You are so desperate for this woman to come across badly that you have added that she has slept with married men to get pregnant and then carried on smoking and drinking throughout the pregnancy. I'm not buying it.
Unfortunately it is true. This women is mixed up. I did have sympathy at the beginning but this is when it started to wane.

I didn't mean to criticise the women like that, I just thought it was an interesting question and had been mulling it over. No I am certainly not perfect myself.

OP posts:
MrsRobbieHart · 03/10/2021 11:29

No I started a thread discussing how much sympathy you can give someone who is deeply unhappy and lonely when it is of her own doing.

Why do you need other people to tell you how much sympathy you should have? You feel how you feel. Own it. Are you very lacking in self esteem that you have such little faith in your own feelings and need to put it to public vote?

DrSbaitso · 03/10/2021 11:29

I would rather have happiness to be honest

Everyone would rather "have happiness", but different things make different people happy.

Starting an online bitchfest about a woman you scarcely know, because you are apparently so burdened by your mutual friend expressing sympathy for her, isn't a very happy action.

Bounce55 · 03/10/2021 11:27

Find better friends?

AnotherName456 · 03/10/2021 11:26

I've just seen your recent update and honestly, I'm not sure I even believe what you are saying. You are so desperate for this woman to come across badly that you have added that she has slept with married men to get pregnant and then carried on smoking and drinking throughout the pregnancy. I'm not buying it.

Bounce55 · 03/10/2021 11:24

If your friend is gossiping/slagging off someone you can be sure she's doing the same to you. Some people just can't help themselves
Can't be arsed with people like that and tbh you're just as bad with this thread

gingercatsparky · 03/10/2021 11:24

@whycantwegoonasthree

Your friend is a gossip, and you are Judgey McJudgePants who apparently had a compassion bypass at some point. To be honest your thread reflects far more poorly on both of you that this other woman.

You started a thread inviting us to join in with your gleeful gloating about a woman with a newborn who is in hospital with Covid?

Fucking seriously?

Your gossipy friend is probably gossiping about you to others too. Probably about what an utterly horrible person you are.

No I started a thread discussing how much sympathy you can give someone who is deeply unhappy and lonely when it is of her own doing. She is only an example.

Why do I care? I guess because my friend seems to always want us to have sympathy for x and follow the poor her conversation which I can't do.

OP posts:
rainyskylight · 03/10/2021 11:23

I don’t think it’s very nice of your friend to be gossiping so much about another friend behind her back. It’s not nice to be talked about and pitied. I don’t think it’s nice of you to continue the gossiping with random strangers on the internet.

MrsRobbieHart · 03/10/2021 11:23

Oh you sound really unpleasant OP. I hope your friend stops sharing with you about her other friends. You don’t deserve to know anything about her.

CremeEggThief · 03/10/2021 11:23

Honestly? If I were you, I'd be wondering what your friend is saying to her friend about you, as she seems a bit of a gossip! Surely you two should have better things to talk about than discussing the private life of someone else, who you don't even know personally?